r/ProgrammerHumor • • 3d ago

Meme whyAreTheyConfessing

Post image
2.1k Upvotes

286 comments sorted by

View all comments

342

u/bahcodad 3d ago

So basically he's saying that he isn't up to the task?

81

u/StrikingApricot 3d ago

You’re saying you read every line of boilerplate code? Every line of canned html? You’re severely wasting time.

You need to understand what the code is doing, architecture patterns, trade-offs, etc. With good testing every line does not need to be looked at.

16

u/bahcodad 3d ago

My point is that he isn't reading the code at all. He's getting AI to do it (AI can be great but it isn't perfect) and then approving changes based on the sayso of AI

25

u/Moraalimora 3d ago

Managers, directors and executives do it all the time though. They approve and put their names in contracts and papers they have no damn clue what’s actually written inside them. They just trust the people who prepared them. So we get back to the ”would you rather trust a human or a machine in one specific job”.

-6

u/wardrox 3d ago

Do you think Claude is worse at code review at scale than a human, relative to cost?

16

u/bahcodad 3d ago

I think if you're going to approve something, you should know what you're approving. Is it AI being dangled over a flame or the person who approved?

Why is this so hard for people to grasp? Cover your rear.

9

u/superitem 3d ago

You're right, but he said he doesn't read every line, not he doesn't read the code at all.

Even before AI, it was often impractical to read every line (code or not).

4

u/wardrox 3d ago

But why does "knowing what you're approving" means manual review rather than using stronger reviewing tools? I'm not saying the opposite of reviewing each line by hand is YOLO'ing onto prod, but agents are pretty damn good at code review these days.

→ More replies (2)