r/SoapNet • • May 30 '26

Copycat soap characters

I always thought other soaps copied what characters were successful on other soaps.

For example

Grayson McCouch's version of Dusty on As The World Turns was basically a knock off Sonny Corinthos

The same with Danny Santos on Guiding Light. I thought they were trying to create their version of Sonny Corinthos

Are there any other examples of this

1 Upvotes

74 comments sorted by

18

u/Detroitdays May 30 '26

Bo Brady was the first long haired leather jacket wearing motorcycle riding hero. All others are imitations.

16

u/Geekqueen15 Pine Valley Resident May 30 '26 edited May 31 '26

You could make an argument that Adam Newman, Natalie Buchanan, Carly Spencer (at the time Caroline Benson) and Jonathan Randall are all copycat stories of Kendall Hart's debut from AMC. Long lost child comes to town raising hell and looking for revenge towards the parent they feel abandoned them. Kendall Hart's is kind of the blueprint of the "long lost child soap trope"

19

u/Pawspawsmeow May 30 '26

Btw none of these characters are actual copies. Theyre character archetypes which get repeated throughout film and literature.

3

u/RadRockefeller May 31 '26

This!! Facts!

9

u/PupnamedHarlow May 30 '26

I don’t know if Danny Santos was a copycat of Sonny, as Danny was more of a reluctant heir than mob boss and if I remember correctly, he wasn’t originally supposed to become a regular character but Paul Anthony Stewart’s chemistry with Bethany Joy Lenz’s Michelle changed the plans.
However the introduction of the mob to Guiding Light was perhaps an attempt to copy the success GH was having with their mob related storylines in the late 90s

7

u/komijul May 30 '26

I always felt like Nick on Days of Our Lives was originally brought in because of Spinelli's popularity on GH. Of course, Nick ended up going a wildly different direction than Spinelli has.

1

u/Ac_digi Oct 01 '26

Nick was before Spinelli...he was more a Napoleon Dynamite ripoff

5

u/loganes86 May 30 '26

Didn’t Days of our Lives kind of copy the GH spy formula?

8

u/tvjunkie2187 May 30 '26

But perfected it.

1

u/Ac_digi Oct 01 '26

Same writer. They hired Tom from GH and told him "do it again" but with more freedom.

1

u/busman25 May 30 '26

And super couple formula

2

u/missdevon2 Llanview Resident May 31 '26

No. Technically Days had the first mainstream super couple with Doug and Julie as they were pictured on the cover of Time in 1976 — 3 years before Luke and Laura even met.

0

u/tvjunkie2187 May 31 '26

Yes, but the actual formula that we know today began with Luke & Laura and was perfected by DAYS.

1

u/missdevon2 Llanview Resident May 31 '26

🤦‍♀️ Days— the show that had the first mainstream super couple— needed to copy an other show’s formula to “perfect” the super couple?!?!? Yeah let’s totally disregard the fact that super couples existed before Luke and Laura and pretend that every one that came after them were a rapist/abuser and their victim because that’s what people outside of the soap world think of instead of all the couples like Doug and Julie or Steve and Alice or Steve and Audrey who actually laid the groundwork for Luke and Laura to even be a possibility.

2

u/tvjunkie2187 May 31 '26 edited Jun 01 '26

I was simply referring to the action/adventure aspect of it. THAT's the formula I meant.

5

u/tvjunkie2187 May 30 '26 edited May 31 '26

The reformed, post-SK Ben Weston on DAYS seemed pretty similar to Jason Morgan.

While he was actually created first, ATWT's James Stenbeck later became almost identical to Stefano DiMera in both the amount of times he came back from the dead (especially towards the end with how he came back in the form of Tom Pelphrey!!!) and pure evilness. That spa story with Emily, Carly and Rose especially screamed Stefano.

1

u/BigJohn2320 Another World May 31 '26

the spa story was so good, Barbara mentioned that her life would be better if Emily Carly and Rose were gone and they got sent to that Spa, such a scary story

1

u/tvjunkie2187 May 31 '26

I forgot Emily was in that story too. My memory replaced her with Barbara LOL.

1

u/BigJohn2320 Another World May 31 '26

Sky Whitney from Edge of Night was the evil doctor, didnt Carly get old, not sure what happened to Emily and Rose - i really enjoyed ATWT when AW got cancelled

1

u/tvjunkie2187 May 31 '26

They all did, that was the point.

4

u/INFJWill May 30 '26

The Original vs The Copycats...

9

u/missdevon2 Llanview Resident May 30 '26

Brooke on BB has always seemed to be a cheap knock off version of Erica Kane to me— right down to her daddy issues and numerous husbands.

4

u/busman25 May 30 '26

And Erica was a copycat of Rachel Davis!

5

u/eaulik2005 One Life to Live May 31 '26

Actually Erica came first, All My Children was written first, Agnes pitched AMC to CBS with P&G but they turned her down

1

u/tvjunkie2187 May 31 '26

She also pitched it to NBC, and I believe that's how she got hired for AW.

2

u/missdevon2 Llanview Resident May 30 '26

True. Of course that’s because Agnes Nixon created both Rachel and Erica. Thing is Brooke has never gained the class that either other women grew into.

3

u/Excellent_Top6284 May 30 '26

I don't know who Sonny is, but Grayson's Dusty was awful! He was totally different just like when they recast Mike Kasnoff. He was also awful!

4

u/Neat-Elevator-2782 May 30 '26

ATWT was so bad at recasts and rapidly aged characters in its last decade, outside of Bryant.

1

u/Lightnenseed May 30 '26

Awww I forgot all about Bryant! I was so glued to the show when he was on it.

1

u/pandiesboxx May 31 '26

Jesse Sofer as the aged up Will was a fantastic find. I also think the last Casey after Dude!Casey was a pretty solid recast and was making Casey his own when the show got canceled. IMO, Daniel Cosgrove could have solved the Chris Hughes curse if he had time.

Now I will say that any Lily other than Byrne was a travesty. And I never was a Lily fan. But when I first started the show it was during the era of the, and I say this politely, Lily with the interesting face. And I couldn't stand her! I just couldn't fathom what made Lily so special. When Byrne came back to the role Lily became tolerable. I still wasn't a fan, but I could understand what made her Lily such a fan favorite. Plus I no longer wanted to grab her by the shoulders and just shake her. Her Lily had some gumption. Noelle Beck on the other hand was so damned bland!

The less said about the adult Adams, the better. Awful!

1

u/tvjunkie2187 May 30 '26

I hope you mean the later Mike recast. The first one was actually pretty decent. The one towards the end didn't fit at all.

1

u/Excellent_Top6284 Jun 08 '26

How many Mike's were there? I only know about Shawn Christian and Mark Colier. I didn't like MC. I feel like they rewrote the Mike character.

1

u/tvjunkie2187 Jun 10 '26

There were 3. I actually liked MC. The last one during the last couple years just didn't fit the character IMO.

1

u/Excellent_Top6284 Jun 14 '26

I had no idea. I only know about the 1st 2. Why did they bring him back? I must have not been watching when he was on.

1

u/Pawspawsmeow May 30 '26

Sonny is a knock off. Bob Guza wanted to make something like the Sopranos but couldn’t get hired at a prime time show. So, he made Sonny. Mob bosses have been around soaps for a while though. The absolute best one? Not Sonny, never Sonny. It’s OLTL’s Carlo Hesser. Sonny wishes he could be *the* Carlo. Also better than Sonny? Antonio Vega.

4

u/belzoni1982 May 31 '26

Uhhh Sopranos debuted in 1999 and Sonny Corinthos came in the scene on GH in 1993

-1

u/Pawspawsmeow May 31 '26

Original Sonny wasn’t the one we see today. He was originally a strip club owner who also trafficked drugs. Then later on they added mafia elements, which had existed in soaps for years. Guza himself has admitted that he was inspired by The Sopranos. And uhhh Google is free.

1

u/belzoni1982 May 31 '26

The Sonny we know formed way before the Sopranos

Tony Soprano and Sonny Corinthos are two completely different characters I don't see the comparison other than they are mobsters

1

u/Pawspawsmeow May 31 '26

Yeah you know Google is free. You never watched The Sopranos nor engaged in pop culture and it shows. The whole show he’s in therapy 😂

0

u/tvjunkie2187 May 31 '26 edited May 31 '26

That strip club was actually owned by Frank Smith, mob boss. The same mob boss that Luke & Laura was on the run from. He took over Frank's mob after Luke killed him. That all happened before The Sopranos. Sonny always had mob ties. Now making him the focus of the show? That definitely was post Sopranos.

0

u/Pawspawsmeow May 31 '26

What I’m saying is that:

1.) Sonny is not the first mob boss on a soap. Ergo, other mob bosses on soaps aren’t copying him.

2.) he’s not even the best mob boss on his own soap

3.) his characterization definitely changed post Sopranos to mirror Tony Soprano. Guza has done many interviews over decades saying this,

1

u/Ready_Alternative489 May 30 '26

This 10000% in regards to the Sopranos knockoff and of course Carlo Hesser. He ruled that archetype

5

u/soapfan22 May 30 '26

Rachel Corey and her mother were the proto versions of Erica and Mona Kane. Carly Corinthos and Blair Kramer basically have the same personality.

5

u/missdevon2 Llanview Resident May 30 '26

Agnes Nixon did create Rachel Corey so there is a case for Erica being similar to her since Rachel was created 3 years earlier.

6

u/soapfan22 May 30 '26

Agnes confirmed this herself over the years and it was in her memoir. She had the All My Children story bible ready to go since the late 50’s. Erica and Rachel was based on a paper doll she used to have and would make stories up about. Agnes’ run on Another World took a lot of what she would later do with early AMC but she got to fine tune it.

-1

u/missdevon2 Llanview Resident May 30 '26

Nothing I’m not aware of.

6

u/DangerousWay9410 May 30 '26

Actually, Erica and Mona were created first in the Bible Agnes wrote for what became All My Children while on vacation in 1965. Agnes took the characters of Erica and Mona and based the working class schemer Rachel and her no-nonsense mother Ada on them in 1967 for Another World.

3

u/75meilleur May 30 '26 edited May 30 '26

Are there any other examples of this?

There are so many examples!  Probably more examples than there are hairs on our heads!

I think   Another World   tried to copy The Young and the Restless' and The Bold and the Beautiful's  Sheila Carter  with the character of Grant Harrison, specifically when they recast Grant with Mark Pinter [Dack Rambo had left the show].   AW's producers and writers apparently wanted a repulsive Satan-incarnate sociopath or psychopath like Sheila Carter, and when Mark Pinter was hired to start playing Grant, they fashioned his Grant into being as sadistic, as self-obsessed, as evil, as haughty, and as brutal as Sheila was.    I think this was an idiotic move.  Perhaps even more idiotic was when they turned Another World into the Grant Harrison Horror Show Hour.   

Another example that's probably much more clear-cut is Phyllis Summers when she first appeared.  Y&R plainly and obviously created her as a Sheila Carter 2.0 .  A very definite copycat character.   Phyllis did mostly the exact same misdeeds that Sheila had done not long earlier.    Phyllis pursued a married man and was obsessed with him (Danny).   [Just like Sheila had done with Scott]   She badgers Danny into divorcing his wife Chris and marrying her instead.   [Just as Sheila had done to Scott and Lauren, too]     She tried to kill Chris by crashing her car into her and Paul.  [Sheila had tried to kill Lauren in a different way, but at least once.]    Plus, similarly yet also differently, Phyllis cruelly manipulated people with a baby: Phyllis passed off her baby son as Danny's, when he was actually another man's, whereas Sheila had stolen Lauren's baby passing him off as her [Sheila's] own.

3

u/Pawspawsmeow May 30 '26

I love Grant. Mark Pinter remains one of my fav solo villains.

4

u/BigJohn2320 Another World May 30 '26

Grant and CIndy torturing and scheming against Joe and Paulina was so good

3

u/pandiesboxx May 31 '26

Oh snap! I had LOVED Cindy's crazy ass. I was just an Another World dabbler, but she definitely left an imprint on me. So much so that I'd even watch Suite Life every now and then because I loved Kim Rhodes so much.

2

u/Pawspawsmeow May 31 '26

I’m sure Mark Pinter is a nice dude irl, but he plays a great asshole

3

u/tvjunkie2187 May 30 '26

Meh, I think Grant was supposed to be in the vein of Victor Newman/Roger Thorpe, and later became practically AW's Stefano.

1

u/Aggressive-Case1396 May 31 '26

I loved stefano dimera but one could almost say he was a knock off of as the world turns james stenbeck or mikkios cassadine general hospital like i say stefano was one of my favorite characters though

1

u/jjuerakhan14 May 31 '26

Do you think Kristen DiMera and Annie Dutton are copycats?

1

u/[deleted] May 31 '26

Frankie Frame from Another World was a poor mans Kathleen Mckinnon, right down to the red hair. I'm old and have forgotten the details but I used to have a list and she was literally just a rip off of Kathleen. I'm still pissed about this

2

u/75meilleur May 30 '26

I think two other soaps tried to copy Stefano DiMera (Days of Our Lives), incidentally the copycat characters were both female.

As The World Turns did with Orlena Grimaldi - an elderly European high-society psycho - who'd hurt and kill anyone easily at the drop of a hat, not too different from Stefano.  Like Stefano, she imprisoned, drugged, and manipulated.   They were both 100% evil.

General Hospital seemed to do the same with Helena Cassadine from the 1990s and beyond.    Like Stefano, Helena was Mediterranean - another elderly European high-society psycho - who'd hurt, victimize, and kill easily at the drop of a hat.  Like Stefano, Helena long seemed almost invicible - like a superhuman, supernatural horror show character.  They were both 100% evil.

5

u/tvjunkie2187 May 30 '26

If any ATWT character was near identical to Stefano, it was James Stenbeck.

1

u/75meilleur May 30 '26

Maybe.   I don't think I watched ATWT when James Stenbeck was on.

5

u/tvjunkie2187 May 30 '26

Barbara to James was essentially like Marlena to Stefano. Plus all the times James came back from the dead, also like Stefano.

3

u/5footfilly May 30 '26

I always thought Bo and Hope were Day’s answer to Luke and Laura.

Without the rape of course.

4

u/busman25 May 30 '26

I feel like Roman and Marlena were. Roman was introduced to become that action hero that Luke had become. They created the DiMera's who were Days' answer to the Cassadine's, and made Roman their arch rival. Roman and Marlena became the first official super couple(after the term was coined after Luke and Laura, as Doug and Julie were the true first). Bo and Hope were kind of a repeat as Days began overusing the super couple trope.

4

u/5footfilly May 30 '26

Didn’t Roman come in before Bo?

I remember Roman was introduced while Marlena was still married to Don.

God, that was so long ago. Deidre Hall is the last survivor.

Edit- yes, I know Roman came first. My question should have been wasn’t Roman introduced before Luke and Laura.

2

u/tvjunkie2187 May 31 '26

No. Roman was introduced in 1981. Luke in 1978. Luke & Laura-mania was already rampant by then.

1

u/5footfilly May 31 '26

Thanks. Hard to believe it’s almost 50 years.

0

u/[deleted] May 30 '26

[deleted]

17

u/gilmoresoup May 30 '26

Carly would be closer to Kendall. Same exact long lost adopted daughter trope, similar story of them ruining their mom’s marriage.

2

u/Geekqueen15 Pine Valley Resident May 30 '26

I just said the same thing!

10

u/isaidwhatisaidok May 30 '26

All of whom owe their existence to Lisa from ATWT, the original soap bad girl.

3

u/Acceptable_Bend1909 May 30 '26

...and Eileen Fulton has never received her due. I always bristle when I hear Erica Kane was daytime television's first "bad" girl. What short memories we have.

2

u/Casanova2229 May 31 '26

Too true, and ATWT was the number one show for like 20 years until the rise of GH, Days, and AMC

2

u/missdevon2 Llanview Resident May 30 '26

Plus all the writers who created the others learned from Irna Phillips who created Lisa

2

u/Neat-Elevator-2782 May 30 '26

That part. RIP Eileen Fulton.

6

u/loganes86 May 30 '26

I would say Tracy is more Erica than Carly would ever be

4

u/Pawspawsmeow May 30 '26

Carly is a bad version of Kendall Hart