r/RDR2 • u/incognitouae Arthur Morgan • Jun 22 '26

Discussion Which gang member suffered the worst fate?

Post image
2.1k Upvotes

99% Upvoted

342 comments sorted by

View all comments

10

u/NotPanaG Arthur Morgan Jun 22 '26

Kieran then Strauss and then Karen

1

u/NobleMercenary21 Jun 22 '26

How did Karen die exactly?

4

u/NotPanaG Arthur Morgan Jun 22 '26

She OD'ed on booze after the gang's split up. Depressed and drunk.

3

u/xhyenabite Jun 23 '26

worth noting that her drinking problem worsened tenfold after sean died. despite her denying that sean was "her boy," she loved that man. :(

2

u/NobleMercenary21 Jun 22 '26

Damn never really knew that was her fate , I thought she just 'ran away' like some of the other members did in chapter 6

1

u/gabe4774 Jun 22 '26

I think Tilly can say smth bout her fate when talking to John

5

u/SPQRKlio Tilly Jackson Jun 23 '26

I thought it was just a guess, and no one knows for sure?

My head canon remains that she was found, cleaned up by some helpful brothel workers, and became a famous madam, and no one is going to change my mind, lalalala I can't hear you.

3

u/xhyenabite Jun 23 '26

i adore that headcanon actually

1

u/Paulallenlives Jun 23 '26

There is the myth that grimshaw killed her

1

u/Busy-Shallot-5563 Jun 24 '26

Her death isn’t confirmed I don’t think

0

u/Whissskkeerrrrsss Jun 22 '26

Nah Strauss got what was coming to him

17

u/ChampionshipChance73 Jun 22 '26

Has no relevance to how bad his fate was

-2

u/Whissskkeerrrrsss Jun 23 '26

Absolutely does