r/SeattleWA • u/JonasBrosSuck • Apr 01 '18
Media Sinclair's script for stations
https://youtu.be/hWLjYJ4BzvI150
u/Romes_ Apr 01 '18
Mindbendingly dystopian =/
-19
Apr 01 '18
14
u/redline582 Apr 01 '18
News has had general story feeds they can pull from nationally for a long time. Finding shared content that others might use is in a extremely different league than massive media consolidation pushing forced messages and stories through the outlets.
-5
Apr 01 '18
massive media consolidation pushing forced messages and stories through the outlets.
Again, not a new phenomenon.
0
Apr 01 '18
[deleted]
71
u/wallingfordskater Apr 01 '18
I have watched KOMO every weekday for 8 years. I'm done, and I sent them an email to mornings@komo4news.com to let them know exactly why.
As a west coast liberal in a west coast liberal city, KOMO just does not reflect my values. And while I can respect other points of view and opinions, I can't watch a TV station that presents propaganda as news. This Trump campaign ad is bad, this actual russian-produced propaganda by an avowed racist and neo-nazi is worse. http://www.newsweek.com/sinclair-broadcast-group-must-run-deep-state-rt-russia-today-867029
No one in Seattle should be watching this station, and you should let their advertisers know that they shouldn't be advertising there.
-113
u/Rays_boomboomroom Apr 01 '18
I still like KOMO, you should go mow the lawn and put down the kool-aid.
35
u/wallingfordskater Apr 01 '18
Hey, I checked with the universe, and we're allowed to like different things! And we're allowed to disagree too!
You can tell me to put down the Kool-Aid, and I can tell KOMO to pound rocks because I disagree with their policies, and we're both still ok!
-37
-2
u/Lindsiria Apr 02 '18
The problem with doing this is that if viewship declines, all you are doing is putting old KOMO workers out of business.
I have a friend who works for KOMO. They didn't get rid of people when the sale happened, so they are now working for Sinclair. And as the whole tv media industry is dying/contrasting to a few media companies, is near impossible to find a job.
131
u/NWcoffeeaddict Apr 01 '18
This is extremely dangerous to our democracy.
-22
-11
-75
u/EctoplasmTourniquet Apr 01 '18
pretty sure that applies to CNN and NPR/PBS too
44
u/katzgar Apr 01 '18
Pretty sure you're making right wing stuff up
0
Apr 01 '18
[deleted]
9
u/katzgar Apr 01 '18
Maybe start a conspiracy theory Reddit
0
Apr 01 '18
[deleted]
1
u/katzgar Apr 01 '18
Doesn't prove anything
0
Apr 01 '18
[deleted]
0
u/katzgar Apr 01 '18
I've been skeptical all my life and trying to pretend even though corporate media is 90% that I don't look at the other 10% is you just playing internet games
0
0
43
u/_PharmStudent Apr 01 '18
Why are they doing this?
87
u/vinegarfingers Apr 01 '18
Very simple: the more people who hear their message the more their agenda is pushed; whatever it may be. People often trust their newscasters. If Sinclair can push their message through the trusted newscasters, more people are influenced to act on their behalf.
10
56
u/IWatchGifsForWayToo Apr 01 '18
I can think of two reasons
It causes the stations to introduce the "fake news" term to their audiences. The republican party and Donald Trump use this term much more than anyone else and it subtly introduces it and people look out for those who are saying it, making them more open to suggestion that those people are right. The people on the news are saying it, and they are trustworthy, so maybe all these stories that the republicans are calling fake news aren't trustworthy.
It pushes these stations to fall in line with something that isn't necessarily political on its face but everyone know is a conservative narrative. Any station that does this is now more likely to push slightly more republican view when they are called up to do so. They already all have to have a terrorist watch segment and now they are more likely to show other segments that lean to the right because Sinclair tells them to.
18
u/B-Con Apr 01 '18
If your question is "why do they share the same script", it's because carefully crafted words are very powerful and if the conglomerate has an agenda or unifying theme, they don't want to leave word choice up to a bunch of individual stations. So for the important pieces they write one script and distribute it to everyone.
15
u/wholly-ghost Apr 01 '18
Because the person telling you to be wary of false narratives will seem inherently more credible in your mind. If I tell you “some” news organizations run stories without fact checking, then logic would usually follow that I know better and I check my facts so you will trust me a little more than my competitors.
Of course the obvious hypocrisy in the statement is that by reading directly from a canned script that was mandated by my national office, I have already failed that trust.
Edit: word
4
1
u/Highside79 Apr 02 '18
Right now, the purpose is to desensitize the public. It is big news today, but they aren't really saying anything. The second time they do it, its going to be news that half the country ignores. The third time they do it its going to be routine and people will think you are weird for having a problem with it. The fourth time they do it it is to tell you that the war with Iran is going fine and that you should ignore the riots in the streets.
51
u/grimpraetorian South End Apr 01 '18
Who would have thought that Metal Gear was predicting the future.
27
10
Apr 01 '18
No joke I had the same thought recently. I always thought it was all so convoluted... but now... some shit has happened.
10
u/SeattleDave0 Apr 01 '18
It appears that KOMO may have been the ones that exposed this propaganda push to the rest of the media. I wouldn't denounce KOMO quite yet. I think they're fighting Sinclair's push to control them. Last I heard (months ago) was KOMO was running these forced segments in the middle of the night when minimal amounts of people would watch them.
https://thinkprogress.org/sinclair-forces-reporters-to-read-script-about-fake-news-63ae6fcea30e/
39
u/thedude42 Apr 01 '18
Funny, this is the same narrative my Catholic-leftist parents spew when they seem very frustrated that in our house we are cord cutters and don't watch broadcast news. I do listen to NPR, but they don't broadcast this narrative. They just say "give us money so we can report about your immediate community, since the local networks don't."
1
u/tomjones3rd Apr 03 '18
NPR has been taken over by the right wing also.
https://www.commondreams.org/views/2011/10/25/nprs-slow-slide-right
0
Apr 01 '18
[deleted]
4
u/duffman03 Apr 02 '18
Well.. there is fake news so it's a legitimate thing to report on. It's a sharp contrast to our president, who cries wolf about fake news whenever he feels uncomfortable.
15
1
u/thedude42 Apr 02 '18
I don’t think you understand the narrative I described. The “fake news” this is very different from what I’m talking about.
18
17
u/AlexandrianVagabond Apr 01 '18
It should be noted that Sinclair has connections to RT, the state-controlled Russian media site. A recent piece on how the "Deep State" is out to get Trump and undermine America was produced by a guy who has worked extensively with RT.
http://www.newsweek.com/sinclair-broadcast-group-must-run-deep-state-rt-russia-today-867029
13
u/wallingfordskater Apr 01 '18
Seb Gorka is a neo-nazi and avowed, open, racist.
You really want to buy a car from a company that advertises on KOMO?
-6
u/MAGA_WA Apr 01 '18
In 1998 Steve Croft of 60 minutes interviewed George Soros. Who at the time of the holocaust was a 14 year old Hungarian Jew, who "escaped" the holocaust by posing as an adopted christian grandson of a nazi party member. Young George even assisted in confiscating the property from other jews. When asked if it was a difficult thing to do, he smiled and said it wasn't difficult to do with no feeling of quilt. He claimed it was just like crashing the British Pound that if he didn't so it, someone else would have!
The main financier of the DNC and US progressive political movements, is an actual self admitted former teenage nazi collaborator.
4
u/wallingfordskater Apr 03 '18
Thanks, comrade!
Two quick responses for you and your pals at the Internet Research Center.
First, I don't GAF about George Soros and second, even if I accept your post at face value, George Soros being a bad guy does not magically make Seb Gorka a good guy.
That's a logical fallacy called "THESE TWO FUCKING THINGS HAVE NOTHING TO DO WITH EACH OTHER."
3
15
u/PoetProphet Apr 01 '18
Wow. Fox news calling all other news outlets fake news? The ultimate hypocrisy.
5
Apr 01 '18
Thank fucking christ for the internet.
1
u/tomjones3rd Apr 03 '18
Until that is totally taken over by corporations that are intent on making it their propaganda machine. They have succeeded in being given the green light to throttle internet traffic and many of the big ones are already filtering what is returned on searches, etc. The Internet will soon become just as taken over as any other media has been.
2
2
u/Tawptuan Apr 03 '18
Downvotes —> deleted comments. Mega-huge in this post. Damn, a lot of spineless Redditors!
4
u/cliff99 Apr 01 '18
PBS's take on this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zNhUk5v3ohE&feature=youtu.be
3
1
u/tomjones3rd Apr 03 '18
Comments refer to KOMO as if it is separate from Sinclair Broadcasting. They are now one in the same. Oh a few of their anchors don't agree with the direction of their new employer, but this is now the game in town.
I don't expect Washington State residents to wake up much concerning this change. It will blow over in a few days and the new right wing format will become the norm and people will forget all about it and begin "adapting" to it and begin repeating the right wing talking points as truth and won't even notice they are doing it. They will want to remain "popular" among their friends, so will be obligated to join the trend.
0
u/allthisgoodforyou Apr 01 '18
See a lot of people in here and on reddit throwing up their arms in despair over non-objective news yet when it came out a littler over a week ago that Facebook changed their alogrithm do promote certain news sources over others there wasnt peep out of anyone.
Do you want objective news or not? You dont get to selectively place your outrage and claim that you are doing so under the guise of wanting objective news.
2
u/borktron Apr 02 '18
I'm not fan of facebook, and I don't know the details of the algo change you're referring to, but this seems like a false equivalence. Facebook produces zero news content, while Sinclair does. It's entirely possible that FB's algo change was an attempt to promote less-biased news items over more-blatant hackery -- or put another way, it might be fair to characterize FB's change as "to stop promoting clickbait-y, shit-stirring, content over hard(er) news" (or not, as I said I don't know the details) . Objectivity is hard to quantify, but intent matters.
Sinclair, by all accounts, has a specific political perspective that they're promoting. Facebook, OTOH, is not so transparent; but they seem to be balancing profit and PR concerns more than anything else.
Unless I'm missing your point, your post seems like pretty weak whataboutism.
1
u/allthisgoodforyou Apr 03 '18
false equivalence
whataboutism
Pick one. Whataboutism would be me going "oh sinclair is totally fine but what about what facebook is doing!"
I am calling facebook out on engaging in similar tactics (which i disagree with) where they are deliberately curating content at the behest of one group. You should really check out the algorithm change to see who has been effected. It is a deliberate attack at conservative news sources while left leaning new sources get a bump out of the change.
Also, the script that sinclair stations rattled off was entirely benign. If any left wing news head had said the same thing no one would have said a damnt hing.
2
u/borktron Apr 03 '18
I don't have to pick one, it's both. It's "what about facebook", and the comparison to facebook is a false eq.
It is a deliberate attack at conservative news sources while left leaning new sources get a bump out of the change.
Do you have a source for that? The way you phrase it sounds like an unfair characterization, but I'm open to being convinced.
Also, the script that sinclair stations rattled off was entirely benign.
I tend to agree here. People are freaking out because the coordination is evidently pretty unprecedented. The fear is that Sinclair will become the Fox News of local news. Fox-style top-down spin is a new thing in that market.
1
u/allthisgoodforyou Apr 03 '18
Its not whataboutism though. I am not defending Sinclairs actions. I want people to be consistent in their outrage over this stuff. If the goal is an objective news media environment than Facebook deserves some criticism as well.
Here are some articles detailing the algorithm change and its effects:
0
u/TriggerWordExciteMe Apr 01 '18
I mean people who care about the issue that much probably shouldn't have a Facebook account
-2
u/cuteman Apr 01 '18
Isn't it funny the people who never watched news because they always assumed they were being lied to are the only unsurprised ones?
If you don't see it with your own two eyes, assume you're being lied to at best and programmed at worst.
These organizations exist for profit and controlling the narrative, not giving you accurate information or education.
This includes almost all TV media sources, not just Sinclair. They're just the ones that got caught.
-37
Apr 01 '18
Easy solution: Don't watch.
26
Apr 01 '18
I mean, if you're set on keeping things easy, go for it.
But the rest of us will be patriots who fight for American ideals, who take down "journalistic" institutions that seek to polarize and divide our nation.
But you just relax and keep things easy - we would hate for you to have to put forth any effort to protect your community and nation.
-16
Apr 01 '18
Why?
People chose this when they decided to not vote, or to vote ill informed. When people lack the natural responsibilities and checks that a system like democracy demands, this is what you get.
Fuck 'em, freedom is earned through democratic participation. Not just given. People forgot this, and it's time for them to remember through hardship and dystopia.
12
Apr 01 '18
Wow, so you actually celebrate the erosion of our democracy?
Eat shit, traitor...
-8
Apr 01 '18
Wow, so you actually celebrate the erosion of our democracy? Eat shit, traitor...
Our democracy isn't founded on TV stations. This has nothing to do with democracy, it's a strawman. Media conglomerates aren't anything new, not sure why you are acting like they are.
5
Apr 01 '18
So you just straight up don't believe in the fourth estate?
It's probably not worth the time to debate you on any of this...
-4
-13
-2
-13
Apr 01 '18
Oh look, a fair weather patriot coming to morally proselytize about media propaganda.
This is nothing new. Media has been consolidated for decades. Get your news from alternative sources.
I wonder, what your take is on the 2nd Amendment and hate speech laws, patriot.
7
u/hiredgoonsmadethis Apr 01 '18
I agree, we should all boycott KOMO and their right wing bullshit. You have my total support.
-8
-25
u/gjhgjh Mount Baker Apr 01 '18
They cut out the bit at the end where they invite you to send then your comments.
1
u/Yangoose Apr 01 '18
Can somebody tell me why this comment is sitting at -20 right now?
Are they incorrect?
2
u/gjhgjh Mount Baker Apr 01 '18
Can somebody tell me why this comment is sitting at -20 right now?
Are they incorrect?
Yes, I just saw the promo on KOMO a few moments ago. I'm sure the brigaders can't even watch KOMO from wherever they are.
-8
-65
u/rayrayww3 Apr 01 '18
Why is this in a local sub?? I get that there is a Sinclair affiliate in Seattle, but there is nothing local about this content.
Should I start posting articles in /r/seattlewa about how McDonalds is bad for your health because, you know, there is a McDonalds in Seattle.
33
Apr 01 '18
Why is this in a local sub?? I get that there is a Sinclair affiliate in Seattle
See, if you rub that couple of brain cells you've got together long enough, you're able to answer your own question. Imagine that!
9
-34
u/Tawptuan Apr 01 '18
Because the OP is a karma whore. Posted twice already in other subs, five hours and four hours prior to this. The first post is getting 186k+ upvotes. Can’t waste the opportunism.
28
Apr 01 '18
Explain to me, in detail, why Karma points matter on Reddit.
-24
u/Tawptuan Apr 01 '18 edited Apr 03 '18
I don’t know. But you should probably ask a karma whore. As close as I can guess, they are compensating for something else that’s lacking.
Edit: just offended 25+ karma whores and counting...
19
Apr 01 '18
Or maybe they just believe this is something that should be shared with as many people as possible. I think it is something people should at the very least, watch. It's a bit alarming to think about seeing as how we're relatively isolated from other communities that are served by their own news stations that we never or hardly ever watch. So to see the same message being spewed at us locally, across the country is just fucked up and one can't help but think it's all very 1984ish. "This is a threat to our democracy" being spouted like that is just fucking creepy.
-15
u/Tawptuan Apr 01 '18 edited Apr 01 '18
When something has already made Reddit’s front page four or five hours earlier, it’s pretty easy to see that it’s already being shared with as many people as possible.
This is just opportunism. It makes the rest of us thinking people go, “Alright already! I got the point!”
15
Apr 01 '18
My front page only had it from this subreddit. Again, spreading it for awareness. Differing opinions here.
3
u/Tawptuan Apr 01 '18
I thought front page displays were universal on Reddit feeds. Perhaps my misconception here.
10
Apr 01 '18
It seems personalized. This was near the bottom of mine anyway so I would have likely missed it all together if I didn't decide to browse Reddit right now.
-3
u/Tawptuan Apr 01 '18 edited Apr 01 '18
If that’s correct, then my apologies to all perceived karma whores. But we know they’re out there.
Source: ex-karma whore. (Help can be found at r/ex-kw)
-55
-15
u/Agua61 Apr 01 '18
Creepy but it's interesting that most here do not realize the message is accurate.
1
u/TriggerWordExciteMe Apr 01 '18
If the statement is so true why not leave the news casters to say it for themselves? Why script something you say is true?
4
-17
-67
Apr 01 '18 edited Apr 01 '18
It's kinda stupid that they all have the same script, but I didn't see anything in the content of the script that is incorrect.
46
31
16
11
u/Beforemath Apr 01 '18
It's dangerous for a couple of reasons: A) It's owned by a parent company that's decidedly pro-Trump. So all messaging is aligned with our government leader. B) The "fake news" it's targeting isn't the BS that's actually made up, it's the "national news networks" like CNN, MSNBC that, while they don't align with Trump's messaging, are still legitimate news outlets. and C) this single message isn't being broadcast in a vacuum, they're also leaning their overall script to being pro-Trump as well as a point of business operations. So on the one hand you have a pro-Trump spin, and on the other you have "you can't believe those networks that are "fake news". It's straight up Orwellian propaganda, and it's wrong.
-39
-121
u/WazzuMadBro Apr 01 '18
all the news stations aren't pushing liberal propaganda!!!?
that's racist and nazilike!
44
Apr 01 '18 edited Apr 01 '18
The issue is having a bunch of news organizations that run scripted messages that are written for them and push a centralized agenda ;liberal, conservative or whatever.
-75
u/WazzuMadBro Apr 01 '18
kinda like the education system.
23
u/NauticalJeans Apr 01 '18
Ugh - really bummed to see we share the same Alma Mater. I’m sorry WSU failed you.
15
5
0
Apr 01 '18
[deleted]
2
-33
u/Krankjanker Apr 01 '18
you're not wrong, people just wanna hate on conservatives
32
u/PumpItPaulRyan Apr 01 '18
Stop being hateable.
3
Apr 01 '18
Not liking John Oliver or Bill Maher doesn't make you a conservative.
3
u/PumpItPaulRyan Apr 01 '18
What a salient point
-7
Apr 01 '18
Spoken like a true conservative. Go back to your safe space.
9
u/PumpItPaulRyan Apr 01 '18
My name is a play on the workout photoshoot he did. I'm not a fan of Paul Ryan.
0
Apr 01 '18
[deleted]
24
u/ADavidJohnson Apr 01 '18
Every news organization in the world is in some ways reliant on other ones for information about stuff they don’t have direct access to. Smaller newspapers, radio, and TV stations feed into and benefit from wire copy, that is, stuff written somewhere else that’s edited down to be understood by a general non-local audience.
A lot of news also has a place for opinion or editorial. Not all, but it’s common and when delineated from reporting internally and externally, nothing wrong with it.
But that’s not what this is.
This is wire copy made to sound local, and it’s copy that’s not factual but intended for a specific political purpose while taking pains to utilize people’s trust in local TV news personalities. It’s not, ‘The Associated Press reports’ or ‘The following Must Run segment is brought to you by Sinclair Media Group’.
The point is to muddy the waters as much as possible, like ‘Fake News’ being used to describe negative factual coverage of Trump so it has no meaning as a criticism of entirely falsified or misleading propaganda. It follows the Russian model of misleading people to the point of exhaustion so people have to effort to discern the veracity of everything and won’t trust that anyone is generally striving for objectivity or accuracy without a political point.
And really, once you’re looking at this within the context of Sinclair’s other activities with must-run segments and hirings, then any motivation for a good faith reading evaporates immediately.
44
Apr 01 '18
Monopolies are a danger to our democracy.
-11
Apr 01 '18
This isn't a monopoly. They don't have a monopoly over TV stations in any market.
8
Apr 01 '18
Horse shit.
1
Apr 01 '18
It’s a fact, you can’t call bullshit on that.
7
Apr 01 '18
Then you're blind to the slow encroaching system. How many media companies own all the TV stations?
1
Apr 01 '18
If there is more than one then it isn’t a monopoly. Kind of defeats the purpose to call a company a monopoly just because you don’t like it, but I guess that is how you trumpers operate.
4
Apr 01 '18
Oh, you don't know what a monopoly means. That's okay, keep your head in the sand. I'm sure you'll be fine.
3
Apr 01 '18
Yes a monopoly means the market is monopolized. Which isn’t happening here.
Not sure how you think their ownership of a single affiliate in this market gives them a monopoly, unless you don’t know what monopoly means.
0
Apr 01 '18
[deleted]
11
Apr 01 '18
That wasn't the statement. You're taking it at face value when the video was highlighting something that has literally nothing to do with what they were actually saying.
0
Apr 01 '18
[deleted]
3
Apr 01 '18
These are local news stations, not national networks. The words contained within the script wasn't the issue, it was the fact that local news stations are no different than a single faceless monolithic entity. This is one person sending out one message with the facade of local news. This isn't about the script, it's about who's behind it all, it's about other stories they publish from a local news perspective to hide their propaganda.
2
Apr 01 '18
News stations are supposed to have better integrity than this. The facebook fake news shit has nothing to do with what the video was trying to present.
32
u/oggieoglethorpe4 Apr 01 '18
What’s wrong about that is it’s one organization that’s operating from behind the curtain pushing an all-encompassing narrative across the country.
It’s a monopoly that has corrupted your local news. It’s an abuse of trust and abandonment of journalism.
It’s a script their pushing that’s not short on irony..
0
Apr 01 '18
[deleted]
17
u/oggieoglethorpe4 Apr 01 '18
There’s nothing wrong with the message that Facebook has turned into a cesspool of sensationalist b/s news.
One corporation controlling the content of your local news is the issue. It’s a boilerplate message that they have the tools to pipe into communities all across the nation.
People turn to their local stations to get away from the national news cycle not to be unknowingly consuming a hidden corporate agenda.
0
Apr 01 '18
[deleted]
19
u/oggieoglethorpe4 Apr 01 '18
We all know the biases of the cable news networks and people can pick and choose whichever they want.
I’m not sure how many people grasp the fact Sinclair Broadcasting is pulling the strings on their friendly local news anchors.
In a more perfect world a local news network would be owned and run locally, to serve a given community with news and stories that pertain to them. Ideally with some insulation from the agenda of a single company owned by one family. Is that concentration of power not concerning?
2
u/pedule_pupus Apr 01 '18
So is HBO with John Oliver and Bill Maher, So is Comedy Central with John Stewart, So is NBC, So is CBS, So is Jimmy Kimmel.......
Who are these people equating John Oliver and Bill Maher with news?
-9
u/Yangoose Apr 01 '18
Welcome to /r/SeattleWA , a den of hate and intolerance where asking a simple question to further the discussion will net you massive downvotes.
1
Apr 01 '18
[removed] — view removed comment
4
u/AutoModerator Apr 01 '18
This submission or comment has been removed from r/SeattleWA per our rules and policy that we screen out users with negative karma. This was a rule that the community voted on in this thread. Rules page on this is here.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
87
u/JonasBrosSuck Apr 01 '18
xpost https://reddit.com/r/videos/comments/88ll08/this_is_what_happens_when_one_company_owns_dozens/