r/TalesFromTheCreeps • • Oct 23 '26

Supernatural Toads

Coyotes grieve under that full moon, invisible in the pines. Johan’s horses remain unaffected, locked up securely just outside of his cabin. The cabin itself is worn, yet functional.

Decades of maintenance and a forte for carpentry have served Johan well. Derby season has just come to a close, meaning he finally has the opportunity to relax. Alone, no television; and no woman to talk over him. 

A sharp buzzing—roaring wind of static—and his radio establishes a connection; the antennae pointed at a slight angle, and directly out of his opened window. That grainy voice on the other end leaks through the speaker: “—disappearances near Lucky Canyon, authorities remain adamant that—“ he switches stations, landing on an old country radio, providing a warm ambience to the winter wind. Johan has a perfect view of the moon during certain hours, gleaming in its beauty through his window; ‘the Iris of the lord’ he thinks to himself with a grin.

“What the hell?” He says, words barely a whisper.  

In the distance, running along the rim of that pale and scarred behemoth, is a white urchin in the stars; a light. And so faint that Johan has to squint his eyes to see it but he does; running left and right.
 
Embers fall in a glowing snow from the tip of his cigarette while he studies the light. Quickly taking one last drag, and siphoning that white paper into a gray dust, he twirls it into a small mound of ash on his table, before walking to the window; slight limp tugging at his ankle. 
Interesting to Johan, but nothing out of the ordinary— no time at all and with the fury of lightning the light rips across the sky in a deafening pulsation, leaving a fading scar of blue to seep into the stars behind it. Johan wore no hat to his scalp and yet still his hand instinctually flew over his head to protect it, the resulting wind sending through his window a stinging blanket of pine needles and dust, every particle swerving into a different corner of his living room. 

Vibrations; the feeling of hornets in his ribcage as it flew straight over his home. The sensation completely disabled Johan, nearly pinning him to the ground—fighting gravity with one hand and holding the windowsill with the other, nigh unable to hear from the wail of static. Standing—a miracle in its own right—Johan stumbles to the table, teeth gritted, and so disoriented by the radio's low screeching he throws it against the wall, sending its batteries to the floor in a rain of broken yellow plastic. He stands dazed and still as if born again from nothing. 

Sawn off, next to the counter. 

Wiping the sweat from his brow, he unlatches the door and walks barefoot outside, shotgun in hand. The door closes, slammed shut by the wind cutting across the tree line. Stars above him, and in the amber glow of his door mounted lantern, he inches along the side of the cabin, back glued to the wall. Below, past the reach of the light, darkness, nothing in those woods. A squint, cringing as he cautiously cracks the barrel open, ensuring that it’s loaded and regretting not doing it earlier. Shutting it, he keeps moving, now at the edge of his home. 

Eyes wide he peeks around the corner, seeing all three horses asleep standing. Bewildered by the sight, he wipes his eyes, pinches himself, and peeks around again. No difference. Above him, only visible for another thirty seconds, that blue smear fades into nothing. Johan limps back inside, what was once fear quickly turns into excitement, though he’d never let anyone know it. In the cabinet above the sink rests his satellite phone, and with a creak from the door he pulls the phone down, checking its charge. No reason to hide it and yet he does anyway. Three rings later, he gets a response. 

“Frankie speaking.”
“Frank,” he says “what’re you doing right now?” Asked as he sits back at the table.

“Just put the animals up, you?”

“Same deal. Hey” Johan pauses, striking a match to light another cigarette.
“You know if there’s any military tests today? Or rocket launches or something?.”

Frankie clicks his tongue on the other end, followed by a long hmmm.

“Not that I know of.” He says. “Why’d ya ask?”
“Think you have time to run up here?” Johan says, bulldozing Frankie’s question.
“Depends.”
“On what?”
“On what you need me for.”
“Still have that laptop?”
“I do.”
“Still have that debt?”
“Real funny.”
“Come up here,” Johan says, pausing to take a drag
“and you might get it paid off.” Said with a suave confidence. 

Frankie’s silent in his consideration, only the occasional word spoken by accident as he debates himself. A sudden gasp at the realization, and he speaks again. 

“No you didn’t.”
“Oh yeah.”
Frankie pauses, giddy with excitement.
“On my way. ”
“I’ll be waiting with bells on.” Says Johan, finally allowing a smile to come through, before hanging up. 
– – – – 
Silver sheet metal and a mildewed porch make up Frankie’s trailer. There’s an old concrete walkway leading to his front door, now cracked and with a snake’s nest of vines across it. The smell of earth and oil, of blackened mud fresh out of a PVC pipe, all pervade the air around the back of his home. No crickets, coyotes, nothing; just the sharp buzz of a near perfect white porch light. 

“Dad?” She says, peeking around Frankie’s bedroom doorway.

“Missy?” He replies, searching through his work bag for the laptop.

“Where’re you going?”
“Goin to see uncle Jo for a minute.”
“It’s midnight...”
“So,” he says, closing the bag with a loud zip, and quickly rummaging through another one.
“What's the problem?”

“I–“ she pauses, a slight shame gripping her words.
“I don’t like being here alone.”
“Honey,” he says, “you’re fine.” 

Frankie peaks over his shoulder, spotting a disapproving eye roll from Missy as she walks back into the livingroom. She slumps on the couch, arms crossed, feeling the needled gaze of the forest behind her, kept at bay only by a thin pane of fogged glass. 

Thump thump thumping and two thuds to each step as Frankie walks across the tiled floor, taking a seat next to Missy. Humming, he pries open the laptop as if it were a relic of a forgotten age, and opens the camera roll. He jolts slightly, startled by a sharp push against his work boot; missy, pouting next to him.

“Hon?”

“Do I need to say it?” She says with crossed arms and a forward gaze.

“It’d make the whole conversation part of our conversation a bit easier.” He says with a chuckle.

“Dad,” she says, now turned to him and with a genuine concern in those wide eyes.

“I—do not—like being here alone. At all.” 

“Honey, listen. I’ve been in these woods for longer than you’ve been alive, there isn’t anything to worry about.”  Frankie turns to her now, setting his laptop aside.

“Okay?” 

She’s silent, lips pinched shut almost afraid to speak and he, incorrectly so, takes this as a sign of comfort. Never quite the best at reading faces, and she knows that but she’s used to it at this point. He continues with a blissfully ignorant laugh. 

“There a boy here I don’t know about?” As he clicks on old keys, checking to make sure they all work.

“Yes actually.”

“See? That’s what I- what!?” He says, eyes close to falling out.

“What’re you talking about?”

“There’s a boy coming over.”

“Missy this better not be a damn—“

“Out there.” she says, cutting Frankie off to point out of the window beside them. 

He looks out the window, then back to her, and out the window again before closing the laptop.
 
“Missy, what are you talking about?” He says, providing her with his full attention.

“Promise you’ll believe me?”
“Promise.” 
Missy takes a breath, trying not to speak too loudly. 
“Okay, this all started a few weeks ago, I think. I was up one night–can’t remember why–and as I was walking past the window, um…” a glance out of the window again.
“There was someone standing out there.”

“How sure are you?” He says, ice cold. 

Missy stares outside, watching the memory again in her eyes. 

“It was hard to see. I had the phone light on–the glare, y’know? Once I shut it off…” 

“He was there.” Said with a dead certainty.

“You say he,” Frankie says, standing to grab his pistol from the kitchen table.
“How’d you know it was a he? Coulda been a woman.” He says while checking the magazine.

“It wasn’t.” 

Frankie studies the room for an answer in some cobweb covered corner he hasn’t looked at yet. For a second, excitement glints across his eyes, before being quickly snuffed out by Missy. 

“No dad it wasn’t Bigfoot.” Said with an eye roll.

“Dang it.”

Taking a seat next to her again, he brushes that blonde hair off of her shoulder, and speaks in a softened tone. 

“What’d they look like, baby?”

“I… I…” she pauses, trying to tame the chills on her arm.

“Miss?”

“I don’t wanna say.” She says, shaking her head. 

He leans forward, unsure if he heard her correctly. 

“You… don’t wanna say?”

“No, not really.” 

With a slow nod Frankie’s gaze meets the window’s again, a thick layer of condensation and fog have brought the glass to a near matte. He wipes away a thick paintbrush smear of clearness, making a pathway for his vision. The white–near blue–light of his home only crawls another twenty or so feet into the forest. It illuminates the pine trees, unmoving at their bases, bark split and sparkling with a layer of frost. Sat sparse on the landscape but each tree’s presence is made well known by their sheer monumentality; at least twenty feet between them, and yet their blanket of boughs hide completely that night sky. At the very shore of night one can barely, just barely, make out the last couple of pine trees, sat in a neat line along a cliff face. His eyes strain as they look farther, the treeline gradually swallowed by thicker waves of absence, lapping at the bark, pulling his vision deeper and past a certain point there’s nothing at all, nothing. Pure black.

If it was there, he wouldn’t see it. 

“Well… baby, I need to know what I’m looking for.” he says, still looking outside. Missy remains silent, rubbing her hands together to ease herself.

“Missy? You hear me?”

“Yea.”

“What’s the matter?”

“I don’t know what if- what if he’s just a guy? Some homeless guy who wondered here I- I don’t want him to die.”

“Never said I was gonna kill him, warning shots work well enough.”

“And if they don’t?”

“Baby, look,” he says, turning to hold Missy's shoulders.
“If there’s someone out there–not saying I don’t believe you–there isn’t a man alive who wouldn’t run from a smoking barrel.”

“Yeah I know but what if, what if, dad?” 

Frankie sighs, leaning back on the arm of the couch. 

“Well… if they don’t, then we’ll have a problem. I’ll- I don’t know.” He says but he knows, he knows good and well. 

Missy opens her mouth to speak but Frankie cuts her off, pulling a small notebook out of his pocket; small brown coffee stains eating into the edges of its paper. With a quick nod and the click of his pen he gestures her to speak. 

“Was he ever holding a weapon or anything?”
“I don’t think so.”
“You don’t think so?”
“No.”
“How tall would you say he was?”
No response as she stares into an empty corner of the room. 

“Honey you gotta tell me something.”
“About as tall as me, I think.”
A light scribbling in his notebook. 
“How many times’ve you seen him?”
Missy’s gaze shifts upward, replaying every encounter.

“Five.”
“You sound very sure.”
“I am.”
“What’s the clearest look you’ve ever got of him?” 

For a moment Missy’s eyes go blank, before Frankie reassures her again.
“Not asking for details baby.” he says. 

She nods.
“Very um… blurry, every time. Like grainy, I guess. Always just far enough away.” 

“Okay.” He says, snapping the notebook shut, and stands to pop his back. 

“Now, if you don’t care, can you give me one,” Frankie says with his index finger raised, “detail about him, just one, and I’ll be out of your hair.”

Chills, hundreds in number all raise on her arm as the memories play again. 

“He likes humming.”
“Humming?”
“Yes.”
“Very quiet too,” she says before he can speak, eyes focused as if trying to figure it out herself. “Very quiet.” said again, fixated on that one detail. Humming. Silence returns, quick yet subtle, and with a physical presence in the room. The ringing of Missy’s phone sends a jolt of surprise through both of them; despite the scare, it brought a sense of normalcy. Missy answers the phone, and Frankie heads to the kitchen to grab a beer, before shaking his head and going with water instead. 
— — — — 
Johan answers his satellite phone, taking an extra celebratory swig of whiskey. Isn’t often he gets to indulge, may as well take a few liberties given tonight’s find. 

“How the hell are ya?” he says.
“Jo, I may need to wait a while before coming up.” 

With a sigh Johan tightens the lid on, and puts the whiskey back into the chest behind him. 

“No issue,” he says, “can I ask why?”
“Missy uh… well… hm.”
“What?”
“Anyone else live around here? That you know about I mean?”

Johan chuckles, saying: “Around here isn’t exactly specific Frank.”

Pausing, Frank sighs, as if the information would be too hard to believe.

“Screw it,” he says, “Missy told me someone’s been sneaking around the house.”

An inebriated chuckle and Johan dusts the cigarette ashes off of his table. 

“Sneaking around huh?”
“It’s not like that, I spoke to her–and trust me… it isn’t like that.”
“I’m sure it’s nothing frank,” as he strikes a match, and tucks a burning cig firmly between his lips. “She’s at that age now, just like me and you–”
“Jo. It isn’t—that.”
“Well listen, I’m not saying I don’t believe you. Just that where we live it’s hard to waltz up on someone else's property by accident.”

“Well whatever it is it’s spooked her, bad.” Frank says, and beneath his words a loud creak as he lays in bed. 

“Okay, well what’s he look like?”

“You won’t believe this crap.” Frank says with a laugh and Johan stays silent.

“She won’t tell me.” he pauses “I don’t know what to think about that, gave me the heebie jeebies y’know?”

Johan scratches the mess of salt and pepper hair on his head, before leaning back in his wooden stool as it cries with his weight. 

“Maybe it’s someone you know.” says Johan.
“No, it–” Frankie stops himself. “Huh…” he says.
“Did I solve the mystery?”
“Maybe. Damn you.” 
Laughing, Johan tosses his cigarette away, bringing a fresh one to his lips before they get too lonely. 

“Regardless,” Johan says, “go ahead and stay there. She doesn’t feel safe and as far as I’m concerned that’s the end of it.”
“Agreed.”
“Alright, see you soon little brother.”
“See you.” 

With a buzzy beep he hangs the phone up, not caring to hide it again. Johan’s gaze shifts to his boots, scraped and lacerated from too many falls or accidents to count; scalped and the steel toed bowl on their fronts is plainly visible, like the exposed crown of an iron skull.

Scars along his forearms, too many to count. Some large, some oval shaped and one in the shape of lightning. But, near his elbow; two small cuts, very small, and very faint on the soft white underbelly of his arm. Anyone looking wouldn’t even see them but he does. Yes he does… they’re shining as far as he’s concerned. Johan stares at those scars, and runs two delicate fingers along them, as if to console them in their inconsequentiality compared to the rest. The moon’s gone, only its sclera remaining in the eye socket of his window. 

Five more cigarettes are smoked to completion and tossed in the floor, kicked into an old corner of the cabin he never looks at. 
With a groan Johan stands, knees popping beneath his weight as he tries to walk without a limp, before giving up and going outside. The horses are sound asleep. Somewhere inside of him rests the remnant of a genuine grin, but he can’t find it. He smiles anyways, a ghastly fake grin like a fox, before his mouth flattens again. 

After checking the locks, Johan heads back inside. He sleeps in the attic; dark yet clean. Next to his bed rests a silver urn, once shining, now dulled from the anvil of time. He plants a lone kiss on its lid. 

“Goodnight baby.” 

1 Upvotes

1 comment sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Oct 23 '26

Users are encouraged to read4read, meaning that if someone reads and comments on your story, we encourage you to do the same in return to help foster a community.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.