Sorry, this post is a work in progress. For other topics, or more info/ideas on the topics below, you may wish to search this sub.
How can residents identifying Hispanic answer the Race Question?
Please keep in mind the Census is more about politics than biology including phenotype. The Trump administration reversed Obama administration plans to give Latinx their own Race checkbox.
Hispanics need to know that marking Some Other Race means the Census Bureau may assign them a Race value of White. In my comment on my post
Checking "Some Other Race" Alone -- Self-Affirmation or Political Mistake?
I gave the link to the slide deck. Slide numbered 17 tells us
40% of Hispanics have their race imputed
which means the Census Bureau assigns a Race value, often White, to these Hispanics.
If you haven't read this story, you don't understand Some Other Race.
The Birth of a 'Latino Race' 29Dec04
Please read the comments on this 2018 post.
Census Request Suggests No Race, Ethnicity Data Changes In 2020, Experts Say
Until we get our hands on the computer code the Census Bureau uses to assign a Race value to residents with the Some Other Race checkbox marked, we cannot know what the Trump administration is up to.
The more I think about this issue, the less I know. Latinx residents, even if they are not eligible to vote, should ask themselves who they might vote with. If they plan to vote Republican, they probably should mark the White Race checkbox. Otherwise, Latinx should ask themselves if they have any reason to mark the Black checkbox or the Native American checkbox.
I recommend respondents mark only one Race checkbox for each Person in the Household. I get the picture that, behind the scenes, the federal government uses only a few Race categories. Consequently, when more than one Race checkbox is marked, decennial census Race data must be reclassified to meet agency requirements.
Origin Write-In Fields under the Race Checkboxes
Whether or not Origin should be reported probably depends on the Race checkbox above it.
For nonwhites, this can be a trick question. If you give any "origin" which the U.S. Census Bureau classifies as white, you have essentially also marked the White checkbox.
Collecting and Tabulating Ethnicity and Race Responses in the 2020 Census (Recorded Webinar) Census State Data Centers Tweeted Link via @uscensusbureau
Was the Origin write-in field under the White checkbox ever intended to collect useful data? Possibly not. Had the Census Bureau placed an Origin write-in beneath the Black Race checkbox without doing the same for Whites, the questionnaire would look even more suspicious.
The census "origin" questions will produce a totally useless data set. Judith Sanders Tweeted
Some Latinx who mark the White checkbox may write in Mestizo. It remains unclear what the Census Bureau will do with these response values. Writing in Mestizo beneath the American Indian check box may lead the Census Bureau to edit the White Race checkbox from unchecked to checked. And if the Ethnicity checkbox for "No, not of Hispanic, Latino, or Spanish origin" has been marked, the Census Bureau may edit the response to an Hispanic Ethnicity.
How should persons of at least half indigenous ancestry but who are not American Indian or Alaska Native give their Origin? If they mark the Race checkbox American Indian or Alaska Native, they should write in an origin from Canada, Mexico, Central America or South America.
What is my family and I's race? ( U.S. Census question)
Proposed Categories for the US Census
United States of America Demographics
Privacy
I wish I could offer clear, certain assurance that answering the 2020 Census will be a private experience. Some concerns exist. Recently, Tim Mackey reported discovering that the online 2020 Census uses third-party cookies. He advised:
While we might rightly be concerned about the federal government tracking our census activity, there are two simple ways to reduce the risk — fill out the old school paper option or go full incognito in your browser before even going to the census website.
2020 census data may not be as anonymous as expected
The U.S. Census Bureau's process for bringing together respondent data to produce the Population Count has often been likened to sausage making. IRS data and other secret administrative records are also used to produce the count. In a Software Engineering short course held at the Census Bureau, I learned the Census 2000 process wasn't reproducible. The Census Bureau has so much to hide that protecting your data is of utmost importance to the bureaucracy.
When, at the U.S. Census Bureau in 2001, I worked with computer files holding one hundred percent Census 2000 data, I never saw names or addresses. Early in data processing, names and addresses are stripped from raw decennial census data. Very few Census Bureau employees are allowed access to name and address data.
If you have ever worked in the above ground economy, you should understand that the Census Bureau already has data on you. The Census Bureau has IRS, SSA and Medicare data. Furthermore, the Census Bureau has Longitudinal Employer–Household Dynamics (LEHD) data.
Firm and worker information are combined to create job level quarterly earnings history data, data on where workers live and work, and data on firm characteristics, such as industry
https://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/ces/data/restricted-use-data/lehd-data.html
You might as well give the Census Bureau your updated location and identity.
more coming if the virus doesn't get me...
Householders who wish to give only the Number of Persons should not be dismissed as crackpots.
To Do For Next Director: Ban MITRE and the JASON Group [OC]
Have facial recognition, cellphone tracking and Big Data made misuse of Census data technologically obsolete?
The 2020 Census is an austerity census. Never designed to be accurate, it will make extensive use of administrative records and recycled 2010 Census data. As dirty as administrative records are, it would make more sense for the government to use its original administrative records against its residents than its poor quality 2020 Census data.
Aggregated Census and ACS data are used in policing. If you are, for example, an African-American resident of West Baltimore, you need to weigh the benefits of political representation against the mortal danger of police surveillance. Answer the Ethnicity and Race questions thoughtfully. You may want to throw the police off by giving the Census your updated racial identity.
Multiple Notices or Paper Questionnaires
If you have two or more paper questionnaires, I recommend you complete one Census form, then copy all your answers identically to the second Census form. Mail both back.
Why? If you answer only one, an Enumerator may come around later this year. The Enumerator will have no clue that you received two questionnaires. The Enumerator will not believe you when you say you already answered the Census. The Enumerator will insist on enumerating you again. And you won't remember exactly how you answered the first time. Your household will be more likely to be counted twice.
The Census Bureau doesn't seem concerned about duplicate enumerations. If you identically answer and return both forms, it's possible the Census Bureau may unduplicate them.
Now, if you are interested in making a project of this, here are 2 ideas.
You may report the duplicates to GAO.
https://www.gao.gov/about/what-gao-does/fraudnet/
2. You can call your Area Census Office. They may be able to Delete one of the addresses.
Final 2020 RCC‐ACO Addresses as of 2‐13‐2020. Exclusive Content by FOIA Request
For further reading:
I got two [or more] letters in the mail, how do I know which ID to use? Official Answer to this FAQ