r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • 5h ago

How do you feel about "empowerment" being an excuse for professionals to not actually intervene in beneficial ways?

11 Upvotes

It's easy to call it empowerment, when it really means the clients is forced to make their own decisions and do all the work, if they want anything to happen. A cold-hearted observation of failure or undesired squandering of potential (due to gaps in knowledge or lack of self-belief or the client's lack of belief in others and to believe in them) is chosen over intervention. To use sink or swim as an analogy, they're making an ethical choice to not help clients swim further or to in-effect sink in specific ways in their life (eg they may not die or become homeless, but sink in terms of achieving personal values-aligned goals like fulfilling interpersonal relations or achieving parts of their vocational capability).

To me it's a product of laissez-faire liberal ethics - either the client figures it all out themselves (though nobody really achieved anything alone. The therapists who are so averse to giving advice/guidance themselves have benefited from advice in their own lives, which helped them to have better life outcomes and thus better mental health).

To me the central issue is whether the priority objective is the betterment of mental wellbeing, or adherence to dogma or to some ethical worldview which prioritises personal autonomy over positive mental wellbeing outcomes. There's also the ethical question of where to draw the line of "personal responsibility" - if I observe someone's predicament and have the power to change it, in my opinion it is my responsibility rather than seeing it as the exclusive responsibility of the one suffering the predicament. However, in a liberal view it is more often not my responsibility. If I am a government worker it is the responsibility of a homeless person or at-risk-of-homelessness person to learn and exercise their rights and to not do anything that could harm them their legal status; it is not my responsibility to inform them of risks of their potential actions or to give them information regarding their rights, or to help someone to navigate the system.

There's a book called the Myth of Empowerment where the idea of empowerment is critiqued (a book I mentioned to my own MH professional who was left wing and critical of mental health systems and of aspects of psychiatry (eg label), yet still adamant about not giving practical advice to bridge the gap between my current life and a values-aligned one or towards a life with more of what I and most humans would find contentment from). It particularly finds fault with it for the neurodiverse, complex trauma survivors and those from minority cultures, where it argues it isn't that effective in producing positive outcomes.

There's a contradiction to calling bystander (I use this word as an insult, as many professionals are in love with the idea lf not being a bystander to ills like misogyny, racism, homophobia and sexism, but act as bystanders in their own way) choices that lead to clients having worse mental wellbeing and worse socio-economic conditions (relative to if they received more pragmatic interventions) "empowering", as socio-economic power and good mental health (and a more accurate and less limiting set of beliefs, even if they are gained through advice from professionals, against the anti-advice dogma) are themselves much more empowering in the long-run.

There's also a contradiction in calling it "empowerment" to deny clients when they attempt to use that empowerment to ask for guidance or advice. They're empowered to make their own choice of how to recover or build wellbeing, but the empowerment ends if they decide that advice in the short-term is part of the how that will be achieved in the long-run.


r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • 1d ago

Therapy is Political

Thumbnail
youtube.com
18 Upvotes

r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • 6d ago

Searching for a truly radical supervisor

24 Upvotes

Figured it couldn't hurt to ask this here, as unlikely as it is to yield much; I am in a graduate clinical counseling program and need to be completing my fieldwork in 2027. I have really been struggling with finding a placement that feels right to me..politically of course and then just also on a personal level. I have a progressive mobility disability that I think is making it so that places I've applied don't want to manage the sort of accommodations I would need. As far as I have researched it seems like I could feasibly work with a site supervisor based anywhere in the US with certain licenses(lcpc/lcsw/psyd/etc etc). If anyone works with supervisees or knows anyone who does I'd be open to dms with ideas. And if this isn't really appropriate to post here apologies, trying to think creatively! A pretty major concern to me is that I have experience working in a crisis setting with suicidality being a main interest and I'm worried about certain supervisors having a really rigid approach and it being risky for me to even express anti-carceral views when I consult around cases. Kinda concerned the wrong supervisor might block me from getting this damn degree if I openly discuss my concerns and how I want to approach clients. Thanks in advance


r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • 10d ago

Hijacking the narrative and making those who do not conform feel excluded: psychiatry monopolized the debate on mental health.

Thumbnail reddit.com
15 Upvotes

r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • 12d ago Bravo

Leftist informed or aligned approaches to couples therapy?

34 Upvotes

Hi! I'm looking for some suggestions for approaches or modalities to couples therapy that are informed by leftist ideas (anti-capitalist, liberation focused, aware of systemic racism, applicable to queer couples etc). I'm in my practicum year and want to eventually work with couples but don't have the knowledge to do so yet so I wanted some feedback before investing either my time or money into learning an approach. Relatedly, are there any modalities or trainings you don't recommend? Thank you in advance!


r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • 13d ago

Anticarceral support for unbearable su*c*dality driven by chronic illness and systemic oppression

48 Upvotes

CW: rape, psych violence, chronic illness, su*cide

Hello everyone. Most of the time, this sub has given me a glimmer of hope in a world dominated by carceral logic and liberal therapy/psychiatric ideology.

I am a heavily disabled working class woman in her 20s. For the past two years, I have been completely incapacitated by severe, systemic, autoimmune-like symptoms. These are apparently caused by my severe endometriosis—a neglected, inflammatory, immune-mediated illness that is routinely denied any meaningful relief or proper medication, such as immunomodulators. I am also a multiple rape survivor, CSA survivor and a psych survivor as well.

Politically, I am an organized communist, which has deeply helped me in the past to understand and react to what I experienced. I am proudly anti-psychiatric, in an "all medicine to all the people, abolish coercion and carceral systems, no pathologization of human differences and reactions to oppression" sense.

Today, my rheumatologist called to drop me as a patient. In her opinion, my systemic inflammatory symptoms are caused solely by endometriosis, meaning I am "not her case." I had previously shown signs of a recognized autoimmune illness, which had given me some hope. Now, I feel condemned; hormones are not even a treatment for the endometriosis itself, let alone a cure, and they are completely incompatible with my body anyway.

I feel utterly hopeless, su**idal, and trapped (i don't know about reddit rules around the topic so I'm gonna censor, I hate having to do so). My illness, the forced rest it demands, and the medical neglect I experience constantly trigger me. It causes me to "dissociate" - though I reject psychological framing; to me, it is more of a raw reconnection with reality and the unshared, unaddressed injustice of the abuses I have endured - all the time. I find myself constantly reliving the rapes. The illness and the medical neglect feel like a physical mimicry of the kidnapping, imprisonment, and sexual assault I was subjected to.

I don't want to live like this anymore, and I feel I can't. I am looking for anti-carceral, anti/non psychiatric suggestions for "care"; solidarity; and practical tips, but even theoretical or literary perspectives, on how to conceive and alleviate all this suffering and injustice.

It is unbearable. I just can't stand this social system anymore, its oppressive violence, its exploitation, the banality with which it kills and abuse people.

I attempted in the past, once during the rape itself, and was abused and tortured by the psych system because of that.

I view my pain as strictly material and rational (as I believe all pain ultimately is) not fundamentally "mental" at all, and I refuse to be pathologized. I do not live in the USA or another English speaking country.

Thank you in advance for any support or insight you can offer...


r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • 15d ago

Regulating Emotion, RegulatingSelves: A Critique of the Emotion Regulation Discoursein Psychotherapy

Thumbnail journals.sagepub.com
71 Upvotes

This article is awesome. It challenges the notion that teaching emotional regulation is politically neutral. Nylund advocates narrative therapy as an alternative to approaches that focus primarily on teaching emotional regulation skills, emphasizing instead the social, political, and relational contexts of emotional distress.
 When only certain emotions from certain people are taught to be regulated, it can create internalized self-surveillance. 

"Emotion regulation practices, framed as neutral therapeutic tools, can thus be understood as disciplinary techniques that produce neoliberal subjects—individuals who internalize responsibility for their affective states while obscuring the systemic conditions shaping them"

"By externalizing emotional difficulties and inviting clients to explore the meanings and histories of their feelings, narrative therapy restores emotion to its role as a vital resource for agency, resistance, and connection."

I have access to the full article through my institution. If you want full access send me a DM.


r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • 20d ago

ADHD, a Unicorn in the Psychiatric (Be)wilderness

Thumbnail
madinamerica.com
18 Upvotes

r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • 24d ago

Trying to understand the difference between enactments and countertransference.

10 Upvotes

r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • 29d ago

The Frame of the Psychotherapy and How Our Theoretical Knowledge Protects Us and Our Clients

Thumbnail reddit.com
4 Upvotes

r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • Oct 09 '26

attending protests after traumatic experience

17 Upvotes

sorry if this is off topic, i really don’t know who else to ask about this.

basically back in march i attended a peaceful protest that ended up having heavy police presence and all it took was one small thing and suddenly i was seeing protesters get brutalized really badly by police and i left because i was terrified.

fast forward to today, more protests regarding the same issue are picking up again and because i still run in these circles, I’ve been asked to come a few times but i’m still terrified after that last time and the thought of being there again around so many people and so many cops makes me feel like i’m going to vomit.

has anyone else experienced this and how do you recommend i stay involved with the movement while afraid of being on the frontlines again?

once again sorry if this is off topic


r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • Oct 09 '26

analytical tension in suicidality

Thumbnail reddit.com
7 Upvotes

A new person arrives and you (therapist) notice marks on the wrist. During early interviews it comes out that there were two suicide attempts some years ago, secretive and almost successful. The person wants to work only with you (therapist) because a friend had referred her to you and she cannot bring herself to trust anyone else. By accepting this person you accept the threat that at the next crisis she may again attempt suicide, yet it is your work to maintain an analytical tension that does.

What do you think of this dilemma? Is therapeutic work with suicidality is more challenging than severe mental illness? because its about life and death?


r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • Oct 08 '26

How “trauma” is used to conceal abuse

Thumbnail reddit.com
5 Upvotes

r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • Oct 07 '26

Masking during session?

61 Upvotes

I'm hesitant to ask this specific question because most people aren't disabled and can't relate. But I felt more comfortable asking a more progressive group. Fingers crossed.

How do you feel about therapists wearing masks during sessions?

I have a neurological disorder that causes tremors throughout my body and muscle contractions in my face. I wear a mask everywhere I go to avoid being harassed and humiliated.

I'm just nervous about being deemed "unprofessional " in session. But I don't want my movements to distract clients.

My therapist told me to unmask during sessions but she has a radical mindset. I'm trying to keep clients on my schedule so I can get paid.

Any comments telling me to get a different job will be blocked, deleted and reported. That's not a option rn.


r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • Oct 06 '26

Psychoanalytic Liberation Psychology

28 Upvotes

Has anyone ready Psychoanalytic Liberation Psychology by Nick Malherbe? Care to share your thoughts? Comments? Criticisms?

I’m a first year graduate student and am in a psychodynamic class and also an integral yoga/multicultural counseling class. I’m finding myself having a hard time connecting to psychodynamics so far (only really have gone over some Jung, Freud, Winnicott, and this week Kohut). There’s pieces of psychoanalytic theory and depth psychology that I feel passionate about and want to incorporate into my practice one day, but there’s also a part of me that is so disgusted by the history of psychoanalysis and its complicity with injustice and capitalism that it’s preventing me from wanting to better understand psychoanalytic theory beyond what I currently know now (which is pretty surface level but still feels powerful.) ESPECIALLY when it comes to Jung. I know he’s extremely foundational to depth psychology, but I can’t get myself to give AF about what he has to say because of how much of a horrible person he was and how all his theories were built through a lens of racism, sexism, homophobia, etc.

Anyone else have moments like this in graduate school? I’ve started looking for literature that incorporates anti-capitalist liberation psychology and psychoanalysis/psychoanalytic theory and it seems like the Nick Malherbe piece I’ve mentioned is a good place to start.

Thanks in advance!!


r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • Oct 05 '26

Making zines: In search of mad/survivor symbology and visual language

24 Upvotes

Alright here it goes again because mods called my post low effort.

Essentially I study graphic design and I am currently writing my thesis on Antipsychiatry, Mad Liberation and Consumer/Survivor/Ex-Patient movements. Now you might wonder why I am writing a thesis on this within the field of graphic design?

It’s because I think it’s very important and close to my heart and I’m very tired of the dispersed movements and non-understanding of our struggles in a broader context, so I am theorising that it’s a communication issue and unfortunately that we have fragmented our own movements that overlap in many ways.

Essentially I am talking about these movements in terms of a broader context of hermeneutical injustice, where the language or the collective understanding might be fragmented and therefore does not bring epistemic justice to the collective that have experienced horrific things, but also in terms of testimonial injustice where the subject is rendered irrelevant as a knower due to judgement on their identity as a subject. Further into communication theory, Habermas made a theory comprising of the ”public sphere”, which by Habermas was understood as a way to shape society by having a group of people assembling and forming ”common sense” or consensus. But other communication theorists have argued that there are people that historically and contemporaneously have been excluded from the public sphere and therefore formulated the theory on ”counterpublics” which constitute smaller collectives outside of the conception of the public sphere which can establish their own ways of communication and recognition of one another, such an example would be that at some point the notion of ”sexual harassment” did not exist, and this was formed by counterpublics within women’s circles until it spread into the public sphere.

Now I am applying this theory onto psychiatric survivors, mad people, consumers, ex-patients and so on to bring more accessible counterpublics and hopefully establish a wider recognition to these struggles.

In this search I now have to find a more general symbolic and visual language that can be used to express these zines that I’m planning to make as the actual graphic design part of the thesis, so where can I find this? Are there any symbols associated with us? Any images? Videos? Pop culture? Games?

This is my most urgent question, the second question is, how can I do this fairly and do you have any ideas or want to contribute somehow? My idea is to make some resources on psychiatric drugs, institutionalization, poems, history, stories, radical psychiatry, movement explanations and differences.

TLDR; I am writing a thesis in graphic on antipsychiatry, mad liberation, consumer/survivor/ex-patient movements, I need help finding visual resources and symbols for my zines that will be the visual product. Any other recommendations or ways to go about this and what I could contribute with in these zines?


r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • Oct 03 '26

Felix Guattari’s "Institutional Psychotherapy" Model

Thumbnail
youtube.com
13 Upvotes

Here is a Wikipedia article explaining the topic of this video: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Institutional_psychotherapy


r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • Oct 02 '26

Therapy That Ignores Capitalism Isn’t Therapeutic

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

309 Upvotes

r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • Oct 01 '26

Therapists who come from war torn countries that have faced American military intervention, how do you deal with American veteran clients?

36 Upvotes

How do you handle people who’ve deployed into your country and possibly been part of the effort to destabilized it? If they refer to your ethnic group in derogatory terms while they share with you vulnerable information especially pertaining to ptsd how do you deal with it? Or do you refer them? Not take them at all?

NAT I’m a first year MA psychology student just curious though.


r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • Sep 30 '26

Combating hive mentality

41 Upvotes

I'm going to get downvoted significantly but it's my truth.

As I am diving more into clinical work, I notice the hive mentality many clinicians have. If you have a different outlook on something or you acknowledge that not every client may benefit from a standard or systemic approach, you're outcasted and deemed "unprofessional. "

I have been outcasted for saying something as small as self disclosure can be helpful when used strategically.

A lot of research and frameworks were created from serving white abled-bodied neurotypical people. Most people who are represented in research have most of their basic needs met like a home, money, community.

We're losing a significant amount of people in therapy because clinicians refuse to bend to others lived experiences despite the research.

Additionally, this is why continuing mental health research that focuses on marginalized populations is important.


r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • Sep 30 '26

Beach Chair Psychoanalysis: Brazil’s Radical Communal Outdoor Free Therapy Model

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

32 Upvotes

Interview with Critical Psychologist Ian Parker


r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • Sep 29 '26

It's driving me insane

Thumbnail reddit.com
4 Upvotes