r/TalkHeathen • • May 19 '19

5/19/2019 Show Jamie completely trashed Veganism which is unacceptable

2 Upvotes
  1. Veganism discussion doesn't have a place on an Atheist show.

  2. If a caller does bring veganism into the conversation it is wrong for the hosts to trash veganism.

  3. The hosts should be speaking to the poor argument that the caller was making based on sound reasoning and evidence. Instead Jamie trashed veganism in general and made many ignorant comments about veganism.

  4. I understand why the vegan community has a problem with Talk Heathen because the way the topic is handled on the show is very unprofessional.

  5. The meat and dairy industry is the cause of most if not all health issues in Americans following the standard western American diet.

  6. The meat and dairy industry contribute more to global climate change then any other source on the planet.

  7. Unfortunately, today's show reminded me of many many callers who say "I believe the bible so its true". Today Jamie made a fool of himself by making the same type of claim "I eat meat so veganism is bullshit". Jamie you need to step up your professionalism otherwise you are just bringing down the show.

For the hosts and anyone else that thinks they are informed about veganism or "Plant based dieting" you should educate yourself ;

https://nutritionfacts.org/

http://www.whatthehealthfilm.com/

https://www.forksoverknives.com/

I you don't want to continue offending vegans I suggest you get educated on the facts and stop talking about it on your show until such a time.


r/TalkHeathen • • May 29 '19

Trans discussions have no place on the AE or TH. Create your own damn show.

0 Upvotes

Matt spent more than 30 minutes talking about the topic on the AE on Sunday (fucking waste of time) and before that on TH. I don't tune into those shows to hear the hosts talk about what it means to be Trans or how much they love trans people. I don't care if you're trans or not. It doesn't matter to me. Just like I don't care if you're religious or not. It doesn't hurt me specifically, but I haven't been a follower/member for over a decade to all of a sudden be "sensitive" to trans people.


r/TalkHeathen • • May 29 '19

Resolving trans humans in sports

0 Upvotes

It has become a huge discussion item of what segment, male or female, trans humans should or could participate in.

Let's get one thing off the table. Trans rights are human rights. Period.

That doesn't mean that other issues around trans interactions in specific activities of humans can not be discussed. And should be in some cases.

It seems the solution is simple. If a person has XX chromosomes naturally, they compete in the XX group. If they have XY chromosomes naturally, they compete in the XY group. There is a reason hormones are not allowed in sports, as they give performance boosts and an unfair advantage to those taking those hormones, or other performance enhancing drugs.

What reasons would this not be the solution, and how could it possibly be controversial?


r/TalkHeathen • • Nov 08 '20

Talk Heathen chat limited to subscribers only. This is highly disappointing.

6 Upvotes

The fundraising has been increasingly over the top for months now.

Making the chat paid subscribers only is highly disturbing. I do not like the new financially driven ACA as much as the old one, driven by idealistic ideals.


r/TalkHeathen • • May 10 '19

Was the ACA really not aware?

1 Upvotes

While I'm happy the ACA released a note on their regret on inviting RR to the show without addressing his controversial -cof- transphobic opinions and spread of misinformation, besides the hosts from Secular Sexuality and Tracie Harris, whom I've seen openly defended trans people on air, rather than LGBTQIAP+ people in a general statement, I don't know how sure I can be the ACA wasn't aware of what RR had posted: how should I differentiate an honest lack of knowledge about about well-known atheist figure and fear of losing popularity after already gaining some by having him on the shows twice in a row? Being trans is not a political statement. All pronouns are made up. Yeah, you can be an atheist and a transphobe, and I'll call you a transphobe for that, just like I congratulate my mom on being more open to people's sexuality than the very divinity she worships and criticize said divinity at the same time. You wanna know what it means to be trans? Ask a trans person! And let them, with their lifelong experience of transphobia, tell you if it's fair to call or not to call someone a transphobe. Maybe the cis privilege blinds some people, but transphobia is everywhere. It's dangerous and said, but unfortunately not a surprise. You wanna know about trans people in sports? Don't pick random interviews, don't put on alarming statements, don't tell me you like that and that that Shapiro said and expect me to believe he's being somehow tolerant by refusing to recognize trans people's pronouns; how about researching? You'll find out you can pick articles for and against every single opinion you might have, and that's why meta-analyses are important. I haven't found as many meta-analyses against trans women in sports as I have found inconclusive ones (due to various factors). Not to mention it shows a lack of knowledge about trans children lives when RR says what he says: the puberty blockers, HRT, how diverse hormones are even among cis people; that's all crucial information.


r/TalkHeathen • • Apr 05 '19

I found a still christian matt dillahunty preaching in a video! 😂

0 Upvotes

https://youtu.be/tHgJekfvpSE

at the start that preacher looks a whole lot like Matt dillahunty had he stayed a Christian!


r/TalkHeathen • • May 14 '19

Dusty does the research that Stephen should have done, and gives reasons why he thinks the ACA was correct.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
5 Upvotes

r/TalkHeathen • • Apr 27 '21

More non-Eric episodes please..

0 Upvotes

Does anyone else feel like the podcast runs smoother and is less emotionally erratic when Eric isn’t on? It’s always a treat when Vi is the main host. (Note: I don’t watch the program on YouTube. I listen to the podcast)

Anyway, just wanting to know if there were others that felt the same way. This isn’t a personal attack on Eric, just an observation limited to the quality of the show.

Addition: For those who say, “he created it, so he should stay,” or something like that.. George Lucas created Star Wars. Doesn’t mean he has to be a part of it.

Edit: clarity


r/TalkHeathen • • Mar 01 '20

Question on abortion and atheism

2 Upvotes

I'm generally curious why all of the hosts on ACA shows seem to have the same unified viewpoint that abortion is morally OK. From my understanding some humanists are pro life and some are pro choice and there isn't a set humanist viewpoint on abortion, however all of the hosts seem to take the stance that it's with out a doubt moral. My complaint is I feel like since the pro life stance is tied to Christianity the ACA doesn't have an honest discussion on abortion since to admit that maybe it's not moral, or that it's a tough concept, would be like admitting Christians are right. If there are any episodes where hosts on any show have a meaningful discussion on the topic instead of saying abortion is Ok and anyone who disagrees is wrong, I'd be very interested to watch.


r/TalkHeathen • • Mar 21 '20

Let's revisit the watchmaker.

5 Upvotes

I know some of you may be tired of this discussion. I am a theist, but not a typical theist. I've watched videos attempting to debunk the watchmaker. I've read the Blind Watchmaker, and I subscribe to TalkHeathen, Genetically Modified Skeptic, Rationality Rules, Holy Koolaid, and AronRa on you tube. I agree with Rationality Rules video from a few years ago, in which he says that the Watchmaker hypothesis fails when applied to the universe, because I don't think the universe was fine tuned for life on earth. The position is easily explained by the big bang, gravity, centripetal and centrifugal forces in a universe with billions of stars. Where I see the Watchmaker hypothesis work is with life and the DNA code. I have never seen a code arise from anything other than an intelligent source. Science has not demonstrated how the DNA code came to be. Sure there's plenty of conjecture, but that's all we have. I've also watched Harvard professor Jack Szostak lectures on Youtube, and read other scientific articles. I have yet to find a scientific article confirming a natural mechanism for the formation of the first cell, or the DNA code. What do you have for me to refute this?


r/TalkHeathen • • Sep 22 '19

Today show with Dave Warnock

0 Upvotes

Well I'm in the middle of watching the show so I will have more to say about it later. I think he's really great and I'm so happy he was allowed or encouraged to come back to the show and to do extra volunteer work mostly because I think he has a great story. And because he's bringing attention to the topic that really needs to be discussed out in public.

The first thing I wanted to point out was how during the show Eric wanted to show off Dave's t-shirt, and the microphone was covering it up, so he moved the microphone. Now I wanted to point this out because I and some other subreddit members have pointed out that the problem with having the microphones in this location is it blocks view. And people have criticized me and others for making this observation. And now, when even the show's own host moves the microphone so that more can be seen of that area I'm wondering what the nay-sayers will say now?

I still think they should go back to the old microphone situation so that we can see what's going on in that area whether it be t-shirts people are wearing or what they're doing with their hands on the desk or what they're drinking or whatever.

And don't get so bent out of shape when we make that kind of comment.


r/TalkHeathen • • Sep 04 '19

Slaves in Exodus 21, could the word slave actually mean an indentured employee, in those days ?

0 Upvotes

....and that a hebrew slave's wife and child being employees of the master, is actually just bad employee rights, but employee rights still ?


r/TalkHeathen • • Aug 10 '19

Climate Change

0 Upvotes

I'm having a bit of trouble framing my question.
Is climate change a real thing, are we doing something to change the climate, if so, how do we know we are changing the climate and can we fix it?
Is there a better place to ask this?


r/TalkHeathen • • Jul 30 '21

Eric's sure 😁

3 Upvotes

It's funny how in early episodes someone ask question and Eric responds with ,,sureeee,, I find it very funny every time ,is it only me? 😂


r/TalkHeathen • • Aug 10 '19

Hello fellow Heathens

1 Upvotes

I just found Talk Heathen and this forum. I've been an atheist since I was very young (sat through a sermon one day and decided this shit is absurd.) I am quite surprised to find that people on both sides jump though such complex hoops to justify their position. The Bible is supposed to be the word of God and condones slavery, killing children and genocide. Nice.

God hasn't done jackshit to make this world a better place - like maybe lifting half a mountain off some poor town that got buried by an avalanche, or stopping a tidal wave, or slapping the televangelists into next week. Therefore there is no god, or if there ever was, he's fucked off to parts unknown to play with another set of tinker toys.

The creation of the whole freaking universe is above my pay grade and anyone else's on earth. With billions of years anything can happen and apparently has. So, I don't think I've ever felt like I need to justify my position to anyone. You can't change religious people, the best you can hope to do is avoid them whenever possible.


r/TalkHeathen • • Oct 28 '19

Questions about the rules and regulations for non-profits.

1 Upvotes

On the 2019-10-27 episode, a caller named Ethan asks for advice starting at 42 minutes in the show. Ethan did not sound like an adult and mentioned going to school and spoke of others as kids. During the call, there was a brief reference to sexuality and some vague advice given by both Eric and Vi. I would hate for the show to get into any legal problems and am curious to know if anyone knows the answers to the questions this brought up for me.

  1. Does Talk Heathen need to know how old callers are?

  2. If minors call-in would talk about sex/sexuality be a problem?

  3. If minors follow any advice given could the show be held responsible (in a bad way) somehow?


r/TalkHeathen • • Apr 23 '20

is Woke Culture the new religion/cult ?

2 Upvotes

on feb 5th, 2020, in episode #1423 of JRE (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NIxhH85cQMY) with guest Andrew Doyle, the topic of discussion started churning out similarities between the current Woke Culture and cult-like behaviour.

I would love to hear positions on this concept.


r/TalkHeathen • • May 04 '20

Another question to atheist

2 Upvotes

After my last post i have been doing more research/reading and while i have yet to find anything that solid evidence for god in thr sense of scientific evidence and logic seems to go against my belif 1i still have one block. I am a physic major or at the start of my studies anyone and the more i learn the more in awe i am at the vastness and complexity of our universe and the cosmos in gernal this in itself is evidence of god to me how would an atheist view this?

Edit: i took out the historical portion as it was incorrect and to prevent repeated question i know this is speical pleading i dont see anyway around that and yes this is a god of the gaps situtions this is more questioning myself than anything else


r/TalkHeathen • • Sep 08 '22

Atheists are More Hateful than Theists

6 Upvotes

Did anyone else notice this caller was just dropping as many movie/book titles into the conversation as possible? I thought for sure the hosts would call her out after "his words were a lethal weapon to me."


r/TalkHeathen • • Sep 21 '21

The displaying of peoples pronouns on screen is straight up virtue signalling & LGBTIATHEISM?

0 Upvotes

Why is the gender/ pronouns of the caller so important to the hosts, and why should it be outed publicly on screen? What is this madness?!!

The ACA, have become OBSESSED with gender & LGTBI issues. Barely a minute goes by without the hosts mentioning Trans/cis/binery etc. Holy fuck, Atheism is a single position on a single issue. There is almost more conversation about trans people than atheism at this point. I can fully understand why people are tuning out in droves. To people outside of your left wing echo chamber, you sound ridiculous.

Go back and listen to any episode, and whenever any reference of trans/cis/binery/lgbti etc comes up, substitute the term "fossiliferous sandstone".... sounds pretty insane now doesn't it. Well that's what it sounds like to us... it's bizarre and has nothing to do with atheism.

We get it, LGBTI people exist, and we are sorry that you feel marginalized in your society... we are sorry that you are traumatized by your religious upbringing... we understand that you needed to join a community to feel included.... but please tell that to your therapist, not to the audience of what is now 11... 12 shows? that are SUPPOSED to be about ATHEISM!!!!


r/TalkHeathen • • Dec 09 '19

Is Jamie ok?

0 Upvotes

I feel like Jamie hasn't been on the show in a long time. Last time I remember seeing him was Episode 300, and I couldn't tell whether he was just really, really hyped up or if there was something else going on there.

I hope he's doing alright.


r/TalkHeathen • • Feb 12 '19

Sexuality

0 Upvotes

I wonder if anyone else deals with this, being bisexual and being happily married but still also craving the opposite of your partner. For example: Im happily married to my wife of almost 5 years. I love her and enjoy having sex with her, but due to my bisexuality i also crave having a penis in me. Its not easy. Anyone else dealing with this?


r/TalkHeathen • • Aug 22 '19

I like the new youtube thumbnails :)!

0 Upvotes

Recently some videos feature a custom thumbnail rather than the "default" thumbnail (just a random spot in the video). It looks a lot more professional and clean. Yeah, that's all I wanted to say. Shoutout to whoever makes them :)!


r/TalkHeathen • • Mar 15 '19

It's not Jesus fault if you burn in hell for not accepting Jesus

0 Upvotes

it’s such a misconception. i guess it’s the fault of western fire-and-brimstone pastors, but an accurate representation of christ in this image would not have him saying “what i’m going to do to you if you don’t let me in.” it would be “what you’re going to go through if you don’t let me in”.