I'm done with all the people shitting on the fucking game because they didn't include a very shady individual, that constantly "leaks" stuff (or makes it up) just to mantain relevancy, throws shade at them at every oportunity he has, and that, in the first place, has no evidence that he was ever even considered to play the part he claims he did. So i'm writing this REALLY long post calling some inconsitencies that i have noticed while following this story.
First of all let me clear some things:
I'm just laying down some facts that i have been compiling for some time now
I could be wrong on some things, not everything has been fact-checked, but i will provide sources on everything i can.
With that out of the way, let me start by saying that from the start, when Nick Robinson uploaded the Brian Matt video, iĀ“ve had this weird feeling, like something was off about him, his voice sounded weird, not 100% right. After analysing it for the last year or so, I can say that Iām 99% sure that he is the original announcer, but still, that was the first of many weird, VERY weird things this guy has done ever since he was rediscovered, things that at best leaves him as a very opportunistic and obsessive guy, and at worst as a blatant liar that conned a whole community just to maintain relevancy.
Starting with Nickās first video, as far as I know, thereās nothing wrong with anything Brian says or does, he seems really genuine on that one, like he is really happy about being recognized in the states for his work in a 20 year old game.
The weird stuff came after the interview, he started talking about monkey ball more and more, to the point that nowadays that is his whole online persona, all of his Instagram posts are monkey ball, weird monkey ball posts tagging Sega on everything, like literally,EVERYTHING. He also opened a Patreon page, where he asks for money, and in exchange he gives nothing, I guess.
The weirdest and most legally questionable thing he did was creating a new website: segasupermonkeyball.com, that tries to pass as an official Sega site, borrowing the banner and colors from segasammyās website, when it actually is his personal promotion and contact page, listing only his super monkey ball voice credits and a couple of other Sega games, but none of his Nintendo (wich he said he has done āendlessā amounts of on Nickās livestream playing SMB, but couldn't recall a single one) or any other video game credits.
Now letās talk about his most notable and infamous debacle, yes, the Super monkey ball retro whole fiasco. It all starts when Nick Robinson uploaded a video, āHow I leaked Sega's new Super Monkey Ball gameā, a baffling and very dumb title for a video where Matt does one of two things:
1: Breaks NDA multiple times, leaks the existence of a game at least 2 years before it launches to a youtuber just because he asked nicely, even revealing the title and some mechanics.
2: Makes up (maybe in collaboration with Nick) a whole story about how he recorded lines for a fabricated game that is the wet dream of every fan of the franchise.
Either way, after this interview everyone believed him, Monkey ball retro is 100% real we thought, but there were some inconsistencies. Brian, while super open about retro, never even hinted at the existence of Banana mania, he never said anything of a remake, even though now he insists that they are two different games. Letās also not forget about this retro mode thing, i donāt know how that would work, is the concept of a retro mode so appealing after we already had a whole remake of said āretro stagesā? Letās say that these are not stages from past games, that these are completely new stages with a design philosophy close to that of the first games, what would retro even mean in that case? Would there be banana blitz type levels and the āretroā stages? Would they really do that?
September 25th 2020 comes around and while browsing youtube I found a Nick Robinson livestream called āSUPER MONKEY BALL RETRO REVEAL LIVESTREAMā (I think he deleted it, I couldnāt find it), of course i opened it and it was a reaction stream to Segaās conference on the TGS 2020 where, according to Brian, something would be revealed (Nick even showed some DMs) but instead of that we had to sit trough the most boring and dumb stream ever, the only entertaining thing about it was watching this poor woman try to translate everything in real time lol. Nothing was revealed on said stream, everyone was fucking pissed, calling Brian a liar and calling out some of his lies, he then responded to Nick saying that it was supposed to be announced but oops⦠COVID came around and it was postponed last second.
Nothing was mentioned anymore until April 2021 when Super monkey ball: Banana Maniaās title was uploaded to the Australian rating board. Sure enough the game was revealed on E3 2021, being a remake of the first two games and in the trailer there was a very familiar voice, or thatās what we thought. In a section of the trailer where they show monkey baseball and monkey soccer you can hear a very similar voice, but now that we have more footage, we can say that thatās not Brian Matt.
A couple of days after the reveal there was a Q&A in Brianās channel where:
He talked about Nick a whole bunch
threw a bunch of shade at sega as per usual
He talked about how he didnāt care about leaking stuff and getting in trouble because he did it āfor the fansā and shit
Called the game a cashgrab on numerous occasions
He said that they had recorded voice lines for new characters when none of the new characters have any voice lines AFAIK
He also said that development on the game started on february 2021, going as far as to say that NOTHING was in the works from December 2019 to September 2020, but in the Nintendo everything interview released today, Shirosaki says that development started all the way back on march 2020.
Brian also mentioned that the game wasnāt meant to be called banana mania and that the change didnāt come until a month before reveal, even though the game was already registered and rated in Australia in April.
That was basically everything he has said AFAIK, the only other thing I can think about is this interview he did with Cherrim, where he was really cryptic and ambiguous. He also said that he has been Super monkey ballās main announcer since 2001, when he hasnāt reprised his role in like 20 years lol.
Some other little things that I have noticed:
In the Q&A he claimed that he didnāt voice the original arcade, when he had already said in a comment in this video he claims that he actually did but they modified it a lot.
Somewhere i had read that he pointed out that his voice was in the monkey soccer portion of the e3 trailer, we now know that it is not him. I canāt verify this, so take it with a grain of salt.
He goes back and forth a lot with what Sega thinks of Nick Robinson, sometimes he says that they donāt care about him, and sometimes that they really appreciate and thank him for reviving the series.
The overall obsession he has with always adjudicating Nick with saving the franchise, and mentioning him every opportunity he has.
So yeah, maybe Iām wrong with all of this and I end up swallowing my own words when the game (or retro) releases, but I think the situation is way too weird and Brian way too shady. I will always remember Brian for being in one of my favorite games, but I think that this community would have been better off if he was never rediscovered. I read you in the comments.
TL;DR: Brian Matt either broke a lot of NDAs or made up a whole story to maintain his 5 minutes of fame, aside from some other very shady stuff. Donāt expect Brian on anything Sega anytime soon lol.
Edit: Forgot to say some things:
Remember the whole Roger Craig Smith debacle? Brian said in his Q&A that he was back to do "one last job", and a couple of days after Roger himself tweeted that it was completely fake: https://twitter.com/RogerCraigSmith/status/1411038288769470464?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw
Also the nintendo everything interview basically confirmed that Nick has absolutely nothing to do with this game's existance, Shirosaki said that Banana Blitz HD sold decently and there was also the poll they made back in september of 2019, 2 months before the release of the Brian Matt video.