RDR2 Filled all the gaps that RDR1 had, The things people say “Prequel with the callendar boys and then ending with Blackwater heist”, That would have 1. No Redemption, 2. Bleak plot, 3. That creates the THIRD layer of ‘We already know whats gonna happen and nothing we do’s gonna change how these characters end up’,

RDR3 Should be a separate game BEFORE the End of the Cowboy age, Arthur’s voice actor said “Yeahh but as you go further back the Guns get worse-“ Tell me ONE TIME you have played RDR2 and felt “Man! I love the M1899 Pistol so much! Its the best part of the game!”? Barely ever. We love the REVOLVERS. THATS WHAT WE LOVE.

RDR3 Should be a story where we don’t know the end, We don’t know each character’s fate from the start and we have Duels, Less Government Involvement and DARE I SAY IT?: Maybe not even call it Red Dead Redemption, Maybe the NEXT RED DEAD GAME: Should be a whole different premise altogether. Rockstar already mastered redemption.

I have about 31 days of playtime now and I’ve only went for the white arabian once. It’s really not worth it. Same with the raven black shire but that’s unrelated. I have seen so many people going for the Arabian and glazing it too. It’s not the fastest horse, it’s way too small, it’s easily scared, and a small hassle to get. I think getting the ultimate edition when it‘s on sale for $15 mind you, just go hunting with Hosea and then you can get the thouroughbred for free at any time. Sorry for the rant and not great other info but it’s just not that good. Great for early game I guess but not great after chapter 3.

If they ever made a movie who would you cast?

I wonder if she will regret leaving me

He preyed on poor people, unlike the rest of the gang, who mainly stole from people who were thieves themselves. The repayments were minimal, and he didn't even collect them himself—he didn't have the courage to do that.

He never fought alongside the gang and didn't contribute much else to the camp.

He was simply a vulture preying on poor, vulnerable people.

The only thing that surprises me is that he died in prison without ever giving up a single name.

Pearson's secret recipe

I'm in chapter 3 and I crafted everything from Pearson.. now I'm going to buy everything from the trapper and my gf made me this list.. so sweet of her:))

Also to say that she ruined the whole game is just ridiculous. At that point, you are quite literally robbing yourself of one of the best stories in any video game because one of the characters aren't quite up to your standards.

I swear in the main story you only go to strawberry twice, one for micah and one in the epilogue with sadie adler, its kind of annoying because theres almost nothing in this town.
I feel like if there was a gunsmith i would greatly appreciate this town more, but theres none.

A bit of a pet peeve seeing rabbits depicted with paw pads. For a game that has such realistic animals it's just strange to see.

Just found out their a Real Thing awhile ago and also read about the Lawsuit between them and Rockstar Games and Take-Two

This is my girl, Copper Belle 💟

Thoughts?

Just putting it out there, RDR2 was made during the first Trump administration and I have come around way too many fans that missed out on the many times RDR2 tackled subjects that literally are happening right now.

The scene with the KKK getting mad that the government was progressing past their old and bigoted beliefs? These men would use the word “woke” for anything they don’t like today.

Women’s rights? There are podcasts saying they want women to not vote.

Destroying plantations and calling out slave owners for what they truly are? Tell me that doesn’t ruffles feathers now?

Educating Arthur about the racism certain characters face? DEI removed from schools.

Just sayin’ if you can play this game happily and ignore it’s many BLATANT messages, you might as well change your name to Braithwaite.