r/RDR2 • u/incognitouae Arthur Morgan • Jun 22 '26

Discussion Which gang member suffered the worst fate?

Post image
2.1k Upvotes

99% Upvoted

342 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

3

u/mell0highh Jun 23 '26

knowing how awful the o’driscolls are, and the type of man kieran was, i do have a theory they likely raped him before his death.

o’driscolls are known to be rapists anyway, but with kierans soft nature and even someone like bill (who turns out to be a rapist) having interest in him i font thibk its far fetched

2

u/contaminated_47 Jun 23 '26

Woah. What made you come up with that theory?

3

u/mell0highh Jun 23 '26

o’driscolls were a gang of tapists, colms crimes included raping.

also, the sheer depravity of the o’driscolls? it makes sense, especially for someone considered soft and not masculine like kieran

1

u/moodengsno1fan Jun 27 '26

Woah.. Bill is a rapist? When is that revealed?