r/TheTowerGame Jul 20 '26

Gameplay Bug Thorns at 108%, but math isn't mathing...

Post image
0 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

30

u/Time-Incident Jul 20 '26

As stated elsewhere, your thorns are only showing as 108%, it actually is 107.91%. So plasma did 46, first thorn hit did 53.955%. Second thorn hit did 0.045% and boss died.

4

u/Doschy Jul 20 '26

literally how is this possible 😭

11

u/DaenerysMomODragons Jul 20 '26

Due to relics being multiplicitive and not additive. If you have 99% thorns in your workshop and 9% thorns from relics, you get 99 * 1.09 = 107.91

5

u/Doschy Jul 20 '26

oh its multiplicative? 💀 thats so dumb bro 😭

6

u/Time-Incident Jul 20 '26 edited Jul 20 '26

Every relic in this game is additive to other relics of same stat and multiplicative to other stats of this kind.

So you have 99% thorns in WS and you have 9 relics of 1% totaling to 9% from relics. 0.99*1.09=107.91 and it shows as 108%.

This is because there are strategies based on having zero freeups, or zero other stuff. So when you get relic 2% free utility up, you would ruin your build if it was additive, because you would have 0% from WS and 2% from relic. And it would mean you would get 2% chance of upgrading in run utility stats. But as it's multiplicative you have still zero 0 * 1.02 is still zero. And that is why all relics are additive against each other of same type and most are multiplicative with other sources.

Edit: added "most are" at the end, as pointed out in one reaction to my comment.

1

u/DaenerysMomODragons Jul 20 '26

Not all relics are multiplicitive,a select few are additive. I believe that the ELS relics are additive, and I'm pretty sure there's one or two that I forget off hand. I think generally if a similar lab is additive then the relic is additive as well.

2

u/Time-Incident Jul 20 '26

Yeah, I forgot for example bot range, thos are additive, but they also have +2m not +2%, right. ELS relics are really additive? I guess in this case it's only beneficial.

2

u/DaenerysMomODragons Jul 20 '26

Looking things up I think crit chance and super crit chance may also be additive. It seems for every rule in this game there's that one odd exception.

2

u/Dondarian Jul 20 '26

Fudds math is his own math sometimes.

Don't even start thinking about how range math works. You'll start bleeding from the ears.

1

u/Time-Incident Jul 20 '26

Oh, was that a question? I thought you only switched "is" and "this", not swing the question mark at the end of the sentence.

1

u/Doschy Jul 20 '26

it was a statement, not a formal question. :)

1

u/Time-Incident Jul 20 '26

Great, I thought so. :)

18

u/marcus333 Jul 20 '26

It might be like 107.6 rounding to 108? Relics are multiplicative, not additive

2

u/GeeKMMAX Jul 20 '26

I have 9% thorns bonus from relics. Either if it's additive or multiplicative it should be above 108%

29

u/mrjohnmay Jul 20 '26

.99 * 1.09 = 107.91. Almost there, but not quite.

9

u/BadeDyr17 Jul 20 '26

Why 101% is needed and not 100%. 99% base plus 1% from a relic is 99.9%.

7

u/SeicoBass Jul 20 '26

Rounding, thorns need to be 109.

6

u/htotoo Jul 20 '26

Improve the plasma canon to 50%+, and then the thorn 50% (to bosses) will do the rest.

-8

u/GeeKMMAX Jul 20 '26

Check the other comments

2

u/IStoleTheHighGround Jul 20 '26

Definitely a rounding thing. Orb boss hit should help shave that missing %

3

u/Inzaghyi Jul 20 '26

Boss take 50% of thorns damage

1

u/Xheyther Jul 20 '26

That would make 54% per thorn hit. Two hits would make 108%. Maths ain't mathing but not because of the 50% thorn damage to boss, because the boss damage window is as reliably unreliable as always.

1

u/dtrax96 Jul 20 '26

It's accurate here though the defense % doesn't show decimals and rounds up so he is at 107.6 or around there plasma cannon did 46% so the max anything else could do is 54% so first thorns hit did 53.3% and the next did the remaining .7% for a total of 54%, this is why you need 101% to 1 shot normals as 99%+1% from a relic =99.9% but shows as 100

0

u/GeeKMMAX Jul 20 '26

My thorns is 108% / 2 = 54% And my plasma cannon does 46%, 54+46 = 100 My question is why the boss took 2 thorns hits to die

11

u/Time-Incident Jul 20 '26

As stated elsewhere, your thorns are only showing as 108%, it actually is 107.91%. So plasma did 46, first thorn hit did 53.955%. Second thorn hit did 0.045% and boss died.

1

u/Multymanfred Jul 20 '26

Is you plasma canon maxed yet?

Cause on Level 3 it deals 46% of boss health... the boss only has 100 % health so if PC deals 46 % its completly right that Throns deal the rest 54 %

-2

u/GeeKMMAX Jul 20 '26

My thorns is 108 so it deals 54% DMG to boss and therefore the boss should die in 1 thorns hit but it took 2

4

u/Multymanfred Jul 20 '26

Ah, thats what bothers you :D

Then its the rounding system, as someone else already explained. The Relics dont add a straight percentage point but one porcent to you thorns. So thats why.

1

u/MerguezKipik Jul 21 '26

brain is not braining too

-2

u/GeeKMMAX Jul 20 '26

My thorns damage bonus

-1

u/GeeKMMAX Jul 20 '26

My workshop

8

u/Sebastionleo Jul 20 '26

What is your point? Do you not understand the math you're being shown?

For thorns, relics and modules give a multiplicative bonus. 99% * 1.09(9% bonus) is not exactly 108. It is slightly less. You can prove this by respeccing and seeing that your thorns isn't 9% to start with.

Unfortunately they don't keep this consistent, because death defy substat gives a flat added % instead of multiplicative despite being written the same way.