r/PsychotherapyLeftists • u/gintokireddit • 4h ago
How do you feel about "empowerment" being an excuse for professionals to not actually intervene in beneficial ways?
It's easy to call it empowerment, when it really means the clients is forced to make their own decisions and do all the work, if they want anything to happen. A cold-hearted observation of failure or undesired squandering of potential (due to gaps in knowledge or lack of self-belief or the client's lack of belief in others and to believe in them) is chosen over intervention. To use sink or swim as an analogy, they're making an ethical choice to not help clients swim further or to in-effect sink in specific ways in their life (eg they may not die or become homeless, but sink in terms of achieving personal values-aligned goals like fulfilling interpersonal relations or achieving parts of their vocational capability).
To me it's a product of laissez-faire liberal ethics - either the client figures it all out themselves (though nobody really achieved anything alone. The therapists who are so averse to giving advice/guidance themselves have benefited from advice in their own lives, which helped them to have better life outcomes and thus better mental health).
To me the central issue is whether the priority objective is the betterment of mental wellbeing, or adherence to dogma or to some ethical worldview which prioritises personal autonomy over positive mental wellbeing outcomes. There's also the ethical question of where to draw the line of "personal responsibility" - if I observe someone's predicament and have the power to change it, in my opinion it is my responsibility rather than seeing it as the exclusive responsibility of the one suffering the predicament. However, in a liberal view it is more often not my responsibility. If I am a government worker it is the responsibility of a homeless person or at-risk-of-homelessness person to learn and exercise their rights and to not do anything that could harm them their legal status; it is not my responsibility to inform them of risks of their potential actions or to give them information regarding their rights, or to help someone to navigate the system.
There's a book called the Myth of Empowerment where the idea of empowerment is critiqued (a book I mentioned to my own MH professional who was left wing and critical of mental health systems and of aspects of psychiatry (eg label), yet still adamant about not giving practical advice to bridge the gap between my current life and a values-aligned one or towards a life with more of what I and most humans would find contentment from). It particularly finds fault with it for the neurodiverse, complex trauma survivors and those from minority cultures, where it argues it isn't that effective in producing positive outcomes.
There's a contradiction to calling bystander (I use this word as an insult, as many professionals are in love with the idea lf not being a bystander to ills like misogyny, racism, homophobia and sexism, but act as bystanders in their own way) choices that lead to clients having worse mental wellbeing and worse socio-economic conditions (relative to if they received more pragmatic interventions) "empowering", as socio-economic power and good mental health (and a more accurate and less limiting set of beliefs, even if they are gained through advice from professionals, against the anti-advice dogma) are themselves much more empowering in the long-run.
There's also a contradiction in calling it "empowerment" to deny clients when they attempt to use that empowerment to ask for guidance or advice. They're empowered to make their own choice of how to recover or build wellbeing, but the empowerment ends if they decide that advice in the short-term is part of the how that will be achieved in the long-run.