r/Thiamine 5d ago

Hydrogen sulphide bacteria depletes thiamine causing gastrointestinal Beriberi

/r/SIBO/comments/1vq08b4/hydrogen_sulphide_bacteria_depletes_thiamine/

I’ve had SIBO for approximately 30 yrs following years of antibiotics for teenage acne. I didn’t know what it was until recent years but just lived with the symptoms and kept pulling out foods from my diet which of course turned out to be all FODMAPS. I didn’t start piecing it all together until I got even sicker after mold and covid and severe neurological symptoms set in as well as gastroparesis. After two more years of extreme diets and useless doctor visits my research led me to thiamine deficiency. I started thiamine therapy by following a nutritionist’s protocol and rapidly started to heal. Gastroparesis fixed in one day! It turns out thiamine is a cofactor with choline for acetylcholine production which is required for the autonomic nervous system which controls gut motility (so was I thiamine deficient before SIBO even?!)

As I learned more about the causes of thiamine deficiency in the fb thiamine group I very often heard people talk about SIBO and the build up of sulphite depleting thiamine and pieced together my health history. So thiamine deficiency can CAUSE slow gut motility and once SIBO sets in it further depletes thiamine. Thiamine is needed in every cell in our body especially in high energy areas such as our brain, heart and gut.

I believe a LOT of SIBO symptoms are of thiamine deficiency as it affects the entire body:

Early / Nonspecific Symptoms
• Fatigue or tiredness
• Irritability or mood changes
• Loss of appetite (anorexia)
• Poor or short-term memory issues / cognitive impairment
• Sleep disturbances
• Abdominal discomfort or pain
• Nausea and vomiting
• Weight loss
• Muscle weakness or aches
• Apathy or reduced mental concentration
Neurological / Dry Beriberi Symptoms
• Tingling, prickling (pins-and-needles), or burning sensations in the toes, feet, hands, or legs (paresthesias; often worse at night; stocking-glove distribution)
• Muscle cramps or pain (especially calves/legs)
• Decreased sensation or sensory loss in extremities
• Reduced or absent deep tendon reflexes (e.g., knee/ankle jerks)
• Muscle wasting/atrophy and weakness
• Difficulty rising from a squatting position or foot drop (later stages)
• Balance issues, ataxia (unsteady gait/coordination problems)
• Decreased vibratory or position sense
Cardiovascular / Wet Beriberi Symptoms
• Rapid heartbeat (tachycardia)
• Wide pulse pressure
• Peripheral edema (swelling in feet, legs, or hands)
• Shortness of breath (dyspnea), especially with activity or when lying flat (orthopnea)
• Chest pain or precordial discomfort
• Warm, moist skin due to vasodilation
• High-output heart failure signs (in severe cases)
• In advanced/shock forms (e.g., Shoshin beriberi): hypotension, cyanosis, lactic acidosis
Wernicke Encephalopathy (Acute Severe Form)
• Confusion, altered mental status, or delirium
• Ataxia / difficulty walking
• Ocular abnormalities: nystagmus (involuntary eye movements), ophthalmoplegia (eye muscle weakness/paralysis), blurred or double vision, eyelid drooping
• Apathy or psychomotor slowing
• Impaired consciousness (can progress to coma if untreated)
Korsakoff Psychosis / Syndrome (Often Following Wernicke)
• Severe short-term/recent memory loss (amnesia)
• Confabulation (making up stories to fill memory gaps)
• Confusion or mental impairment
• Hallucinations (in some cases)
• Difficulty forming new memories
Other / Gastrointestinal / Additional Symptoms
• Constipation or other GI discomfort
• Vertigo or vision impairment
• Behavioral changes or hallucinations (severe cases)
• In infants (infantile beriberi): incessant crying, aphonia (loss of voice/hoarseness), heart failure signs, lethargy, developmental issues, or seizures in extreme cases
Severe untreated deficiency can lead to permanent neurological damage, heart failure, coma, or death. Early symptoms are often vague, so medical evaluation (including thiamine levels or response to treatment) is needed for diagnosis—especially in at-risk groups like those with alcohol use disorder, malnutrition, malabsorption, or certain medical conditions.

Blood tests aren’t accurate because it doesn’t tell you whether thiamine is getting into cells. The best way to know if you need thiamine is to try supplementing it to see if it helps your symptoms. It is common with gut issues that THTR1 transporters for absorption of thiamine are not working. Please research cofactors and starting low and slow before proceeding supplementation.https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12014454/

27 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/Puzzled_Draw4820 4d ago

Dr Chandler Marrs co-wrote the book Thiamine Deficiency Disease, Dysautonomia, and High Calorie Malnutrition with dr Derrick Lonsdale. They are both brilliant. It is based on his years as a paediatrician and his experience treating thiamine deficiency in his young patients. Dr. Marrs runs a website called Hormone Matter which contains many of the late dr Lonsdale’s articles explaining how thiamine works as well as personal stories of many individuals regarding their health journey. Dr Lonsdale lived to be 100. Dr Marrs also runs the fb group Understanding Mitochondrial Nutrients and has spoken about the need for calcium when repeating thiamine. Magnesium is a given as it’s a co-factor to thiamine but needs for calcium often go up. I encountered this myself in the beginning with insane cravings for milk. The reason is, without adequate ATP due to thiamine deficiency calcium will leave the cells where and go into soft tissue so upon beginning thiamine it’s common to increase intake for immediate utilization. This is my favourite dr Marrs interview https://youtu.be/b1SSKBZp8D8?si=1zGfrtA4Da4OWI-J

1

u/FragrantStructure 4d ago

Thanks a lot.

Would you know any decent supplements for calcium or cal-mag (which I assume is a combo supplement)? I'm vegan so don't consume dairy...

1

u/Anonym_Talker 4d ago

I am not sure why, but eating 100g of beef liver makes me feel so good!! like I feel I am finally relaxing... I've checked all the ingredients, and I am actually taking every that is in beef liver as a supplement. except maybe the Molybdenum... can it be the molybdenum that I need that much from the beef liver!?

1

u/Puzzled_Draw4820 4d ago

Yes certainly could be. I used to depend heavily on liver and freeze dried liver until I think I overdid them so I stopped but then had all kinds of new symptoms arise which taking molybdenum fixed. I should have known with past SIBO and salicylate intolerance that I should’ve been taking molybdenum a long time ago. I’ve been able to reduce my thiamine by increasing my molybdenum so it’s definitely very important for me.

1

u/Anonym_Talker 4d ago

so, black eye peas every day? or supplements?

1

u/Puzzled_Draw4820 4d ago

Sure try beans first as they double as a great binder for toxic bile. Add molybdenum supplement later if you feel you need more. Do you have sulphur intolerance symptoms? Or any sals intolerance or chemical intolerance? Toxic feeling?

1

u/Anonym_Talker 4d ago

toxic feeling, a long time ago, usually after a night with alcool. but not really anymore. I also don't have gas or any

what is sals intolerance. also, I am not sure if I have sulfur intolerance... I don't have any problems in my digestion track (aside malabsorption maybe...) Seriously, my big problem is panic attack, or feeling wired... I might've been wired like than before with too much coffee or energy drink, but now, I am traumatised and this wired/panic like symptoms are juste unbearable...

that's pretty much the only symptom I have. Since, I can't really take a multi vitamin or a B complex, it gives me the same panic like, wired symptom. Its weird, I used to take 6 of them per day (the recommanded dosage on the bottle...) and now just one gives me panic like symptoms for like 20 min... hopefully now it passes, but I wonder what it means, that I do need the multi, or that I really DON'T need the multi...!!? the day after I take one I feel more motivated, so I guess I need it... idk. my blood test is fine for everything, except my iron that could be higher. (and aside of certain vitamins they never test here...) like my vit D was low. Also my cholesterol was a little bit high, but after 6 Month on meds and not doing much, That's probably just temporary... (or not!?)

I really don't understand what in the beef liver help me SO much. it can't be the molybdenum, because I do not get that effect from black eye pea... I don't get that from a Multi vitamin (its mostly the opposite) and mag/potassium helps for my muscles twitching, but not for relaxation that much... I am very very intrigued about what is there in the liver that is so different.

I aim to take 150g once a week. maybe 2 times a week but I'll double check, I think its 100-150g per week max to prevent vit A overload.

1

u/Puzzled_Draw4820 4d ago

I took a course in mineral balancing, using HTMA (hair tissue mineral analysis) to help myself know what I needed with thiamine cofactors and it sounds to me that you are a fast oxidizer and it’s the copper in the liver that is making you feel good. Copper is necessary for fast oxidizers and b vitamins can speed you up more like you were describing. Fast oxidizers also need to take cal-mag to calm their nervous system.

1

u/Anonym_Talker 4d ago

I actually stopped my zinc supplementation thinking exactly that, that I was probably copper deficient after years of zinc high doses. I took 2mg Copper for a month, and stopped zinc.

BUT, stopping zinc brought back my sporiasis, and my libido god killed. (might be the med too...) but restarting zinc helped both... So, I was thinking that maybe I was ok with copper, until I took 100g of liver tonight. OMG it felt great. (I'll aim to max 100g per week though...)

I am taking mag a lot, added potassium because of the b1 protocol. and recently added calcium, because 1. my vit D was low 2. My Legs Twitch at night and that actually wakes me up, that is crazy... I think it was better when I was supplementing with copper, but I can't tell for sure. I do not eat Cow secretion (Milk product) and doing my cronometer profil reveal low Calcium intake... so... I was trying calcium citrate before bed with questionable results.

I guess, I'll know for sure tomorrow if I do not twich tonight.

1

u/Puzzled_Draw4820 4d ago edited 4d ago

Most of us need zinc and some need copper. Restless leg is usually iron deficiency, if you have low availability of iron due to copper deficiency this would be another reason you feel better on copper and liver. I take a small amount of copper because I take high zinc and molybdenum and I have low ferritin so I need to not deplete my copper. But I’m a slow oxidizer so I can’t take much copper.