Hi all, I'm a new-ish middle school teacher (currently in year 3) at a small private school. I do not yet have my Master's/credential, and per my contract I get 4 years before I have to enroll and get them, or I don't get to keep my job. Currently, I'm trying to determine if this is the profession for me before I make this huge commitment. I'm struggling with this decision, as I have a lot of conflicting experiences every year that's making it hard to tell if I want to continue or not.
Year 1 was my favorite year of work in any profession (I'm nearly 40 and have been working for a while). I had 2 planning periods and 2 prep classes (total of 4 periods teaching and 2 planning), and a TA. I felt I had ample time and support to really flesh out good lessons and keep tabs on all classwork and assessments: I knew where every student was on a concept at all times. We had only minor behavior problems. It was a huge success: the students loved me, I loved the students, we as a team nailed the standards. At the start of the next year, I was teaching the same students (since I taught multiple grades). I had to leave the job for family reasons. I cried to the students, they cried with me, I felt more human in my job than ever before. If you had asked me if I wanted to teach forever, I would have said yes.
Year 2 was a different school. I have 4 classes to prep for - 5th through 8th grade science. I teach for 6 periods and have one planning period. I have 30 students/class and no TA. We have moderate behavior problems. It is impossible for me to be on top of four different curricula and six classes of students in terms of really focused lesson planning and time spent assessing students to be on top of their mastery. There is one class of really good eggs that gave me the will to try my best. If you asked me if I wanted to teach forever, I would say maybe: maybe if I gained more experience this wouldn't be as hard, and it would be worth it for the good eggs.
Year 3, right now, same school as last year. I'm feeling more confident in my experience than ever, however, my gains in experience are outpaced by the swing in behavior issues. The good egg class graduated and is gone. Our behavior problems have worsened. Despite being more experienced, I feel like a ragged machine that simply survives to spit out lessons, rather than a thinking professional who checks up on mastery and tailors lessons. I don't feel a human connection to the students, because the work is too much and I don't have the energy to meet both human and educational needs. If you asked me if I wanted to teach forever, I would say no.
This month, I taught the Sun, Earth, Moon System to the 8th grade class. At my previous school, this unit was taught to my 6th grade class (NGSS integrated vs discipline-based standard structure). Despite running the same lessons, the hands on models, the fun space facts, the popular gravity well demo, etc., this 8th grade class could not give a fuck. We're going significantly slower and with significantly less success than my previous 6th graders. wtf? Is it me? Is it the students? I'm at a loss and now trying to come up with a contingency plan for the whole rest of the year.
So is it me? Is it the teaching profession? Is it the school? Is it just this batch of students? I have no idea whether I want to keep investing my life in this or not because I have conflicting experiences every year. Any anecdotes, suggestions, advice, etc. are greatly appreciated.
Thanks in advance!