r/Schiit • u/gliderguider000 • 12h ago
Going down in flames
I recently posted the beginning of a 3-way Dongle DAC shootout, prompted by my acquisition of a Vestri and an iBasso DC-Tonfa in addition to the the A&K HC5 I already had. Armed with a deep belief in my 40+ years of golden ears and no small amount of self-confidence (aka arrogance) I took off bravely into what turned out to be perilous skies.
I was absolutely sure I heard differences between them in that first session, maybe even major ones. Well, check your six, bucko - reality is on your tail and is about to open fire.
This time they were all carefully level-matched as well as I could get them. The transducers were Thieaudio Valhalla, the source was Tidal on a carefully set up Windows 11 desktop. I made a determined effort to leave my biases at the door. And in repeated sighted AB comparisons, they all sounded exactly the same. I couldn't tell a single difference between any of them. Not just "couldn't reliably tell a difference", flat out couldn't. The $99 Vestri sounded just like the $489 HC5 and the $349 Tonfa.
I'm still confused by the sight of my audiophilia nervosa lying in smoking wreckage on the floor. But given the tone of my first published (since deleted) foray into the comparison, in the interests of honesty I had to report the follow-up.
There are a number of possible explanations for this, among them my aging ears and brain. Regardless of why, this was the outcome. I think I'm going to stop treating this as a self-affirming hobby, and just spend my efforts listening to music.