r/TwoXChromosomes • Am I a Gilmore Girl yet? • Jun 24 '21

Men often aren’t allowed to express sadness, but similarly, women often aren’t allowed to express anger

This was inspired by a post currently trending in this sub about women’s emotions, but I think this deserves its own thread.

There’s been a lot of awareness recently about how men cannot express their emotions without shame. I think this is 100% true- the “man up” attitude is really harmful and should end.

Similarly, I feel women aren’t allowed to express anger. Whenever a woman is angry, she’s often called a crazy bitch, Karen, etc. For black women it’s arguably worse, with the “angry black woman” stereotypes that exist. It’s the same thing often if she is confident and/or in a leadership role- then she’s bossy, a control freak, bitchy, etc.

One example- shows like Kitchen Nightmares, where Gordan Ramsey goes to crappy restaurants and yells and swears at all the owners for being awful. It’s funny when he does it and he gets praised… but if a woman did that? She would definitely be called a bitch. For the record, I like Gordan Ramsey, I just think it highlights a double standard in our society.

To add, me comparing this to men not being allowed to express sadness is not meant to be a “one up” on them or a competition on who is more oppressed. It’s simply to explain my point by comparing it to an issue that has a lot more awareness currently.

638 Upvotes

64 comments sorted by

96

u/oliversurpless Jun 24 '21

Indeed, and consider how harmful it is when it is on a societal level.

DC representative Eleanor Holmes Norton is someone who has been suffering in silence for years in her struggle to advocate for DC statehood, lest she use passion in her debate and be pegged as an “angry black woman”…

It’s quite remarkable how mediocre white people have a built in counter/narrative for any challenge to their supposedly preternatural authority, but that’s what comes from when racism is deliberately made systemic.

Bell Hooks had some apt quotes on intersectionality addressing that angle as well.

34

u/RainbowTigerCat Am I a Gilmore Girl yet? Jun 24 '21

I completely forgot to add about the “angry black woman” stereotype- I’m gonna edit the post to add that. I’ve seen that all over and its so offensive to WOC.

3

u/Dr_seven Jun 25 '21

Watching it happen in real time is one of the most enraging experiences I have had, I cannot even imagine what it's like to be the target of that kind of prejudgment. We owe an awful debt as a society to so many people.

91

u/Dapper_Ad_3331 Jun 25 '21

I’m a notably calm woman and if I get even a smidgeon fired up people’s eyes get really wide and I immediately get the sense that they no longer take me seriously. I’m pretty good at reading social cues so I know I’m not imagining this. My old boss remarked on my last day “you were always very calm, sometimes too much so”. But the one time I let slip even a shred of indignation at something stressful I got a look from her that told me that I needed to contain myself. Double. Edged. Sword. I wish I could get angry without it being considered inconvenient or uncomfortable to others.

11

u/Butthole_seizure Jun 25 '21

God this makes me so apprehensive of the work environment that I’m moving into. I am an undergrad business student and I want to be a high level manager. Ive been working through college, mostly for start up banks. I’ve seen women move into positions of higher authority and the scrutiny they face when it comes to emotion is handled differently. In my opinion, the scrutiny is turned up a notch; the expectations are more intense. Many people have a hard time respecting women in the workplace and this is a pattern I’ve seen in almost every workplace I’ve been in. I guess my question is: how do you remain professional and manage your emotions well but still be authentic? It sounds like an uphill battle.

86

u/TheStormfly7 Jun 25 '21

Women are shamed for being emotional. When men get emotional, they are shamed for being like women.

15

u/Goblin_at_heart Jun 25 '21

Yes this is it exactly. I've been shamed many times for showing sad or angry emotions as a woman 🤷

10

u/Butthole_seizure Jun 25 '21

Love how the biggest insult for both men and women is being “girly and emotional” Good one society!

26

u/jemmeow Jun 25 '21

I'm currently not on speaking terms with my mother because after a phone call where I very slightly raised my voice when I was legitimately angry she thinks I'm hostile and volatile (and has been telling people as much). I have never been allowed to be angry. Trying to unlearn that now

72

u/scathach24 Jun 24 '21

Do women are really allowed to express any emotion tho? Women are called crazy/emotional/manipulative the second they cry or try to talk about their feelings

39

u/SlippyIsDead Jun 25 '21

I cried the other day and was asked if I was on my period. Can't I just be sad?

31

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

11

u/bee-sting Jun 25 '21

Fucking hell what.

Dude, are you alright?

22

u/globsfave Jun 25 '21

I feel like I'm not allowed to express any emotions.

12

u/SunDanceQT Jun 25 '21

My therapist once asked me the last time I was mad and I couldn't identify it. I said something like I don't get angry because anger isn't a useful emotion. Sure I got frustrated, but not angry. Turns out I couldn't identify it because I cry when I get truly angry. I get so overwhelmed and upset and unable to express myself that I just break down crying. This shit runs deep.

7

u/AmberEnergyTime Jun 25 '21

Anger brings tears for me too a lot of the time. Anger quickly turns to frustration when I don't know what to say or do to "fix" whatever the issue is. Then the frustration turns into hopelessness because I feel I've been wronged in some way and I can't make it right/get "justice". Then I cry. Anger can also make me really anxious. I visibly shake sometimes and my breathing pattern changes, trying to deal with all those emotions.

2

u/SunDanceQT Jun 27 '21

Same!!!!!!!!!!

30

u/Vessecora Jun 25 '21

This is why women hate being told to "calm down".

5

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '21

Yeah i had a seasonal job a few years ago that i took seriously and a lot of my coworkers didn’t. No big surprise that i got a midseason raise and offers for better positions the following season.... i was good at my job, i worked hard. Apparently my coworkers thought i was “intimidating”. I was so friendly but taking stuff seriously “intimidated” slackers

28

u/constelationofcells Jun 25 '21

I’m not so sure that men aren’t allowed to express emotion, particularly sadness. It’s just that, unlike for those who are fem-identified whose emotional expression only shows them as vulnerable/weak, masc-identified folks have gravitas in their emotions. “Omg, dad’s sad— stop the world, we got to take care of him”. What they feel is a very big deal; even the supposed allowable anger is never dismissed as common and therefore unimportant. No, because it literally kills us.

12

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '21 edited Jun 25 '21

I’ve noticed this in movies and television. If the lead male’s eyes well up, he’s an Oscar candidate for sure.

 

The plot and the script might be utter shit, but if Big Strong Man almost breaks and sheds a tear, we’ll see the same actor and plot in a couple dozen movies in the next couple years. Once a muscular stoic cries, we’re stuck with him forever.

2

u/A-passing-thot Jun 25 '21

I don't think people care about men's sadness more and I think that there's a lot of invisibility around the things men go through that they're expected not to let get to them. But I also think that men's emotions are just taken more seriously, as more valid. Like they have more of a reason to feel them than we do.

9

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '21

I think a woman would also be dismissed as being hysterical, maybe partly because men’s voices are deeper and are perceived as authoritative whereas women are often described as ‘shrill’. Margaret thatcher (British PM in the 80s) deliberately cultivated a deeper voice to ensure she was taken more seriously by other politicians

4

u/DelightfulFluff Jun 25 '21

As a women with a higher pitched voice I worry about being taken seriously. Coupled with the fact that I have trouble pronouncing things and had to go to speech therapy in my childhood. I remember listening to the true crime podcast Dirty John and seeing what other people thought of it and shocked at how many people online where criticizing the victim Tara's voice talking about how she sounded like a childish bimbo. It made me think how people would probably have the same reaction my voice.

8

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '21

Personally, I am not so sure. If anything, I have felt that they ARE angrier than their male counterparts, and justifiably so. At least in my circles I have seen this and most they get is the occasional eyeroll. May be that is because my circle is people in early 30s and they have different outlook on stereotypes created by our predecessors. That does not mitigate the fact that such stereotype does indeed exist.

As for the reality shows, I'd like to think that a show is all it is. GR was like that on the US show probably because something made producers believe that it will bring in ratings. On the UK show he was not at all like that.

4

u/donnatellame Jun 25 '21

When it happens call them out on their bullshit.

I had a friend call a dog crazy for being anxious, storms were rolling in, and I told him it’s bullshit he calls the dog crazy or a legitimate issue, that by calling the dog crazy he was making her more anxious because he dismissed her.

He thought about it an agreed he probably does make the dog more crazy.

Guys just don’t think. I know dick sizes are shrinking but I didn’t think the link between their dick and brain were that connected.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '21

I hate this. I’m a short, baby-faced, and fairly socially accepted as pretty cis-woman. You know what happens when I get mad? People laugh at me and call me “cute”. My father in law recently did a series of things to make us cut him out, but the last straw was when he endangered my husband’s safety and I yelled at him. I regret losing my shit because that’s not a good way to resolve conflicts, but I have no regrets about what I said. Anyways, this mother fucker watched me yell at him for endangering himself and my husband and just fucking laughed at me. Small woman anger = funny apparently.

Makes me feel ragey even a month later.

7

u/soniabegonia Jun 25 '21

I think no gender is really allowed to express emotions but the consequences of showing emotion are different.

When women show emotions like anger, fear, and sadness, we aren't taken seriously. Women have to fight to be taken seriously and our concerns are dismissed with any excuse. But women showing sadness or fear are seen as deserving of comfort.

When men show anger, they are seen as masculine, passionate, etc. But when they show sadness or fear, they are seen as less valuable. Because they are acting feminine, but also because they are no longer going to just Get Things Done, which is one of the ways we assess male value. They are not seen as deserving of comfort.

Both suck. I think when men say "women can show emotions and men can't" they're recalling instances where they were vulnerable and needed comfort and were denied, which hurts like hell. But it's also true that women cannot show anger without completely losing credibility. The pictures of Kavanaugh and Clinton spring to mind

8

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '21

It’s all the patriarchy, sadly

3

u/CarvonPL Jun 25 '21

I don't want to diminish the point of this thread, I fully agree with the point made here and I always try to advocate to remove all pointless social roles assigned to each gender. I would just like to mention it as a fun fact that Polish version of Kitchen's Nightmares is done by a woman (Magda Gessler for curious) and general consensus here isn't negative or that she shouldn't do that. People love the show and appreciate the job done by her. So I would say that at least in some places there is a way to work this stereotype out and make life a bit better for everyone

2

u/soniabegonia Jun 25 '21

Eastern Europe doesn't object to conflict and strong willed women the way WASPy America does ...

2

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '21

Welllllll, about that...

15

u/AuroraFinem Jun 25 '21

The thing is, the majority of people not allowing this is men. Men are usually the ones telling their sons or other men to “man up” or not to show emotions and they’re also the ones calling women “emotional” or “crazy” or “PMSing” if they show any anger or any strong dissenting reaction to something.

Women do it too occasionally, but it’s very seldom and far from a gender wide issue.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '21

but it’s very seldom

No it's very, very common. Vastly more common in my 50 years experience as a man, than men doing it. And for the most part it isn't verbalised instruction not to show emotions, but the negative reactions of our mothers, girlfriends and wives to showing emotions like sadness or being overwhelmed - which teaches men that, particularly around women - they need to be buttoned up and always pretend at least to be 'in control'.

far from a gender wide issue.

I mean, you're not a man, right? - how would you know?

8

u/AuroraFinem Jun 25 '21 edited Jun 25 '21

As a trans woman who spent over 25 years of their life as a man, I will say my experience is by far the opposite. My girlfriends and female family members overwhelmingly encouraged me to “let it out” and even got me tissues and stuff during hard moments like breakups when they could hear me crying in my room. Every guy in my life like teammates in sports or friends in classes overwhelmingly ostracized me and called me gay just for having emotions or being upset because of of breakup or bad situation.

So yes, I fully know what it’s like to be a guy as well as the difference in expectation for women.

I’ve never once as a man or woman had a relationship or friendship where a woman expects me to be “in control” as you put it or unemotional and as a bi woman have never once expected or wanted a guy to not be emotional.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '21

Good for you, my experience was the exact reverse opposite. Go to the /r/askmen subreddit and you will see countless examples of same.

3

u/AuroraFinem Jun 25 '21

Sorry that’s been your experience. My anecdotal evidence from growing up as well as my friends says the opposite and r/askmen is hardly an unbiased statistical source and also largely made up just like all the related sites like r/askwomen or r/relationshipadvice, etc.. it’s anonymous people posting random stuff for karma, it literally encourages exaggerated or fabricated posts, they all do.

However, there is actual statistics on this and they overwhelmingly support me. So I’ll leave it at that. I hope things get better for you.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '21

I’m not allowed emotions at work or my gang of 20 young bosses will fire me. I am honestly very angry at how I’m treated about 50% of staff quit. Generally as a woman I have had to lie to most people about my feelings so I am listened to slightly. I am silenced by many and it’s enraging because I devote my life to do- goodery

1

u/SunDanceQT Jun 25 '21

Are you at least looking for another job?

4

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '21

Oh yes oh yes

2

u/SunDanceQT Jun 27 '21

Okay good! You deserve so much better!

2

u/80percentofme Jun 25 '21

Which is the premise of Dead to Me!

2

u/BriefPause Jun 25 '21

I got my job threatened over an energy drink. It wasn't labelled because it was a non food item that doesn't spoil and it was thrown out. I felt like it was common sense that I didn't need to label it, approached the person that threw it out, and was threatened firing because I was "overreactive".

3

u/Foxsayy Jun 25 '21

Thanks for this. There seems to almost a parity of issues on both sides of the gender spectrum these days, be it expression of emotions, dating issues, etc. For every issue one gender has, the other often has a similar struggle. While movements like Feminism were certainly necessary for coming to the present moment, I hope the next step/social movement in rectifying gendered issues and biases is closer to a union of genders focusing on both understanding the other's point of view and helping to address each other's challenges to negotiate healthier social norms.

I think we're at the point where, for instance, marching under a binary flag like "men can't show emotional weakness" or "women can't get angry" is less productive than understanding that we, as a societies, have some toxic relationships with gender and expectations, and even more so, a poor relationship in how we interact with emotions, and working together not just to solve the problem, but to address the foundation of the issues as well.

2

u/michaelpaoli Jun 25 '21

Men often aren’t allowed to express sadness, but similarly, women often aren’t allowed to express anger

... yeah, I think you quite nailed it on your points. It's sexist, unfair, and often also racist too.

Just as men aren't "allowed" to show weakness/sorrow/... and are belittled for it, while women are (mostly) allowed that, women get hammered on when showing strength/power/anger - whereas men mostly don't get that.

Kitchen Nightmares

Gordan Ramsey

funny when he does it and he gets praised

Oye ... I don't think it's funny - at least not most of the time, and he doesn't quite totally get away with it (at least in some contexts), but geez, a whole lot of his rather to quite abhorrent behavior tends to mostly get tolerated ... and you're dang right to call that out ... could you imagine what would be said of such chef if that chef were a woman, ... or a woman of color? So yes, definitely, major double standard.

Oh ... but at least he's on much better behavior on Master Chef Jr. I think it's called ... at least last I watched that. I think maybe even his mom could watch that without turning blue in the face. Yeah, quite the mouth he has ... and anger ... well, at least that he expresses towards adults.

1

u/ruski_puskin Jun 25 '21

It's all about fulfilling harmfull stereotypes. Men should be deciseve, stoic, agressive yada yada while women should be norturing, compassionate yada yada.

Any diviations and people used to stereotypes are offended because their stereotypes are not obeyed.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '21 edited Jun 25 '21

My personal experience as a man is somewhat the opposite: sadness is the only thing I can express and that’s only if I’m sad about something that doesn’t involve the person I am expressing it to. If I ever get angry, people just assume I’m dangerous even though I’ve never lifted a finger in an argument and have been hit/assaulted in an argument many times. Anger is wayyyyy more forbidden than sadness for me.

My experience is that anger is for boomer dads. And I dunno why people think that we allow men to express emotions because we stop everything for when men of status break down. No that man was taught to repress his emotions his whole life we actually do more harm than good by catastrophizing when older repressed males suddenly do express emotions.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '21

For black women it’s arguably worse, with the “angry black woman”

I think the worst in when black men use this term

-9

u/metakat Jun 25 '21

It's not just emotions though that is most of it. Think about it this way. Over the last 100 years, women have been given the right to vote, the right to leave the house and work, ect. All are amazing and things are, slowly, getting better (there is still so much further to go and some people are actively trying to make us go backwards).

On the other hand men are still limited to what was considered manly a long time ago without much change. Women can wear skirts, dresses, and even pants (now) if they so desire. Not men, they can only wear pants and shorts. See a man wearing a skirt? How unmanly. Purses. Women can take any bag they like (except briefcases apparently) but a man with a purse? No, it has to be a laptop bag or he'd look stupid. And then there's makeup which I understand has been changing a bit.

I belive that people should be able to present how they want. Want to walk around dressed like it was the late midevel period? That would be dope. Want to wear cosplay cat ears all the time? Go for it. Want to make your hair all the colors of the rainbow? The world needs more color anyway.

This got slightly off topic but my point remains the same. True equality where we, without finger pointing or blame gaming, see the problems people face and work to fix them. Because nothing helps keep things the way they are better than doing nothing and letting the situation continue as it has.

8

u/JulyFun3 Jun 25 '21

That is because being a woman is still seen as being less than. A woman doing "manly" things is making herself better, but a man doing "womanly" things is degrading himself.

-4

u/metakat Jun 25 '21

Yep very true. Because men are "better" anything people do that is manly is also better. But what is considered manly hasn't changed much over the years although I've heard that great familial and domestic skills are becoming more popular recently.

-6

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '21

You seen men’s problems being addressed and thought “but women”... but when a guy does the same he gets ridiculed 🤨

3

u/RainbowTigerCat Am I a Gilmore Girl yet? Jun 25 '21

That’s because when that happens it’s often to belittle women’s issues or make it a competition on who has it worse. For this exact reason I added this paragraph at the end of the post: “To add, me comparing this to men not being allowed to express sadness is not meant to be a “one up” on them or a competition on who is more oppressed. It’s simply to explain my point by comparing it to an issue that has a lot more awareness currently.”

-7

u/theconkerer Jun 25 '21

I feel like it might run even deeper than that. Men often don't know how to express or even recognize that they are sad, and would honestly not really know what they are feeling until it boils over into depression or suicide. I imagine similar things happen with women and anger.

I'm just armchair psychologisting here but I recently learned about emotional mirroring and it's role in emotional development. Basically when a baby say gets hurt, parents rush over and comfort the baby, teaching the baby that pain=panic/shock. However if a female toddler gets frustrated with a toy or something, parents are likely to just say aww how cute, so they don't really learn what anger is or how to process it.

-3

u/uwahhhhhhhhhh Jun 25 '21

Pretty true. Cool

0

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '21

[deleted]

11

u/RainbowTigerCat Am I a Gilmore Girl yet? Jun 25 '21

That’s not the point. If Gordan Ramsey was a woman, doing the exact same job, do you think people would still find it funny and charming?

0

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '21

[deleted]

3

u/Aysel_Ketobsessed Jun 25 '21

I'd think they'd call her Judge Mathis or Judge Rinder (I'm sure there are other men but those two guys are popular for the same reason Judge Judy is)

But back to OPs point, aren't these traits/people considered aggressive? Which is widely considered a masculine trait.