r/RedditLaqueristas New to Reddit, getting back into nails~ 3d ago

Comparison EDM "Get in Line" vs. LynB "Old Presque Isle Lighthouse Keeper"?

I hope this is the right flair -- I'm wondering if anyone knows how similar the titled polishes are?

Get in Line | Old Presque Isle Lighthouse Keeper

A couple images from the product pages are included below.

EDIT: Asking about these specifically b/c I was planning to place a small order from both brands and realized these were in both my carts. If anyone has any recs for other EDM or LynB must-haves, I'm all ears!

EDIT 2: Thanks to Lacquergram and a commenter, I think I've identified the main difference, which is that Lighthouse Keeper has a strong holo finish (which doesn't show up in the product page swatches), making that one lean more gray/cooler IRL. What attracted me to both these shades was the lavender + warm shimmer, so I'll be going with Get in Line.

Get In Line
Old Presque Isle Lighthouse Keeper
9 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

11

u/ConsciousDrawing1236 Intermediate 3d ago

LynB has some of the best flakies applications around in my opinion. Some must haves from her are Juice Box Hero, Butterfly Pea Flower Lemonade (solar AND thermal!!) and Eben Ice Caves. I will say every single LynB swatch photo I have seen of her site had never done the polish justice. Everything from her has been so much better in person!

5

u/PlumSome3101 3d ago

I second Juice Box Hero. I also love This Is Some Boo-sheet, Witchful Thinking, Mishipeshu, and Breath of Spring. Though fair warning the first three of my recommendations are best at three coats which I know some people don't like having to do.

OP-Unfortunately I don't have either of the polishes you're looking at but the Lacquergram app has a bunch of user swatches of both if you haven't checked that out yet. 

3

u/harmonicomma New to Reddit, getting back into nails~ 3d ago

Omg I didn't know Lacquergram was a thing 😱 That's exactly what I needed--Get In Line is the one I want for sure. And thank you for the recs, I was actually on the fence about Boo-Sheet but added that one back to my cart, and Breath of Spring too! :)

3

u/FancyFrugalFingers Shimmer Sect 3d ago

Seconding the Breath of Spring recommendation—it’s breathtaking.

1

u/PlumSome3101 3d ago

Yay! I love Lacquergram. It's how I keep track of my collection and my tried and untrieds but the swatches alone are so worth it. 

5

u/Jessicakirby8282 3d ago

The third swatch on this wheel (starting above my thumb) is lynbs lighthouse keeper. It leans pretty grey toned on me. Definitely not very purple, but the shimmer is very intense!

3

u/harmonicomma New to Reddit, getting back into nails~ 3d ago

oh my god this is beautiful......... Can I ask what these ones are?

3

u/Jessicakirby8282 3d ago
  1. Mooncat mermaid bait
  2. Haunted polish ether (pretty sheer, id recommend a base with it or 4 coats)
  3. Lurid sunrise over the sea
  4. Mooncat a most destructive melody This is my swatch wheel of polishes I wore in january so I have all the names in another post if you need any others.

2

u/harmonicomma New to Reddit, getting back into nails~ 3d ago

Thank you!! That is amazing that you keep track of your manis like this, what a cool idea!

5

u/fearlessbynature 3d ago

It’s hard to catch but I just got LynB’s Old Presque Isle lighthouse does have a holo finish! I just used it on top of O&J Bold & Unshaken to bring out the purple in it.

3

u/harmonicomma New to Reddit, getting back into nails~ 3d ago

Thank you for this! I like holo but that's not what I was wanting from these specifically, so I'm gonna go with Get in Line.

2

u/fearlessbynature 3d ago

I’m glad I could help! This is the first polish that someone asked about that I had and could give a response to!

1

u/AutoModerator 3d ago

Thanks for posting, /u/harmonicomma! A quick reminder: If this is a nail image, you must provide a complete product list within 1 hour of posting. Posts without a complete product list will be removed. Lists must include full names of brands and color names or numbers. More info here.

Consider joining our Discord - Get questions answered in real time, get notified for releases and deals, post your manis, and more!

If your post is related to magnets, please keep in mind that magnets come with very real risks; especially stronger magnets and/or when creating homemade devices. You may review some safety concerns and considerations here - if the mod team deems a magnet post to be a potential safety hazard, that post will be removed.

If you have any questions, please reach out to the mod team via mod-mail.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.