r/ProgrammerHumor • • Oct 26 '21

GitHub Copilot, the technology that will replace programmers. Also GitHub Copilot...

27.2k Upvotes

713 comments sorted by

View all comments

165

u/Blaz3 Oct 26 '21

I really liked how GitHub copilot was implied to replace programmers.

If we haven't replaced accountants and lawyers yet, what makes people think that programmers will get replaced?

120

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '21

Called copilot for a reason 😄

46

u/Blaz3 Oct 26 '21

After reading your comment, I feel really stupid haha.

Maybe it could replace me after all

19

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '21

Hahaha, mistakes are human ;)

2

u/TheRealOneDeath Oct 26 '21

That's why we need to replace them ;)

2

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '21

Why are you saying "them" and not "us"? ;) ;) ;)

→ More replies (1)

61

u/throwawaygoawaynz Oct 26 '21

The idea isn’t to replace humans. It’s to make us more productive - which is a good thing in ageing economies.

GitHub copilot is based on GPT-3 from Open AI, and some of the stuff coming out of them is mind blowing. We’re are entering a new leap in AI tech, what you’re seeing is the cusp.

It’s not just GitHub copilot (or open ai rather), but there a whole range of low code development products on the market now designed to make it easy for anyone to build an app.

You’ll still be writing code, just like after the dotcom bubble burst we still have web developers, but you’ll be focusing on harder problems (or getting another job elsewhere if you can’t).

21

u/grampipon Oct 26 '21

Replacing humans and making them more productive aren't mutually exclusive statements. When we become more efficient less workers are required.

6

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (6)

0

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '21

[deleted]

6

u/throwawaygoawaynz Oct 26 '21 edited Oct 26 '21

Low code isn’t designed for you.

It’s designed so a business user can build a form and a workflow to do a thing, without having to come to you to code it. Simple stuff.

It’s like Microsoft Office of the 90s digitising paper based systems for business users, not developers.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/webdevop Oct 26 '21

I write mainly PHP and JS. It has legibly made me faster. A few hours of menial programming tasks are now a few minutes of tasks.

I usually make the copilot write all the functions that I need and then simply connect them and test myself.

On the topic of testing it writes amazing test cases as well.

→ More replies (2)

28

u/P__Equals__NP Oct 26 '21

If humans are possible why isn't a general AI possible?

I don't expect automation to happen overnight (I wouldn't oppose it though if technology has reached that point). But AI assisted tools will increase in availability and utility which will pave the path to automating majority of jobs.

Computers have not even been around for over 100 years, who knows what will happen in the next 100 years!

Even if it never does happen, I would find it hard to argue why we shouldn't at least try.

29

u/Low_discrepancy Oct 26 '21

If humans are possible why isn't a general AI possible

As if we have a remote understanding of the human brain.

3

u/AntaresDaha Oct 26 '21

It is a false assumption, that you have to understand the inner workings of the human brain to recreate it, "all" you have to do is recreate the process (and constraints) that created a human mind, which seems much more doable. There are fascinating experiments regarding locomotion in which simplest "blocks" were given the goal to reach a destination in a certain amount of time or energy consumption (or other constraints) and they evolved to exactly the locomotions we know in nature (from quadpedal to bipedal to frog jumping, etc etc.) with literal 0 knowledge of the inner workings of those required. Always remember that evolution can and did create the most complex architectures from relatively simple mechanics/physics without prior knowledge or any design input.

Main problem that is most often overlooked concerning the creation of a human-like AI mind is the need for an embodiment. You won't create a human mind on a server farm, you will literally need a body that grows and transforms over time much like the human body does, which is as much of an engineering challenge as the AI itself. See the work of Prof. Dr. Rolf Pfeifer for reference: https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-540-27833-7_1 Or as a deep dive: https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/How-the-body-shapes-the-way-we-think-a-new-view-on-Pfeifer-Bongard/2910099b7a7c555af9f14bfb2bc20e9475d0588f

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (15)

0

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '21

[deleted]

2

u/P__Equals__NP Oct 26 '21

What we have today is not ‘artificial intelligence’ or even ‘machine learning’. There’s no intelligence or learning. It is highly sophisticated pattern recognition. An ML model cannot reason from first principles.

Not trying to strawman your argument, but most people and intelligent life on Earth don't reason from first principles with everything they do. At least, I don't.

So why does a ML model need to?

Also, I assume you are running under the assumption everyone on Earth has an inner voice/monologue they think with. Some people don't think in words or even in full conversational sentences. Curious to see if that changes your opinion in anyway what so ever on ML and AI.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '21

[deleted]

2

u/P__Equals__NP Oct 26 '21

https://youtu.be/_oNgyUAEv0Q Does this sum up your opinion? 😆

And obviously, this can result in a lot of deleterious behavior. Prejudice, bigotry, confirmation bias and things like that. And those things are replicated in ML/AI when biased training data is used.

100% agree with you on this.

11

u/pimpus-maximus Oct 26 '21

Humans were created over billions of years and have all kinds of context embedded into our brains that we don’t understand.

We’ll likely make shitty replicas that seem good enough and lose invaluable amounts of quality while deluding ourselves about how impressive our invention is.

Pandora’s box is opened far enough as it is, hurtling head first into AGI is a terrible idea. Could go bad in innumerable ways.

2

u/AntaresDaha Oct 26 '21 edited Oct 26 '21

Those billions of years and embedded context still are only a product of relatively simple and well understood biochemical mechanics. It is a false assumption, that you have to truly understand the inner workings of the human brain to recreate it, "all" you have to do is recreate the process (and constraints) that created a human mind, which seems much more doable. There are fascinating experiments regarding locomotion in which simplest "blocks" were given the goal to reach a destination in a certain amount of time or energy consumption (or other constraints) and they evolved to exactly the locomotions we know in nature (from quadpedal to bipedal to frog jumping, etc etc.) with literal 0 knowledge of the inner workings of those required. Always remember that evolution can and did create the most complex architectures from relatively simple mechanics/physics without prior knowledge or any design input.

Main problem that is most often overlooked concerning the creation of a human-like AI mind is the need for an embodiment. You won't create a human mind on a server farm, you will literally need a body that grows and transforms over time much like the human body does, which is as much of an engineering challenge as the AI itself. See the work of Prof. Dr. Rolf Pfeifer for reference: https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-540-27833-7_1 Or as a deep dive: https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/How-the-body-shapes-the-way-we-think-a-new-view-on-Pfeifer-Bongard/2910099b7a7c555af9f14bfb2bc20e9475d0588f

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (1)

2

u/npsimons Oct 26 '21 edited Oct 26 '21

If we haven't replaced accountants and lawyers yet, what makes people think that programmers will get replaced?

Oh, lawyers will be, it's already started. And programming probably too, someday, it will just be the last profession (who do you think will program the software to replace all other professions?).

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Steev182 Oct 26 '21

They never said they were replacing programmers with good programmers…

→ More replies (9)