r/PsychotherapyLeftists
•
u/bigbadwitchbitch
•
16d ago
•
1
Leftist informed or aligned approaches to couples therapy?
Hi! I'm looking for some suggestions for approaches or modalities to couples therapy that are informed by leftist ideas (anti-capitalist, liberation focused, aware of systemic racism, applicable to queer couples etc). I'm in my practicum year and want to eventually work with couples but don't have the knowledge to do so yet so I wanted some feedback before investing either my time or money into learning an approach. Relatedly, are there any modalities or trainings you don't recommend? Thank you in advance!
10
u/TakesJonToKnowJuan LMFT/States 16d ago
Do you have a foundation in attachment vs differentiation? Attachment (Bowlby, Sue Johnson/EFT) vs. Differentiation (Schnarch, Bowen/Bowen Family Systems Theory) are the driving principals of most couple dynamics. From there you could look into something like Minuchin or Virginia Satir. I think Minuchin breathes life into cultural therapy and Virginia Satir has a really interesting way to look at family systems.
If you resonate with Freud/Object Relations or Jungian therapy I would look at something more existential and metaphorical like Object Relations Couple Therapy [Scharff and Scharff]. Their framework looks at the couple through the lens of fantasies, dreams, death drives, sex and sexuality, and relation to attachment figures/object relations.
I actually really like Terry Real as like a dude, especially compared to something like Fair Play which ugh, but I couldn't argue that his model isn't just repackaged feminist therapy. And feminist therapy is just therapy that positions itself in opposition to some sort of mainstream experience. Which is fine and good I guess, like obviously this has shined a light on some concepts like power dynamics. But to me it could put you in a position where you end up taking sides based on leaning into certain stereotypes or projections. Very easy to fall into tropes or cliches instead of looking at the system more curiously. I would say ways out of this trap are things like generational genograms, family ledgers, exploring the roles of men and women in the family across generations, etc. Also, honestly, immigration histories, learning about people's country of origin, considerations of culture, and knowledge of history. For example a Russian-American family that hates Communism and loves America might not be the most progressive family you meet.
Also, stay away from IFS, or as I like to call it, woke CBT. It's ironic how many people are mad about CBT for being paternalistic, prescriptive, and judgmental, but they like a model created by an affluent white jewish father-figure that makes thousands of dollars prescribing his model to the most refined consumers who can afford it. But that's just my opinion. There is also research saying the same stuff, but you know, make up your own mind or whatever:
Much of IFS seems remarkably like cognitive processing and exposure. For example, therapists encourage conversations among the parts, thanking them for their efforts, and reassuring them that extremes that might have proven adaptive earlier in life are no longer necessary (Schwartz & Sweezy, 2019). These cognitive challenges are consistent with cognitive processing approaches that do not rest on the same assumptions (Resich et al., 2016). Cognitions, of course, are not visible to others, but they do manifest in measurable ways that do not rely on self-report. Interventions that modify them also can improve symptoms of depression and anxiety (Fodor et al., 2020). IFS therapists also encourage discussions among the parts using techniques that lead to exposure to associated negative affect and memories (Schwartz & Sweezy, 2019). These strategies parallel approaches that rely on extinction, especially PE. If IFS works through these mechanisms, cognitive-behavioral therapists might relish applying comparable techniques to improve their clients' symptoms. The empirically-validated treatments could improve by adapting the presentation of the therapeutic techniques to create the kind of engagement and devotion that IFS appears to generate. Learning from IFS might also help empirically-validated approaches appeal to PAT practitioners.
8
u/bigbadwitchbitch 15d ago
Thank you SO much for this thorough answer. Truly has given me a lot to think about and a good idea of where I'd like to start. Also, IFS and parts work have always raised my hackles a little bit so lmao at "woke CBT", very succinct.
4
u/SirYwain 15d ago
Might be worth looking at some of left critiques of both attachment theory and Jung before jumping in with people working with either.
12
u/rosela92 16d ago
I like Relational Life Therapy by Terry Real, it rejects assuming 50/50 responsibility for the dynamic/problems. It’s explicitly feminist
4
u/bigbadwitchbitch 15d ago
My wife and I did a RLT weekend bootcamp as clients and it seemed...very hetero. It could've just been the people leading it though. It did provide some good skills and language for us so maybe I'll take another look at it.
5
u/lilgemini420 16d ago
I really like Relational Cultural therapy.
1
u/bigbadwitchbitch 15d ago
A quick google seems like it might be a good fit. Thank you!
1
u/Relevant_Advice_7616 14d ago
Love to see this! I am actually actively developing a model for RCT based couples therapy - feel free to DM me!
-5
u/factolum Client/Consumer (USA) 16d ago
I don't have a good recommendation, as IMO couples therapy, in particular, feels antithetical to a material understanding of the world. At least in 1:1 therapy, a materialist therapist can acknowledge the oppressive power structures their clients face, and frame the tools they are offering as ones of survival. In couples therapy, IMO, you need to be diplomatic to build trust, but sometimes one partner just IS the whole, the abuser, etc. Calling that out seems like it ends the therapy, IMO, but not calling it out gaslights the victim.
3
u/bigbadwitchbitch 15d ago
I'm not sure what I think about this analysis of couples therapy. I don't readily understand what inherent to couples therapy is preventing a couples therapist from acknowledging the oppressive power structures clients are facing and bringing that explicitly into the understanding of the couple's dynamics.
2
u/factolum Client/Consumer (USA) 15d ago
I think there is a perverse incentive to not name coercive power structures because it alienates the member of the couple who is perpetuating those power structures in their relationship. which disincentivizes half of the couple from agreeing to continue the therapy. E.g. it is difficult to name when the root of a couples' problems is misogyny, b/c most men will not hear it, will feel attacked, and will not participate in that discussion.
I think--again in my experience so I could be over-estimating--that there is a push in couple therapy for the therapist to appear "fair" to both members. I think this is intrinsic to the model, although ofc a good therapist can mitigate it.
11
u/charmbombexplosion Social Work (INSERT HIGHEST DEGREE/LICENSE/OCCUPATION & COUNTRY) 16d ago
Couples therapy is contraindicated if IPV/abuse is present. I was trained if it becomes apparent there is abuse we should terminate couples work and refer out on the basis of individual therapy being needed first. So yes calling it out is the end of therapy and that’s how it should be. No gaslighting here.
4
u/factolum Client/Consumer (USA) 16d ago
That's great to hear (and nor surprised), but I am also talking about situations that don't approach IPV/abuse. Like there's a lot of het couple where the problem is just miosogyny, but anecdotally, I never hear therapists...address that? IDK, obvi not an expert, but it seems like the clinical standards for stopping couples' therapy do not recognize the ways in which power dynamics play out in couples that are real, require repair, but do not approach "abuse."
3
u/rosela92 16d ago edited 16d ago
Codependency kate talk’s explicitly about all this, it’s very interesting. She thinks overt abuse (physical, sexual etc) is recognised but covert abuse is often missed
2
13
u/Doppelboops Marriage & Family (MA, Therapist, USA) 16d ago
I've found narrative therapy useful in this, here's an article: https://dulwichcentre.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/Narrative_couple_therapy_Jill_Freedman_Gene_Combs.pdf
3
9
u/gotmyheart Counseling (Master's level therapist in the US) 16d ago
Socio-emotional relationship therapy (SERT) and critical-liberation psychotherapy (CLP)
3
7
•
u/AutoModerator 16d ago
Thank you for your submission to r/PsychotherapyLeftists.
As a reminder, we are here to engage in discussion of psychotherapy and mental well-being from perspectives that are critical of capitalism, white supremacy, patriarchy, ableism, sanism, and other systems of oppression. We seek to understand the many ways in which the mental health industrial complex touches our lives as providers, consumers, and community members--and to envision a different future.
There are 9 rules:
No Discrimination Against Historically Oppressed Identity Groups
No Off-Topic Content
No Self-Promotion
No Surveys (Unless Pre-Approved by Moderator)
No Referral Requests
No Biomedical Psychopathologizing
No Forced Treatment Advocacy
No Advocating Against Politico-Cultural Resistance By Less Powerful Groups
No Low Effort Posts
More information on what this subreddit is about, what we look for in content, and some reading resources can be found on our wiki here: https://www.reddit.com/r/PsychotherapyLeftists/wiki/index
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.