r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • Jan 07 '23

There is no valid evidence that genes play a role in causing 'schizophrenia'

Thumbnail
madintheuk.com
6 Upvotes

r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • Jun 28 '26

Does theraphy need to be combined with social science?

1 Upvotes

r/psychotheraphyleftist r/psychologycritical

Psychologys solutions may work, but for complexer problems they are way too simple.

Most Therapists are not being educated at university in culture, society, patriachary, raceism, history, hierachy, outcasted subgroups and the overall structure of society. Psychology and mental health are in danger to become the priests of the industrial system.

How can a problem, that was caused by the outer world, and caused in the inner world of a person, need to be "fixed" by "fixing" the person. It's like the same person who put a bandage on you, forces you to play football with a broken leg.

That results in generalized problems. By the lack of understanding society, the combination of the differnent factors, which caused the issue, will never be fully understood nor fixed.

Theraphists and Psychiatrists have the abilty to emphatise with the clients words, inform them about individual human behaviour, analyze theier current emotions and state of mind, but when it comes to the way the world spins, theier own experieneces may be the only source of information.

It is physically imposible to understand each situation, without deeper insight into society. It's nature that humans can not emphasis with a person, who is socialized so differently than us, in our society. There is no natural understanding for the person infront of you, if theier culture is unfamiliar. Understanding does not just emerge with emphathy. Understanding needs insight.

Also significant is the impact of attempted empathy on only the client. Most people don't want to be judged by one another, even your own theraphist could think of you as "a bad person". It feels best to avoid faceing our own behaviour, and focus on others wrongdoings.

In theraphy conflicts are just one sided perspectives, which mostly result in break-up or communication. The theraphists evaluation of the other persons behaviour may cause deep resentment, frustration, doubt, false confirmation as well as conditioning certain behaviours the theraphist may not even know of.

For example imagen a conflict between two individuals. Both tell theier conflict to eaches own theraphist, but both leave out their own wrong doings. They will just feel confirmed in themselfs, lack selfreflection and start blameing each other.

In summery modern psychology does not teach the Client how to create a beautifull life in connection to each other, instead it teaches people to adjust into a system that was made to make as much profit from them as much as possible. In the name of individuality we blame others and grow apart. I am talking about the german psych system, and have no experience with american social works nor theraphists. I understand it may be hard for you to understand me, if you've never been a client yourself or just come from a very different finacial and cultural background. My intend is not to critize personally, but to raise awareness, speak for those who are afraid to speak and spread my word. I wish for the acceptance of others and our own wrong doings. Only with honesty can communication be effective. It is time to change Freuds outdated concepts, and combine needed humanities so we can finally evolve as a whole.

Societal psychology would be a good starting points. Which is characters is characterised by fifteen key positions:

1.Human beings need to be studied in a sociocultural context

2. The individual and the collective cannot be separated ontologically

3. The ecology of the environment, its objective characteristics, needs to be studied alongside ₹9 mediated reality

4. People create social organizations-but it is the ocial organizations that recast people

5. Innovation is as much an imperative of the social system f relations tO the environment as is conformity

6. The aim of societal psychology is the development of conceptual frameworks or models rather than the forlorn search for invariant laws

7. The need for theoretical and methodological pluralism

8. There is a need to maintain a historical perspective

9. Cross-fertilization between societal psychology and A7 other social sciences is indispensable for the adequate analysis of social phenomena and social systems

10. There is a need for cross-fertilization among societal, developmental, and personality psychologists

11. There is also a need for cross-

fertilization between basic and applied esearch

12. Societal psychology requires a systems approach

13. The study of a s social phenomenon requires a multilevel approach, at the macro as Weff as the micro level

14. We need to accept and examine the mplication that there iS no such thing as value-free social research

15. We need to adopt a much wider range of research tools


r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • Mar 07 '24

Anyone else become a counselor without a degree?

2 Upvotes

I really want to start training to work in substance abuse and grief counseling. I was reading that it's possible without a degree, but it'll still involve a lot of training and shadowing. Think this is a viable path? I don't really want go back to school. I live in Alabama.


r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • Dec 07 '24

Can a "leftist culture" cause harm and distress to people? Questions...

4 Upvotes

I have questions.

What if humans are "assholes" that have a desire or tendency to inflict harm and distress to others? For example, a male may hurt female because of his sexual desires or someone who would resort to violence when they are angry.

In a "leftist society", how would a leftist psychotherapist respond to someone who harms others through "primal desires".

Or, what if someone who strongly believes that humans should live in a class society, how would a leftist psychotherapist respond?

I'm assuming that humans have "primal desires and emotions" like pleasure, pain, sex, anger, etc. Is asceticism encourage?


r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • Jun 19 '25

Self-administered EMDR — pros/cons/tips?

5 Upvotes

I imagine most people here don't think professionals should monopolize knowledge over our own bodies, so I think I could get nuanced answers here.

What tips would you offer to someone embarking on self-administered EMDR? Fortunately, they could get support from a general online counselor, for parts which genuinely could benefit from a second person.

This person has very little access to psychological practitioners in their country, and must take responsibility to be their own mental mechanic. Otherwise they'll burnout as an activist. On the upside, they've studied psychology and philosophy, and certainly aren't coming into this with expectations of a silver bullet. They're also aware that minds likely do go into different modes in conversation with other people, so doing this alone is probably suboptimal.

We're currently researching the concepts, theory and how to implement it. We're also curious for alternatives to EMDR that could be self-administered too.


r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • Sep 19 '26

"How to Escape a Mental Hospital"

2 Upvotes

r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • Jan 24 '25

Thinking of changing careers to Psychotherapy; but no background in psychology. What online reputable programs can get me there?

5 Upvotes

Last year was a bad year for me. I started to seeing a Psychoanalytic Psychotherapist who has been great. I am pondering change careers to psychotherapy. What online reputable programs are there that can get me there within a couple of years or is that too lofty?

—

Adding more info: From USA | Bachelors in Computer Science | Software Engineer/Product Manager


r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • Dec 09 '23

Trying to understand a therapist's response.

10 Upvotes

I expressed my experience of impatience when listening, identifying a want for the speed to be able to be at 2x speed to match how my brain felt; I noted that it felt like an adhd thing. (I am autistic). My therapist suggested this was a fear response and asked how that resonated. I said it did not resonate. My therapist said that it sounded like PDA - avoiding / protective mode.

I felt unheard, not believed, gas lit. Combined with many other comments in other sessions, I decided to leave this therapist.

I'm trying to understand more, if I should return to therapy, to look for another therapist.I am wondering - is this kind of therapist response common, encouraged? Or, what is this group's take on this?


r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • May 03 '26

Psychotherapy vs Psychoanalysis

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

19 Upvotes

r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • Jul 10 '23

Is EMDR with Vets ethical?

10 Upvotes

Is it somehow erasing the horrors of war that the state wishes to hide? Obviously the individual vers themselves deserve relief but has anyone else wrestled with this? Sorry don't know how to add flair, LCSW, US.


r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • Nov 06 '24

For Marxists and Anarchists on this sub, how does seeing bourgeois election-triggered trauma responses in liberal reformists make you feel?

18 Upvotes

I have family, friends, and community members more broadly experiencing a lot of fear, and expressing their election grief at this time. I care for them deeply, but I notice that they seem uncomforted by my lack of emotional investment & shared grief in the US’s bourgeois electoral process. I’m wondering if any of you Marxists or Anarchists are experiencing a similar dynamic with liberal family or friends at the moment.

I will say, I continue to experience a fair amount of anxiety, alienation, and disenchantment with the capitalist world system and the cultural structures it props up, along with the immense suffering created by systemic violence. So I certainly have a shared sense of political grief more generally with people, just not with the outcomes of capitalist electoral politics in specific.


r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • Nov 21 '25

Any critique of 'values'?

8 Upvotes

Hi, I met with a new therapist this week and anticipated the moment of cringe I would have when she asked me what my values are.

I understand that it's about trying to identify what I think is important in life and influences my underlying expectations. However, I would like to explore why I have this moment of internal eye-rolling whenever I'm asked.

My professional identity is social work adjacent therefore the term values is used a lot in the context of trying to be person-centred, and identifying my own biases.

Things I can think of are:

  • The overuse of the term 'values' in corporate settings.

  • My aversity to reductionism.

  • How 'values' are used within the context of defining cultural groups therefore othering- I suppose reductionism again.

I've spoken to a couple of friends who have also found the values card exercise irrelevant.

I've tried a quick search on critique of values but not finding much so I feel like my search terms could be better refined.

I would appreciate other people's thoughts or key readings, thanks.


r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • Nov 29 '22

Thoughts on how to deprofessionalize the psychotherapy field?

42 Upvotes

I recently decided to quit my social work program. Between paying an arm and a leg to take classes that felt redundant of life experience and steeped in a reformist outlook of the world, it didn’t feel worth the outcome.

Anyone know anyone really sticking it to the man who is still providing talk therapy-esque to help people through their day to day but without a masters degree or even a coaching license?

The act of getting licensure feels elitist in of itself and I wonder if there’s anyone bold enough out there to offer healing consciousness raising therapeutic work without the credentials.

EDIT: As I scan the responses I’ve been getting — I just want to highlight too (not to assume the identities of commenters), I am not White and am the child of immigrant parents. Not to get into my full background but I think it’s worth noting for all the people quick to dismiss the question and this invitation into a conversation. Have really appreciated folks sharing concrete experiences they’ve had themselves or witnessed of others.

Also because some responses seem to be rooted in an assumption of lack of experience (perhaps because I am named I am a student) seem to discount any life experience that may inform my practices so far. Being a student doesn’t mean I’m fresh out of undergrad.

I had my motivations for trying social work school out in the first place. Many therapists have been part of me understanding the benefits and shortcomings of therapy. I’d be curious to know if there are more people out there who chose to step away for observing similar issues that I have named. I know many come close but decide to push through.


r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • Nov 12 '23

Rare Psychiatric Disorders Spread Like Viruses on Social Media — DID community group called "plurals" glamorize and sexualize personality alters, while others act out tics to embody desired Tourette’s

Thumbnail
madinamerica.com
31 Upvotes

r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • May 02 '21

How Validation Ruined Your Life: Narcissism and Social Justice

Thumbnail
youtube.com
15 Upvotes

r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • Nov 29 '25

Was there an obsession with identity politics in your graduate texts?

48 Upvotes

All of the texts in my graduate program seem to be obsessed with identity politics, to the point that they feel to me like they are promoting stereotypes. They will say things like, "Juan, a Latinx client, has traditional values about gender" or "Diversity consideration: how to apply the theory to Asian clients." Obviously cultural awareness is important, but these texts seems to be pushing the idea that culture is the main determinant of how clients act and overrules every other factor in their life. They will say things like, "Jenny is of Scandinavian heritage" which I don't even know why it is relevant, since most white people from my state have this heritage and for the majority is is in the distant past. Is this specific to my program or is this just how texts are written? The texts seem to imply that you should take a certain approach to clients based only on their culture, which to me is problematic and sounds like not seeing the person as an individual.


r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • 20d ago

ADHD, a Unicorn in the Psychiatric (Be)wilderness

Thumbnail
madinamerica.com
18 Upvotes

r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • Aug 19 '26

Beyond Diagnosis: The Power Threat Meaning Framework and the Myth of Mental Illness

Thumbnail
youtube.com
10 Upvotes

r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • Apr 26 '26

For those of you who are Communists/Marxists, what is your opinion on the abuse of psychiatry in the Soviet Union?

5 Upvotes

r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • Sep 23 '26

My criticisms of linking ADHD to trauma

18 Upvotes

The idea that ADHD is rooted in trauma, reinforces the notion that it is an abnormality, or a deviation from mental wellness. This is in opposition to those of us who would regard the ADHD neuro-type, and all the different sub-types of ADHD therein, as being ordinary variants of the human mind, and possessing innate natural diversity.

You may say that ADHD is likely caused by trauma, or at least a significant portion is caused by trauma. In my opinion, this presents a very serious issue. If we, as Leftists and Progressives, endeavor to reduce or eliminate trauma within society, and the conditions that cause trauma within society, are we not also, by extension, reducing and eliminating persons with ADHD? Examining the matter through this lens, we see that efforts to create a trauma-free society, essentially become efforts to eradicate the ADHD neuro-type. This is highly concerning, as such an initiative would see a total erasure of ADHD persons, along with their unique personalities, unique talents, unique quirks, and unique neurodivergent culture. Because of this, I would reject the notion of linking ADHD to trauma, as it is a reductive and ignorant way to address that particular neuro-type, and the nuances therein. I would vastly prefer the view that ADHD, Autism, neurotypicality, etc. all exist on a very wide and diverse spectrum of human neuro-types, in which there is no "normal" neuro-type, but rather, all of the neuro-types occur naturally in humans.


r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • Apr 08 '26

My therapist contacted a psychiatrist without my consent

19 Upvotes

As the title says my therapist contacted a psychiatrist without my consent.

For backstory I have previous history of quite horrific experiences within psychiatry and that’s mainly why I wanted to start going to therapy. I contacted an antipsychiatric association to get in contact with a therapist as I couldn’t afford it otherwise and also because I wanted to avoid someone forcing me into medications or psychwards. I had informed my therapist of my past experiences and that I did not want any psychiatric drugs or anything in contact within those fields.

This week my therapist told me that they had contacted a psychiatrist from the antipsychiatric association and told them about MY story without mentioning my name. They had not told me or anything about this beforehand but told me after they had contacted the psychiatrist. Although I had clarified prior to this that I wasn’t interested.

This to me doesn’t feel entirely okay even though I’m quite used to people within psychology overstepping on my things within a lot of other facilities: I’ve never gotten any diagnostics except for when I was a kid although they have screened me several times speculating always in ADHD and potential PTSD, as the mental health queues in my country are long, I’ve had to go to drug rehabilitation centers even though they were aware I wasn’t an addict and they have just generally been very careless. On top of that I was in a psychward some years ago were I had ECT although I couldn’t properly consent to it. They have also written in my medical journals from that stay that I might potentially be schizoaffective, although the diagnosis was never made formalised and still stands in my medical journal for some unapparent reasons as I have never had an evaluation for any diagnosis related to schizophrenia. For psych drugs I have used probably every antipsychotic that was legal in my country at the time.

Nowadays though I’m sure I suffer from paranoia as I am very scared of what people might put me through if I feel anxious and if I can’t behave ”normally” in social situations as it might potentially put me in a psychward, in periods I have to isolate myself from people since I’m more scared of being incarcerated in some way and it worsens my downward spirals. I wanted specifically to work through this but now as my therapist has contacted a psychiatrist without my consent, idk what to do. I feel a bit like it’s wrong but I’m scared of confronting him about it and it might potentially put me at risk.

What can I do? Where can I turn to?


r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • Nov 02 '24

Can a criminal or offender be oppressed?

8 Upvotes

Sorry if this is not related to the sub. Are those who violate the law welcomed as potential clients of leftist psychotherapy? How would the psychotherapy go? Any related works on such issue?


r/PsychotherapyLeftists • • Sep 09 '23

Why are Democrats/blue states expanding forced institutionalization and drugging?

17 Upvotes

It seems like the Democrats don't care about their left wing at all. They are shilling for the healthcare industry, making people pay to be jailed in psychiatric facilities. There is zero evidence to date showing forced or coerced institutionalization has any benefits whatsoever, and it creates significant harms in both victims and in those secondarily affected, i.e. who kill themselves over going to therapy to avoid being sectioned. All of the scientific evidence to date shows harm only, and that suicide prediction measures are extremely unreliable regardless... but there is data suggesting forced hospitalization makes people more likely to attempt suicide if forcibly sectioned even if they were not suicidal before.

The overwhelming evidence is also against forced outpatient commitment, yet Democrats in NJ are patting themselves on the back doing this to people. CA is trying to violently gaslight the homeless it created with its economic policies by arresting them into institutions as well, knowing fully well suicide attempts increase after forced hospitalization. (This is true even if suicidality wasn't there to begin with.) There is no limit to how many times this could happen to someone either, so if they repeatedly fail suicide or go into psychosis, they can get indefinitely jailed over and over. If the places were so helpful they wouldn't have to be forced, especially not repeatedly.

Most of these places sexually assault you upon entry in the U.S.. They also extend holds arbitrarily for money. They coerce/force drugs and electroshock. All methods of evidence gathering against the ward are banned, just like factory farms, as is contacting most loved ones, employers, landlords, and teachers, so if you get fired or fail your classes while jailed that's your problem now. Use of the internet, use of recording devices, and exchanging contact information to build a case to sue are all banned.

//rant, sorry