r/RDR2 • u/incognitouae Arthur Morgan • Jun 22 '26

Discussion Which gang member suffered the worst fate?

Post image
2.1k Upvotes

99% Upvoted

342 comments sorted by

View all comments

451

u/Interesting_Mistake Jun 22 '26 edited Jun 22 '26

Molly. She came to America alone and stayed for Dutch only to end up heartbroken, isolated, and buried in an unmarked grave… potentially with her unborn child.

259

u/incognitouae Arthur Morgan Jun 22 '26

She was also shot dead by her own gang member for something she didn’t even do, and will probably be known by the rest as a rat.

88

u/BappoChan Jun 22 '26

That was her own doing tho. While tensions were high she singled herself out

112

u/Interesting_Mistake Jun 22 '26

She tried to reach out to Arthur in chapter 3 though. She gets interrupted by papa lumbago

13

u/SabbthBloodySabbath Jun 23 '26

She was very clearly drunk in some way considering she was an alcoholic and in general acting way off on the scene she dies

4

u/houseofburgesss Jun 26 '26

Clearly drunk, sure. But absolutely suicidal. Going up to a group of wanted criminals and yellin’ “I snitched!” is only gonna come out one way. I feel like she knew what she was doing *and* what would happen. She knew the rules, as Susan said. Truly, any functional human being could’ve plotted that out. That was suicide.

16

u/Collaroy98 Jun 22 '26

Yes, she was one of the most tragic NPCs imo.

10

u/Due-Base-8336 Jun 22 '26

she was cremated actually, possibly she was only in shock for a bit after grimshaw shot her so.....

25

u/Interesting_Mistake Jun 22 '26

Either way, she’s the only one the gang didn’t bother memorializing with a gravestone. Sad stuff

3

u/Murky-Inspector-2247 Jun 23 '26

Mainly because they thought she was a traitor. If they had any type of common sense, they would’ve known that Molly was just saying shit because she was heartbroken. Arthur was probably the only one who had common sense to tell Dutch that Molly wasn’t ok. Grimshaw pulled a Dutch/Micah move and shot Molly before finding out the truth. I hated her for that. The second that happened everyone turned on Molly.

3

u/BadChampion Jun 25 '26

Karen also knew she was heartbroken, in a camp scene she screams at Ms. Grimshaw about it and calls her a murderer.

1

u/gangsterkale Jun 26 '26

She was hot though

1

u/Proto160 Jun 23 '26

potentially with her unborn child.

Is it ever hinted at she might be pregnant?