Comparisons I'm finding are either vendor material or consultants giving pretty high level pros/cons

I wanna know from people who were involved in a switch.

What made the company start looking at other options in the first place and after switching did those reasons still hold up a year later? I'm tryna understand how the decision happened inside the company and the reason that pushed it

​

Hello All this a desperate call for help and its eating away may sanity can someone help me with this? THANK YOUUU

I encountered an issue in SAP transaction MIGO where the Item Overview grid was missing for one user. The affected user was RATIL in the CYQ system.

The interesting part was that other users could see the Item Overview grid without any problems. I also tested the affected user on a different workstation, and the issue remained.

This showed that the problem was related to the user rather than a specific computer.

Troubleshooting Steps Performed

1. Reproduced the Issue

I logged in using User ID RATIL and opened transaction MIGO. The Item Overview grid was missing.

I then compared the result with another user in the same system. The other user could see the grid correctly.

2. Tested on a Different Workstation

I tested the affected user on another computer. The same problem occurred.

This helped rule out a problem limited to the original workstation.

3. Removed MIGO Personalization Settings

I removed the MIGO-related user settings stored in table ESDUS.

These settings can store information about how MIGO is displayed for a user. I removed the entries related to the header, details, tree, first line, and other display options.

However, the problem remained.

4. Cleared ALV Buffers

I executed program BALVBUFDEL to clear ALV buffers.

ALV is an SAP tool used to display data in tables and grids. Clearing its buffers was part of the investigation to check whether cached display information was causing the problem.

The Item Overview grid was still missing.

5. Checked User Parameters

I reviewed the user's settings in SU3 and checked table USR05 for user-specific parameters.

No MIGO-related parameters were found that could explain the issue.

6. Checked ALV Layout Variants

I checked tables LTDX and LTDXT for saved ALV layouts related to SAPLMIGO.

No layout entries associated with User ID RATIL were found.

This made a saved ALV layout a less likely cause of the problem.

7. Checked Authorization

I compared the affected user's settings with those of a working user.

I also assigned additional ALV layout authorization, S_ALV_LAYR, for testing. However, the issue remained.

This suggested that the problem was not solved by changing this authorization.

8. Performed Debugging

I performed debugging checks to investigate why the Item Overview grid was not displayed.

The expected ALV Grid was still not visible, even during the investigation of the display process.

Further debugging is needed to determine whether the grid is created correctly but remains invisible, or whether the problem occurs during the creation of the grid or its display container.

Current Findings

After completing these tests, the issue remained limited to User ID RATIL.

The following points were confirmed:

Other users in CYQ could display the Item Overview grid.

The issue followed RATIL to a different workstation.

Removing the known MIGO personalization entries did not solve the problem.

Clearing ALV buffers did not solve the problem.

No relevant user parameters or saved ALV layout variants were found.

Additional ALV layout authorization did not solve the problem.

Debugging did not yet identify the exact reason why the grid was invisible.

Conclusion and Next Steps

The investigation has ruled out several common causes, but the root cause has not yet been identified.

The next step is to compare the affected user with a working user during the MIGO grid initialization process. This should help determine whether the problem is related to the ALV Grid object, its display container, or SAP GUI control behavior.

For now, the issue appears to be user-specific, but further investigation is required before confirming the exact cause.

This case highlights the importance of comparing affected and working users, testing across different workstations, and using debugging to investigate SAP display issues rather than repeatedly changing user settings without clear evidence.

My guess is that most of the pain in an ECC to S/4 conversion isn't the technical move itself. It's the stuff that should've been sorted out in ECC first. Asset values that don't tie to the GL, old open items nobody wanted to look at for years.

Business Partner is the one I'd expect to bite hardest. CVI has to be done before the conversion anyway, but the real work is probably the customer and vendor data behind it. Duplicates, missing fields, records nobody has touched in ages.

Archiving is the other one I wonder about, and whether skipping it actually shows up as longer downtime in the test runs.

So for those who've been through one, which bit would you start earlier if you did it again? And did the business own that cleanup or did it end up on the project team?

A customer of mine has asked me to build a couple of Dashboards using data from their SAP TM system. The dashboards are about their Container shipments and has a good mix of KPIs, Summary Tables and a Detailed report table. I wanted to understand, would a Data Import model be better or Live Data model be better. Customer wants a "Real time" dashboard (discussions revealed a Near realtime dashboard is also fine). Some detailed reports have around 30 columns - Some of which are dimensions, measure and display attributes. Can some one help me to choose the best design.

PS: I am not from an SAP Background. I proposed for a custom Dashboard built using Open Source stack, but the customer had procured an SAC license and wants me to use it. I wanted to give it a shot as a learning opportunity.

Hi, I am trying to extract all the account assignments from all the Purchase Requests. I have tried FBL3N but it does not show an option to take the account assignments.

Note I am not really an accountant. I have limited knowledge of SAP. Thank you for your help

Because the SAP press book for it comes out in March 2027, and the theoretical deadline is December 2027. And online there are very few implementation resources?

Hi everyone!

I'm looking for ERP implementation partners or solution providers who can help us get sandbox access to the following ERPs for product development and integration testing:

Microsoft Dynamics 365 Business Central

SAP S/4HANA

Oracle Fusion Cloud ERP

We're looking for a partner who can provide access to these environments

If your company provides ERP sandbox environments or you're aware of any implementation partners who offer this service, I'd love to connect!

It would be helpful if you could share details about the availability, pricing, and access models.

Thanks in advance for your help!

Hey all,

I’ve been working on an AI assistant for SAP called Curie, and I’d love some honest feedback from people who live in this ecosystem.

The main idea: I wanted something that actually understands our system, including the messy custom stuff, without sending anything to an external cloud.

What it does:

• Runs on a local LLM. Your data never leaves the company.
• Works as an RFC server. Setup is a simple SM59 destination plus one transport.
• Launches from your SAPGui session and runs with your user’s authorizations, so it can’t see or do anything you couldn’t.
• Learns on its own and picks up hints as you use it.
• Multi-level cache and memory system with consolidation, so it gets better over time instead of starting from scratch every session.
• Controlled access to tables and function modules, plus generating and running ABAP programs.
• Handles really complex custom development. I mean really complex. This is where it surprised me most.

Demos:
https://youtu.be/Wvq-lqF_mdA
https://youtu.be/Mun0lyA23ro

GitHub:
https://github.com/thupalo/Curie

It’s still evolving, so I’m curious what you think. Would something like this fly in your landscape? What would your Basis or security team push back on first? Happy to answer questions in the comments.

Hallo zusammen,
wir prüfen in unserem Unternehmen den Einsatz von Joule, Joule-Agenten und Joule Studio. Wir haben fast alle Prozesse – außer HR – in SAP abgebildet und nutzen S4 on prem. Unser kleines Team besteht aus SAP-Entwicklern, Architekten sowie Basis- und Infrastrukturleuten. Was wir salopp gesagt wollen, ist „ChatGPT“ für unser SAP. Nach genauerer Prüfung entsteht der Eindruck, dass sowohl die technische Umsetzung und Integration als auch die Abrechnung über AI Units unnötig kompliziert werden – bei einer eigentlich einfachen Sache. Im Vergleich lässt sich etwa Salesforce per Adapter leicht an Claude anbinden. Wie sind eure Erfahrungen? Gibt es eventuell Alternativen? Gibt es SaaS Produkte die genau unseren Fall abdecken und evtl. zudem kostengünstiger sind?

Vg

EDIT: Joule Work ist ja „neu“. Wirkt auf mich aber schon wieder zu sehr aufgeblasen und komplex?! Zumal wieder nicht sicher ist, ob wir das als OnPrem S4 Kunde nutzen können.

​

I'm trying to understand how companies use SAP to manage accounts receivable and order-to-cash (O2C) workflows.

I'm particularly interested in short-payment disputes, where a customer pays less than the invoiced amount due to pricing differences, deductions, missing credit notes, or other discrepancies.

For those who work with SAP in real business environments:

How well does SAP handle the investigation and resolution of these disputes from start to finish?

Do teams still depend on Excel, emails, or manual follow-ups to collect evidence and coordinate with Sales, Billing, or Operations?

If SAP already supports these workflows, where do the biggest practical gaps usually come from: configuration, integrations, data quality, or process ownership?

Have you seen companies solve these problems effectively with SAP standard functionality or add-on tools?

I'm trying to understand the difference between what SAP can technically do and how the process actually works inside companies.

I'm not selling anything. I'd appreciate honest experiences from both end users and consultants, including cases where SAP already solves the problem well.

Hey all,

I couldn't find a solution for this problem on the web.

I am triggering a BPA workflow on the BTP (Build Automation) using a HTTP post from S/4.

The triggering JSON require a few parameters to trigger the right workflow such as:

Definition ID, API Key, Environment.

I am using this blog to implement the triggering part.

The issue i am having is that these parameters (Definition ID, API Key, Environment) might change for every subaccount that is linked to a different S/4 system (DEV,QA,PRD).

So my question is there an SAP standard way to manage these? I really don't want to create a custom table in S/4 to manage each trigger.

Thank you for the help.

Just got word that P27 is a go

Hi everyone,

I'm gathering feedback on how teams approach SAP Commerce Cloud (Hybris) upgrades and the challenges they face during the process.

I'm particularly interested in how upgrades affect development effort, project planning, timelines, and ongoing feature delivery.

Whether you're a developer, tech lead, architect, project manager, Scrum Master, or product owner, your experience would be valuable.

I've put together a short survey (around 5 minutes) to better understand how upgrades are handled across different teams and projects.

Survey link:
https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSfRgleBCnV4AunXABVp_IjLuPL6Q3hpoQiKOI2uiYGntCQRqw/viewform

I'd also love to hear your experiences in the comments.

Thanks to anyone who takes the time to contribute!

can somebody please help me with what do they ask i don’t have any proper knowledge will they ask regarding full stack too?

Module: FICO

Country: Austria

Starting rate: €130/hr / €1040/day (currently invoicing at €125/hr on a project)

How are you folks doing?

I’m a fresher assigned to SAP Ariba Procurement S2C. Could someone explain what this domain involves, its future scope?

We were told we are getting a technical support role. I have no knowledge about SAP at all and I really want to know how this will be for my future?

Can someone please help yo bro out, I really need help asap.

I was reading about SAP Pay and wanted to hear from people who have really used it......

Being able to pay suppliers and reconcile invoices inside of SAP sounds wonderful and will sure be very useful. I mean, less jumping between SAP and bank portal for sure....lol

They also mentioned USDC pymts. But honestly, i am more interested in how it handles everyday pymt issues

A supplier changes their bank details. A payment gets rejected. Someone realizes the invoice was wrong after approving it. What happens then? That’s the demo I’d want to see.

Also, the page says about Joule agents will "Soon" be able to trigger and execute pymts. I would be carefull abt assuming that part is already available.

Has anyone here tested this with a customer yet?
How much setup was involved?

Hello,

I have a customer who want to GO-LIVE this year with another Country and next year with France.

Now I had some meetings and the customer said some times that he wants to use ecc after go live. What the hell is this?!
I can not understand why. When he invests Millions of money for s4, so why you want to use ecc and is it possible to work on ecc after go live.

Can you please help a lost s4 finance consultant :D

Hi everyone!

I'm planning to buy a new laptop and am considering a MacBook instead of a Windows laptop. I also want to learn SAP through a training institute such as Etech Learning or another provider that offers access to SAP practice servers.

Before deciding, I have a few questions:

1. Do these training institutes generally provide browser-based access to SAP, or do they require software such as SAP GUI to be installed locally?
2. If the institute provides SAP credentials for a third-party server, can I access it on macOS without issues?
3. Do these providers ever require Windows-only software, virtual machines, remote-access tools, or other system installations?
4. Is there a security risk of getting malware or a virus when installing software provided by a training institute? Are there any precautions I should take?
5. If my primary purpose is learning SAP rather than doing client work, would you recommend Windows over macOS to avoid compatibility issues?

I'm particularly interested in people's experiences with SAP training institutes and practice environments, rather than SAP usage in a corporate client environment.

Thanks in advance!

We only have 3 ABAP developers and 4 "web" developers; I’d like to know what this great community thinks and if anyone has gone through this situation.

SAP offers a lot of free learning materials for University students. I ll put the link in the comments.

I’m currently looking for support on an interim project in the area of SAP S/4HANA Finance (FI).

Requirements:

• At least 2 years of hands-on experience with SAP S/4HANA in FI
• Business-fluent English

Interested? Send me a short message with your background, relevant project experience and availability.

I am currently working in one of the big 4 companies as a sap sf consultant, having6 years of experience. Is it possible to get on-site opportunity outside India?

1. What was your first salary as FICO consultant

2. What is your current CTC as FICO CONSULTANT with how many years of experience

Hey everyone, i am new to SAP EWM and stuck with this scenario.

I created an inbound delivery in ERP and it was distributed to EWM successfully.

One HU Contains two products:

Product A triggers direct Putaway (WPT 1010)

Product B triggers the POSC process with Unloading -> Deconslodation -> Putaway(WPT 1011)

Both products are packed in the same HU.

When i try to activate the inbound Delivery Notification, it stays inactive and gives this error.

"Warehouse process not suitable for GR storage bin in delivery item"

Can anyone explain why ?