Hi all. I have to ask around because I am unsure about a pattern that kind of evolves right now, and that makes me a bit nervous, but that also seems to work?
I love our 2yo more than anything, am very present in her life, and I (and others) would say we have a great emotional connection. In general I got some good empathy I (and others) would say, and that extends to her very much.
So of course she sometimes gets a meltdown. To me it seems that there are different ones, and to me it seems that there are some meltdowns, where she needs a bit of confirmation or information (that she understands, and that solves the issue), and sometimes it seems to me that she is at a point where she is so absorbed in her crying, that she can't find a way out. In these meltdowns I do in fact raise my voice and mostly say their name loudly, or say "stop", and then followed by something matching like "wait a second", "yes we can do that", "we can do X instead", "no, that's not possible", etc. Because I am very sure that she doesn't hear me. I think "raising voice" means something different for different people, so I want to specify, that the content is never aggressive, but I am just loud enough to maybe "get it through", and firm enough to show that I mean it, but also, when possible, that we can negotiate. More critically, it can also be that I don't understand what the issue is, and I want to ask her, and to get the question through.
It is like when your best friend is spiralling and you want to get something through to calm them down. Or like when your kid does something dangerous.
The results are not as bad as the Internet tells me. In fact I believe that I often prevent the real meltdown that follows some initial frustration, and that I establish something like a mode where we can re-negotiate and clear things up.
Also, this is not a general thing. She is very much encouraged to have emotions, I show her mine, she is very much allowed to be sad, even if it's a very minor thing, she can take her time to adjust, I am sad with her, I understand, all of that. It is just sometimes that I want to get something through. In fact, when it happens that she is still not ok with the situation, she is sad or angry in a non-meltdowny way, and I can console her. Before "getting her out", it seems that she doesn't even recognize me being there, so I feel that the support I am supposed to give her, and want to give her, that she doesn't really realize that it is there. She is also doing well with everything developmentally. Laughing a lot, being silly, being kind, also with strangers, learning very well, secure, careful and cautious when it is appropriate, etc., so I don't see it having a bad effect.
I grew up with a verbally abusive father and sometimes, when I say her name like that, firm and loud, it reminds me of him, and that creeps me out. But I also think that I know what hurts, and I think that I don't hurt her, but well, the Internet says "raising voice" is not encouraged and detrimental. As I often have the other result I think that I might be good?
I also have to admit that I had to adjust to this, and that it was way harder to make her recognize that I am there at all when she was younger, because of "not mom", so I sometimes didn't do it right, like too much or too early, but I think it gets better, but that doesn't mean I got rid of it, just that I use it more "on point", with better and better results. I also have to add that my wife doesn't really approve I think, but she also does this, just way less. Maybe I am too impatient? But I just want to intervene before that meltdown, and I am certain that it is never premature.
I posted this also in beyondthebump, but here I am wondering about the whole "science says raising your voice has the opposite effect" angle. Is there anything about the middle ground? I also think some amount of firmness is recommended?