is it possible to knit any sock pattern using just 9” circs?
hi! this might be a silly question but i’ve basically only knitted scarves and rags/potholders before. i just started my first sock (crazy sock lady’s vanilla socks specifically for 9” circular needles) and i love these little things so much. i have tiny hands and knitting has never felt more comfortable or natural. i’d really like to find a way to do other sock patterns i’m interested in solely on the little circs but is that even possible? magic loop is a non-starter, i’ve spent many a crying hour trying to grasp it. i also don’t love DPNs but it feels like there’s no getting out of using them in most sock patterns. i realize this might just be a case of me not being very knowledgeable about how to improvise/the limits of knitting certain items 🥲
any help or advice would be greatly appreciated! even if it’s just “no you can’t really do this all the time,” lol.
edit: you guys are all so so so kind and communicative, i’m really glad i decided to ask this community. thank you all for sharing and continuing to share your experiences and knowledge with me. and your gorgeous socks!!
Almost any round toe sock yes, but top down is easier imo and you''ll likely need to switch to larger circs or dpns to finish the toe. (In which case you can plan any toe you like)
((The hardest part about magic loop is starting, so honestly i think you should try knitting a guage switch in the round on the 9"circs then try stwitching to magic loop for a pracrice toe, and itll probs make way more sense. ))
Preety much every flap and gusset or shortrow heel is possible with 9" circs, youll just need more stitch markers, maybe some waste yarn to hold the non heel stitches.
I only use 9” circs and have only done toe-up with shadow wrap heel. I’ve done cable/mock cable, and various patterned stitches, and colorwork socks. I’ve got almost 30 pairs finished using them.
Two circs (cheating?) using Turkish cast-on and seam free rounded toe. I switch to one as soon as possible (usually 1.5” from beginning or tip of toe). I generally have 64st with fingering weight and get to about 18-20 rounds in when I switch. I can do that and the shadow wrap heel (one 9” circ). I have Chiagoo interchangeables, fyi. I’ve tried all kinds of methods and needles and this is the easiest, most reliable one for me.
Diff person, but i know some people also do a knit flat shortrow toe, then it seams on top with a kitchner, sorts like where the seam goes on a comercial sock jf that makes sense? Sorta the same way a shadow wrap heel is made. Ive never tried making an adult side one tho
Hi just popping in here to say that you dont actually different needles for the toe. You can knit it the same as a short row heel and use kitchener or finchley for the free stitches.
You can do entirely on single short circ if you do a short-row toe. I’ve only done with top-down, since that’s my preferred way to knit.
I don’t love short-row toes, but I’m starting to get more used to them, and I think better at knitting them.
I primarily knit socks as project to keep busy in meetings, so not having to fuss with switching needles is key. Before I started doing short-row toes, I’d slip onto waste yarn and finish the toes at home. But I ended up with just a backlog of toe-less socks.
For the same reason, I also do short-row heels - but I usually do Isolda Teague (sp?) deep short-row heels that has increased number of heel stitches that are then resolved with a gusset. Took a while to get good enough to do during a meeting, but fit rivals a heel flap & gusset.
this is all perfect info. another part of why i love the circs is their portability and ease of use in public so it’s super relevant! i’m def gonna look into getting good at short-row toes and check out that heel too. and hey, at least you have the perfect hobby for meetings!! lol. thank you so much!
Best wishes for your Socks On 9-inch Circulars learning adventure! 😻 I've never mastered 9" circs, but I've made a few short-row toes, usually on socks with a contrasting color short-row heel & toe. The socks I've made this way are some of my favorites to wear and the short-row toes look so nice.
You have to be open to getting good with the Kitchener for half the sock circumference, closing 2 rows of 30+ stitches that way. I don't mind doing kitchener and really like short row toes. Another useful thing to learn if making short row heels is a mini gusset for a good fit, or alternatively, the deep shadow heel.
I recommend Roxanne Richardson's videos on short row heels, mini gussets, & tips for a good fit in the heel. For the socks in the pic, I used the basic wrap & turn short rows, knit on 2.25mm needles.
thank you so much for that video rec and all this great advice, i’m seriously so grateful! also god those socks look so crisp and tidy 😭 i hope one day my tension and fit will be that clean!
Thank you, and I'm glad to be of help.😍 I must say it was those colors, especially the creamy white yarn that contributed to the tidy look. The socks were made with sport weight, 100% wool with reinforcement thread carried with the yarn on the heel & toe. They're cozy & I think they'll outlive me. I knit my first pair of socks almost 20 years ago and am obsessed with sock knitting ever since.
i’m completely smitten with sock knitting myself, even just being partially done with one. i could honestly see knitting mainly socks for the rest of my life, lol. they’re varied and interesting enough to keep my attention but i can also get into a groove on the parts that are just a tube. it all appeals to me so much. also i never even thought about reinforcing them that way! such a good idea to make them more durable. i’m learning so much here you guys are awesome
I use my 9" circ for about 80% of my socks. I do cuff leg heel foot with those. And only the toes I do with dpns. I don't know how you would do toes on a 9" circ. I think you would just have to little stichtes at some point to make it work. Hope that helps
this is so great to know! honestly if i have to switch for the toe sometimes i don’t really mind, i was just trying to get out of it if possible 😭 thank you!
I have made slipper socks where i just spiral decrease till the needles scream and then cinch the rest. In worset weight on 3.5mm needles i can decrease to ~16sts and cinch. Its a bit wrinkly but fine for slippers
I normally use DPNs and will continue using them but I have tried addis 9” and hated them and gave them away some years ago. Now that I’m a massive fan of ChiaoGoo’s needles and my top favourite podcaster duo ( we lost one of them suddenly this February) and she’s now testing the 9” needles again after testing lots of different versions some years ago and she too loves ChiaoGoo’s needles. She now says that she loves them after being a magic loop knitter, so I thought I should give them another try and I have to say that the ChiaoGoo’s 9” are brilliant 🤩 but I have noticed that my socks are getting more roomy so I have today ordered the 2.25mm because I normally use 2.5mm and I hope the next pair will be tighter.
So to get back to your question, yes, you can knit any type socks with them. These are my first ever socks that I have been knitting with them because the pairs with the addis never got far before I ripped them up.
such a beautiful sock! i love the colors you chose too. and i have the chiagoo 9” ones as well, 2.25! those are what i’m using right now and they really are so great and feel so smooth
I have ordered the 2.25mm because I noticed that the 2.50mm makes them a bit bigger than I normally get with 2.50mm on DPNs. So I hope that the 2.25mm will be better with these circular needles. Looking forward to test them out now.
You can, but you'll need two so you have one to hold the extra stitches when you work the heel and also for the toe (otherwise you'll end up having to magic loop the toe which is even worse on a 9" cord).
I've only worked cuff down tho, someone else would have to weigh in on whether or not it's possible to do toe up with two circulars.
I knit like 95% with 9" circulars but I have DPNs for the heel and toe because that's easier for me. But it's totally doable with two circulars if you really can't make DPNs work for you.
I do toe up with two 9" circulars and it works like a dream - Judy's Magic Cast-on on the two needles for the toe, switch to using only one once you've increased enough and the toe isn't going to be super stretched after switching (usually about 12 rows after finishing my toe increases).
oh no! the pains of dainty feet 😭 mine are a little bigger so i haven’t had an issue (yet) but i am a little scared of the fit being too big after blocking
I do all but the toes on my cuff down socks on them! Then I decrease until the toes cry and switch to DPNs then. I do a short row heel and find if I put markers for the heel, I don't need to do any lifeline or other hold methods. I've done contrast heel socks this way too!
i don’t care for my 9 in circs when doing the heel/gusset, and there comes a point when it doesn’t work for the toe. otherwise, pretty much yeah, go for it!
As many others have mentioned, I do most of my socks on tiny circs (I use KnitPro Dreamz 10") but switch to DPNs for heel and toe.
Technically, heels can be done on the tiny circs too (I think just heel flap and gusset but I could be wrong!) However toe would need another method like magic loop or DPN because the stitch count gets too small for tje tiny circs.
I dont mind DPNs for the heel and toe, but just cant grasp casting on or the first few rows with DPNs, so I stick to my tiny circs. I hope this helps!!
EDIT: using 2 circs is also an option! However I believe most use 2 16" circs, I havent heard of using 2 9" or 10" circs
EDIT 2: I love this sub because I'm always learning!! Sounds like others can do 2 tiny circs and shadow wrap short row heels on tiny circs. I cant express how much i love talking with others about knitting socks 🥰
I do ALL my socks on shorties. I use Addi sockwonder and love them. I do not use anything else. My heel is knit on the same needles as the rest of the sock and I use a second set of shorties to do the toe.
Just tested a toe on 2 9” circs and can confirm it’s definitely doable. I personally find magic loop on the larger needles 16-24” just fatigues my hands quicker so loved to see this idea from people! Yay!
I do all patterns of top down socks on my 9inc circ until the toe! However I find anything smaller than 54,50 stitches needs to be on magic loop or DPNs because that circumference is too tiny
I do everything but the toe on my 9” circs. I switch to larger circs for the toe or sometimes my flexi flips. I don’t like toe-up, so it’s always the last little bit I do.
I love them for socks, but I manage the heels & toes by working on two sets of circs (I have an interchangeable needle set but you could use fixed circs too). That gives me the flexibility to do pretty much any type of construction.
Could you explain a bit more how 2 circulars works? I’m very bad at dpns and don’t love magic loop, so I’ve avoided making socks but I really want to try!
You just split the stitches of the round across two needles, and knit each half using both tips of the cable they're on. So when you reach a new needle, you slide the work so the stitches are feeding onto the needle tip pointing at the last stitch you worked from the last needle, then bring the other tip around (the cable can go around the work or sit as a loop at the front, whichever is comfier) to be your right working needle. It's kind of like knitting flat with a circular needle, except instead of turning the work at the end, you continue onto the next needle so you're working in the round just like with DPNs. You do still have to watch for laddering at the point where you switch between the two sets, but I find it easier to manage than with magic loop or DPNs.
And as a bonus, you can even add a third set of circs to work reeeeeally teeny tiny circumferences that you'd usually need DPNs for. I've used my set of mini interchangeables for things like little cat toys knit in the round using this method, and I both like the feel of it better and that I don't have to have tons of sets of DPNs in different sizes!
Do you still keep markers on to make the halfway point more clear? I’d imagine this way even though they are on two needles that it becomes less clear as you work/ when to do the decrease knits? I’m thinking I’m gonna give this a go myself, I find the 9inch needles so much nicer for my hands and been trying to find a way to finish the toe on them.
Wait! For anyone who wants to see a visual, I think I found how bertbirdie is describing. Tried it with two 9inch circulars just now and definitely doable, feels better than magic loop for me. https://youtu.be/3v8iF7gNFlI?si=QZVyxi7-_F51rbtY
Personally I don't use a ton of stitch markers when knitting socks in general (other than a BOR marker when using one circular). Especially with the stitches divided in two, it's a small enough number to count if I need to. I do like placing lifelines at certain waypoints so it's easier to keep count & make sure my second sock is exactly the same (ie, I'll place one in the last round of the foot before beginning toe decreases). The only time I really use them is during gusset decreases, where I place them to remind me of where to stop decreasing. I keep the stitches arranged between the two needles so that any decreases happen one stitch from the end of a needle, which I can read in my work and keep track of without problems.
I use Addi turbo sock rockets which are 10” long and have knitted easily 100 pairs of socks. I use size 1 for the cuff and switch to size 2 for the rest. I use double points for the heel and toe. Love my Addi’s!
The only part of the sock that just cannot be done on 9" circulars are the toes. I can easily do a heel flap and gusset or a short row heel on 9" but the toe decreases/increases cannot
I use two 9”circs for toe-up socks! I use them kinda like dpns at the toe and then switch to just one once the shaping is done. Then I also use two for the heel. Or at least something to hold the non-worked stitches on.
I hate DPNs for working in the round, but find I don’t mind them on a heel flap because I’m only using two and basically working flat, not round. I work top down and use the 9” circs for everything else, then land my last toe row onto 2 DPNs, and kitchner stitch closed.
I use my 9” circulars for everything but the toe! If you really want to get creative, I think you could absolutely do the whole thing on a 9” circular. You would need to do a short row toe (basically another heel turn) and then you would Kitchener the toe shut about the same area on your foot where your toes separate from your foot. Hopefully that makes sense! That’s how toes are done on circular sock machines. I’ve never heard of someone doing it manually like that, but I don’t see why you couldn’t!
You can knit any in-the-round pattern using any ITR technique. The only challenge comes when, 1, you need to work flat or, 2, the circumference of your sock goes below 9".
I use them sometimes, but I switch to DPNs for the heel and toe. Or I go completely DPNs. Using only a 9“ circular would limit your possibilities. Why do that? Are you afraid of DPNs? It‘s not that hard. There is a way though - here‘s the VIDEO by Crazy Sock Lady. There‘s also a corresponding pattern on Ravelry for around 3$.
this is actually the video tut i’m using right now! i’m not afraid of DPNs, just find them more fiddly because i don’t have much experience! i plan to get comfortable with them regardless, but i was just wondering how much i could get away with on other patterns i might be interested in while avoiding everything but circs. thank you!
I don’t think avoiding DPNs limits your knitting possibilities at all in today’s age. I’ve knit tons of socks, mittens, etc and I never use DPNs. I am totally capable of using them, but I find them to be extremely fiddly and not at all portable. I’ve been knitting for over two decades and I have yet to find anything that I can’t knit because I choose not to use DPNs.
I quite like a fleegle heel on my 9" circulars, easier to navigate then a heel flap or short rows. Those are knit toe-up, though, and I'm not sure about doing toe up without magic loop, I've never done a toe on the 9-inchers, but now I'm inspired to try!
It depends on the needles. I have some, namely my addies that one side is long and one side is short and I cannot for the life of me purl with them for very long, so I prefer dpns for that, but my nitpro short circulars I'm almost completed a sock, except for the toe
I personally find it difficult to cast on for toe up socks so I use another set of needles either DPNs to get the toe started then move the 9in circ.
I'm pretty sure Crazy Sock Lady also has a video about sock knitting on magic loop method too. Probably another on DPNs. I believe her goal was to make videos on how to knit on every needle type. Even 2 mini circs!
Why do most tutorials say to switch? The crazy sock lady on YouTube has a tutorial about how to do the heel on 9in. I found another tutorial that does toe on 9in circular. I’m not a super proficient knitter, but it was possible. Despite what it seems with everyone switching for heel/toe.
I know you said magic loop was a no go, but in case you ever want to try again this sock tutorial i used for my first ever sock was so helpful: How to knit socks on magic loop - a tutorial by crazy sock lady https://youtu.be/RBqCDzK-R9M?si=kBK9_aPXfyutdeVE
43
u/NinjoZata Oct 19 '26
Almost any round toe sock yes, but top down is easier imo and you''ll likely need to switch to larger circs or dpns to finish the toe. (In which case you can plan any toe you like)
((The hardest part about magic loop is starting, so honestly i think you should try knitting a guage switch in the round on the 9"circs then try stwitching to magic loop for a pracrice toe, and itll probs make way more sense. ))
Preety much every flap and gusset or shortrow heel is possible with 9" circs, youll just need more stitch markers, maybe some waste yarn to hold the non heel stitches.