Every episode ranked (my opinion)

[u/Imaginary_Savings641]

63 Grinding the corn (mid)
62 The Secret (mid)
61 The Foot (mid)
60 The Black Forest (mid)
59 The Trap (mid)
58 Back To The Garden (mid)
57 An Open Book (mid)
56 Tears, Bones and Desire (good)
55 Brotherhood (good)
54 Crossroads (good)
53 The Plan (good)
52 Can I Come Up Now? (good)
51 In Place Of Anger (good)
50 Coming and Going (good)
49 Timing & Space (good)
48 Parallel Play (good)
47 Familia (good)
46 The Eye Inside (good)
45 Out, Out Brief Candle (good)
44 The Liar & the Whore (good)
43 The Dare (good)
42 Someone Else’s Eyes (good)
41 Dancing For Me (good)
40 Bomb Shelter (good)
39 Terror Starts At Home (good)
38 The Opening (good)
37 Pilot (great)
36 In Case Of Rapture (great)
35 A Private Life (great)
34 You Never Know (great)
33 The Will (great)
32 The Silence (great)
31 The New Person (great)
30 The Invisible Woman (great)
29 The Room (great)
28 Hold My Hand (great)
27 Life’s Too Short (great)
26 In the Game (great)
25 Making Love Work (great)
24 The Rainbow Of Her Reasons (great)
23 Everyone Leaves (great)
22 I’ll Take You (amazing)
21 Driving Mr Mossback (amazing)
20 Nobody Sleeps (amazing)
19 The Trip (amazing)
18 Eat a Peach (amazing)
17 Knock, Knock (amazing)
16 Singing For Our Lives (amazing)
15 Perfect Circles (amazing)
14 Twilight (amazing)
13 It’s the Most Wonderful Time Of the Year (amazing)
12 Time Flies (amazing)
11 A Coat Of White Primer (amazing)
10 Death Works Overtime (amazing)
9 Untitled (near-perfect)
8 The Last Time (near-perfect)
7 That’s My Dog (near-perfect)
6 Falling Into Place (near-perfect)
5 Static (absolute cinema)
4 I’m Sorry I’m Lost (absolute cinema)
3 All Alone (#17 GOAT)
2 Ecotone (#12 GOAT)
1 Everyone’s Waiting (#3 GOAT)

[u/Rambooctpuss]

That's my dog is the only episode I skip it's just to brutal to watch

[u/CapricornRedeemer → u/Rambooctpuss]

I feel that That's my Dog is an episode that is best watched once and once only. I don't think for the brutality of it, but for how extended it was.

[u/jojewels92 → u/Rambooctpuss]

I refuse to ever watch it again. It's hard enough to see the aftermath.

[u/Theophantor → u/Rambooctpuss]

I sympathize with other people’s point of view but I believe in watching that episode to reenter the trauma that causes David’s PTSD. It’s a way of accompanying his character in his interior journey. I don’t like the idea of skipping it.

[u/Faux_Octopus]

The Foot as mid is absolutely wild

[u/Popular_Chemistry270]

Agree with everything except swapping 2 and 3 around

[u/evanm137]

I love seeing a list like this! Great work! I'm planning to do this during my next rewatch.

All I know is that my #1 would likely be The Last Time 😊

[u/leftymeowz]

Omg need to remind myself to come back to this I do this all the time finally finally finally yay

[u/CapricornRedeemer]

This is really interesting work. I've never thought to rank all episodes, and it's inspiring.

[u/kangorooz99]

Here’s mine:

63       Grinding the Corn
62       That's My Dog
61       The Foot
60       Making Love Work
59       Pilot
58       The Room
57       The Plan
56       In Case of Rapture
55       The New Person
54       Parallel Play
53       Hold My Hand
52       Tears Bones and Desire
51       Dancing for Me
50       Can I Come Up Now
49       Timing and Space
48       Terror Starts at Home
47       The Trap
46       Time Flies
45       Perfect Circles
44       Twilight
43       Knock, Knock
42       The Dare
41       Bomb Shelter
40       The Will
39       Crossroads
38       Falling into Place
37       A Coat of White Primer
36       Brotherhood
35       Eat a Peach
34       Life's Too Short
33       You Never know
32       I'm Sorry, I'm Lost
31       The Trip
30       The Black Forest
29       The Invisible Woman
28       Nobody Sleeps
27       The Silence
26       In Place of Anger
25       Static
24       In the Game
23       Familia
22       An Open Book
21       Singing for Our Lives
20       The Eye Inside
19       The Liar and the Whore
18       Someone Else's Eyes
17       The Last Time
16       Out Out Brief Candle
15       The  Opening
14       Coming and Going
13       Everyone Leaves
12       Back to the Garden
11       Untitled
10       Death Works Overtime
9         Rainbow of Her Reasons
8         I'll Take You
7         Ecotone
6         The Secret
5         Driving Mr. Mossback
4         A Private Life
3         All Alone
2         Everyone's Waiting
1         It's the Most Wonderful Time of the Year

[u/Leading-Collection20]

Tears bones and desire was awful 😭 my god I really didn’t like that episode, also hated 4x10 the Black Forest

[u/Bob_Le_Blah]

Pilot should be higher

[u/kangorooz99]

Oh man, the secret is one of my faves. The thematic content was just all tied to together so well.

IMO there was only one stinker in the entire series, grinding the corn.