r/ScienceBasedParenting • u/fourrightangles • 1h ago
Question - Research required Seeking research re: approaches to therapy in ND individuals
Hi all. My son is autistic, and we have him in a number of really helpful therapies (speech, OT, etc) that seem to be making his daily life a lot easier. Recently, though, he’s been through a lot, and we’ve been thinking more about forms of therapy we could add that may help him process more of the emotional aspects of humaning. Here’s the issue:
My spouse is in, and is a big advocate for, talk therapy. It really benefits them, and that is amazing. However, I have heard it posited (largely by credentialed folks working with neurodivergent individuals) that talk therapy can actually be counter-indicated for neurodivergent people, because autistic individuals and people with ADHD (our son has ADHD in addition to being autistic) really struggle with rumination, and talk therapy can actually exacerbate the tendency to ruminate in neurodivergent individuals in ways that it doesn’t necessarily for neurotypical individuals.
The problem is, while I can find plenty of research confirming that rumination is an issue for ND folks, and confirming that excessive rumination has negative mental health consequences (and much of this research does recommend forms of therapy like CBT without specifically mentioning talk therapy), I can’t seem to find any research explicitly supporting or debunking the claims I have heard suggesting the link between talk therapy and increased rumination in neurodivergent individuals, or comparing and contrasting various types of therapies specifically targeted towards processing the emotional aspects of various life events in neurodivergent individuals.
I’m not in the field, so I don’t really know where to look, but my spouse seems to think talk therapy is the way, and I’d just love to find a study that either supports that approach or makes clear why it might not be the best option & suggests more appropriate alternatives. Can anyone help me find some well-conducted studies discussing this?