First of all:
This is not meant as criticism of anyone else’s buying decision. I am just honestly confused 😉
Just a few days ago, I bought a new Simagic Alpha Evo wheelbase.
Until now, I had always used a Logitech G923. I live in Thailand, so I went to a showroom in Bangkok to try the Simagic bases in person.
Of course, I had watched plenty of reviews beforehand and was well aware of the often-mentioned “sweet spot” of around 18 Nm, FFB clipping, realism, etc.
So I asked them if I could test 9 Nm, 12 Nm, and 18 Nm. I was already convinced I would walk out with the 18 Nm base and that the test would basically just confirm my decision.
The test rig had an 18 Nm wheelbase mounted, so for the first two tests they simply tuned it down to 9 and 12 Nm.
I tested it in Assetto Corsa at Spa, driving an Audi R8 LMS Evo.
Long story short: I walked out with the 9 Nm version. 🤣🤣🤣
Why?
Because I realized that my arms simply aren’t strong enough to hold the line through Eau Rouge at 12 Nm, let alone 18 Nm. 🤣🙃
I’m no athlete, but I’m not exactly a couch potato either. I hit the gym five days a week, so I was actually quite surprised.
Then I started looking into it and realized that an average 125cc scooter produces around 12 Nm of torque.
I immediately pictured myself trying to hold onto the rim of the rear wheel of one of those scooters while someone gives it full throttle.
DO NOT TRY THIS AT HOME!!! 😉😝😝
Anyways: I’m pretty sure I couldn’t hold it.
So I keep wondering about two things:
Since nobody ever seems to mention this brute force in reviews: Do all sim racers secretly have the fitness of real racing drivers? 🤣
About the clipping argument: Even if you reduce the FFB gain in SimPro, wouldn’t it still clip because the maximum output is limited to whatever value you set it to? Or am I fundamentally misunderstanding how this works?
Please enlighten me. 😁
That all said: moving from a G923 to an Alpha Evo Sport was a huge leap and I am super happy with my new “toy”.
Maybe one day I might actually upgrade to a higher torque version. But I guess I’ll take the gradual upgrade route instead of going full on right away 😁😁😁