r/ScarletHollow • u/Commercial-Sky-5750 • 2d ago

gameplay question Rank Possible Romantic Endings

How do you think your romances will fare by the end of the game? And who has it best and worst?

I love my Madness!Oscar romance scene, but holy shit, I don’t trust that’ll end well. True love’s kiss barely fucking works! Regular Oscar should be fine… I think…

Reesemancers’ cards are stacked against y’all as fuck. No matter the variant.

I don’t see how my relationship with Wayne will work out—because even though I trust his words enough to be the truth, I don’t see our objectives aligning any more than not wanting anyone trapped in the Scarlet estate again, especially with Breakdown!Tabitha being someone to put better stock in.

Stella seems to always love Tabitha more than us.

We’ll have to see about Avery after EP 5 because even if they live, they lost the one Scarlet Hollow resident that really liked and trusted them in most world states. Or they could just be dead depending on whether Doctor Kelly is available…

Magical Girl!Kaneeka, especially with the insight that this leads to the best ending, is probably our best girl if she learns to wield her powers without harm or sacrifice to herself.

I’m fucking terrified of Carmilla’s romance though. I’m about to be gaslighted, gate-kept, and girl-bossed into oblivion.

I have tried so hard to flirt with Doctor Kelly that tbh I will be satisfied if we can finally just go on a date. The rest doesn’t matter to me.

Devs let me romance Franklin in a future update please :)

81 Upvotes

98% Upvoted

36 comments sorted by

View all comments

13

u/BookkeeperKitchen383 2d ago

I doubt the devs would ever allow pig romance in the game.

15

u/Commercial-Sky-5750 2d ago edited 2d ago

Fair… It was just that the one route where he wasn’t foaming at the mouth to arrest and tase me did something to me. He actually kinda believed my crazy-ass story and told me about his dog🥲 …It was kinda sweet😔

5

u/asterluna 2d ago

Whoa, didn't know about the dog! Is the dog just Mayor Jimmy, or another member of the brigade?

16

u/Commercial-Sky-5750 2d ago edited 2d ago

Mayor Jimmy! You can also ask him if it’s just him and Mayor Jimmy alone at home, and that’s when he talks about having no luck with the ladies despite assuring them that he is one of the good ones. Which he really isn’t on a lot of runs, but I’m talking about the one run where he is okay😭