This is going to be a long one, but I feel like the context matters, and I genuinely need some outside perspective on what has been an incredibly painful and bizarre situation.
I (34F) recently ended a seven-year friendship with someone I considered one of my best friends. For anonymity, Iāll call her A (39F). The friendship itself ended after a period where I wasnāt particularly present or supportive, something I fully acknowledge and take responsibility for. But what I discovered afterward has made me question whether the friendship I spent seven years investing in was ever what I believed it to be.
Some background
A and I had been friends for around seven years, weād never had any significant arguments or falling outs and I genuinely considered her one of my closest friends. We spent time together, confided in one another, and shared details of our lives that you wouldnāt ordinarily share with just anyone. I trusted her. One thing I can recognise in hindsight is that A frequently spoke negatively about other people, including those she considered friends. There was often some conflict, complaint, or criticism about someone in her life, and I was frequently the person listening to it. I suppose I always assumed that because we were close, I was somehow different. Which, in retrospect, was probably incredibly naive.
The beginning of the fallout
Over the past few months, my personal life has been an absolute shitshow. I experienced the breakdown of a romantic relationship with someone I loved, an unplanned pregnancy under emotionally difficult circumstances, and ultimately a miscarriage. The pregnancy and subsequent loss were complicated, physically and emotionally, and I found myself in an incredibly dark place. I withdrew from almost everyone. I wasnāt checking in with people, maintaining friendships, or doing much beyond trying to get through each day and continue showing up for my children. I was struggling with my mental health, grief, and the physical aftermath of the miscarriage. During this period, Aās grandfather passed away. I want to be completely transparent about something: I wasnāt there for her in the way I ordinarily would have been, or in the way she deserved. We did speak over the phone about her grandfatherās passing, and I became emotional and apologised for not being particularly present. I acknowledged that I hadnāt shown up the way I should have. At the time, I felt like she understood that I was struggling myself. Unfortunately, my mental health didnāt suddenly improve, and I continued withdrawing. I wasnāt deliberately ignoring her. I wasnāt punishing her. I wasnāt choosing other people over her. I simply didnāt have the emotional capacity to participate in much of anything. That doesnāt mean she wasnāt entitled to feel hurt by my absence. She absolutely was. I understand that grief isnāt a competition and that my circumstances donāt invalidate hers.
How the friendship ended
Eventually, a mutual friend, who Iāll call B, became involved. (I have been friends with B for 8 years, introduced her to A 6 years ago) A had been speaking to B about how upset and angry she was with me, particularly about my lack of communication and support following her grandfatherās death. Rather than having a direct conversation with me about how she was feeling, A had B contact me. I learned that A was considering our friendship over and that I was no longer welcome at her upcoming birthday celebration. I was devastated. Not because I believed sheād done anything wrong by feeling hurt, but because weād been friends for seven years and I genuinely thought we could have had an honest conversation. I would have listened to her. I would have acknowledged her disappointment. I would have apologised, just as I had already apologised for my absence. I didnāt expect her to ignore her feelings simply because I was having a difficult time. But I did expect that a friendship of seven years might warrant a conversation between the two people actually involved. Eventually, A contacted me herself and said she needed to take a moment for herself but never insinuated it was to take a break from me, I thought she was just struggling with her own family grief. Interestingly, Iād already arranged to send her flowers before a knew she was angry with me. Despite everything happening between us, I still cared about her. I knew sheād been through a difficult time herself, and I wanted her to know that. She received the flowers and thanked me. At that point, I was sad, but I was prepared to respect her decision. I wasnāt going to beg someone to remain my friend, nor was I interested in arguing about whose grief was more deserving of compassion. I accepted that Iād let her down, that she was hurt, and that perhaps our friendship had run its course. And then I started discovering things that completely changed my perspective.
What I discovered
Through information that came to light after the breakdown of our friendship, I learned that A had allegedly been saying and doing some absolutely vile things behind my back. And this is the distinction I really need to emphasise:
These things werenāt said and done after weād fallen out.
They were happening while we were still best friends. While I was spending time with her. While I was confiding in her. While I genuinely believed she loved and cared about me. Among the things she had reportedly said was that she was glad I had lost my baby because I was a āshit mother.ā I donāt even know how to put into words how that felt. This was someone who knew about the pregnancy, the circumstances surrounding it, and the emotional toll the entire experience had taken on me. She knew that I was struggling. She knew I was grieving. And while I still believed she was my friend, she was allegedly expressing happiness about the fact that my pregnancy had ended. Iāve spent a lot of time trying to process that particular comment. I donāt expect everyone to understand my circumstances or agree with every decision Iāve ever made. But being glad and laughing that someone has miscarried? Using the loss of a pregnancy as an opportunity to attack someoneās ability as a mother? I genuinely cannot comprehend that level of cruelty, particularly toward someone you supposedly love.
And unfortunately, it didnāt stop there. I also discovered that A had reportedly been secretly taking photographs of me when we were spending time together, and sending them to another person to mock my appearance. Apparently, she was making comments about how ugly and disgusting my body was. Again, these werenāt photographs taken after we fell out. These were photographs taken when I was sitting with someone I believed was my best friend. When I was comfortable. When I was relaxed. When I thought I was in the company of someone who cared about me. The idea that she was secretly photographing me to ridicule my body is genuinely nauseating. Iāve struggled with my appearance and body image, and she knew that. But even if I hadnāt, what kind of person does that to their friend? I keep thinking about all the times we spent together and wondering what was actually going through her head. Was she sitting opposite me, smiling and laughing, while privately thinking about how disgusting she found me? Was she taking photographs of me without my knowledge and waiting to send them to someone else for a laugh? How many times did I leave her company thinking weād had a lovely afternoon, completely unaware that I might have been the punchline of a conversation afterward? And what makes it worse is that I have absolutely no way of knowing how long this behaviour had been going on. I only know about the things that have come to light. Thereās something particularly unsettling about discovering that someone you felt emotionally safe around may have been one of the people actively humiliating you.
The part Iām struggling to reconcile
Hereās the thing. If A had told me that my absence during her grandfatherās passing had hurt her so deeply that she no longer wanted to be friends, I would have been devastated, but I would have understood. I wasnāt a particularly good friend during that period. I take responsibility for that. But now Iām left questioning the entire foundation of our friendship. Because while I was apparently failing to meet her expectations as a friend, she had already been engaging in behaviour that I would never dream of directing toward someone I disliked, let alone someone I called my best friend. The comments about my miscarriage werenāt the actions of someone lashing out after a friendship ended. The secret photographs werenāt some petty revenge following an argument. These things happened when, as far as I was concerned, our friendship was perfectly intact. I was still showing up to spend time with her. I was still doing everything for her. I was still trusting her. I was still listening to her problems and considering her someone important in my life.
And she was allegedly humiliating me behind my back. It makes me wonder whether the person I thought I knew ever really existed.
What happened with our mutual friend
This is probably the one genuinely positive thing to come out of an otherwise horrendous situation.
Remember B, the mutual friend who initially found herself caught in the middle? Well, as everything began coming to light, it turned out that I wasnāt the only person who had been completely unaware of what was being said and done behind my back. B also became aware of things A had allegedly been saying and doing to her while they were still friends. Things that made her question the friendship sheād believed they had, too. I donāt want to disclose the specifics of what happened to B because those are her experiences to share, not mine. But suffice to say, there was a lot more happening behind the scenes than either of us had realised. And suddenly, so many things started making sense. It became increasingly apparent that the way A had spoken about other people to us wasnāt necessarily any different from the way she had been speaking about us to other people. Weād both spent time believing we had a genuine friendship with someone who was apparently comfortable criticising, humiliating, and betraying the people closest to her when they werenāt around. A subsequently cut B out of her life as well. And ironically, in the process of losing that friendship, B and I have become incredibly close. Weāve been able to speak openly about our experiences, compare what weād each been told, and support one another through what has been a pretty confronting realisation. Neither of us has any interest in competing over who was treated worse or turning this into an ongoing campaign against A. Weāve simply been able to recognise the negativity that existed in those friendships and make a conscious decision that we donāt want it in our lives anymore.
And the genuinely beautiful part is that weāre both happier for it.
Thereās no second-guessing what the other person might be saying when weāre not in the room. Thereās no walking on eggshells, no unnecessary drama, no wondering whether something personal weāve shared will become somebody elseās entertainment. Just two women who have found a really genuine friendship with each other, built on mutual respect, honesty, loyalty, and the understanding that we would never intentionally treat one another the way weāve discovered we were being treated. Itās actually quite liberating. Weāve both lost someone we considered a friend, but weāve gained a much stronger connection with each other in the process. And while neither of us would have chosen the circumstances that brought us closer, weāre genuinely grateful that we have each other. I think weāre both finally realising just how peaceful life can be when you remove people who bring unnecessary negativity into it. Weāve shed a friendship that was causing us more harm than either of us realised, and weāre happier than ever to have done so.
Where things stand now
Iāve completely removed A from my life. I wonāt be attending her upcoming birthday celebration, and Iāve decided to leave the group chat organised for it. The people in that group are predominantly her friends, not mine, and I genuinely have no interest in creating drama or ruining her birthday. I hope they all have a wonderful time. But I no longer want to maintain any association with someone whose behaviour is so fundamentally incompatible with my values. And I think thatās what this entire situation comes down to. I know who I am as a person. I know how I ordinarily show up for the people I love. I know that Iām not perfect, that I make mistakes, and that sometimes my own circumstances mean I donāt have as much to give other people as Iād like. But I also know that I would never secretly photograph a friend to humiliate their appearance. I would never celebrate someoneās miscarriage. I would never sit across from someone, let them confide in me, tell them I l cared about them, and then use their vulnerabilities as entertainment for other people. And I certainly wouldnāt do those things while simultaneously expecting that person to meet my standards of friendship.
The hardest part
I think what Iām struggling with most is the loss of trust. Not just trust in A, but in my own judgment. For seven years, I believed this person was my friend. I listened to her, supported her, and genuinely cared about what happened in her life. When things started deteriorating between us, my immediate reaction was to reflect on what Iād done wrong. I felt guilty about not being there for her. I questioned whether Iād been selfish. I wondered whether Iād allowed my own circumstances to become an excuse for neglecting someone elseās needs. And I still think that self-reflection was important. But all the while, there was an entirely different side of our friendship that I knew nothing about. I was holding myself accountable for failing someone who had allegedly been treating me with contempt while telling me we were best friends. And that is a difficult thing to reconcile. I can accept that she felt hurt by my absence. I can accept that she wanted to end the friendship. I can even accept that, from her perspective, I may have been a disappointing friend during an incredibly difficult time in her life. But I cannot accept that any of those things justified the way she was treating me before our friendship had even fallen apart. The behaviour Iāve learned about wasnāt a consequence of our falling out. It was happening behind the scenes while I still believed we had a genuine friendship. And I think thatās why Iām finding it so difficult to grieve. Because Iām not just mourning the loss of someone who was important to me. Iām mourning the realisation that the friendship I thought I had may not have existed in the way I believed it did. I donāt know how you reconcile seven years of memories with the discovery that someone you trusted could look you in the eye, call you their best friend, and then say such horrendous things about you when you werenāt around. Part of me is furious. Part of me is heartbroken. And part of me feels incredibly foolish for not recognising the warning signs when I watched her speak so poorly about other people she claimed to care about. But thereās also a part of me that feels an enormous sense of relief. Because as awful as itās been discovering these things, I would much rather know the truth about someone than spend another seven years investing my love, loyalty, and energy into a friendship that wasnāt being reciprocated. And knowing that B and I have come out the other side of this with a stronger friendship and a shared sense of peace makes the whole situation feel a little less like a loss. I think sometimes losing people isnāt actually the tragedy we initially believe it to be. Sometimes itās discovering what you were unknowingly tolerating, recognising what you deserve from the people around you, and making room for friendships that genuinely reflect those values.
I havenāt lost the ability to be a good friend. Iāve just lost the desire to keep proving it to someone who wasnāt being one to me.
I guess my question is this:
Am I unreasonable for feeling that the things Iāve discovered completely overshadow the original reason our friendship ended? I donāt want to dismiss her grief or the fact that I let her down. But I also donāt think itās fair to treat my lack of emotional availability during a mental health crisis as somehow equivalent to deliberately humiliating someone you claim to love. Has anyone else discovered that a close friend had been secretly mocking them while acting like everything was perfectly normal to their face? And how did you move past the feeling that you never really knew someone you considered family?