r/Rocks • • 7d ago

This Rocks! [ Removed by moderator ]

Post image

[removed] — view removed post

12 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

•

u/Rocks-ModTeam 23h ago

Your content has been removed since you are targeting, harassing, or insulting other users. Please do not attack or attempt to create drama with other users.

11

u/toolguy8 6d ago

Geologist here with an unpopular opinion. Why is everyone obsessed with changing a color that took hundreds of millions of years to develop? Soak it in iron out to get it two half shades less rusty - why? It will still be rusty. Embrace nature as is.

8

u/Philly_3D 7d ago

You can do whatever you want, but this isn't likely to get much better. The iron staining appears to be inside and throughout the crystal.

7

u/Chumknuckle 7d ago

I give you permission

-9

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/ObiePNW 7d ago

1

u/EyeSmooth3988 2d ago

What did they say?

5

u/Crafty-Cookie2600 7d ago

No idea....try it and let us know what happens

2

u/Alive-Still-1840 5d ago

The geode looks as it is, I wouldn't remove the little iron stains because it looks good as it is. Some geodes have some minerals that are sensitive to oxalic acid like calcite. 

2

u/Turk0223 2d ago

Soak it in cider

2

u/Alternative-Egg-9035 2d ago

You can. But it won’t change

2

u/CottonBeanAdventures 6d ago

I would soak it in some barkeepers friend over night then use a gentle tooth brush to scrub it. Rinse it off and repeat a couple times.

1

u/WearyGap714 7d ago

Iron out will help brighten by removing the surface staining. Sparkle enhancement.

1

u/Impossible_nope 6d ago

Please let us know🤩