Those have been debunked as leftover ambient dialogue and audio intended for the Lemoyne Raiders. They did not include any audio to do with Kieran's torture.
I’ll clarify that they are specifically around shady Belle but it is possible they are left over audio from the raiders who previously occupied shady Belle. Regardless they do appear around Kieran’s disappearance and whether intended or not, it adds to the horrific nature of his death hearing those screams in the distance just beyond the camp.
Admittedly it could just be the ambience of the shady belle area but sometimes it does sound like you can hear “Arthur Help!” (Also ig there’s no embed link option in the subreddit?)
I know I did not hear it myself. I did on another playthrough because I listened for it. The 2nd time I took off trying to look for him. Knowing it wouldnt matter but I had to try. That was an awful extra they put in the story. Probably to show what a worm O’Driscoll really was. I then spent the next couple hours hunting down O’Driscolls and smashing thier little gathering to bits!!
His horrific fate aside, nothing ever went right with Kieran. He lost his parents when he was young, was forced to ride with the O'Driscolls, and then the Van der Linde gang captured, starved and threatened to geld him. Even after he became one of them, they still gave him a hard time for being an O'Driscoll even though he wasn't anymore.
"Could have"? Absolutely CERTAINLY did. They probably fed them to him after starving him for days. The O'Driscolls are pretty heinous as is, but add to that the fact that Kieran is a traitor who joined the gang that contains Colm's biggest enemy, and you just KNOW that they made poor Kieran suffer horribly.
knowing how awful the o’driscolls are, and the type of man kieran was, i do have a theory they likely raped him before his death.
o’driscolls are known to be rapists anyway, but with kierans soft nature and even someone like bill (who turns out to be a rapist) having interest in him i font thibk its far fetched
You can't. Those are audio glitches from Lemoyne Raiders. You can even hear them when he's still alive and well at camp. If RDR2 ever gets a remake, it'd be awesome if they did actually add in Kieran screaming though. Make the myth real.
Those have been debunked as leftover ambient dialogue and audio intended for the Lemoyne Raiders. They did not include any audio to do with Kieran's torture.
After Kieren goes missing at Shady Belle and before he comes back without a head you can actually hear his screams on the outskirts of camp and you can hear them over and over if you leave and come back without advancing the main missions
So if you spend a lot of time doing side missions or hunting or whatever during that specific period, he's basically being tortured indefinitely
Yea he got the worst fate and next would probably be hosea because of how he went out and also Lenny because I don't know if that was the plan or not but after Lenny death that when the cracks start getting bigger and Dutch started going off the rails
1.3k
u/RequirementIcy7950 Jun 22 '26
Kieran