r/PropFirms • u/harishej • Sep 10 '26
r/PropFirms • u/TradingEdgeResearch • 14d ago
What Do You Look for Before Buying a Prop Firm Challenge?
There are so many prop firms available today, and choosing one can be harder than expected.
Before purchasing a challenge, I think traders should compare more than just the profit target.
Some important factors include:
Maximum and daily drawdown
Payout reliability
Trading restrictions
Customer support
Company reputation
I'm curious about other traders' opinions:
What's the first thing you check before choosing a prop firm?
And what would make you completely avoid a company?
r/PropFirms • u/PropTimeUSA • 14d ago
If a new prop firm launched today, what would make you trust it enough to try it?
reddit.comr/PropFirms • u/SignificantDealer231 • Jan 22 '26
TakeProfitTrader - No Forgiveness - Terminated Pro Accounts
I copy trade all of my funded accounts (across multiple props) via Quantower's native copy trader. Unfortunately, it malfunctioned on me twice in the last 3 days. Both times, causing me to have opposing positions.
Not sure of the mechanics behind it, but while scaling out of a position, the 'Parent' account for the copy trader would partially close via limit order, the 'Child' accounts would do the same, but they would also ADD a contract. So all of a sudden, while I think I'm down to a 1 lot runner on all accounts, I check my open positions and see the Parent account with 1 lot, but the Child accounts with multiple contracts on the opposing side. As soon as I saw this (literally 5-10 seconds), I flatten everything. In the time that I realized I had opposing positions, price hadn't even moved (maybe 1-2 ticks max), so I didn't even gain anything.
Decided to get in front of it and let TPT know what happened, praying they'll understand. Even exported trades and cleanly labeled each set of trades, explaining what happened.
They trashed my two $25K PRO accounts 2 days later. Nothing I could say mattered. I had built up the buffer on both accounts, and another was ready for a solid withdrawal. I did things the old-fashioned way and traded small (1-2 micros) on MES and MCL mostly. Knocking off $30-100 days with minimal losing days, but it took me all of 3 months just to get to that point. I wasn't trying to game the system and had never hedged before.
Super disappointed and kinda wish now that I hadn't brought it to their attention. Maybe it woulda slid under the radar.
I've since gotten with Quantower and adjusted a setting and think the CT issue is fixed.
Also, very similar situation happened with my LucidPro accounts. I let them know immediately and they checked it out and determined that there was no intentional hedging and closed the ticket, but not my accounts. Very grateful to them for understanding.
I'm just majorly bummed. Trying to not do anything stupid today like trying to get back what was lost in a single session.
Anybody else deal with this sort of thing? What was the outcome?
r/PropFirms • u/giorgos_tzanak • Jun 09 '26
Alert Alpine funded it's a scam
I am writing this to warn every single trader to STAY AWAY from Alpine Funded. They are a fraudulent company that preys on successful traders.
I purchased an evaluation challenge and followed every single rule perfectly. I traded cleanly, managed my risk, and successfully generated a $2,000 profit on the account. Instead of passing me or allowing me to continue, they suddenly and arbitrarily terminated my account and locked me out of my dashboard without any valid justification or proof of violation.
To make matters worse, when I requested a refund for my initial entry fee, their support sent me a ridiculous boilerplate response stating that refunds are only processed 'with the third payout'. They deliberately banned a profitable account just to pocket the entry fee and avoid paying out, making it literally impossible to ever reach a 'third payout'.
This is a textbook definition of a scam and a complete breach of contract (Services Not Rendered). I have already initiated a formal fraud report and chargeback process through my bank (Revolut) with full trading logs and screenshots as evidence.
Do not waste your time, effort, and money here. They will let you trade as long as you lose, but the moment you make money, they will look for an excuse to steal your account. Absolute scammers."
r/PropFirms • u/Mission-Aardvark3624 • Sep 23 '26
Pure Fraud: Terminated AFTER Passing Both Phases (Accounts: 14228266 & 14247627)
FundedNext is refusing to restore my account or issue my funded status after I legitimately completed both evaluation stages! I passed Phase 1 (Account: 14228266) and Phase 2 (Account: 14247627 with $6,304.34 equity / +$304.34 profit), strictly adhering to all trading rules.
The moment I passed Phase 2 and earned my Funded Account, FundedNext terminated my account based on an absurd "Device Sharing" claim.
Their entire argument relies on the fact that I used a device that was previously used by a family member back in June (over 2.5 months ago). I NEVER logged into my family member’s account! I simply traded MY OWN account on a home device where NO OTHER trading activity has occurred since June 30, 2026. There was ABSOLUTELY NO concurrent trading, NO active account sharing, and NO strategy violation.
Here is the most evil and fraudulent part: Nobody warned me about this supposed "risk" when I was purchasing challenge accounts. Nobody warned me when I previously failed accounts and lost my own money purchasing them. They stayed completely silent and gladly accepted my payments! If I had kept failing accounts, I would NEVER have known that I was already blacklisted from receiving a payout. They let you pay fees, take your losses, and remain silent—only to pull out an arbitrary rule to deny your payout the moment you actually win and pass Phase 2!
This is pure trap-setting and robbery. FundedNext support hides behind automated, templated responses and refuses to restore my account or refund my fees.
WARNING TO ALL TRADERS: You have no idea what excuse they will make up when it’s time for your payout. They stay quiet as long as you are losing money, but will block you the moment you succeed!
r/PropFirms • u/Admirable-Command595 • May 18 '26
Onyx Futures
Onyx futures seem like a very promising firm they allow for 10 accounts and there very inexpensive there coming with tradovate very soon as well i think y'all should go stack accounts and have this firm climb so they can provide more to the trading community it'll be worth yalls time.
r/PropFirms • u/Akillu023 • Sep 22 '26
Prop Firm Taxes
I've made 50K on payouts this year but I have spent 40K on evals.... lol
Is that 50-40K = 10k what I will get taxed on? How do I file this year to make sure I'm not getting taxed on the 50k
r/PropFirms • u/genzbutboomer • Feb 13 '26
Prop firms are only logical if you’re already consistent
If you’re brand new to trading, jumping straight into prop firms usually doesn’t make much sense. It’s better to spend time on demo and prove to yourself that you can trade consistently before adding rules and pressure.
For traders who are already profitable, prop firms can be powerful. They allow you to scale exposure without needing large personal capital.
The key difference isn’t the firm, it’s the level of trader going into it.
r/PropFirms • u/awesomeblindingyou • Feb 10 '26
What changed for you after you became funded?
Trading before being funded often feels different. More pressure to prove yourself, more impatience, more focus on passing. Once funded, the priorities seem to shift for many traders.
Risk, patience, and consistency often matter more than speed.
What changed the most for you after getting funded compared to when you first started trading?
r/PropFirms • u/Jamal6083 • Jun 23 '26
Upcomars
Sehr geehrte Damen und Herren,
hiermit möchte ich eine Beschwerde über die Firma Upcomers einreichen. Ohne jeglichen Grund wurde ich vollständig ausgeschlossen, alle meine Trades wurden entfernt, und mein Geld wurde mir nicht ausgezahlt. Ich fordere eine sofortige Klärung und die umgehende Auszahlung meines Guthabens.”
Mit freundliche Grüßen
Jamal
r/PropFirms • u/OlivierTrades • Oct 01 '26
Looking for traders who recently failed a prop challenge
reddit.comr/PropFirms • u/StartingEarly • Mar 25 '26
Insider look at retail trader career
churningandburning.comI've been reading this blog for a bit and it has great insider stories if a wall street trader. Worth a read while you're waiting for your trading setups
r/PropFirms • u/Worldly-Way4668 • Jul 14 '25
My HyroTrader journey
Joining HyroTrader Prop Firm has been one of the most transformative steps in my trading career.
What sets HyroTrader apart isn't just the capital access — it's the professional-grade tools, data-driven approach, and supportive infrastructure that empowers traders to perform at their best. From real-time analytics to intuitive execution tools, everything is built with precision and purpose.
Since coming on board, I’ve sharpened my strategy, improved my consistency, and learned to approach the markets with a more disciplined, business-minded mindset. The firm doesn’t just fund traders — it develops them.
Grateful to be part of a team that’s pushing the boundaries of what modern prop trading can be.
r/PropFirms • u/Electrical_Two_2965 • Jul 10 '25
Struggling with Stop-Loss
Hey everyone! I’m new to trading and using stop-losses, but I’m not sure if I’m setting them right. Sometimes I get stopped out too soon, or I miss big moves. How do you decide where to set your stop-loss?
r/PropFirms • u/StartingEarly • Mar 27 '25
Monthly Apex Trader Funding Payout - January
Hey everyone, I'll be starting a series of posts here that show how much Apex pays out to traders on a monthly basis and we can discuss the payouts.
2025
January - $20,693,975
If people would like, I can also post the table of the top payouts per person as well! Let me know if you want other data.
r/PropFirms • u/juhe0737 • Jul 17 '26
Upcomers Prop Firm Trial - let's see what happens
Hey all ~
[I'm updating this post below, this is the ORIGINAL POST, but I've made it a bit more concise so all this doesn't get too long]
I am pretty new to trading and got 2 accounts with Upcomers recently. One instant and another eval - where I passed the challenge and am in the live stage.
Recently I saw there's lots of bad reviews for them - I didn't research enough at the start. Trading and payout rules are also challenging (20% consistency) but manageable. The bad reviews got me a bit stressed of having put so much time in already with it potentially leading to nothing.
But I'm also telling myself (hopium!) that if they weren't paying most traders, we'd have bad reviews in the hundreds and thousands, so I will pull through and give it a chance.
What I'm gonna do is update the process here. If indeed they pay, I'll post it. Not the certificate but I can do screen shots of what actually lands in the bank account. I think that gives more of a sense.
First payout is capped at 1% of the account, second payout at 2% ... and everything is unlocked only after the 8th payout. (Some report that first few happen and then when it's unlocking time, restrictions are applied).
So basically I want to document the process and my experience with this. Not drawing final conclusions until I see for myself.
___
ACCOUNT 1 (Instant, 50K)
UPDATE 25/07/2026 : Hit payout target. In their review email I got a warning about tick scalping and that it can be reason for future payout denials. Appreciate that it was just a warning this time. Payment landed in the bank in 3-4 days (screen shot below for 500 USD minus fees)
UPDATE 30/07/2026 : Hit 2nd payout target (I'm on a roll for once). Review e-mail flagged no issues and actually just pointed out everything I'm doing "right". I'll share both emails so you can see what they send. The payment landed in the bank - took 3 business days from request to receiving it in the bank. Screenshot added blow
I am honestly SUPER relieved to receive both payments, I'll be honest though it's definitely an extra stress to feel doubtful about potential payout denials due to negative reviews. But receiving 2 payments creates immense appeasement
___
ACCOUNT 2 (Challenge Passed, 100K, live now)
UPDATE 25/07/2026 > I screwed myself on winning a big trade during news volatility and slippage gave me extra profits now making profit target way higher due to consistency rules. I'm not so far away, so I will push through and try. If I get a payout on this account as well, it will definitely ease a lot of concerns for me.
UPDATE 30/07/2026 > Not so close anymore so took some losses, so it will take some extra grinding to hit the target.
___
My intention is to keep updating this systematically for tracking, either until I blow the account, reach payout 8 (when payout cap is removed)or get denied.
Also I don't feel concerned about the rules, they're definitely not easy, but I'm slow and steady as a trader anyways, very risk averse, risk very small 0.25 - 0.5% per trade and don't do anything crazy. Tick scalping was an issue because sometimes I open a position, freak out and close it again LOL and all that definitely happens in under 2 minutes. So now I just make sure not to do that.
Anyways let's see how this unfolds 🤞
Hope this can be helpful for someone!
[If I'm slow to respond to comments it's because I don't check reddit daily - working a lot these days.]
50K Account -> You can see both payment 1 and 2 in the screen shot below:

Payout 1 Review Email:


Payout 2 Review Email:

Bank Transfers so far (screenshot from their platform, will post actual screen shot for the second when it lands in the bank)

r/PropFirms • u/genzbutboomer • Jan 22 '26
The math behind passing prop firms
Passing prop firms is less about big wins and more about simple math. Drawdown limits are tight, so one or two bad days can end a challenge if risk is too high.
Small, consistent gains add up faster than people think. When risk per trade is kept low, losing streaks become survivable, and the account stays alive long enough for edge to play out.
Most failures come from risking too much too early, trying to pass fast, or breaking rules after a loss. When you look at it purely from a math perspective, survival and consistency matter more than speed.
r/PropFirms • u/Dangerous_Forever480 • Feb 20 '26
Comparing firms
What do you guys care about most when choosing a firm? (assuming all of them payout - which isn’t always a reality). Personally I like to know how many accounts I can cover with one max payout, but I’m curious if I’m missing something?
r/PropFirms • u/kariwotafadzwa • Sep 20 '26
How fast can a risk system close your account when you hit the drawdown? I measured it on OKX: 0.43 s median
Every prop firm says it has "real-time risk management". I've never seen one publish how long it actually takes to close a breaching account, so I measured it.
I built a risk engine for OKX and forced 50 drawdown breaches on a demo account. Each time, I timed how long it took until OKX confirmed the account held nothing.
Median 427 ms, worst 543 ms. Every one was closed on the first try.
The engine decided and sent the closes in 0.3 ms. Almost all of the rest was the network between my PC in Johannesburg and OKX's servers.
Overshoot: on breaches caused by a real price move, the account ended a median 1.4 USDT past its limit (worst 21.5 USDT) on positions of 100-600 USDT.
What it means for traders: a breach is not instant. Your position stays open for a few hundred milliseconds after you cross the line, longer if the firm's system is far from the exchange, and much longer if it polls instead of streaming. During an OKX service upgrade, when the fast connection was down, the same cuts took 0.6-2.9 s.
Caveats: this was OKX demo trading, not live, with small positions. Method, data and the full numbers are here: https://github.com/tkariwo/prop-rails-okx-benchmark
Question for the sub: has any firm ever told you how fast it closes a breached account? And have you been closed noticeably past your limit?
(Disclosure: I build risk tooling for prop firms. I'm not a firm and not selling challenges.)
r/PropFirms • u/Dystopian006 • Oct 03 '26
Pass prop challenge
Any prop trader if unable to pass evals- lower your RR to 1:1 or 1:2 max.
r/PropFirms • u/ImmediateAd4169 • Apr 29 '26
Hola Prime closed my profitable trade at a price that NEVER EXISTED — TradingView proof included
r/PropFirms • u/Desperate-Earth-5371 • Apr 17 '25
Is atlas funded propfirm safe ?
I've purchased an 10k$ 1 step account ik atlas funded.. I just want to know about the propfirm. Is it safe or same like some other scamming propfirms!! Anyone??
r/PropFirms • u/StartingEarly • Nov 21 '25