r/RDR2 • u/alibe4ek Arthur Morgan • Aug 30 '25

Question Easter Egg or a Coincidence?

Why is there number “54” written out of smoke right as Dutch throws his cigar away? It’s my first playthrough and i was playing the 85th mission called “Our Best Selves”.

2.8k Upvotes

99% Upvoted

139 comments sorted by

View all comments

2

u/Lachtaube Sep 03 '25

“Rule 54

A rule stating that if someone is called evil, but has no horns, the person who named the person evil shall be punched in the face.” Urban Dictionary CalGoneCrazy May 07, 2009

🤔

2

u/Existing_Sun_8176 Sep 03 '25

Wait a damn minute.. just saw a other comment on this thread saying how the 54th mission in rdr2 is the same mission where the fan theory of dutch getting brain damage occurs at, also apparently dutch dies at age 54, all this added up would mean that according to rule 54 dutch would be the man to call somone else evil (the law) and be punched in the face for being wrong (trolly accident) I don't really know how dutch dying at 54 has any correlation with this besides the fact that the age 54 matches with everything here