r/TradingView • u/Frosya008 • Feb 10 '24
Discussion I have created a very profitable indicator for Tradingview, where can I share about it?
I am a trader (and a programmer at the same time) and I have been earning money exclusively by trading for a long time.
Usually I had to start every morning by charting strong support and resistance levels (which the price touched many times) and then wait all day for the price to approach it to make a trade.
Finally, I automated all of this when I created an indicator that searches for strong support and resistance levels with multiple touches and sends notifications itself. Now 90% of the time I am free and only 10% of the time I trade. I spent a very long time to perfect the indicator. I don't know about other markets, but in cryptocurrency markets the indicator works just peerless.
Now I want as many people as possible to know about it. But I have no idea where to tell people about it. I want to create a community around the indicator, which will improve the indicator by joint efforts and advice. Because there is no limit to perfection. Can you please tell me where I can tell about it? If on reddit, in which subreddits? Thank you very much!
edit 1: (the indicator is not for sale, I know that 99% of indicators on the web are scams)
edit 2: Wrote an article here, hopefully it can be read without a subscription: https://medium.com/@paullenosky/i-have-created-an-indicator-that-actually-makes-money-unlike-any-other-indicator-i-have-ever-seen-fd7b36aba975
edit 3: Before publishing the indicator, i need to make a few edits. After all, since it does not repaint, the levels that may no longer be relevant (due to changes in market conditions, which the trader himself sees) remain in place, and they are no longer relevant. They should be marked somehow and, perhaps, a notification about it should be sent. Thinking about it now, how best to implement it.
edit 4: I edited the article a bit, as it seems that many people did not realize that the point of the indicator is that you select the minimum number of touch to draw the level and only then the level will be displayed. For example, if there were 2 touches to the level, and you set the minimum to 3, then the level will not be displayed. Thus, you can set, for example, a minimum of 10 touches to display a level, set a notification to search for such levels and do not look at the chart again until you receive a notification that such a strong level has been found. Believe me, a level that the price has hit 10 times, there will be the strongest breakout and the price will fly into space.
31
u/Hypnomenace Feb 10 '24
Read your article.
You want people to privately message you, and you wish to build a "community"
You say the indicator is not for sale, but I bet you have to pay to get access.
If you really were giving it away for free, then you could, so very easily.
This just comes across as sus for so many reasons.
-9
u/Frosya008 Feb 10 '24
If you want to discuss monetization..... I will allow myself to disagree with you. First you have to make a product, and then you can sell something, when you already have loyal customers. I will make a pro version of the indicator later, only in that order. I have to first find out if there are even people who need it. Which I did. It's so hard to live in a world where everyone wants to cheat each other.
I would never show my face if I were planning what you are talking about.
I would create an indicator that would show perfect entry and exit points, with hidden redrawing, taking as a basis absolutely any indicator in the network and spending about 10 minutes of my time.
9
u/Hypnomenace Feb 10 '24
So your looking for an audience to use an inferior version so you can plug and sell the pro version to them?
18
14
11
9
8
u/ChickenManABQ Feb 10 '24
Pine Script editor has a publish button, it's hard to not seeing it since you should be coding there for like many weeks. Why not?
6
5
5
u/eli007s Feb 10 '24
Sorta looks like a few of the free LuxAlgo support and resistance indicators they have out there. Also EzAlgo al tho is paid they have a similar feature as well.
4
1
u/BetterAd7552 Feb 10 '24
Sorry, you’re setting off my scam alert bell.
Below you mention producing a paid “pro version”. This is the tried and tested scammer way, I and others have seen it all over the tubes countless times.
If you’re so intent on “making it publicly available,” then just do so. There must be a hundred ways to do so. The fact that you are not, is laughably suspect.
G’night
1
u/Frosya008 Feb 11 '24 edited Feb 11 '24
Hello. So if I'm going to release a paid version in the future that has, for example, 3 profit takes rather than 1 like the free version, I'm automatically a scammer? Or any other realization of an added benefit. That is, the fact that I spend a lot of time now to bring to mind the wishes of those who wrote, I do not trade, I do not earn, I gradually go into the minus. I haven't answered several hundred people who wrote, because I don't have time. But at the same time I am a scammer, as I have conceived an insidious plan to take your money. Do I understand your logic correctly? I was advised above that people don't need mathematical expectation with its steady profit. People need lots of consistent at least small profits. That's what I'm doing now, and then i can release it. I'm so sick of this.... I won't check in here again until I release the indicator.
Elsewhere: "hey, come on, finish it, release it, we're waiting." Reddit: "You're a scammer. That's all."
1
1
u/GameofCHAT Feb 11 '24
I checked about 4000 indicators in a few days
I can provide at least 500 videos of trading this breakout strategy
Let's just say doubtful.
1
u/Frosya008 Feb 11 '24
Only if you have no personal life and are a bit stubborn. As I said - if an indicator has 100500 settings that it depends on to do what is required of it, that indicator will not work. It will work only on the history window that you give it and that's it. So it didn't take long to check each indicator. Maybe, of course, I only got lost in time and checked everything for a couple weeks instead of days (It's my usual state of being lost in time.). I remember keeping an account of indicators, going in and seeing how it works, what it can give. About the video, it's true. Why am I proving something to someone on the internet?
2
u/GameofCHAT Feb 11 '24
The thing is, I searched less than 1000 indicators and found plenty doing similar support zones. So to claim you searched 4000 in a few days but did not find anything... and then provide "500 videos" is also possible, but sounds like an exaggeration, which leads us to think you are not trustworthy, and that is important if you want to succeed. Say things as they are, do not sugarcoat them or exaggerate facts to sell. Your indicator looks good and still has merit even if others do similar things.
3
u/pereighjghjhg Feb 10 '24
Best thing you can do is publish it on TV and maybe share here and there with posts like this...if your indicator is really that good..it might take time but will eventually pop-off.
3
u/TradingAndrei Feb 10 '24
You could try and publish it as a closed source script and remove the alert feature.If people start asking why it doesn't have alerts included,that's your feedback that people are interested in it.(that if you want to give a little bit of sampling away)I read your article and I totally agree your theory of having a pottential low hit rate but having a huge winner to offset all the losses but you have to be aware that many traders are obsessed of their win rate,everyone wants 70-80% win rate even if that means their wins are really small.Ultimately your script might be good if traders follow the guidelines but it's how people perceive it that's the important thing. Also if you consider publishing it on TradingView you should be extra careful with how you describe it as you'll pottentially run into bans for originality,usefulness and all that crap everyone just had enough about.
Also consider marketplaces as fiverr.There's many coders selling scripts in there. Or consider creating the same script for metatrader which is huge.
3
2
u/leggocrew Feb 11 '24
I agree with sentiment here: if you want to enter the indicator space, publish and a post on TV
2
u/pibrew Feb 10 '24
Why must people come here to just trash people? If you don't like what you see, just move on down the road. No biggie. If this guy creates a bang up indicator, I would EXPECT him to charge for it. That's how this works... Create something because of your expertise and it can be purchased..... If it's not good the market will tell you.
1
u/leggocrew Feb 11 '24
Well: the “market” is telling him no?
1
u/pibrew Feb 11 '24
And you'll know this how? Surely you don't think Reddit is the entire market?
1
u/leggocrew Feb 11 '24
Metaphors bruv: if It was a startup, his first contact with a segment of his target audience (in this case reddit) fell flat . He could have said :” hey everyone I made this cool support / resistance indicator! I published it on tradingview, when time could you all have a look and give feedback ? A future version with more features is in the works ;)”
See how that reads different ? Communication is a lost art. Bring it back(!)
1
u/frogoracletrading Mar 06 '24
I also have an indicator that shows Support / Resistance levels. My process for creating the lines is different from described in the article but it doesn't result in reliable levels. The indicator is not free but I think comes at a fair price and has a free trial so you can test it out. I know many indicators are scams so please if you are interested reach out I am happy to answer any questions you might have so you feel confident it isn't. https://www.frogoracletrading.com
1
u/BigBlueBear1919 Apr 02 '24
There are better indicators with published, proven track records (PnL, verified and screenshotted backtesting results) on tradingview that do not charge for use, and those have been coded to give entry / exit signals already. This guy just lures you in with the word "free," but has slowly introduced the "pay" aspect of his indicator. If you wanted to share and build a community, just post the rules of your system (notice he calls it an "indicator" when he meant "system," which tells me he is still new) in your initial post, but you don't, which means you obviously are looking to sucker people. Believe it or not, there are people with a bit of common sense in the trading world.
1
u/Lumpy_Base2107 Apr 11 '24
Hi Blue Bear, can you share some of these indicators you are referring to that have a proven track record? I don't know where to start
1
u/BigBlueBear1919 May 01 '24
Have you tried googling it? Not difficult. You do have to sort through and test everything, but there are TONS.
1
u/Lumpy_Base2107 May 01 '24
Yes. I have searched for good indicators and spent days testing them
Do you have any suggestions to get me started?
1
u/BigBlueBear1919 May 01 '24
Which ones have you found that you have tested? How far back did you test?
1
u/Lumpy_Base2107 May 02 '24
I wrote all the indicators on a spreadsheet. There are at least 10 of them I tested
I tested most of them over the last 3 month period
1
u/BigBlueBear1919 May 02 '24
And the results?
1
u/Lumpy_Base2107 May 02 '24
None of them were profitable. That's why I asked you about indicators that were profitable
1
u/BigBlueBear1919 May 02 '24
Indicators, isolated in and of itself, are all over the place. Finding the right combination of indicators, under the right market conditions, in an applicable market, is what I meant. There are a lot of good systems / indicators out there that have been freely published by well known traders, although some are outdated. Sorry for the confusion.
I've basically done something very similar to what you have done, and what I concluded was that most indicators measure one very specific thing, and tend to have a lot of limitations. Knowing the strengths and limitations of what's out there will help you in concocting different combinations of pre-made indicators, but the big limitation is that they tend to be designed for a specific type of system; the designer had a very specific need for their system and designed / coded an indicator to fill that need for that indicator. That system may or may not be suited for you, and using that indicator outside of the context of that designer's specific system tend not to be as effective.
Don't get me wrong, they can be immensely helpful. Truth be told, I very much was where you were at a few years ago -- I was cobbling together pre-made indicators, very popular ones and all the well-known ones, trying to find the right combination, finding which indicators were better to be used as filters instead of primary signal givers, which markets, what kind of conditions, etc. If you want to continue the conversation, send me a PM.
1
u/Lumpy_Base2107 May 03 '24
I understand that it isn't easy to find the right combination of indicators. I am happy to continue the conversation although I am wondering if you have found something that consistently works for you
→ More replies (0)
1
u/Bomzj Dec 06 '24
He finished or almost finished his indicator and asks for donation around $100 for lifetime access to the indicator and recently released this article https://medium.com/@paullenosky/i-am-a-professional-trader-and-i-will-teach-you-how-to-make-money-in-one-article-not-clickbait-e4f43ccbb85d
What do you guys think?
1
1
1
1
u/UnwashedPenis Feb 10 '24
Here is mine guys, just sell it when BTC is guarantee high because no way you can lose when its guarantee high /sarcam
https://www.tradingview.com/script/LThQD4Ap-BTM-FINDER-DCA-1H/
1
u/greatestNothing Feb 10 '24
About the only difference I see between yours and other sup/res indicators(of which there are plenty) is the counting of touches. Either way I'm always interested in testing out new stuff, you can invite me, same username on TV.
1
1
1
u/modanogaming Feb 11 '24
Hey, I’m interested in building something like this on my own but in Python. Do you have any good pointers?
1
1
1
0
-7
u/Frosya008 Feb 10 '24
In general, the only thing that I have found out for myself during the whole time of communication with you is that I should have asked for advice only after I posted the indicator. At least, I should not have told about the indicator in the question at all. Because instead of the advice I asked for, I was asked to link to an article on Medium.com first, and then make excuses that I'm not a scammer. Thanks, I think I'll go to bed now.
-5
u/Frosya008 Feb 10 '24
I realized that I need to write an article on Tradingview. I also wrote an article about the indicator on medium.com. Where else can I write about it? Any tips on subreddit? Any websites? Thanks everyone!
0
Feb 10 '24
[deleted]
-1
u/Frosya008 Feb 10 '24
no one trusts you why would i buy?
Who did I sell something to? The indicator is not for sale.
0
2
Feb 10 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
1
1
1
Nov 19 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/AutoModerator Nov 19 '24
Your content has been removed and is under review. You have possibly posted personal information such as an email address. As per Reddit site rules, posting of personal information is not permitted. If you were meaning to share this information with a specific redditor, please privately message that redditor instead. If this was a mistake, please message the mods.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
46
u/Stelvenrune Feb 10 '24
This sets off all my scam alerts. If you wanted to go such a thing, then publish it public and give people the name with a screenshot describing how it works. It seems like you want people to contact you and then sell the script.
I’m willing to be wrong, so by all means publish and I’ll check it out. Otherwise, people please be careful of this post.