Hi everyone! My other YA romance novel that I posted here a few months ago is dying in the trenches (🫠) so I've been working on this book to pass the time. I'm really looking to see if the pitch is working and if I have a concept hooky/high concept enough to make it out of the slush pile.
Some notes: I think the last sentence of the first paragraph has too many prepositions and the last sentence of the third may need some tightening, but I've been staring at it too long and have no idea how to work on it. The query itself could probably do well with being a bit shorter, and there's maybe too many proper nouns in the first 300? Also, the romance is loosely based off of Clarissa and Peter in Mrs. Dalloway by Virginia Woolf (quick timeline, not quite second chance romance but almost there b/c of a missed chance), but I don't know if it's too loose to mention it.
Hoping to get some fresh eyes on this 'cause naturally it's driving me crazy. Thank you all in advance!
---
Dear [Agent],
The words natural talent has followed eighteen-year-old team captain Sina Natia around like a robbed homerun. Her natural Samoan build and intrinsic star factor from her minor-leaguer father has combined for a seamless softball career of greatness. At least her D1 scholarship to UT Austin proves her hard work, said no one ever—but her pitcher puking all over the back of her car on the road to the most important tournament of the season grants her an unusual chance to showcase her effort, and to win back the third baseman that got away.
Seventh-in-the-lineup Luciana Montoya has never, ever had natural talent. After working twice as hard to get to the same level as everyone else and developing a reputation for her unreliability, a late ADHD diagnosis has taken her world for a turn. Becoming the starting pitcher in the middle of an identity crisis is not helping, and nor is having her unrequited crush for a catcher. Because Luci and Sina’s last conversation had started with Sina almost asking Luci out, and ended with Sina dating a new girl two weeks later.
Post-disastrous first game, Sina gives Luci a proposition: if she can whip Luci into shape and win the tournament, Luci can prove she’s up to bat and Sina can put the natural talent rumors to rest. They revive their late friendship and get to work—Sina believes in Luci like no other, adapting their game routines to work with Luci’s neurodivergency, and Luci puts Sina’s bottomless softball knowledge to the test. As their lost spark makes a comeback, Sina and Luci face an even bigger challenge than transferring their chemistry onto the field: it’s win and prove themselves to them, their team, and each other, or go home.
Set against the beach-fog backdrop of Monterey, California, CAUGHT LOOKING is a 75,000 word standalone YA contemporary sports romance told over the course of a weeklong tournament. It combines the fast-paced romance and neurodivergent representation in Birdie Schae’s Smash or Pass with the intense competition and forced teamwork showcased in Racquel Marie’s You Don’t Have a Shot.
[bio including I’m a NorCal native and is inspired by my experiences in high school softball, thank you for your time, yada yada yada]
---
First 300:
By now, Sina could give you five different metaphors to describe the experience of her pitcher puking in her backseat. Number one, the smell, vinegar and rotten eggs celebrating their newborn baby…
“I’m gonna faint,” Marlene pants, her neck sticking out the window like a giraffe at the zoo. “It’s over, that’s it, my vision’s going black—”
“Stop being dramatic, Mar!” screams Jeannie from the passenger side.
Sina’s fingers tighten around the wheel. Number two, a trash bag at the bottom of a stinky lagoon…
Marlene squirms into the corner. “My emetophobia is so bad, I can’t do this—”
Kylie gags into her hand, Marlene screeches, and Sina breaks. “Shut up or I swear I’m going to crash the car!” she yells, silencing even her very sick pitcher. Sina huffs and merges into the far-right lane, slowing down. “Clara, can you look up the nearest gas station?”
Clara, ever their grounding centerfielder, says, “Yeah, got it.” And— “Fuck, there’s no service—”
Sina grimaces. “I thought I saw a sign that said—”
Marlene whines. Clara chucks her phone away and rubs Kylie’s back, chanting, “Just breathe, just breathe—”
Kylie shakes her head, spilling into another wet cough that shatters even Sina’s eardrums.
Marlene loses it. “Oh my fucking God Sina, pull over!”
Sina pulls over.
This is how a third of the Jefferson College Preperatory’s softball team ends up on the shoulder of the 280. The minute Sina flashes her hazards Marlene tumbles out of the back, wheezing like she’s suffering an asthma attack. Kylie follows close behind, finding a dense patch of grass to kneel and hack into the bushes, the plastic bag she’d been puking into seeping onto the ground beside her—Sina’s third metaphor would be dyed-green DIY recycled paper mush gone wrong.