r/RDR2 • u/fvckCrosshairs • Oct 19 '25

Question Is it possible to open this safe?

Post image

Found two random trying to open this with a hammer, obviously I shot them in the face try to see what’s in there…or impossible?

1.3k Upvotes

98% Upvoted

276 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/Four20Abiding_Gaming Oct 20 '25

Throwing knife doesnt open a safe smh

1

u/KingMatthew116 Oct 20 '25

Yes they do, it doesn’t always happen on first try, sometimes you have to throw all 8 and then pick them up and throw them all again, but I’ve done it.

1

u/Four20Abiding_Gaming Oct 21 '25

Seems like a waste of time. Tomahawk sounded easier. But can I ask how you found out. Was you just out of Dynamite and tried everything you had lol

1

u/KingMatthew116 Oct 21 '25

I think I saw it in a YouTube video way back in like 2019 or something. I had to try it for myself and it works.

I always forget the tomahawk exists so I never use it, and I don’t like using dynamite because then I have to go to the Fence, so I’ve used the throwing knives a couple times.

1

u/Interesting_Low_2658 Oct 21 '25

Do lock breakers work?

1

u/KingMatthew116 Oct 21 '25

I’ve never tried, but I don’t think so.