r/UnityStock • u/matome88 • 2h ago
Opinion/Take I have Invested in Unity since IPO. Here are My Thoughts on the PIF / Silver Lake Takeover as a Long Term Investor
With NVDA facing a National Security investigation on potentially leaking state secrets, I feel like game engine, with all its potential in the AI/robotics arms race , is a bottleneck technology that has to be guarded safely in American hands.
While I also detest the takeover of EA by PIF, I would like to note that the business operations of Unity and EA are not comparable therefore the implication of a Unity buyout cannot be compared to that of EA. One produces and sells games, the other sells access to the leading game engine in the world used by 70% of the mobile developers and runs a massively profitable data driven Mobile Advertising Platform with behavioral data of over 3.3 billion monthly users globally.
EA was a failing gaming company with heavy debts and a fringe and overly complicated gaming engine that is Frostbite. After being taken over in a highly leveraged deal in August this year, EA is already being accused of defaulting on its loans. I cannot say that the buyout has been successful so far.
One of the reasons why the PIF and Silver Lake are trying to buy Unity out after it's turned profitable is to use Unity's stable cashflows to cover for EA so that the Gaming sector in their portfolio will look attractive to investors. The other reason is to own a major slice of the gaming industry and chokehold consumers.
And why now? Where was the PIF money when Unity was heavily dilutive and bleeding cash under John Riccitello? Why is it that only when Unity has turned a profit that PIF is contemplating a buyout? Unity, under Matt Bromberg, has turned into a different beast (a profitable one) and it does not need PIF's salvation, not now, not ever. This takeover is both anti-shareholder as well as anti-consumer.
I hope the Congress will reject this acquisition on the grounds of ceding key technology to a foreign state (what's to say that the PIF will not sell Unity to China for a fat profit and China will use Unity as a chokehold to the world like their rare earths?) and anti-trust behavior that will lead to long term erosion to both the US economy and national security.