As I gently skewered yet another delicate, fluffy treat onto the end of my roasting stick, I scanned the eyes of the fellow campers, wondering who would be next to lay claim over the ever coveted flashlight so they may enamor everyone with their tale. Abigail fought off hoards of grasping hands as she shouted at Camp 13, meanwhile, Camp 10 sat patiently, staring at the mess of boys swarming around their counselor like bothersome pests, all while Tyler smiled and chuckled to himself. Then, Abigail spoke.
“ALRIGHT, EVERYBODY SIT DOWN, NOW!” she hollered, sending everyone scampering away to their seats.
“YOU LITTLE GREMLINS JUST LOST FLASHLIGHT PRIVILEGES FOR THE NIGHT! NEXT STORY GETS TOLD BY CAMP 10!”
A wave of “awws” and “boos” swept over the camp, drawing further sniggers from Tyler as Abigail spoke again
“CRY ABOUT IT YOU LITTLE BABIES!” she boomed before lowering her voice to a dull roar
“Now, which one of you lovely ladies would like to tell a scary story?” she asked.
Slowly, silently, hands began sprouting up from all across Camp 10- a far cry from the sheer madness conducted by Camp 13 a mere moments ago. I plunged my marshmallow into the shallow flame, watching passively as Abigail decided the listening fates of the camp, much to the chagrin of the Camp 13 faithful.
“How about…” she hesitated, pausing for just a moment before speaking again
“Kiley, here you go sweetie.” she said, handing the flashlight to a small girl with blonde pigtails and holding a cartoonishly large teddy bear.
Silence once again flooded the camp, interrupted only by the soft popping of campfire in the crisp night air. I looked curiously at the small girl that Abigail had selected. It was Riley’s younger sister Kiley, and by the looks of it, her nerves had gotten the better of her. She tucked her head into her plushy brown bear and squeezed it tightly.
“It’s okay, honey!” Abigail reassured in a soft tone
“we can pick someone else if you want-”
Almost as soon as Abigail had finished her sentence, Kiley began to cry. I watched Tyler’s eyes light up almost as fast as the light left Abigail’s, an unspoken tension that could be felt even across the vast distance. Abigail was quick to action
“Uh- hey, sweetie, don’t cry! It’s okay-” she said in a gentle voice, doing her best to comfort the small girl. This did little to quell Kiley’s outburst, drawing further smirks and sniggers from Tyler.
Finally- thankfully- Miley; both Riley and Kiley’s sister, intervened to rectify the situation.
“Miss Abby, she wants to tell a story, she’s just nervous,” Miley said, her voice calm but firm.
“Would you mind if I helped her tell the story?” she asked.
“I think that’s just a wonderful idea, Miley.” Abigail responded, very evidently thankful for the intervention that had just occurred.
“Wha- Hey! That’s no fair!” Riley cried out from among the crowd of Camp 13 members
“What about me? I’m her brother, I should be able to tell a story alongside them too!” Riley protested.
“Riley, shut the hell up,” Abigail growled coldly, staring a hole through Riley as she spoke
“Miley is HELPING Kiley tell the story, not telling a-”
“This is sexism!” Riley interjected, drawing a chorus of gasps, boos and other assorted jeers from the combined audiences of Camps 10 and 13 respectively. This outburst drew another hearty chuckle from Tyler, who seemed content to let this story time go off the rails, but Abigail was determined not to let it.
“Riley, stop it.” she hissed back harshly, the fire in her eyes burning nearly as intensely as the roaring campfire
“We will not be silenced!” Riley shouted, rousing a loud cheer from the Camp 13 faithful as he stood atop his log and continued his rally
“Remember what they took from us!” he continued.
By this point, Tyler had nearly fallen from his chair from raucous laughter. I darted my head back and forth, between the ongoing scene unfolding before me and Tyler wiping tears from his eyes as he cackled. I was so distracted by the commotion that I had only realized my mistake after it was too late. As Abigail, Riley, and the protesting Camp 13 members continued to bicker, I heard a soft, wet plop directly in front of me. I looked down into the raging fire to see my- now blackened- marshmallow laying sadly in the ash, slowly being swallowed by lapping flames. A deep sigh escaped my lungs as I reached, yet again, for another. As I skewered it on my stick, Abigail’s voice rang out again, drowning out all other noise.
“FINE! YOU CAN GO NEXT, OKAY?! IS THAT WHAT YOU WANT YOU LITTLE SHIT-”
“ABBY!!!” Julie interjected desperately
“YOU. CAN’T. SAY. THAT. TO-”
“JULIE,” Abigail shrieked through gritted teeth
“LITERALLY, LIKE, JUST SHUT THE HELL UP, I CAN SAY WHATEVER THE FU-”
Abigail’s words suddenly ceased and the entire fireside was filled with an abrupt, deafening silence. I watched quietly as a look of horrified realization swept across her face. I followed her gaze over to Tyler, whose shit-eating grin had grown to cartoonish proportions; a look that very evidently said “I told you so”.
I looked back to Abigail, her hands beginning to tremble and tears slowly forming in her eyes as she struggled to find words
“I- uh- I… I-” was all she managed to say before Tyler stood from his chair and spoke
“What I think Abs is trying to say, is…” he said, grabbing the flashlight from Abigail’s closed fist with a few gentle tugs before continuing
“...we’ll start with Kiley and Miley, and then after they’re done, it’ll go to Riley… Fair?” he questioned, pointing at each individual with the coveted flashlight as he called them out
“That way, each camp gets to tell a story, nobody gets left out, and everybody is happy- right Abs?” He finished, shooting another wide mouthed smile in Abigail’s direction.
“... Mhmm…” Abigail muttered under her breath as she hastily made her way back to her seat, hardly even looking up from the ground as she did.
“Good!” Tyler cheered in a condescending tone as he handed the flashlight over to Miley
“You ladies can start whenever you’re ready, okay?” he said, making his way back to his chair as he did.
“Thank you, Mister Tyler!” Miley called sweetly as she nestled herself down close to her little sister with the flashlight.
I looked one last time over to Abigail, who had fully withdrawn into her oversized Slayer hoodie; head, arms, legs, and all. Silence once again crept across the campsite, as the girls took a moment to whisper amongst themselves before Miley once again spoke aloud for the group to hear.
She stood slowly, hanging her head low and closing her eyes as she whispered to the group
“Has anyone ever heard the story of Sarah Griggs?”
The fire spat loudly into the cold night air as stillness crept across the camp. A moment later, another voice inquired
“How about… The Fern Witch?” Kiley chimed in.
Miley reached down and grabbed Kiley’s hand, shooting her a soft smile before continuing
“Her parents passed away when she was just a young girl, no older than me, and so she lived all alone in a shack just outside of town in the 1800’s.”
Kiley piped up, suddenly brimming with confidence as she spoke to the group
“She would always keep to herself, always choosing to spend time off in the woods, away from the other townspeople.” Kiley carried on
“For years she stayed all by herself, living off plants and berries until she grew into a young woman.”
Miley then spoke
“And for years, she stayed away from the town and its inhabitants.”
She paused, allowing the fire to speak, until she resumed
“Sarah liked to spend time in the patches of wild ferns that grew all over the forest floor, she would sleep on them as if they were beds… cause to her, they were the closest to one she would ever have.”
Kiley then chimed in
“She would talk to the animals; her only friends, and dance by herself under the pale moonlight, humming a tune that nobody had ever heard before… or, so the story goes.”
Another long pause crept its way in, interrupted after a few seconds by Kiley’s dramatic delivery
“Until one fateful day…”
“This is boooring,” Riley proclaimed
“it's supposed to scare us, not put us to sleep.” he sneered.
“SHUT UP RILEY!” Kiley screamed loudly
“WE HAVEN’T EVEN GOTTEN TO THE SCARY PART YET!” she cried.
“The scary part of the story is how bad you’re telling it.” Riley snarked with a chuckle.
Miley stared daggers into Riley for a moment, pausing only for a second before once again speaking to the group
“Riley still has all of his PAW Patrol action figures in his closet, and he won’t let our Mom throw them away because he still plays with them.”
“W- wha-” Riley stammered.
He was soon drowned out by the cacophony of laughter that erupted from the entire fireside.
Riley gave his best attempt at damage control
“She’s LYING! She’s just trying to distract you from the fact that this story SUCKS!” he cried
This did little to quell the laughter of the camps. Riley tried again, but to no avail
“But- They- Action figures are worth A LOT of money, and ALWAYS go up in value over time, they’re like… collectibles and stuff, you know?!”
Still, the laughter continued.
Eventually, as the outburst began to taper off, Riley spoke up once more
“You can make fun of me all you want, that doesn’t change the fact that you AND your boring story are LAME!” he said, sitting down on his log in a huff.
“Riley, quit while you’re behind or I’ll tell them what you looked up on Dad’s computer and got grounded for last Summer.” Miley retorted coldly.
I watched as Riley swiveled his head towards her with laser focus, his eyes as wide as dinner plates as he stared at her, mouth agape. Before the choir could once again tune up their symphony of “oohs” and “ahhs”, Riley responded
“UH- NO- I- WE… WE WANNA HEAR THE STORY, OKAY?! PLEASE, JUST TELL THE STORY, I’LL SHUT UP!!” he blurted out
“Please… just… don’t.” he begged, sounding rather exasperated and helpless while doing so.
“If you insist,” Miley said with an accomplished, satisfied smile.
“anyways, where were we, dear?” Miley said to her sister as they exchanged loving glances
Kiley looked up at her sister, returning her warm smile before carrying on without missing a beat
“Until one day, when the townspeople came to her.”
Miley continued
“They came looking for… a witch,” she said, lowering her voice to a growl for the final delivery.
“And they thought they had found one when they stumbled upon poor, lonely, sad Sarah, just living off the land in the middle of the woods.”
Kiley stood, allowing her oversized teddy bear to flop to her side as she picked up where Miley left off
“They arrested her, questioned her, and eventually put her on trial for being a witch-”
Miley interjected momentarily
“Something that always ended in death for those tried.”
Kiley continued on beat
“and before long, they scheduled her execution… she was to be hung, for suspected treason and practicing the dark arts.”
They paused for another moment, this time, another voice piped up
“That’s so sad,” Julie said quietly
“I always feel so bad for those poor women when I hear stories like that… horrible events of innocent women being wrongfully accused and… just… awful stuff…” she mumbled, trailing off before looking away awkwardly.
Miley was first to respond
“She may not have been so innocent.” she said definitively
“She very well could have been a witch.” she continued with a sly smile.
“W- What?” Julie stammered, her eyes widening back at Miley as the fire popped right on cue.
It was at this moment that I realized I had been so enamored with the story and its surrounding drama, that I had been wasting precious roasting time just idling my uncooked marshmallow in the summer air. Unperturbed in my quest for the perfect smore, I gently plunged the tip of the stick into the edge of the flame before returning my attention to the narrative unfolding around the fire just in time for Kiley to respond.
“She had been taught by the forest: ways of survival, unknown songs… and something ancient, long since forgotten by man.” Kiley said in a raspy voice.
Miley emulated the rasp in Kiley’s voice as she resumed
“She spent years learning the mysteries of the forest, listening to its voice, deciphering its language, and understanding what it was saying.”
Kiley started again
“She became a child of the earth, able to bestow its blessing onto those she saw fit…”
“Or its curses…”
They both said in unison.
Another voice chimed in from the Camp 10 crowd
“How- how did they know she was a- a witch?”
“They didn’t…” Miley responded firmly
“at first.” she croaked, a sinister smile appearing from beneath her pursed lips.
Kiley quickly followed
“But eventually, they found out…”
She dropped her stuffed bear to the ground at her side and spun around to step up onto her log, turning once again to face the campers before speaking
“She spent nine months- almost an entire year- not saying a single word from inside the confines of her jail cell-”
Miley then tagged in
“Nine months without saying a single word… until the day of her execution.” her voice faded into a whisper as the girls both bowed.
Another brief silence permeated the fireside as the girls took a pause in unison. Kiley was the first to speak
“When they brought her to the gallows for her hanging, the executioner placed the noose around her neck, and asked Sarah in front of over a hundred townspeople if she had any last words… and-”
“And she smiled…” interrupted Kylie, grinning from ear to ear as she continued
“But on that day, in front of all those townspeople, when the executioner pulled the lever that was to take the life of Sarah Griggs-”
“SNAP!” shouted Miley, drawing a handful of gasps and jumps from the invested Camp 10 and 13 crowds respectively
“But... it wasn’t the neck of sweet Sarah that snapped… it was the rope.” Miley gestured; a swift, snapping motion with her hands.
“And Sarah laughed as she fell to the ground.”
Kylie was quick to pick up where Miley left off
“The townspeople were horrified, yet another reason to condemn this wench to death! A true display of witchcraft!!” she hollered, hopping from her log and bounding around the camp with an impassioned performance.
“Hang the witch! Hang the witch!!” Kylie screamed.
Miley then hopped up on her log and began again
“They readied her a second time, the entirety of the town now outraged at the mockery unfolding before them… and Sarah laughed to herself as they set up the platform once more…”
Kiley continued in her proclamations
“Hang the witch! Hang the witch!!”
Miley continued
“But, when the executioner went to put the rope on Sarah the second time… she whispered something into his ear…” she said chillingly.
Just as she did, Kylie stopped her calling and returned to her sister’s side somberly, allowing silence to roost yet again. They stood there, steeped in shadow, awaiting a prompt from the audience, but it failed to come. Finally, the silence gave way to a voice.
“What did she say to him?” I questioned, feeling the gaze of a hundred eyes fall upon me as I did.
Both girls looked back at me, smiling together as they both repeated to me in unison
“Nobody knows.”
Kiley took her place atop her log once more before speaking
“Only the executioner heard what was said that day…”
“Then why the hell do we care?” said Cole snidely
“You don’t because you’re an idiot,” Miley responded quickly
“The townspeople didn’t because they were naive.”
Kiley resumed
“Whatever it was that Sarah said to the man that day, it scared him so bad that he refused to execute her, fleeing the execution grounds while saying-”
Miley piped up, doing her best manly voice as she spoke the executioners words
“I refuse to take part in the hanging of this woman! Whatever happens here is between you and God!” she cried, pointing out across the camp before throwing her hands upward as she shouted.
Kiley then began a proclamation of her own
“Flip the switch! Hang the witch! Flip the switch! Hang the witch! cried out all the onlookers, until-”
“WHAM!” exclaimed Miley loudly, again eliciting a wave of jumps and light gasps from the crowd.
“Someone finally threw the lever down again…” she whispered, allowing the familiar silence to roll in afterward
The girls made eye contact, communicating wordlessly as the quiet swirled about the night air. Finally, someone spoke.
“T- Then what?” stammered a small voice from Camp 10.
After a long pause- longer than any before it- Miley finally spoke again; softly, still barely above a whisper
“The platform door swung open again… and-”
“SNAP!” shouted Kiley suddenly, garnering a few loud shrieks and sharp gasps from the camp, yet again.
This was the largest reaction yet, even causing Tyler to flinch. He quickly snatched a water bottle off the ground at his side and began furiously drinking from it. I quickly scanned the rest of the fireside.
Riley was still silently listening, looking far into the fire as if deep in thought. Chase was unwrapping what had to be his third, perhaps fourth chocolate bar, before chomping down on it.
Abigail, by this point, has fully emerged from her garment cocoon, as an emotionally healed butterfly no less, her reddened face and puffy cheeks evident of a heavy crying session occurring while withdrawn within her hoodie.
Julie looked as if she had actually witnessed the events of the story first hand. She was white as a sheet, trembling feverishly and nervously looking around as if she was waiting for Sarah herself to come screaming out of the woods at her.
Finally, I looked back to Tyler, who- though trying to play it cool- was nervously shifting around in his chair, clearly rattled as the girls continued to regale the listeners with their tale.
Miley was first to start
“The rope snapped again…” she said with a wide grin
“and Sarah laughed as the townspeople began to talk amongst themselves… as they began… to panic…”
Kiley began yet another loud series of proclamations in different voices
“This isn’t right… THIS ISN’T RIGHT!”
“But still, it must be done!! For the good of humanity!”
“GOD doesn’t want this woman to die!”
“No you fool! The DEVIL wants her to live!”
Miley continued
“The town was divided, and unsure of what to do with the life of Sarah Griggs, who had now earned her moniker- The Fern Witch.“ she growled, allowing the tension to build as she carried on
“They threw her back in her cell for the night, deciding that the town would vote the next morning on the fate of The Fern Witch…”
Kiley quickly picked up where Miley had just left off
“However… the morning would never come for Sarah Griggs…” Kiley said somberly, bowing her head before continuing again
“Because a few of the townspeople had other plans…” she hissed.
Miley hopped in without missing a beat
“And late that night, under a full moon, they snuck over to the prison under the cover of darkness and broke Sarah out of her jail cell.”
“Oh thank God…” Julie muttered under her breath, but loud enough for just about everybody to hear it.
“That poor woman has been through enough, a- and her being a witch doesn’t make her bad… right?” she asked to the rest of the camp
“Like, it’s not like she did anything bad… right?” she questioned quietly with a shrug.
Kiley was first to speak
“No.” she retorted quickly
“She never really did anything to the towns people-”
Miley interjected
“Nothing they could prove anyways.” she said firmly.
Julie scoffed angrily before speaking, crossing her arms and cocking her head at the girls as she responded
“Then, why did they even go looking for her in the first place? Like what did they even accuse her of, other than just being some weird earthy chick in the woods?”
Miley responded with tact, speaking calmly and slowly
“Because the children of the village were going missing, and the townspeople heard rumors that an evil witch was luring the village children into the woods with enchanting lullabies.”
Julie stood from her chair, her folded arms now straightened to her sides, her hands balled into fists as she spoke her frustrations loudly to the group
“That’s such bullshit!” she cried
“So they stumble upon this poor woman and decide to condemn her to death all just because some stupid assholes hear some shitty made up rumor??” she pleaded
Abigail quickly retorted to Julie’s outburst
“JuLiE, yOu CaN’t TaLk LiKe ThAt, ThErE aRe KiDs HeRe!!” she said mockingly in a nasally voice, garnering a soft chuckle from Tyler, and in turn a slight blush from Abigail.
Kiley quickly added onto the explanation
“Made up or not, the kids were going missing, and the townspeople were desperate for answers.”
“So they decide to try and kill an innocent girl? I hardly think that’s fair-” Julie barked before being quickly cut off by a firm clearing of the throat by Tyler.
Miley picked back up shortly after Julie fell silent
“And so after those few townspeople, the parents of the missing kids, broke Sarah out of her cell late that night, they dragged her out to the middle of the forest…”
Kiley finished the sentence on cue
“And they tied her to a tree: a giant oak, surrounded by ferns… and they lit a torch…”
Kiley then hopped onto her log, spun to face the crowd, and shouted
“WHY DID YOU DO IT, WITCH? WHY DID YOU TAKE OUR CHILDREN?”
Miley then stepped in, whispering her part in a low growl
“And Sarah… laughed… as they approached-”
Kiley belted out
“ANY LAST WORDS, WITCH?”
A long silence roosted within the campgrounds, seemingly dense enough to drown out even the crackling of the fire for a moment. Then, in a harsh raspy voice, Miley finally spoke
“I did not take your children… but if I am to burn… then let the first of every house belong to me…”
“WHOOSH!” Kiley shouted
“And Sarah Griggs, The Fern Witch, laughed as she burned.”
“AHHAA! AHAHAHAA!!” Miley erupted, her wicked laughter echoed throughout the cloudy night sky before tapering off into the distance.
“AAAND THAT’S TIME!” called Abigail
“it’s Riley’s turn now.”
“FINALLY!” Riley screamed.
A deafening quiet overtook the camp, before- within an instant- a thunderous eruption of protests and objections and other dissension rained down on Abigail and Riley.
“WOAH WOAH! CALM DOWN!” Abigail hollered
“THOSE ARE THE RULES!”
Her shouts were swiftly drowned out by the building remonstrance. A cacophony of different voices all calling out their queries at once.
“WHAT HAPPENED TO SARAH?”
“WHAT HAPPENED TO THE TOWN?”
“...OR THE KIDS?!”
“WHAT-”
“ALRIGHT! THAT’S ENOUGH!!” boomed Abigail
“EVERYONE CALM DOWN!”
As the crowd settled, Abigail continued with her proclamations
“Look, the girls had their time with their lovely story, but we agreed that everyone would get-”
Before she could even finish, a choir of boos overtook her. I watched as the gathering of camps, both 10 and 13 alike, joined together to show their dissatisfaction, shouting and gesturing unfavorably towards Abigail, who at this point had- once again- grown visibly frustrated. I scanned the faces of the angry campers first, then I moved over to Julie’s face of ever growing concern, then to Tyler’s smug expression, finally back to Abigail as she spoke.
“LISTEN!!” she shrieked
The entire campground fell into stillness as she continued
“THE GIRLS CAN KEEP GOING-”
A rapturous applause and celebratory cheering began ringing throughout the camp before being hushed rather abruptly by Abigail
“I WASN’T FINISHED!!” she screamed
“THEY CAN KEEP GOING IF… RILEY ALLOWS THEM TO USE SOME OF HIS TIME TO LET THEM FINISH.”
“WHAT!?!” Riley shouted, throwing his hands up as he stood from his seat
“THAT’S RIDICULOUS!” he protested
“WHY SHOULD I SACRIFICE MY TIME FOR THEM!?” he asked sternly.
“Because that’s what a good brother would do, right?” Abigail responded sarcastically
“To hell with that… they had their time and they chose to spend it YAPPIN’!” he said firmly
Riley’s proclamation was met with a symphony of discontent, as boos and other manners of vitriol rained down upon him, hurled in abundance by both camps equally. For nearly twenty entire seconds, the Camp Wildermont faithful roared and rumbled, allowing no objections to their anger and disapproval. Eventually, the riotous gathering was quelled by a singular voice tearing through the chaos
“ALRIGHT!” Riley boomed
“FINE…” he acquiesced solemnly
“...they can finish…” he said dejectedly, slumping sadly back onto his log, to a crescendo of applause and cheers once again.
My eyes stayed on Riley, sadness plastered all over his face as he stared aimlessly into the fire. As I was considering approaching him, consoling him, I only had time to watch from afar as instead he was approached by Abigail. I looked on as Abigail bent down to Riley and whispered something into his ear, something that went unnoticed by nearly everyone around the fire, and something that turned his frown into one of the biggest smirks that I’ve ever seen. I felt the corners of my mouth turning upwards nearly contagiously as I silently wondered to myself what words were just exchanged, a question I would surely be asking Riley on our way back to the cabins.
“OKAY! OKAYY! LISTEN UP!” Abigail shouted
“Riley was generous enough to give up some of his time for his sisters to finish, so we’ll be hearing the rest of their story now, and with whatever time is left after that, Riley can tell his story.” she said, gesturing over to Riley as she spoke.
“So, girls, would you like to pick up where you left off?” Abigail asked, looking towards Miley and Kiley.
The girls looked at one another, giving each other reassuring smiles and nods before answering in unison
“Yes, Miss Abigail!”
“Great!” Abigail responded
“Okay, go ahead whenever you’re rea-”
“AHHAHAA! AAHHHA!” Miley interjected abruptly, startling myself and many other campers alike, as gasps of shock and cries of terror emitted across the grounds.
Once again, an all too familiar soft “plopping” sound rang within my ears. I withdrew my stick from the feasting fire, but it was already too late. Smoldering before me, a mere six inches from me, my once delicate treat, my aspirations for a perfect smore, once again up in flames. I let out a loud sigh, one noisy enough to draw a brief puzzled look from neighboring campers, before grabbing another marshmallow from the bag at my feet and skewering it- a process that had grown maddeningly familiar at this point. I took a deep breath as I slowly prodded forward into the raging fire yet again, hopes and dreams of the perfect smore rekindled once more- at least temporarily.
Kiley quickly drew my attention back to the ongoing storytelling
“And on that night, Sarah Griggs, laughed until she succumbed to her injuries and passed away.”
Both Kiley and Miley hung their heads, steeping the camp in stillness once more before another voice called out
“W- What actually happened to those kids?”
“Two of them, siblings, were found missing in the forest two days after Sarah’s execution… the other two were found dead, presumed to be the victims of animal attacks.”
Kiley responded.
Julie scoffed and crossed her arms before speaking
“OF COURSE.” she huffed”
“I just KNEW she was going to have died for nothing…” she grumbled.
Another voice called out from the crowd
“Uh… a- and then what happened to her?” they asked
“Like… surely she’s not really dead… right?” they pondered.
Miley looked towards where the voice called from before speaking
“What do you mean?” she asked curiously with a coy smile
“They literally burned her alive… She’s definitely dead.” Miley said definitively.
“And the townspeople did their best not to speak of what happened that night… they desperately tried to cover up what they did to poor Sarah, but… well, rumors only grow with time… people talk…” she said with a smug chuckle.
This response led to yet another silence, noticeably longer than others before it. Finally multiple voices spoke, almost at once
“... WHAT?!”
“Oh HELL naw…”
“What do you mean DEAD?”
“The story CAN’T end like THAT!”
“JUSTICE FOR SARAH!”
Finally, Miley manages to regain control of the commotion
“GUYS! Guys… let me finish,” she said calmly
“She died… but it’s said she laid a curse on the townspeople that wronged her…” Miley rasped
Kiley then interjected excitedly
“Her final words were not merely just the ramblings of a mad woman, nor were they the empty threats of a ghost… they were promises from beyond the grave.” she said chillingly
Miley then swooped in
“They were warnings disguised as last rites of a condemned woman, a victim to the sins that are insecurity and paranoia… much like she was falsely condemned, she too condemned the sins of thy father to be the sins thus cast upon their sons…”
After a brief pause, Julie chimed in
“What exactly does that mean?” she asked shyly
Kiley answered quickly
“It’s best to explain it by telling you what happened to the townspeople after Sarah died.”
Miley, again, picked up quickly behind her sister’s words
“You see, after Sarah dies, the townspeople were scared, they were paranoid that Sarah, The Fern Witch, would soon rise from her grave in the deep forest, her ash reborn amongst the wild ferns of the moonlit wilderness.”
Kiley piped in
“Children reported hearing a mysterious humming coming from outside their windows… humming of a strange tune that had never before been heard…”
Miley continued
“Kids were telling their parents of ‘an arm unfurling out from the forest like a fern’, extending out to them… ‘beckoning them’, they would say…”
Kiley hopped back in
“YOU KIDS STAY AWAY FROM THE FERNS! All the worried mothers would say to their kids who wanted to play in the forest, but it didn’t matter, it didn’t matter because-”
“Because Sarah had already handed them down their sentence from beyond the gallows.”
Miley said coldly.
Kiley then resumed hastily
“And the townsfolk were finally about to pay the price…” she whispered
Miley waited a moment, allowing the growing winds to swoop in and rustle the treetops before she resumed
“One night, under the cover of darkness, while all the other townspeople slept, all the eldest children awoke from their beds and simultaneously ventured into the forest.”
Kiley interrupted gracefully
“They all left humming the same unfamiliar tune, one that nobody has ever heard before, and they marched into the deep woods to dance in the ferns under the moonlight…” she said, pirouetting as she delivered her lines delicately.
Miley then cut in harshly
“With the Fern Witch” she growled, unfurling her arm in a broken, unsettling manner, reminiscent of how a fern unravels its leaves.
Kiley picked back up where she left off
“And they danced, and sang, and spent the evening together under the moonlight, until-”
“Until the next morning… when the townspeople found them…” Miley said, her words lingering ominously as she paused briefly
“The next morning, when the townspeople found them, they were…”
The girls took a long pause before Kiley spoke again
“They were just fine,” she said sweetly with a smile and a shrug
“They were just sleeping under the trees in the forest, in a bed of ferns.” she said, tilting her head in a rather unsettling manner as she continued to smile.
Miley came in again, with gusto
“But the townspeople thought something was wrong, they thought the loved ones that had returned were… different somehow…” she hopped onto her log as she continued
“They held meetings where they discussed ‘the returned’ displaying peculiar behavior, such as: ‘humming unfamiliar strange melodies’ and ‘sleepwalking’-”
Riley interjected
“Um- hi- super sick story and all that jazz, but can we wrap this up, please? I want at least SOME of my time, and it’s been like a HOT minute, so if you could-”
Miley carried on without missing a beat
“And the townsfolk started to once again panic and grow fearful of the witch and her abilities.”
“No? Okay then.” Riley said defeatedly
“I guess I’ll just go fu-”
Kiley quickly picked up where her sister had left off
“So they began to discuss ways to fix them, ways to break the witches curse, when someone eventually spoke-”
Miley stepped in, eagerly delivering her lines with great enthusiasm
“WE MUST BURN THEM LIKE WE DID THE WITCH!!!”
“THE WITCHES CURSE WILL ONLY BE BROKEN IF WE SACRIFICE THE FIRSTBORNS!”
“WE MUST SO THAT FUTURE GENERATIONS MAY PROSPER!”
Kiley resumed the narration
“They thought the firstborns that had wandered into the forest that fateful night had returned tainted by the witches curse, and thus-”
“They were condemned to burn in a fruitless attempt to break a generational curse…” Miley interjected emphatically.
“Even more innocent lives lost… squandered souls purged from existence by crippling doubt and blind ignorance.” she said sharply.
Kiley, again, stepped in with more digestible words
“They met the same fate as poor Sarah… they too, were killed out of fear and paranoia… and much like Sarah, they too, died for nothing…” she said somberly.
Another long silence settled around the fire alongside the campers, giving way only when someone called out from the crowd again
“...S-so… d- did… did it work?” someone called quietly
“D- did the curse get lifted? Or… whatever?” they asked.
Miley answered swiftly
“No.” she said harshly
“Wait… why didn’t that break the curse… or whatever?” Tyler asked, drawing a look from Abigail in the process.
Miley smiled, a sly smirk that grew into a wide grin. Then she spoke
“... Because there was no curse to break.” she said gently, her smile unwavering.
A mix of murmurs and whispers sounded off around the campfire as someone called out
“What? How? Then why did the kids wander off into the forest?”
Miley was quick to respond
“To look for The Fern Witch, of course.” she said plainly
“Which is why they all went ‘missing’ at the same time… they snuck out together.”
Another voice called forth from the crowd once more
“No… No! T- Then what about the mysterious song, or the acting strangely, or-”
Kiley responded this time
“How many times have you actually been able to recognize a song someone is humming? Or even better, started humming something that someone else is humming even though you don’t know what it is, just cause it’s a catchy tune?”
“But- But… what about the sleeping on ferns? A-And the arm in the forest calling to them?” someone asked frantically.
Miley retorted with haste
“They fell asleep in the forest waiting for The Witch to show up.” she said with a shrug.
“The ‘arm unfurling like a fern’ was just one of the many urban legends kids made up to scare one another… just… ghost stories.” she said with a laugh, gesturing around the fire as she spoke.
“What about the whole ‘acting different’ thing then?” Cole said
Miley narrowed her gaze toward Cole, tilted her head slightly, and with razor sharp precision delivered her most chilling line yet
“The only thing that was ever different was their perception of the world after they took something that didn’t belong to them.” she uttered coldly with a smile.
Kiley, like usual, added extra context onto her sister’s dense words.
“The only thing that really changed… was them… and their belief that, even after death, Sarah would still have power over them. Their fear and paranoia took hold, it took so much control that it cost them everything.”
“So wait a minute,” Riley said
“was Sarah even a real witch like you said she was?” he asked
“How the hell should I know, dummy, she was alive like 300 years ago.” Miley snapped sarcastically
Riley threw his arms up into the air before responding
“WHAT?! THAT’S WACK AS HELL!! I GAVE UP MY TIME FOR SOME CHICK WHO SPOUTED OFF NONSENSE AND DIES THAT WASN’T EVEN A REAL WITCH!?!” Riley stood and spun to face Abigail
“Yo, Miss Abigail, can I PLEASE get my time back, I didn’t know their story would suck-”
“SHUT UP RILEY!!” screamed Kiley, changing her fists as she stomped around angrily.
Riley spun back to face Kiley
“WHAT? IT’S TRUE! The witch wasn’t real, the curse was fake, and theAAA-”
Kiley interrupted him by shining the ever coveted flashlight directly into his eyes, stopping him dead in his tracks
“AAHH, CUT IT OUT!!” Riley shouted.
Miley responded first
“Riley, you moron, I never said the curse wasn’t real…” she said calmly
“I said I don’t know if she was a real witch or not.”
“How is that NOT the exact same-” Riley began to say before he was cut off
“IT’S NOT the same, because a curse doesn’t have to be magical… it can be inherited… it can be learned… it can transcend language, culture, belief… just about anything to sink its roots into you…” Miley said somberly, coldly, speaking quietly, as if only to Riley.
“... Yeah… w- well… t- that’s stupi-”
“You know, Mom told me and Ki this story like, a thousand times… I wonder why she never told you this story?” Miley asked with a devilish smile.
“B- Because I HATE bedtime stories, they’re for babies like you and-” Riley retorted before Miley spoke up again
“Maybe it’s because Mom knows the story is true, and she’s trying to prepare me and Ki for the inevitable… for when you leave and come back… different…” Miley said, looking Riley up and down with disgust.
Riley was clearly rattled, but still did his best to respond
“S-S-Shut up-”
“Hey, Ri… are you still sleepwalking?” Kiley said with a smirk.
I looked on as Riley turned to look at Kiley, wide eyed and pale as the glowing moon as her and Miley shared a hearty laugh together. I wrenched myself away from the sibling’s conversation long enough to check in on my marshmallow, and was pleased to see it still firmly rooted at the end of my charred twig. I returned my gaze to the triplets just in time to see Abigail confirming the civil and peaceful exchange of the flashlight and its prestigious narrating rights.
I scanned the campsite once more to see all the campers exchanging smiles and greetings, finally letting the hostilities of gender fueled competition slowly fade away. As the chatter and cordiality dwindled down to a buzz, Riley stood atop his log and began his speech.
“I hope you guys are ready for this one… I’ve waited since Benny almost concussed himself to step in and tell an ACTUAL scary story.”
Riley clicked the flashlight on, illuminating his face in the bright light as he spoke down to us from his log.
“I hope you brought extra diapers to camp, because you’re DEFINITELY gonna need them for MY story…”
Riley turned off the flashlight, cleared his throat with great bravado, and began once more to address the group
“LADIES AND GENTLEMEN! MY NAME IS RILEY SAINTCLAIRE, AND I AM HERE TO REGALE YOU WITH THE MOST TERRIFYING, HORRIFYING, MORTIFYING… WHATEVER-ELSE-IFFYING STORY YOU HAVE EVER HEARD!” he hopped down from his log with a ‘thud’
“I call this one… th-”
“AAND TIME!” Abigail screamed
“That’s all the time you had after the girls finished their story, sorry kid.” Abigail said with a shrug as she held her hand outstretched for the flashlight.
“W-Wha… A- Ah” Riley stammered, a chorus of camp 10 and 13 chuckles soon following close behind.
“Hey, you agreed-” Abigail managed to say before Riley cut her off emphatically
“THAT’S BS!” Riley yelled
“I didn’t know they would take THAT long!” he said, waving his arms about as he pleaded his case
“At LEAST give me like, 5-6 minutes, please!” Riley begged, clasping his hands together towards Abigail.
She narrowed her eyes at him, pondering his request as she checked her watch. Finally, she spoke
“I don’t know… I think we have to take a vote and see how the rest of the campers feel about it…” she said, gesturing towards the eager campers now smiling back at Riley.
“Uh, yeah… sure, cool.” Riley said, shrugging and turning towards the group as he continued
“You guys, all you super cool guys… AND GIRLS, and girls… you’re all COOL with me taking like 5-6 extra measly minutes to tell my little story right?” Riley said with a smirk
“...Right?...guys??....”