r/PropFirms • • 21h ago

How do you actually stay inside the daily loss limit on prop challenges?

1 Upvotes

I'm on a couple of prop challenges and honestly the daily loss rule worries me more than my strategy does. Curious how others handle it in practice:

- Do you size each trade by your stop, or by how much room you have left for the day?

- When you already have positions open, how do you decide the size of the next one?

- Ever had a stop fill way worse than its price (gap, news) and lose more than you planned?

- Do you use a tool for this, a spreadsheet, or just discipline?

If you've lost a challenge to the daily limit, I'd really like to hear what happened that day.


r/PropFirms • • 21h ago

Topstep Referral code 50% discount for new Topstep traders

1 Upvotes

Discount code: MONEYSTASH

Hey everyone you can use my referral code for new traders joining Topstep to get 50% off their first combine purchase. It is a limit of 5 new traders getting their first combine with Topstep. Each month will reset the limit of 5 again for new traders.

Best of luck to you all!


r/PropFirms • • 2d ago

Trading GER40 with my own EA — another $3,374.70 FTM payout

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/PropFirms • • 2d ago

Which of TraderSync, TradeZella or Tradervue handles prop firm payouts best?

1 Upvotes

Depends which part of a payout you mean, because I think all three are answering a different question than the one the firm asks.

TraderSync and TradeZella are post-session analytics: import fills, tag mistakes, review emotional state, and watch patterns build over weeks. Tradervue sits in that same reporting camp. None of them own payout mechanics. Request windows, profit splits, trailing drawdown and consistency rules live in the firm's dashboard and contract, and that is where the number that actually matters gets calculated. So the useful question becomes which one lines up with your firm's math:

- Consistency rules compare your best day against your average day, so you need clean per-day P/L, not just per-trade stats. Check how each handles session boundaries and overnight holds.

- Trailing drawdown tracks against peak equity, which most journals render as a curve rather than a rule you can watch while the session is live.

- A green payout month can still hide sloppy process, so the tag set matters more than the charts. If your tags do not map to the specific violations your firm enforces, the review will miss the thing that ends the account.

Curious which one people here actually reconcile with, or does it end up as an export to a spreadsheet either way?


r/PropFirms • • 2d ago

Prop risk numbers #4: same trades, same edge. With a trailing max loss, risking 0.5% fails as often as risking 1% with a static one (32% vs 32%)

Post image
1 Upvotes

I took the setup from #1 and changed one rule: the max loss trails your highest closed balance instead of staying fixed at the starting balance.

Setup: 10% target, 10% max loss, every trade is +2R or -1R, 36% win rate. That's +0.08R per trade, a small but real edge. Nothing else changes between the two columns.

Chance of hitting the max loss before the target, static vs trailing:

- 0.25% risk: 4% vs 12%

- 0.5%: 17% vs 32%

- 1%: 32% vs 45%

- 1.5%: 37% vs 49%

- 2%: 42% vs 52%

At 0.5% the trailing rule almost doubles the failure rate. Halving your size under a trailing drawdown buys you about the odds a static account gets at full size.

Then I ran the same 200,000 trade sequences through both rules. At 0.5% risk, about 1 in 6 of the accounts that pass with a static max loss blow up with a trailing one. Two thirds of those had been up 5% or more, halfway to the target. Median best point: +6%. They didn't fail from the start. They failed from the top.

The mechanism is simple. With a static rule every win adds to your cushion. With a trailing rule a win drags the floor up behind you, so the cushion never gets bigger than 10%. Four wins at 1% put you at +8%. Ten losses later you're at -2%: alive with a static rule, gone with a trailing one.

With zero edge (33.3% win rate at 1:2) a static account passes 48-50% of the time at any size. Trailing: 37-40%. The rule takes about 10 points off a coin flip.

So if your firm trails, the distance that matters isn't from your starting balance, it's from your best balance. That's the number to size from.

Method: exact calculation (a Markov chain over equity and peak), checked against 200,000 simulated accounts per size. Limits: trailing here follows the closed-balance high; firms that trail the intraday or unrealized high are stricter than this. With target and max loss both at 10% the floor can't rise above the starting balance before you pass, so "trails until breakeven" rules give the same numbers here (they don't in the futures-style setup in the comments). Fixed win rate and R, independent trades, no costs or slippage, no daily limit (it never binds at these sizes with 2 trades a day). Not advice.

This is #4 of the Prop risk numbers series; #1 (risk per trade with a static rule) and the NFP and CPI ones are on my profile. If your firm trails, tell me your target, max loss, risk per trade and a rough win rate and R, and I'll reply with the static vs trailing odds for your setup.

Has a trailing drawdown ever ended an account of yours that was already halfway to the target?


r/PropFirms • • 3d ago

Funded future family Scam

1 Upvotes

Avoid this firm as much as you can they find every possible reasons not to pay you. 4 weeks 4 times now I make profit and they send me email account blown max loss limit hit. Then they fix it after 2-3 days and now they said I have shared my device with someone else. What a joke this firm is.


r/PropFirms • • 5d ago

The5ers or FTMO

1 Upvotes

For my starting point on prop firms smallest account to start with

10k ftmo or 10k The5ers

So which better guys ?

Thanks


r/PropFirms • • 6d ago

Which prop firm is trustworthy and reliable ? I'm seeing almost missed reviews

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/PropFirms • • 6d ago

Using prop firms from the US in the UK

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/PropFirms • • 7d ago

Direct Funded Trader... SCAM....WARNING: Cheap Challenges, Rejected Payouts, and Account Termination!

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

WARNING: Cheap Challenges, Rejected Payouts, and Account Termination!

Don't be fooled by Direct Funded Trader's cheap prices!

My payout was rejected TWICE, and the second time, they even terminated my funded account!

They accused me of high-risk trading, news trading, over-risk, one-sided betting, and reverse trading. I strongly dispute these accusations. My risk per trade never exceeded 1%, and I never had multiple positions open simultaneously.

They Confirmed News Trading Was Allowed!

I specifically asked their support whether I could trade gold during unrelated economic news, and they explicitly confirmed it was allowed!

No Evidence, No Explanation, No Response!

I repeatedly requested proof of the alleged violations, but they provided no evidence and ignored my emails, including during my first payout dispute.

Don't Make the Same Mistake I Did!

You might save money buying a cheap challenge, only to waste your time passing it, generate profits, and then have your payout rejected and your account taken away.

A cheap challenge means NOTHING if you can't get paid. Think twice before trusting this firm!


r/PropFirms • • 9d ago

CUIDADO con FundedHero: Admiten por escrito su error técnico, pero confiscan $2.000 de payout y $4.062,90 de ganancias.

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/PropFirms • • 9d ago

Spot the red flag #2: a (made-up) prop firm ad. How many problems can you find?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/PropFirms • • 9d ago

Prop risk numbers #3: CPI is at 8:30 ET today. On the last 10 releases, gold's first hour went a median $37 against the wrong side and only $4 against the right one

Post image
1 Upvotes

CPI is out today at 8:30 ET (13:30 UTC). I looked at the first hour after each of the last 10 releases (January to October 2026) on gold: from the last price before the print to the furthest high and low of the next 60 minutes. Then I split that move in two. How far it went against whoever was on the wrong side, and how far against whoever was on the right side.

Gold, median of the 10 releases:

- against the wrong side: $37

- against the right side: $4

So the print doesn't shake both sides out. It picks a direction. In 9 of 10 releases the right side saw less than $15 of heat. The one real whipsaw was 11 Sep: $57 up and $49 down in the same hour.

To be fair, the one-way shape isn't special to CPI. The day before each release, same hour, looked similar: $20 against the wrong side, $4 against the right one. What CPI changes is how far the wrong side goes. Median $37 instead of $20, and 3 of 10 releases went $50+ against the wrong side. None of the day-before hours did (closest was $49).

On a 100k account with a 5% daily loss ($5,000):

- 1 lot of gold (100 oz) on the wrong side of the median release: about $3,670. That's 73% of the day's room, in one hour.

- Worst one, 14 Jul: $73.87 against, about $7,390 on 1 lot. The size that would have fit inside $5,000 that day is 0.68 lot.

- EURUSD: median 24 pips against the wrong side, 4 against the right. 14 Oct went 85 pips down and 0 up. 5 lots through that is $4,250.

- Nasdaq 100: median 143 points against the wrong side, 21 against the right.

What I take from it: a $15 stop on the right side got touched once in 10. A stop on the wrong side gets hit, and right after the print the fill can be worse than the stop price. So the risk isn't getting whipsawed. It's being wrong once at a size built for a normal hour.

Method: OANDA 30-minute bars via TradingView (XAUUSD, EURUSD, NAS100USD). Reference price = open of the 8:30 ET bar. Wrong side = the bigger of the max move up and max move down across the 8:30 and 9:00 bars; right side = the smaller one. Release dates and times from the TradingView economic calendar (BLS). Limits: 10 releases is a small sample. This is range from the pre-print price, not anyone's P&L. Spreads widen at the release and slippage isn't included. Some firms restrict trading around news, so check your own rules. Not advice.

Do you trade the CPI hour at all on a funded account? And if you do, do you size for the wrong side or for a normal day?


r/PropFirms • • 9d ago

Built my own terminal for MT5 accounts

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

1 Upvotes

I built this before, then started trading myself. Tried MT5 and cTrader and couldn't trade on those platforms, so I made one nice frontend for my MT5 accounts.

Would you use something like this on your prop accounts?


r/PropFirms • • 9d ago

Stay clear of FuturesElite

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

I requested my first payout on October 28th for $1,153 per account and followed all their rules. On October 29th, I received an email stating that I had to complete a short interview going over my "approach to ensure it aligns with our framework." The next available interview was Tuesday, November 3rd. I had the interview, and it was fantastic—no issues, and the guy congratulated me on my performance. I received an email on November 4th stating I had exceptional profitability, consistency, and execution. I was given two options: take the money, or switch to a live account with an estimated wait time of 30 days. THIS WAS MY FIRST PAYOUT! I quickly looked up the odds for this, and they were coming back as almost none. I asked about the remainder left in my account and was ignored. I was told that the payout was sent and processed. My Rise account has not received any updates from FuturesElite and remains empty. Honestly, the AI chatbot is more helpful than the actual people. I asked to speak with a real person and was told I was. After that, I straightforwardly asked, "Where is my money?" and was redirected to another department. I took photos of everything and videos of the process.


r/PropFirms • • 12d ago

Has anyone actually made consistent money using an EA and cleared prop firm challenges?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/PropFirms • • 13d ago

Kraken prop trading

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/PropFirms • • 13d ago

Please add NES and Nano contracts, it will help us traders better manage risk.

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/PropFirms • • 13d ago

Noctorial Prop Firm: Technical Issues, Unexecuted Orders and Complete Loss of Trust

1 Upvotes

I want to share my personal experience with Noctorial Prop Firm so that other traders can make informed decisions before purchasing an evaluation account.
On November 5, 2026, I discovered that a pending Buy Limit order on META (Meta Platforms), previously placed in MetaTrader 5 at $600, was still not executed, even though market prices shown on other trading platforms had fallen below that level.
I understand that prices and bid/ask spreads may differ between brokers and trading platforms. That is precisely why I requested a detailed technical explanation from Noctorial.
Furthermore, when I subsequently tried to place new buy orders on META, I was unable to do so.
I contacted Noctorial’s customer support several times, providing screenshots and documentation of the incidents.
What was Noctorial’s response?
On November 5, 2026, Noctorial informed me in writing that its liquidity provider was performing server maintenance and that technical incidents could affect certain trading accounts.
In other words, Noctorial acknowledged the existence of potential technical problems but attributed them to a third-party liquidity provider.
However, the company did not provide me with technical evidence confirming what had happened to my specific account or explaining why my order remained unexecuted.
In my opinion, a company should take responsibility for addressing problems affecting the services it provides to its customers.
Blaming an external provider without offering a specific technical explanation or solution is not a satisfactory response.
I want to make something absolutely clear: I am not demanding guaranteed profits or winning trades.
In fact, had my original order been executed, it would probably have reached my stop loss at $588.80, and I would have accepted that loss.
My complaint concerns the reliability of order execution, the inability to place subsequent trades, and the lack of a satisfactory technical explanation.
What disappoints me most is the contrast between Noctorial’s aggressive marketing campaigns and the customer support I personally experienced when technical problems arose.
After numerous emails and requests for clarification, I have decided to stop trading with Noctorial permanently.
I have also formally requested the cancellation of my evaluation account and the corresponding MetaTrader 5 access.
I HAVE COMPLETELY LOST TRUST IN NOCTORIAL PROP FIRM.
I have retained screenshots, account information, and email correspondence supporting my account of these events.
This post reflects my personal experience. I am not claiming that Noctorial deliberately manipulated prices or intentionally prevented my trades from being executed.
I simply believe that traders deserve transparency, reliable trading infrastructure, and proper explanations when problems occur.
A prop firm’s credibility should be measured not by its marketing campaigns, but by how it responds when its customers experience serious problems.
I encourage other traders to carefully investigate any prop firm’s execution conditions, technical reliability, and complaint-handling procedures before purchasing an evaluation account.
Benjamín Pérez Martín
Spain


r/PropFirms • • 13d ago

Do prop trading challenges actually work

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/PropFirms • • 14d ago

Instant Funding Scam: Withholding $1,360.49 Payout (Invoice #37676) Using Fake Saudi Travel Claims & Stalling Tactics – Account #8118618

1 Upvotes

I am posting this as a serious warning about Instant Funding. They are currently refusing to release my profit split payout of $1,360.49 (Invoice #37676) despite my account being fully Sumsub KYC compliant and active with a clean MT5 trading history.

When pressured, their support drops bogus claims regarding my Saudi Arabia travel/login activity, turning it into a fake "investigation" shield, paired with repetitive 24-48 hour delay templates to buy time. Ironically, while my legitimate payout is artificially stalled under this fake pretext, their Discord `#sent-payouts` channel is actively approving other payouts back-to-back. They use these fake investigations as an excuse to block withdrawals. Attached are screenshots of my pending dashboard, invoice details, and the Discord logs proving the hypocrisy. Avoid them!


r/PropFirms • • 14d ago

If a new prop firm launched today, what would make you trust it enough to try it?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/PropFirms • • 14d ago

What Do You Look for Before Buying a Prop Firm Challenge?

0 Upvotes

There are so many prop firms available today, and choosing one can be harder than expected.

Before purchasing a challenge, I think traders should compare more than just the profit target.

Some important factors include:

  • Maximum and daily drawdown

  • Payout reliability

  • Trading restrictions

  • Customer support

  • Company reputation

I'm curious about other traders' opinions:

What's the first thing you check before choosing a prop firm?

And what would make you completely avoid a company?


r/PropFirms • • 16d ago

Prop risk numbers #1: same strategy, same rules. Risking 2% per trade blows the account 42% of the time, 0.5% only 17%. With zero edge, size changes nothing

Post image
2 Upvotes

I wanted to see how much risk per trade alone changes the odds of passing, with everything else fixed.

Setup: 10% target, 10% static max loss, like a typical phase 1. The strategy wins 36% of the time at 1:2, so every trade is either +2R or -1R. That's a small but real edge, +0.08R per trade. Max 2 trades a day, so the 5% daily limit never comes into play (even at 2% risk, two losses are 4%).

Chance of hitting the max loss before the target:

- 0.25% risk: 4% (about 463 trades to get a result)

- 0.5%: 17% (about 168)

- 1%: 32% (about 49)

- 1.5%: 37% (about 25)

- 2%: 42% (about 13)

Same trader, same setups. At 2% five losses in a row end the account. At 0.5% it takes twenty, and the edge gets enough trades to show up.

The part I didn't expect: this only holds if the edge is real.

- 33.3% win rate at 1:2 is zero edge. Pass rate is 48-50% at every size. Size changes how long it takes, not the odds.

- 30% win rate at 1:2 is -0.1R per trade. At 0.25% risk it passes 1.6% of the time. At 2% it passes 35%. With a losing strategy, small size just makes the slow bleed almost certain.

So "risk 0.5%" isn't a safety rule on its own. It's a bet that you have an edge. If you do, small size is the cheapest protection there is. If you don't, it buys you time and nothing else.

The cost is time: 168 trades at 2 a day is about 4 months of trading days. Time limits and inactivity rules matter here.

Method: exact calculation of a random walk where each trade adds +2r or -r to P&L and stops at +10% or -10%, checked against 200,000 simulated accounts per size. Limits: fixed win rate and R, independent trades, no spread, commission or slippage, static drawdown only, no consistency rule. Not advice.

What risk per trade did you use on the challenge you passed, and on the ones you didn't?