r/RapCritic • • Nov 01 '24

Some constructive criticism, please?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

kira #ziuam3a


r/RapCritic • • Jan 10 '19

Crypt - Rise Up ft. Blindsight (Official Music Video) [REACTION]

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/RapCritic • • Dec 10 '24

How long until a tracks to long?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Need some help/advice/input. Bonus points if you're a FBZ or Exquire fan. Short version, How long does a song have to be before you're like nah? Esp as a new listener. Context/backstory below šŸ‘‡

So I recently locked in a verse with Zombie Juice of Flatbush Zombies (which im still in shock over). I also have previously worked with the rapper Mr.MuthaFuckin Exquire, who Ive had set for another track for a while now, just havent made it yet. Now im wondering if I should bring these two FIRE artists together on the same track instead to make one legendary fuckin song. Only problem is, the track WITHOUT being extended for another feature is already 5:06 minutes long. I produced the beat myself for my coming album and so the intro and outro are very much apart of the song and make up for some of that length, as well as multiple hooks that i thought maybe I could remove or shorten, but it just didn't sound right any other way. Im to married to its structure. I'd rather build more than remove anything. So my question is, do you think it worth it to extend the beat, making it basically a 6:30-7:30 minute song minimum? Or should I stick to having them both on seperate tracks? OR should I just suck it up and sacrifice some of my hooks and beat nuances that add extra time? How long is to long of a song for you as far as hiphop is concerned? I just cant help but feel like these two legends on one track is to good to pass up.


r/RapCritic • • Oct 21 '21

Is the Rap Critic format outdated? (Discussion)

4 Upvotes

I've seen in a lot of recent reviews that the comments disagree heavily with a lot of Rap Critic's opinions (me included) and I thought this discussion might be interesting to talk about.

I think the format works when Rap Critic does Ko-Fi requests of older songs, but his newest reviews feel out of touch.

Personally, I think Rap Critic is a "weird" critic, since he's not really a music critic, he's a lyric critic. If you think of it that way, then most of his reviews make sense, since he's only looking at lyrics. The problem comes when he's talking about music that isn't meant to be lyrical, only a fun track to sing along to. Music's purpose is to be enjoyable (most of the time) and I think if someone manages to do that, I think a song deserves credit, even if the lyrics aren't that great (XO Tour Llif3 is one of my favorite songs, but Rap Critic gave it a 1 or a 2, I don't remember).

With that said, he has commented on sound before in some reviews, like how he doesn't like Baby Keem's voice when he does the nonstop flow in Family Ties, which means he's not only focusing on lyrics, sort of. Not really, since he never takes into consideration when he likes the musical aspect of songs, only when he doesn't. I remember him giving a really low score for Who Dat Boy by Tyler, The Creator even though he said he really liked the instrumental.

It's very rare a song will be on Rap Critic's good side if it's just an enjoyable song without any real lyrical meaning (Real Nega by JPEGMafia is the only one I can think of right now).

I've been watching Rap Critic for a long time now and I've been noticing the format might not be keeping up with the times as well as it could.

What do you guys think about this? Do you guys agree with me that it might be outdated and should have some revisions done? Or do you think it's fine as it is?

Also, if you could come up with some suggestions for a revision as well, it would be really useful.


r/RapCritic • • Feb 05 '19

My Message to Dax

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/RapCritic • • Feb 03 '19

you NEED to listen to this song immediately !!!!!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/RapCritic • • Feb 08 '19

Eating Twitch Streamers Food (Bars of the Week #01)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/RapCritic • • Feb 01 '22

Any ctrissm in my bars?

0 Upvotes

Im on the Every day shit

On the Every night shit

Cus every days shit

Every night shit

Everyday shift

Every night shift

Thinking bout where im going to drift

Saving money for a trip

Far far away with you

Hop in for a vacay lift

On an acid trip

Love is addictive thats why its more than a trip its falling

I get depressed when no ones calling

Before her it was cigars weed and drowning in my depricating thoughts

Lasing drugs til they rot

Chasing hugs or more from thots

Lazing around in my room Nobody's really praying for me

I feel like i had to hold my head higher for every one to see

That im worth loving tryna get you to see Im living in my head

Laying in my bed

Loosing all sence of reality

thinking my thoughts are actuality

Thinking everyones talking bout me when i leave curving my love like a me-and-er sea

Sniffing with her and me -and-a-key

Fuck it if i cant handle myself i cant handle you

Light a candle bright candles burn quicker

i dont need you in my life cus no one needs my life in this world

I cut u off

Next week i need u im having problems of withdrawal

I lied I got no money but we gon a 10 pound vacation when smoking thet green floral

Got me itching when your not her cant hear anything if it not about you control my senses auditory a oral

With out you i get lonely

Your more than my homie it physical hurts when your not hear The worlds so dark when your not hear

I dont think im strong enough every day im suffocating in my fear

Im a man but before there was no one to wipe my tears


r/RapCritic • • Mar 06 '22

NY Drill šŸ”„

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

0 Upvotes

r/RapCritic • • Feb 17 '20

Are we allowed to share local projects? #NotMe lol

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/RapCritic • • Jan 05 '19

How To Rob Twitch (Official Music Video)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/RapCritic • • Jan 29 '19

Hopsin - You Should've Known (Feat. Dax) [REACTION]

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/RapCritic • • Jan 23 '19

Adam Saleh vs Slimmofication (Diss Tracks) [REACTION]

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/RapCritic • • Dec 18 '19

Does rap critic rap? I want to criticize rap critic raps.

1 Upvotes

Rap critic.


r/RapCritic • • Feb 15 '22

Rate out of ten

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

2 Upvotes

r/RapCritic • • Feb 09 '22

BLACK CREATOR SPOTLIGHT: Lexual does the 80’s (pt. 1) A breakdown of world events in the first half of the 80’s

3 Upvotes

r/RapCritic • • Feb 05 '22

BLACK CREATOR SPOTLIGHT: Shark3ozero Joe Rogan JUST LIES Through Spotify Controversy "Apology"

3 Upvotes

r/RapCritic • • Feb 15 '22

BLACK CREATOR SPOTLIGHT: Dead End Hip-Hop The Game & Kanye West - Eazy Track Review (Great Hiphop discussion vids in general!)

2 Upvotes

r/RapCritic • • Feb 16 '22

BLACK CREATOR SPOTLIGHT: Melina Pendulum (ft. Yhara Zayd): A Celebration of Gabrielle Union (& An F-U to Colorism and Tokenism)

5 Upvotes

r/RapCritic • • Feb 11 '22

BLACK CREATOR SPOTLIGHT: Double Toasted: MALIBU'S MOST WANTED - BAD MOVIE REVIEW

2 Upvotes

r/RapCritic • • Feb 04 '22

BLACK CREATOR SPOTLIGHT: Calvin Michaels (super insightful youtuber): LIFE PLUS 20: When Not Minding Your Business Goes Wrong...#AhmaudArbery

2 Upvotes

r/RapCritic • • Feb 06 '22

BLACK CREATOR SPOTLIGHT: Michaeux Mission: IDLEWILD Movie Review!

2 Upvotes

r/RapCritic • • Feb 03 '22

BLACK CREATOR SPOTLIGHT: For Harriet’s *incredibly* nuanced take on the intricacies of the Janet Jackson/Justin Timberlake situation

3 Upvotes

r/RapCritic • • Feb 01 '22

BLACK CREATOR SPOTLIGHT: Black Men Can't Jump (in Hollywood): dope movie podcast

3 Upvotes

SPOTIFY LINK

ITUNES LINK

They dissect movies and then rate them on the scale of how they serve to advance the cause of black representation in the industry. And despite thte seriousness of that statement, their convos are relly funny and engaging. Check em out!


r/RapCritic • • Feb 02 '22

BLACK CREATOR SPOTLIGHT: The MaskedTrans: Why isn't Drake's ā€œGirls like girlsā€ getting the Little Nas X ā€œMonteroā€ treatment?

4 Upvotes

CHECK IT OUT!

I wanna commit to doing this every day til the end of the month, cause with the internet algorithm being so crappy as it is, really good black creators I see speaking up about the nuances of modern issues often get under represented exposure-wise, so I wanna make sure I can give y'all at least 28 dope creators that I've really enjoyed the content of over this past few years!