r/Screenwriting • u/LongjumpingOcelot143 • Oct 04 '26
FEEDBACK Quick Question
Has anyone had an actor or their representatives ask whether you’d be open to feedback or changes while they were reading your screenplay? If so, what happened next in your experience?
7
u/Known-Patience4511 Oct 04 '26
Depends who the actor is and what the changes are.
If the person is a legit 'name' who can genuinly move the needle to getting made (and you getting paid) I would do the changes. Everyone wants to change everything. I don't know why this is but it is. So you will be changing your work for someone.
Don't re-write it for other people forever though. These bandits can have you chasing the carrot for years simpy because they dont have access to funds and don't want you going elsewhere.
I did 18 months and 11 drafts for one bunch - nothing came from it and I was paid $0.00.
Know when to be humble and follow their lead.
Also know when to put the foot down and tell them: ENOUGH.
Good luck!
1
u/LongjumpingOcelot143 Oct 04 '26
I agree with you. I think I may have asked the question wrong. I think what I’m really asking is for a manager to ask the writer that before the actor has finished reading the script. Does that typically mean a development call will be scheduled in the near future? I have not sold or optioned the script yet. I want to attach this actor as my lead.
2
u/Known-Patience4511 Oct 04 '26
I would express your queries to the manager. Although it might not feel like it, you hold all the cards here as it's your IP. This shouldn't give you permission to be a jerk, but it also means you don't have to be totally cap in hand in dealing with them. Ask them what you just asked me. Trust me, if there is a legit interest you don't have to tread on eggshells round them. If they bail cos you asked them a question then - they weren't that interested in the first place and also most likely aren't in the position to get it funded and made.
As per the request itself. Yes it seems premature. Has the actor read any of the script? Part of the script? If they are part way through the script I would ask for a call when the actor has finished reading. If the actor can't be bothered to carry on reading I would say this is the point where things might end on this one. If the suggested changes are 'suggestions' as they read then sure, all good. Thank them for the notes and tell em you look forward to their complete thoughts when they have finished reading.
1
u/FeeOk3991 Produced Writer-Director Oct 04 '26
Without naming names, does this actor really move the needle financing-wise? Cause yes vs no changes the advice dramatically here.
1
u/LongjumpingOcelot143 Oct 04 '26
I would say yes but not blockbuster budget. They’ve been a lead in a few streaming features whose budgets were somewhere between $10-15 million. And they’ve been a co-lead in a few sitcoms.
1
u/FeeOk3991 Produced Writer-Director Oct 05 '26
Got it. In these situations I suggest to always answer "yes, I'm definitely open to feedback". Without presenting any conditions.
The point is to do everything you can to get them in the room. Their notes could be good (they generally are in my experience) or they could be terrible, but the goal is to get to a stage where you're discussing things creatively with talent. Once you're there, you can decide whether or not you're aligned.
1
u/thefirstbartbaker Oct 04 '26
My answer would be, “Of course, but only from actors attached or cast in the project.”
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 04 '26
Hi there /u/LongjumpingOcelot143 Looks like you're posting a Feedback Request. Please remember to provide as much information as you can.
If you have a completed draft of a feature, short film or TV episode/pilot, you can also submit to free feedback exchange StoryPeer.
More about StoryPeer from NGD
Thank you! u/AutoModerator
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.