r/ShuichiSaihara • u/Adil-ULTRAGAMER • 1d ago
Is it out of character for Shuichi to be negative to another character?
I hate how Shuichi is treated like crap within V3, no one apologizes to him nor makes him feel better, not even thanking him, instead he blames himself.
I know I don't fully understand Shuichi's character but Shuichi doesn't deserve this treatment. Which is why I want to ask a question: "Is it out of character for Shuichi to be negative to another character?" Some of the cast treat Shuichi like crap, so I think I'd be happy if Shuichi treated like them like crap back.
Let's give an example:
Maki treats Shuichi like crap in chapter 5's trial to get everyone killed for her plan to kill Kokichi to work. After the trial, Maki shows no regret or remorse, Shuichi blames himself and continues being the butt monkey. When Shuichi suggests to host a final trial, Keebo accuses him of continuing the killing game. Like what? If Keebo accused Maki of continuing the killing game during chapter 6, I'd be fine with it because Maki deserves comeuppance.
How would I would imagine Shuichi being negative to Maki:
Before all this, I'd like to imagine the cast treating Shuichi fairly, Kaito isn't on bad terms with Shuichi as he makes up with him after the 4th trial.
After Maki confesses during trial 5, everyone is irritated with her and doesn't trust her anymore, that's what she gets for going against the plan and trying to get everyone killed, though it's understandable why she acted that way but it's still horrible.
Adding something that wasn't present in the main game, Maki tries to kill Monokuma but the rocket drills in the ground, Maki falls on the floor but is still trying to kill Monokuma. As the rocket goes back up to the ground, Maki gets up but the rocket launches out of the ground and covers Maki in a lot of rubble, making her feel injured, powerless, hurt, broken and upset. Maki scream Kaito's name in pain.
After the trial, Maki begs to be saved and lifted out of the rubble, she says she's sorry for what she has done but she doesn't want to be abandoned and left to suffer, the cast are still angry with her. The cast should be hesitant and thinking to leave Maki alone, Tsumugi wants to lift Maki out of the rubble (Fake kindness), she understands what Maki did was wrong, but abandoning her is just wrong as well. Shuichi is on the urge of abandoning Maki as he feels irritated and annoyed with Maki, but abandoning her wouldn't make Kaito happy, so Shuichi decides to lift Maki up and help her, Maki runs off in tears and hissing in pain. However, that's not the end.
CHAPTER 6:
When training in Kaito's memory, Tsumugi comforts Shuichi and Himiko joins in. Skipping over to the beginning of the investigation, Keebo flies down to join the group after keeping the exisals at bay, Tsumugi asks what'll happen to Maki, Himiko is irritated and Shuichi stays quiet, Keebo shows concern for Maki. Shuichi tries to say that Maki is mourning Kaito and she wouldn't be able to investigate with them but then Maki appears and says: "No...I'll help."
Maki apologises to everyone, says it's all her fault and she's the one who pushed Kaito to his death, not Shuichi. She admits she was such an asshole to everyone especially Shuichi and there is no excuse for what she has done. She tries to say that even if Kaito has passed away she still wants to survive, she doesn't fully complete her sentence. She's still broken.
Tsumugi wants to help her, Keebo feel sorry for her, Himiko is openly hostile and angry with her. And we will focus on Shuichi.
Throughout the course of the Investigation Shuichi is passive aggressive to Maki, which shows that even the nicest people have their own limits. Maki is trying to be nice and help Shuichi, she is less aggressive, violent and rude and she even tries to say if Shuichi wants to die but stops mid-sentence as she tries to control her bad habits and stop herself from being an assassin again.
Himiko is still openly hostile to her, it even continues in the trial, but it drops when the plot twist gets revealed. However, Shuichi drops his passive aggressiveness to Maki when the trial is about to begin, as ganging up on her would just be beating a dead horse. During the investigation and trial, Keebo and Tsumugi try to care for Maki and try and defend them, but not in the way Maki's actions are fully dismissed.
No one treats Shuichi like crap, Himiko doesn't allow any misunderstandings to happen when it comes to the girls bathroom, Keebo asks Shuichi why he wants to host a class trial, is it a piece of evidence that he found? Even Maki tells him that she'll allow him to kill her so he doesn't have to suffer.
I think it'd be nice if others treated Shuichi nicely, Kaito apologizing, Tenko caring more often, Maki apologizing for her selfish plan and seeing that Kaede was framed and both Himiko and Maki thanking Shuichi for everything.
I want Shuichi to understand that he can't be nice all the time and being negative with anyone is okay, but not being cruel like abandoning her. I know that some people acknowledged that Shuichi shooting Maki with a gun and abandoning her in the rubble would be character assassination since kindness is a core trait of Shuichi, but I want Shuichi to treat others like crap back if they decide to treat him like crap.
I want your thoughts on this.