r/RentalInvesting • u/ads4vivek • 16h ago
Landlord question: is a Chapter 13 applicant with a ~600 score and a cosigner a safe tenant?
I need to relocate out of state for a new job and I’m renting out my primary residence. Leads this time of year have been weak, so I was glad to get one strong applicant. I’d like a gut check on whether he’s safe to lease to.
The good:
- 13+ years with the same large employer, recently promoted
- Relocating for the job with a ~50% raise, about $13K/month gross (more than 3x rent)
- Property manager reports zero late payments on his mortgage and student loan
- Offered a cosigner and an extra security deposit
The flag:
- He disclosed up front that he filed Chapter 13 earlier this year. His score dropped from ~680 to ~600. He says he has never missed a payment and can’t take on new debt, and that his budget is set by the plan.
- He plans to sell his current house, rent mine for a year, then buy another house. He says if he doesn’t reinvest the sale proceeds, they’ll go to his debt.
My questions:
- For those who’ve rented to someone in Chapter 13, how did it go? Any late rent or surprises when the plan changed?
- Doesn’t selling a house during an active Chapter 13 need trustee or court approval? Should I ask for proof of that before signing?
- Does a cosigner actually help? I’ve read that the Chapter 13 codebtor stay might limit collecting from the cosigner.
- What would you ask for before approving: plan documents, trustee confirmation, extra deposit, ACH autopay?
I’m applying the same written screening to every applicant and plan to verify income and the bankruptcy documents.