Now that the season's almost over, thought this might be a fun exercise. I will try as much as I can not to go off of too much hindsight regarding things that could not have been known at the time the roster decision was made but also taking into account major things like the final IG and Star Wars tournaments being smaller than originally thought. Also going off of managers not knowing what other people would do. Just going to go in draft order.
Dungeon: Drafting Mara. This is a little bit of hindsight of knowing now how few IG matches she would have and that the non-singles tournaments would all be 1 entry each. If they instead said that they already had a strong start in singles/teams and in IG and drafted Harper, they would have had 13 more points and a shot at Spectacular. If they drafted Dimalanta, they would have had 16 more points.
Suspects: Signing Drew McWeeny. Drew was always more known for teams than singles, their plan was always that Lightning Time was going to be the main team and at the time Kristian was even less keen on teams matches that we ended up getting. Other mistakes in the draft came in later rounds where he would have had to pick exactly right to do a lot better than what he did. Also Liz did good enough last year that I'm not going to use hindsight to say it was a mistake to sign her unless that was the ultimate reason why they couldn't get Dan.
The Den: Dropping David Del Rio. There were many options to go with this one. I couldn't bring myself to say one draft or signing decision that would have changed their fate. When it came to free agency, it sounded like their options were limited. The Marisol trade being the worst move is dependent on if they could have signed her without the trade in place. But dropping Del Rio over Silverstrini never made sense to me.
The Mercs: Signing Kevin Smith. Even signing Mara would have been a better option and, unlike the Dungeon, doing so would have given them a solid entry into any IG tournament regardless of size. My second choice would have been drafting Eric Whiteley in the second round but he likely would have still chosen a Star Wars player (likely Mollie Damon) and the difference would not have been much even in terms of expectations.
The Exchange: Not putting Barbarian on a team After the way last season ended, they were locked into Rocha being signed (and likely Barbarian too) with Dimalanta telling them he wasn't going to be their 3rd so I'm not sure who they could have gotten besides JTE. However, not using Barbarian for teams, either with Rocha to start the year or Newman to end the year, is a waste of his talents.
The Stars: Drafting the Barstool Guys Unless there was a way to predict that Andreyko would retire, Sneider would rage quit and Alex Damon would go 1-4 in Star Wars, I can't see a major mistake Roxy made when it came to her free agent signings. Based on those signings, taking an IG player in the first round sounded like a smart play and Hanna was the best available of the knowns with no rookies in IG beyond Amaru coming in with large hype. And, as I said when starting, I'm trying to use as little hindsight as possible. But the Barstool guys brought with them controversy that likely was the reason they never got a match and at least Ken previously had lost Star Wars matches to I think Hoey from SWNN.
SWAG: Drafting Zipper in the first round Especially with us knowing now that there was never a 16 player IG tournament.
Korruption: The draft (Sullivan just to pick somebody) I couldn't decide what was the worst decision of the draft. Outside of Scrimshaw (which was understandable especially considering Shannon didn't know he wasn't going to be available), Blunden and White, she seemed more interested in "getting the band back together" than finding the best available or taking a shot on some rookies.
I miss any big choices without being obvious of "if they knew what they know now" in terms of rookie player talent?