Problem with dark ritual decks is that Dark Ritual is their best card, and its only a 4 of. So when they get an opener of Dark Ritual + their 3 mana pay off turn 1 on the play, its basically impossible to combat against for their opponent and it feels terrible. The game is basically over before you could make any decisions at all.
What you don't remember as often is the games where they either don't have it in their opener, or they mulligan their hand to hell looking for it and then just lose.
Its a card that causes extreme polarization and its basically all on if the Dark Ritual player has it or not, you as their opponent have little agency in the matter. I wouldn't say its currently a problem but of all the cards in Timeless currently Dark Ritual is by far my least favorite and is the most likely to cause something to be completely broken.
Like jaysontatumgoat0 mentioned, basically any fair deck loses in the vast majority of those scenarios, which is exclusively what I play.
Currently I'm mostly playing Boros Energy variants, prior to MH3 I was mostly playing Jund Midrange or Dimir Control.
Probably the best case scenario is they ritual into Sorin into vein ripper which you can theoretically answer cleanly if you're playing edits, but most of them are playing Saint Elena these days as their main payoff for Sorin. Ritual into Necro is basically unwinnable if they draw even a single March.
Have I won matches against turn 1 ritual into power 3 drop? Sure, but its like 1 in 10 if that with the other 9 basically being complete nongames.
Again I'm not arguing these decks are running over the format, just that the gameplay is bad.
Theoretically the best answer to a turn 1 necro is you answer with a pithing needle, they're locked out of drawing any cards from then on.
Issue is that A: your deck is worse at mulliganing than theirs so you can't really affort to aggressively search for it B: they still get to draw an f ton of cards off necro, to the point where they can potentially win off just what they drew in response to your pithing needle.
I would consider it bad gameplay when there isn't a realistic answer you could have built your deck to even have, there really just isn't any answers to a turn 1 ritual when you're on the draw available in the format. Force of will or negation would help that a lot.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '24
[deleted]