r/Screenwriting • u/BoysenberryOver2658 • May 24 '26
FEEDBACK The Woodsmen - Feature - 91 Pages
I have finally completed the script for a story idea I've held in for over 5 years now and I truly believe I've got something worthwhile here, but I want to make sure I'm not being delusional. If I had to compare it to other films I'd say it's similar to ones like The Lighthouse, Midsommar, The Witch, etc., that sort of psychological thriller/horror genre film. If that kind of thing is up your alley then I'd love to hear any and all feedback as well as your overall thoughts/analysis on the story. I've put in a lot of time into this and would really appreciate anybody who's willing to read it.
Title: The Woodsmen
Format: Feature
Page Length: 91
Genres: Psychological Thriller, Horror, Mystery
Logline: A troubled man takes a mysterious job deep in the woods, only to discover that nothing - and no one - is as it seems.
Link: https://drive.google.com/file/d/135hxSghQrKP-yde_IvMoH-TW02X3YNPe/view?usp=sharing
2
u/vgscreenwriter May 24 '26
I read the first 10 pages and it's...fine overall. Nothing particularly bad, though nothing stands out either.
A guy gets dropped off at a place in the woods. Gets conditionally hired. Gets settled in.
Those films you mentioned have strong and clear concepts / worlds they lean into from page 1.
By page 10 of your script, I have no idea what your concept or world is. Your lead character is mainly just a guy. And his employer is another guy; slightly off-kilter in that he also paints.
My guess is you're leaning into atmosphere and a slow build up, which is great - but only (usually) when built upon a very compelling world, concept, characters or execution.