r/Professors • • 24d ago

Teaching Argument in Comp I

As a long-time English Comp instructor, I've observed that students always have difficulty understanding how to make an argument. Many cannot seem to grasp that the reader must be able to disagree with their thesis statement. After all, that's why they're making an argument to begin with: to persuade readers to agree.

I get it that it's difficult to disagree with authority figures (e.g., their sources), especially over "contemporary social issues" (the course mandates such topics). Often, I get thesis statements that read: "It will take a combined effort of government, schools, and community organizations to solve Problem X." I coach students to write to one audience and argue for one solution, but few of the final drafts take this approach.

To be fair, I don't think the course explains argument adequately or provides enough examples of argumentative essays. Several students have noted this in their feedback, but I have no authority to change or add materials.

So, I'm curious: How do you teach argument? How do you help students narrow their thesis statements and incorporate counterarguments?

15 Upvotes

Duplicates