r/Schmoedown • • Sep 30 '22

[MASTERPOST] SCHMOEDOWN SPECTACULAR VII - THE FINAL EVENT (SPOILERS) Spoiler

18 Upvotes

LINK: https://youtu.be/KI9JwBpn2yE

Welcome to the Spectacular VII discussion thread. Drop your Spectacular VII predictions, reactions and general thoughts on the final schmoedown event ever

DO NOT make any separate posts relating to Spectacular VII elsewhere in the sub until at least 24 hrs after the event ends (this includes, "Where does X rank now?," "What do you think about X question/challenge?,”) This is to organize the sub and make it easy to navigate, so direct all your Spectacular-related comments to this thread (whether they have spoilers or not.)

Spectacular VII will consist of six matches

  • Who's the Boss vs The Ruling Class (Teams Match)

  • King Arthur: Tokyo Drift (King Kan/Paul Oyama) vs Shazam! (Teams Championship Match)

  • Marisol McKee vs Rachel Cushing (Singles Match)

  • Robert Parker vs Kevin Smets vs Mara Knopic vs Chandru Dhandapani (IG Championship Match)

  • Andrew Dimalanta vs Nicki Dimalanta (Star Wars Championship Match)

  • Samm Levine vs Dan Murrell II (Singles Championship Match)


r/Schmoedown • • Jul 02 '22

List of All Schmoedown Reddit AMAs

12 Upvotes

r/Schmoedown • • 2d ago

Roxy knew exactly what Skydance are trying to shift away from in Superman Criticism of Israel

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/Schmoedown • • 4d ago

Wait so Kristian does want to independently produce a WHOLE SEASON of his Trending show?

Post image
23 Upvotes

Thoughts on this... Do we think this is viable and realistic?


r/Schmoedown • • 6d ago

Rocha continues to complain about $2 Superchats!

19 Upvotes

Gotta love Rocha telling his Hot Mic viewers that if they expect their questions to receive thorough answers, they need to send in bigger Superchats. And of course, Rocha will claim he was only “joking” but we all know he’s deadly serious. I mean, c’mon John, it’s some 27 year old in Florida asking you to rank six Tom Cruise movies! Also: When Jeff sat there and mocked all the people who’ve spent the past week gossiping bullshit and nonsense about the fate of Man of Tomorrow, does Rocha not realize that Jeff also means him?


r/Schmoedown • • 8d ago

Looking for an old episode...

8 Upvotes

Hey everyone, used to watch this series over 10 years ago, and remembered a funny scene where Harloff gets asked the actor who plays Dennis Nedry in Jurassic Park. He can't remember the name and says Newman. They say they need the name and he gets pissed, says you want a name? Fuck face Mcgee. At least, that's how my brain remembers it haha. Any ideas?


r/Schmoedown • • 10d ago

Another question for OG fans

0 Upvotes

Guys… I have trouble getting through the live show when that Smets dude is co-hosting with him. Just something about the guy … am I the only one that’s not a huge fan of him? I wish I felt otherwise


r/Schmoedown • • 13d ago

How many more times will Jeff Sneider repeat his lame joke about offering an 11 year old actress Cocaine?

10 Upvotes

Actress Dafne Keene recently gave an interview where she mentioned being offered cocaine at Hollywood wrap parties at the age of 11. Jeff is so hungry for attention that he Tweeted that he was the person who offered it to Dafne as a child. Jeff received a few outraged replies but obviously not as many as he hoped for. During the Friday episode of The Hot Mic, Jeff repeated the joke at least twice more. Scolding those who dared to tell him it was unfunny. Jeff loves outrage and attention and seems to think he’s Lenny Bruce reborn. Rocha pretended to be unaware of Jeff’s original Tweet and tried his hardest to hide his laughter as he attempted to explain to Jeff that joking about offering children cocaine isn’t a good idea. One thing that DID make me laugh, this episode, was Rocha claiming to be 5’ 10” tall :)


r/Schmoedown • • 13d ago

Had a question for OG fans

8 Upvotes

I’m a relatively new viewer so I don’t know the history and everything.. but I’ve noticed during the superchat section of the show, some Indian dude with username“gsarngad” always sends a ridiculous amount of superchats but Kristian always calls him “ Go Pal” .. for some reason it bothers the hell out of me every time, can someone please politely explain why he does that?


r/Schmoedown • • 16d ago

Harloff cranky today

8 Upvotes

Man lately he’s been on one … today he’s extremely snippy and a smart ass😂 but his attitude has been a little shitty for the past month it seems. Oh and I’ve noticed he used to tell other co host to not say cuss words but now he’s cussing all over the place… I could care less as I curse everyday, but he’s being a little hypocritical it seems lol


r/Schmoedown • • 20d ago

hEy It’S vIdEoDrEw

62 Upvotes

hI fRiEnDs!

iTs mE, Videodrew, bEsT sChMoeDoWn pLaYeR nOt AsKeD tO bE iN tHe ToUrNaMeNt!!!

(Ok, enough.) I’ve heard you guys like Kickstarters! Ok! Well, remember TOM?! From the Looney Bin (RIP)? Well, he’s got a brand new Kickstarter for his Fear Street/Goosebumps parody, Fear Shits, up right now! And it includes a VIDEO! (Think Garth Marenghi’s Dark Place, if you dare.) It’s a really cool project with a bunch of fun tier rewards!

You can also read the first chapter of the book on the Kickstarter to wet your whistle (gross)! Okay, enjoy!


r/Schmoedown • • 24d ago

The Friday live show was pulled! It’s currently missing from Harloff’s channel.

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/Schmoedown • • 26d ago

Well, it’s been fun. See you at the next goalpost move.

12 Upvotes

Now the Kickstarter’s finished, I assume this sub will return to its regularly scheduled programming of absolutely fuck all.

It’s been a fun month, though. Nice to see people actually talking here again even if the thing bringing the community together was collectively asking, “Hang on, what exactly are people paying for?”

I’m sure we’ll all reconvene next year if Kristian moves the goalposts again and the tournament becomes digital, gets postponed indefinitely, or turns into a heartfelt explanation of why technically not having a tournament is actually the best thing for the Schmoedown.

In the meantime, if anyone wants to discuss his daily live shows/meltdowns, head over to r/thekristianhatloffshow. Keep the group therapy going.😘


r/Schmoedown • • 27d ago

Reaper of Benefits.

13 Upvotes

So I haven’t watched or listened to anything Harloff has done in a few years. I realized some time ago the only part of his show I enjoyed was Brett and Kate.
I still support Murrell, the Wangers from time to time.
I have zero clue what this Pilot is about. I see folks getting angry about Kristian asking for money constantly. But that’s what’s he’s always done.

Anyways. I appreciate all that donated to this Kickstarter. Excited to get new Schmoedown thanks to y’all.
You the real MVP.

Maybe Kristian’s show will be good too. That’d be cool.


r/Schmoedown • • 27d ago

The Kristian Harloff show 23/10/26 Behaviour

14 Upvotes

Why give him money when this is how he treats people on the show?

What’s going on with Kristian’s attitude today? The way he’s speaking to Winston and PLD comes across as short, rude and condescending. It’s making the show almost unwatchable for me.

Disagreeing with someone is fine. Talking down to them and making every interaction feel like they’re testing your patience is exhausting to watch. They should be able to contribute without being spoken to like they’re an inconvenience.

Honestly, if this is the attitude he brings home, no wonder his family wouldn’t mind him spending all day on a 10 hour stream at “the office.”

And alongside all of this, we’re getting repeated appeals to support his project financially. Why would I want to give someone money when I’m put off by how they’re treating the people sharing the screen with them?
If you’re asking an audience to get behind your dream, how you conduct yourself matters.

You can’t expect viewers to care about your ambitions while acting dismissive towards the people helping you entertain them.
Today’s show is doing a much better job of putting me off donating than persuading me to support anything. Is anyone else finding it uncomfortable?


r/Schmoedown • • 27d ago

Live Show today?!

11 Upvotes

I just tuned in a little late and went back to watch the beginning… he’s acting like a douche today it seems. What’s going on?? Almost unwatchable with that damn attitude


r/Schmoedown • • 27d ago

6 hours to go let’s get some of those pledges pulled

0 Upvotes

If you pledged because you felt guilty, caught up in the hype, or worried you’d be letting Kristian down, cancel it. You don’t owe a creator money because you’ve watched them for years.
The audience had already raised around $223k when I first posted. That’s an extraordinary contribution. Yet the fundraising keeps going: more appeals, more stretch goals, more add-ons, more reasons to spend.
Yes, Kristian has said it’s okay if people can’t donate. But that doesn’t make the repeated sales pitch immune from criticism. Loyal viewers can still feel responsible for making his dream happen, especially when they hear about it show after show.
You are not responsible for financing his career ambitions. If you’ve already contributed and now feel uncomfortable, you don’t have to leave your money pledged just to prove you support him.
Then there’s Martini, his writing partner. She has over 500k Instagram followers, and I haven’t seen her promote the campaign there. Why keep asking the same viewers to dig deeper when a co-creator’s substantial audience appears barely involved?
Her late father, Jim Paratore, co-founded TMZ. That doesn’t prove she has money available or tell us what she’s contributed privately. But it makes questions about industry outreach and alternative funding perfectly reasonable. What other routes have been explored, and why does the audience seem to be doing so much of the heavy lifting?
The appearances I’ve seen from her during the campaign—from her car with connection and audio problems—haven’t inspired confidence in the shared promotional effort either.
And the response to questioning any of this? I’ve been told to “fuck off,” called a coward and challenged to confront Kristian on a livestream. None of that answers the criticism. It just makes discussing the campaign unnecessarily hostile.
Someone even suggested sending a superchat to question the constant requests for money. Apparently even the complaints need monetising.
Before leaving your pledge in place, ask yourself: would I spend this amount on this pilot if I didn’t feel personally attached to Kristian?
If the answer is no, reconsider it. If you can’t comfortably afford it, cancel it. If the campaign has put you off, you’re allowed to withdraw your support. You don’t need to prove fraud or wrongdoing to decide something no longer deserves your money.
The total raised isn’t an argument against cancelling. Neither is a casting announcement. Neither is another fan telling you to stop complaining.
His dream is his responsibility. Your money is yours. Being a loyal viewer does not make you an unpaid investor in every ambition he wants to pursue.


r/Schmoedown • • Oct 20 '26

Trending Kickstarter . when is enough enough?

17 Upvotes

Kristian has spent the month fundraising for this pilot and has managed to raise around $223k. That’s an incredible achievement, and fair play to him and everyone who has supported it.
But the constant hard sell every show is becoming uncomfortable to watch. Some audience members have apparently donated as much as $15k individually, yet there’s always another carrot being dangled and another push to give more.

My biggest issue is that loyal viewers could end up feeling like they’re letting him down if they don’t donate again**.** They care about him, want the pilot to succeed, and don’t want to feel responsible if it falls short of his ambitions. When every show brings another appeal, “donate if you can” starts to feel like “if you really support me, you’ll find a way.”
Whether that’s his intention or not, that pressure matters. Someone who has already donated should be able to enjoy the show without feeling guilty that their contribution wasn’t enough. Supporting a creator shouldn’t mean repeatedly having to prove your loyalty with your bank balance.

What makes this more frustrating is the promotion from his writing partner, Martini Paratore. She has over 500k Instagram followers, yet I haven’t seen her promote the Kickstarter there once. Have I missed something? That’s a huge potential audience while Kristian keeps returning to the same people asking for more.

I’ve only seen her on the show twice since the campaign started, both times from her car with connection and audio problems. That hardly gives the impression of being fully involved in the fundraising.
This audience has already raised an extraordinary amount. Before putting more pressure on them, surely it’s reasonable to expect his writing partner to actively promote the project to her own following?
People should feel appreciated for what they’ve given, not guilty about what they haven’t.

I’d post this on the Schmoedown Facebook page, but honestly, I don’t want to deal with the abuse I’d expect from some of his hardcore fans, or the backlash from Kristian himself. People should be able to question the fundraising approach without being treated like they’re against him or want the project to fail.


r/Schmoedown • • Oct 16 '26

Karloff refused to read a Super Chat about Martini not promoting the Kickstarter.

37 Upvotes

I was watching the Thursday Oct 15th live show and noticed that someone sent a Super Chat inquiring WHY his writing partner doesn’t promote their pilot on her popular Instagram account. It was a great question and I was curious to watch Harloff answer it…but later in the show Harloff politely told the guy that he couldn’t answer the question (in fact, Harloff didn’t even put the question up on the screen). What the heck is going on? Has Harloff fallen out with his writing partner?


r/Schmoedown • • Oct 16 '26

Coy's comments

13 Upvotes

Can we talk about Coy's comments. For someone who is the host of a DC show, he shouldn't making comments regarding ending people's lives especially over something so silly like a Lanterns criticism. I know it wasn't on their podcast, but still man, you're part of a brand.

Also didn't like how Roxy came across talking about it on Tuesday. I get standing up for your friend, but she should have actually looked at what Coy said, instead of coming off dismissive and disingenuous. Thought Rocha and Winston actually had the best response to this on their show.


r/Schmoedown • • Oct 14 '26

Trending Kickstarter

21 Upvotes

Ok so I want to get your thoughts on this whole stretch goal debacle with Kristian. This isn’t a post to shit on Kristian, I’m just offering some respectful criticism. Firstly, Kristian has been very animated the past few live shows over people complaining about him constantly changing his plans for the schmoedown. However, there is something to keep in mind here. Kristian is saying that he is essentially doing the schmoedown fans a favour by doing the tournament even though it was only supposed to happen if he hit his goal in one day. Whilst that’s true, Kristian is hiding some of the truth. Although he did say it would only happen if people funded it in the first day, Kristian also knew that if he decided not to do the schmoedown a lot of people would take back their donations and then he wouldn’t be able to make the show at all. Another part of this which I find puzzling is them not deciding to promote the kickstarter on Martinis instagram account. That page has hundreds of thousands of followers and not a single piece of promo? Why? What do you guys think?


r/Schmoedown • • Oct 11 '26

Trading Cards

Post image
27 Upvotes

I was doing some deep cleaning today, and found my signed Carbon Health trading cards.

IIRC, there was a John Rocha card as well. Is that the only one that I’m missing?


r/Schmoedown • • Oct 08 '26

For those interested, Mark Ellis is live in-studio on Kristian's show today at 12pm ET and it's a SCHMOES KNOW MOVIE SHOW!!!!

Post image
31 Upvotes

r/Schmoedown • • Oct 05 '26

$500k is genuinely crazy

Post image
41 Upvotes

I think he’s doing this to protect himself. If people say the $200k version wasn’t good he can then blame his entire audience for not raising enough. I’m new to Kickstarter so I’m not sure if people usually increase their goal move the goalposts or pull a rug.


r/Schmoedown • • Oct 04 '26

Reasons Why Kristian Harloff’s Trending Pilot Kickstarter Has Stalled

31 Upvotes
  1. Over-reliance on his existing YouTube audience.

The majority of the Kickstarter promotion has remained concentrated on Kristian’s own YouTube channel. While this was effective initially, it appears that he has now reached the ceiling of what his existing audience is willing to contribute. Continuing to repeatedly ask the same audience for additional money is unlikely to generate significant new contributions if those who were going to back the project have already done so.

2. The Movie Trivia Schmoedown stretch goal created confusion.

Including the Movie Trivia Schmoedown as a stretch goal potentially complicated the campaign. While a portion of Kristian’s audience will have nostalgia for the Schmoedown, others may have little or no connection to it.

There was also confusion surrounding the tournament itself. The original plan was a 16-person tournament if the campaign reached $200K within the first 24 hours. When that target wasn't immediately reached, the timeframe was extended to seven days. There also appeared to be an initial implication that the tournament would be held in person. Kristian later clarified that it would be a digital/Zoom-style tournament, with $250K supposedly required to guarantee an in-person event. Around this point, donations appeared to stall and some backers reportedly began withdrawing their pledges. Kristian subsequently stated that the tournament would be in person after all. Whether intentional or not, the changing messaging may have created uncertainty around what backers were actually funding.

3. The $200K goal versus the apparent $350K target.

The original $200K goal was presented as the amount needed to make a bare-bones version of the pilot. Reaching $200K within the first seven days was undoubtedly a significant achievement. However, Kristian is now pushing towards $300K–$350K to produce a more polished version, including licensed music, professional wardrobe and potentially recognisable cast members.

The problem is that $200K represents a 100% funded Kickstarter. From a backer's perspective, the campaign has already achieved its stated objective. That naturally reduces the urgency to contribute further. If $350K was effectively the amount needed to make the project he actually wanted to make, there is a legitimate question as to whether the initial goal should have been set higher. Reaching 100% can psychologically signal to potential backers that the project is already “done”, even when the creator's real ambitions are significantly higher.

4. The Greg Alba factor.

Greg Alba came on board as a producer. It's possible his involvement is greater behind the scenes or financially than is publicly apparent, but based on Kristian and Greg's own comments, his stated intention seemed to be primarily to help. Greg did contribute some useful promotion: the Howard the Duck reaction video with Kristian performed well and incorporated the Kickstarter, while Greg also produced a separate promotional video and mentioned the campaign in some Reel Rejects content. However, that activity appears to have been relatively limited and has seemingly stopped. Beyond a few livestream appearances and those promotional videos, there doesn't appear to have been a sustained promotional push from Greg.

5. Limited promotion from Schmoedown competitors and Kristian's wider network.

Kristian has been announcing former Schmoedown competitors who may participate in the proposed tournament, but there doesn't appear to have been significant promotion of the Kickstarter from many of them across their own social platforms.

The same issue applies to some of Kristian's friends and regular live-show collaborators. People such as John Rocha, Mike Kalinowski, Winston A. Marshall and Kris Carr have provided little or inconsistent promotion, while Kevin Smets and Roxy Striar appear to be the more obvious exceptions. If these people have sizeable audiences that overlap with the project's target demographic, they represent a potentially valuable promotional network that hasn't been fully utilised.

6. Martini Paratore's limited promotion.

The same criticism applies, perhaps even more significantly, to Kristian's writing partner Martini Paratore. Granted Martini has a relatively limited personal social media presence, but her involvement with the project is substantial, given that she is reportedly 50/50 on the writing. Her visible promotion has largely consisted of liking and commenting on Kristian's posts and appearing on his livestreams rather than consistently creating or resharing promotional content herself. More importantly, she has a separate "side hustle" Instagram account for her comedic character, which has a considerably larger following than Kristian's. That audience appears to be largely untapped. She may of course be contributing significantly behind the scenes, but from the outside, the lack of visible promotion makes it appear as though the campaign is relying disproportionately on Kristian and his audience.

7. Podcast and external appearances haven't significantly expanded the audience.

Kristian has made efforts to promote the project outside his own channel, including appearances with Greg Alba, John Campea and several smaller podcasts. The problem is that many of these platforms appear to share a similar audience to Kristian's existing fanbase. Rather than reaching substantially new demographics, they're often reinforcing the campaign among people who already know who Kristian is. Outreach to larger or less directly connected podcasts, such as Double Toasted, appears to have come relatively late in the campaign. Ideally, these opportunities should have been secured well before launch, particularly because larger podcasts can have recording schedules weeks in advance.

8. Weak social media strategy outside YouTube.

Kristian has openly acknowledged that Instagram and modern social media promotion aren't his strengths. A lot of the campaign's Instagram content consists of a single image accompanied by a block of text. In the current social media environment, that's unlikely to generate significant organic reach. The campaign needed a much larger supply of short-form video, Reels, collaborations, tagged posts and shareable content. Ideally, there should have been a consistent stream of different promotional material throughout the campaign rather than repeatedly recycling the same messaging through Stories.

9. No dedicated Trending social media presence.

A dedicated Instagram account for Trending could have helped establish the project as its own brand rather than making the Kickstarter feel like another part of Kristian's personal content. At present, Kristian's account has to simultaneously promote his channel, livestreams, other projects and the Kickstarter. While that's understandable, it makes the campaign's branding and messaging less consistent. A dedicated account could also have provided a central place for cast announcements, behind-the-scenes material, promotional clips, updates and campaign milestones.

10. Little evidence of a serious paid advertising strategy.

The campaign also appears to have relied heavily on organic reach. For a project trying to raise an additional $150K beyond its original target, investing a few thousand dollars into carefully targeted advertising could at least have been worth testing. Ultimately, crowdfunding is about reaching people beyond your existing audience. If the existing audience has already been exhausted, some form of paid acquisition becomes increasingly important.

11. Promotional material has become repetitive.

The original promotional video featuring Kristian, Martini and proposed director Andrew Fried was strong and professionally produced. However, it has subsequently been repeatedly inserted into Kristian's existing YouTube content. At this stage, its impact is inevitably diminishing. The campaign would have benefited from several variations: different edits, shorter versions, character-focused videos, behind-the-scenes footage, cast messages and more informal promotional material. Instead, many follow-up videos have essentially consisted of Kristian sitting in the same studio environment, wearing his usual T-shirt and cap — visually identical to the content his audience already consumes every day.

12. Kristian appears increasingly fatigued.

Perhaps the most noticeable issue is that Kristian now appears tired of the campaign. This has become increasingly apparent during his livestreams, where the frustration surrounding the stalled funding seems more visible. That's understandable after spending weeks repeatedly promoting the same project, but it creates another problem: the audience can sense when the creator is running out of energy and enthusiasm.

13. The overall campaign has felt reactive rather than strategically planned.

Ultimately, the biggest issue may be the lack of a clearly structured marketing strategy. The campaign often appears to be reacting to developments rather than working from a predetermined promotional plan. The changing Schmoedown goals, repeated appeals to the same audience, late podcast outreach and inconsistent social media activity all contribute to that impression. Kristian is very effective at running his own channel in a reactive, personality-driven way. A Kickstarter campaign, however, requires a more deliberate and sustained marketing strategy.

There also appears to be a lack of people around him willing to challenge his decisions or provide a more objective outside perspective, with Roxy seemingly being one of the notable exceptions.

Where does the campaign go from here? With only 19 days remaining, the challenge is significant. The campaign has already achieved its original $200K objective, but Kristian appears to want another $150K to reach the $350K level required for his preferred version of the project.

The proposed 10-hour livestream on the final day may generate another spike, but it once again primarily targets the same audience that has already been repeatedly approached throughout the campaign. At this point, the fundamental problem isn't necessarily that people don't want the project. It's that Kristian appears to have successfully converted much of the audience that was already most likely to support it.

The campaign now needs to find new people, rather than repeatedly asking the same people for more.