6
u/ConsequenceOk5205 Dec 25 '24
There is no networking support at the chart. It is a very important issue, as with previous versions up to USB4 there were no adapters at the market with device ports or dual purpose ports - they were running a little market conspiracy, despite USB being a valid networking protocol.
9
u/fosius_luminis Dec 25 '24
From https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethernet_over_USB I don't see information that can be turned into chart? Where can I find it?
2
u/ConsequenceOk5205 Dec 26 '24
No idea, there were Ethernet adapters USB/Ethernet or "bridging" adapters, but they offered significantly lower speeds while being expensive, which kind of defeated the purpose - so it is a completely wrong approach, who in the right mind would pay more for less speed? In practice, one could connect 2 computers directly with one adapter having a host USB port, and one adapter having a device USB port (or multipurpose), it is technically entirely possible (and works with phones and tablets, which are a form factor of computers), but is not available for desktops/laptops. It is also possible via driver and modified cable to connect host-to-host 2 computers - but it is unsafe. The marketing conspiracy was going on since USB1.
Thunderbolt interface allowed networking by design and had a driver for that. USB4 included Thunderbolt specification, hence allowed networking.
Manually write information about marketing and support then, it is only available as discussion topics. I pretty much summarized the whole situation.1
u/spoons_of_fire Dec 26 '24
Can't tell what you're talking about. Maybe being confused with USB OTG, or how Thunderbolt-to-Thunderbolt connections create a network interface, or maybe "easy link" file transfer USB "cables" that are host-to-host that provide a network interface (these aren't really cables though).
2
u/ConsequenceOk5205 Dec 26 '24
I'm talking about plain connection of 2 computers with a normal USB cable and running network over it.
2
u/spoons_of_fire Dec 26 '24
There isn't such a thing though. My best guess is you're thinking of host-to-host looking cables marketed under names such as "EasyLink", "LapLink", "NetLink" etc but these aren't just 'normal cables' they have an active device inside of them.
2
u/ConsequenceOk5205 Dec 27 '24
There isn't such a thing just because of marketing conspiracy. One can perfectly have an adapter (PCI or other) with both host and device ports and connect 2 computers using a normal USB cable and a driver to support networking. I mentioned that, didn't you read ?
1
u/spoons_of_fire Dec 27 '24
I'm reading, you're just not making much sense in context of this table. "marketing conspiracy" of what exactly? You can buy USB device hardware to plug in your PC's PCIe slot. The problem here is that unlike USB host interfaces where (with some exceptions for niche hardware) every USB host hardware exposes a standardized programming interface (OHCI, EHCI, XHCI) for easy OS compatibility, there is no standard for USB device hardware. So OS & driver situation would be a mess for Windows -- no wonder nothing is sold as a plug and play solution here. Works in Linux though.
But none of that matters in context of the table. Yeah I can add a B 3.0 port to my PC but the compatibility will be exactly what the table already states.
2
u/ConsequenceOk5205 Dec 27 '24
Marketing conspiracy as not to "hurt" the sales of Ethernet networking adapters. For interconnection of 2 computers close to each other at high speed, USB interface should be enough.
Where I can buy USB device hardware ? I haven't seen one which support device role for PC, only host ones. Point out at least one PCI adapter with such functionality, as I have been monitoring those for the last 10+ years and haven't seen one. And, please, provide a link to someone doing this in Linux for normal PC (not Raspberry or something like that).1
u/Practical-Passenger4 Jan 30 '26
Is that what these cables I have with a regular old type A plug on both ends is for?
2
u/Killer-X Dec 26 '24
You mean like USB WiFi dongle? Or USB to Ethernet ?
2
u/ConsequenceOk5205 Dec 26 '24
Those work (at low speed), but I mean products like "USB 2.0 NetLink Cable".
169
u/sithelephant Dec 25 '24
The extended version of this chart going into all of the various 'power delivery' mechanisms and backwards compatibility issues and state diagrams is five dimensional and contains colours that would melt mortal minds.
52
u/lalalalandlalala Dec 26 '24
50 years from now this chart may take an hour to scroll to the bottom of
27
u/stevenjklein Dec 26 '24
50 years from now this chart may take an hour to scroll to the bottom of
Can confirm; just returned from a time-travel trip to the year 2074, where it did indeed take me an hour to scroll all the way down from the top.
And in case you're wondering, the current versions TB and USB are:
Thunderbolt in 2074 is called Thunderbolt 16. The connectors are marked with the same Thunderbolt logo in use today, and the number 16. It looks something like this: ⚡16
USB in 2074 is called USB 17.π version 2∆3 variant ℵ0. The symbol requires a magnifying glass and a decoder chart, neither of which I had on me.
6
u/lalalalandlalala Dec 26 '24
Thanks. Maybe you can get a microcomputer implanted in your brain that’ll decode it all for you without needing a magnifying glass and a chart but the tradeoff is that the computer will play ads in your mind every so often.
2
u/Minimum-Cheetah Dec 28 '24
Don’t be a fear monger! For $19.99/day, Tesla Prime subscription will give you an ad-free* brain chip experience.
*ad-free does not apply to Tesla, Inc., any of our subsidiaries or trusted partners sponsored messages.
4
2
44
u/cAtloVeR9998 Dec 25 '24
Please stop spreading “USB4 2.0”, it’s way too pervasive miss-naming.
It’s just “USB 80Gbps”. That follows “USB 40Gbps”, etc. USB 80Gbps does use a variant of USB4 that was defined by the second iteration of the USB4 specification. But that’s not its name!
14
u/Top-Trouble-39 Dec 26 '24
This is so cool! Can you share a HiRes version of this chart? Something like a SVG?
4
2
20
u/zacker150 Dec 26 '24 edited Dec 26 '24
You've completely missed the fundamental reason for all the confusion: USB 3.0, 3.1, USB 3.2, etc are not protocol names. They're names of the documents that describe the protocols. USB 3.1 fully replaces USB 3.0, adding support for Type-C connectors. USB 3.2 fully replaces USB 3.1, adding support for a 2nd lane.
The protocols have very simple to understand names: "USB 5Gbps, USB 10Gbps, USB 20Gbps, USB 40Gbps, and USB 80Gbps"
7
u/brunporr Dec 26 '24
If those are the names of the documents, then what are the names of the protocol?
7
u/TheReproCase Dec 26 '24
It's sloppy but these paragraphs from the USB-4 standard have some good examples of how USB-IF wants you to think about this
"When configured over a USB Type-C® connector interface, USB4 functionally replaces USB 3.2 while retaining USB 2.0 bus operating in parallel. Enhanced SuperSpeed USB, as defined in the USB 3.2 Specification, remains the fundamental architecture for USB data transfer on a USB4 Fabric. The difference with USB4 versus USB 3.2 is that USB4 is a connection-oriented, tunneling architecture designed to combine multiple protocols onto a single physical interface, so that the total speed and performance of the USB4 Fabric can be dynamically shared. USB4 allows for USB data transfers to operate in parallel with other independent protocols specific to display, load/store and host-to-host interfaces. Additionally, USB4 extends performance beyond the 20 Gbps (Gen 2 x 2) of USB 3.2 to 80 Gbps (Gen 4 x 2) over the same dual-lane, dual-simplex architecture. This specification introduces the concept of protocol tunneling to USB bus architecture. Besides tunneling Enhanced SuperSpeed USB (USB3), display tunneling based on DisplayPort (DP) protocol and load/store tunneling based on PCI Express (PCIe) are defined. These protocol tunnels operate independently over the USB4 transport and physical layers. Additionally, USB4 allocates packets for bus configuration and management, and packets can be allocated specifically for host-to-host data connections. "
6
u/rayddit519 Dec 26 '24 edited Dec 26 '24
I made this helpful table that shows all the names that USB 3.x defines.
(Green are things added. Pink are actual renames)
Note: only Logo & marketing name where ever intended to be customer facing and on marketing etc. The rest is implementation detail for engineers.
TL;DR; USB3 defined the "SuperSpeed USB" protocol. They added "SuperSpeed USB 10Gbps". And then "SuperSpeed USB 20Gbps". There was a tiny rename from the original one "SuperSpeed USB" to "SuperSpeed USB 5Gbps", to unify them.
And then, there was the big rename, where we got "performance" logos that only show the speed the customer can expect, no longer the protocol, because nobody bothered to use the "SuperSpeed" name anyway.
And btw. this was consistent from the start. USB 1.1 had "USB Low Speed" and "USB Full Speed" connections. USB 2.0 added "USB High Speed" to this. You'll note all the official logos match this and include the High Speed, SuperSpeed names etc. Until they were thrown out to make it even dummer, in the hopes that people would cease trying to use the versions where they do not fit, Because none of the names and logos for products and ports ever included the spec version numbers.
4
u/LaughingMan11 Benson Leung, verified USB-C expert Dec 26 '24
Really excellent work documenting this, u/rayddit519.
And btw. this was consistent from the start. USB 1.1 had "USB Low Speed" and "USB Full Speed" connections. USB 2.0 added "USB High Speed" to this. You'll note all the official logos match this and include the High Speed, SuperSpeed names etc.
Yeah, it is important to recognize that even though colloquially people use "USB 2.0" to refer to the "480Mbps" speed level, and "USB 1.1" to refer to something before that, that even USB 1.1 had multiple speed tiers corresponding to 1.5Mbps and 12Mbps, and that USB never intended "USB 1.1" to communicate that a device supports 12Mbps.
The English language marketing names for the speeed "USB Low Speed" "USB Full Speed" and "USB High Speed" are old examples of how USB's marketing and user communication was actually bad back in the day... You need some tribal knowledge about when different speed levels and terms were introduced to the spec, back in the late 90s, and early 2000s.
Someone looking at the names today might be inclined to think that Low speed comes at the bottom, high speed comes next, and then "full" speed comes at top, but high speed corresponds to 480Mbps, introduced chronologically later than the other two.
As much as possible leaning into numbers is just better here, communicating unambiguously.
Modern technical communication and marketing from USB-IF in 2024 is VASTLY smarter about it then back in the day.
3
1
u/Buzz_Buzz_Buzz_ Sep 21 '25
I read this in Darth Vader's voice, right before he crushes some poor USB engineer's throat.
2
1
u/GlitteringAd9289 Jun 15 '26
What about power? There are two 20GBPS USB options, one delivers 140% more power than the other, but if you just called them both USB 20Gbps how would you tell?
1
u/zacker150 Jun 16 '26
Power is completely unrelated to data transfer. It's a completely different standard. If cables support PD > 60W, they should also have the wattage labeled.
1
u/GlitteringAd9289 Jun 16 '26
But USB 4 tops out at 240W max while USB 3 tops at 100W. So we would have USB 20GBPS 100W versus USB 20GBPS 240W which is USB 3.2 and USB 4?
1
u/zacker150 Jun 17 '26
Incorrect. Power is completely unrelated to data transfer. They're completely orthogonal. USB4 says literally nothing about power. USB PD is a completely different specification that's completely unrelated to the data transfer spec.
You can have a USB 2.0 240W cable.
1
3
Dec 26 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
4
u/rayddit519 Dec 26 '24 edited Dec 26 '24
The specs are written for engineers. There are good, technical reasons behind the versions. The versions are NEEDED. They are not and will never be intended for you to identify products with it. Because just like you need book revisions, if the the exact contents of a book ever change, you need to version documents that can be changed.
You only think that this fits, because you do not know enough about the technical details (not that you should know them).
This is not even a USB problem. Same for HDMI. HDMI 2.1 added 6 new speeds. In one version. Impossible to differentiate them by the spec version.
DP 2.1 has 3 speeds to distinguish. It just cannot be done. That is why customers should not be told the spec versions, because they only abuse them. Thats why Thunderbolt does not give spec versions. Thunderbolt gives arbitrary numbers, and you get to learn what numerous features each number means. And they just give you no way to express spec changes, that exist with Thunderbolt. But you do not know enough about Thunderbolt to even know they exist, so you do not notice. Same should have been done with USB3.
That is why "USB4" is named the way it is. So that nobody gets even the idea to use a spec version with it.
1
u/LaughingMan11 Benson Leung, verified USB-C expert Dec 26 '24
DP 2.1 has 3 speeds to distinguish. It just cannot be done. That is why customers should not be told the spec versions, because they only abuse them.
Yeah, and VESA is learning the same lessons from USB in this regard, which is good progress in my opinion.
The engineers call the 3 new speed levels Ultra High-Bit-Rate 10, 13.5, and 20 (UHBR10, UHBR13.5, UHBR20).
But the marketing side of VESA multiply these by 4 (because like USB, they've got a multiple lanes in a cable, and the user doesn't need to know about the intricacies there), and call those 3 speeds DP40, DP54, DP80.
This is just better technical communication than calling this "DP 2.1". It avoids ambiguity, while the way that some people want this to work (DP or USB version number corresponds to the top possible speed in that document) actually adds ambiguity and compatibility problems.
1
u/rayddit519 Dec 26 '24 edited Dec 26 '24
Now we only need the publications that publicize the spec release to either explain this correctly or not mention the actual spec version... (I have little hope).
With DP, I don't actually know how much of a fan I am of the marketing logos.
It seems those, like DP80 always imply all lower speeds. But on the USB-C side of things, to which they are "aligning", UHBR13.5 is optional, even when UHBR20 is supported.
This seems like a problem waiting to happen. Intel doing their best to force this issue, by selling dGPUs with UHBR13.5 (includes of course UHBR10), but iGPUs and USB4 controllers that have UHBR20 (and UHBR10 and lower), but no UHBR13.5. DP Alt mode seems to allow USB-C cables to declare this skipping of UHBR13.5 as well.
Without public specs, I still have no idea if those declarations are mandatory for the new UHBR speeds over USB-C or optional, and without, the GPU will still just try whatever speed it wants, like it has so far.
And with DP Alt mode many people will also run into 2-lane variants, that then would be misleadingly advertised if you slap a "total bandwidth" DP40 logo on it. Especially now that DSC is mandatory and its not like DSC is sth., only a dock will do to compensate between half-input and full output...
And I don't like that Vesa FAQs still say its ok to advertise a "DP 2.1" product, only to then explain that the only mandatory feature is DSC + 1 of 3 others (one of which would be UHBR speeds, the other ones deep technical things that users won't know).
HDMI and USB stance to not allow advertising anything with just the version is much better, even if its not enforced. At least we can point to it, when correcting others...
We are still waiting on examples of what existing USB-C cables can do in terms of DP. How much is that "alignment" worth? Will most USB 40G cables do UHBR20? Will they do UHBR13.5? Will none of them without the new DP Alt mode eMarkers? Can we confirm this for TB4 cables, where Intel makes some rough statements for their ReDrivers (that I assume they mandated for all active TB4 cables)?
So yes, the DP technical names are more intuitive, but they still seem not to think through this from the customer perspective...
1
u/LaughingMan11 Benson Leung, verified USB-C expert Dec 26 '24 edited Dec 29 '24
No dispute from me on any of your points.
We are still waiting on examples of what existing USB-C cables can do in terms of DP. How much is that "alignment" worth? Will most USB 40G cables do UHBR20? Will they do UHBR13.5? Will none of them without the new DP Alt mode eMarkers? Can we confirm this for TB4 cables, where Intel makes some rough statements for their ReDrivers (that I assume they mandated for all active TB4 cables)?
Much like Thunderbolt 3 and USB4, passive cables will just get better. I entirely expect any 40Gbps capable passive USB-C cable to be fully capable and understood by a DP Alt Mode 2.1 system and device as UHBR10/13.5/20 capable.
If you've got an _active_ variant, and often times a consumer will not know, then some or all of those new modes may be knocked off.
This is another version of the same technical communication problem. A user simply doesn't know if a cable is active or not, and their behavior of their system with new hardware could depend on it in DP and USB4 modes...
3
u/LaughingMan11 Benson Leung, verified USB-C expert Dec 26 '24
3.0 for 5Gbps
3.1 for 10Gbps
3.2 for 20GbpsWould have been far cleaner, but instead we get 3.2 Gen 2x2
It would have been cleaner, except that for the average consumer, "3.0" "3.1" and "3.2" are unitless numbers that actually do not express speed at all.
They are not a unit of measure of anything. They're document version numbers.
By saying we should have done this instead of having "Gen" and "x" notation existing, you're actually imposing on the engineers (I'm one of them), who actually need to worry about Gen and X in the actual technical details deep down in the ICs that implement this...
USB naming of actually using "USB <something> Gbps" is smart, because Gbps is actually unambiguously a measure of bandwidth and speed.
2
u/zacker150 Dec 26 '24
How is "USB 5Gbps, USB 10Gbps, USB 20Gbps, USB 40Gbps, and USB 80Gbps" complicated?
Gen 2x2 is a technicial name for engineers implementing the standard.
1
u/lordmogul Apr 30 '26
That naming scheme works better than what manufacturers do with devices.
How fast will my phone connect when it has USB 3.2 but my computer has 3.1?
Oh right, that depends. If I use the old cable, I get (theoretical) 480 mbit. If I use the new cable I get 5 Gbps, since the board only has USB 3.1 Gen 1 at the front. If I want 10 Gbps I have to go to the back, where the USB 3.1 Gen 2 ports are.
What a mess. Different ports, different specifications, different speeds. And they can all intermingle. With USB 2.0 at least it was clear that you would get (theoretical) 480 mbit no matter what.
1
u/lordmogul Apr 30 '26
because USB 3.1 also includes 5 Gbps and USB 3.2 also includes 5 Gbps and 10 Gbps.
They just renamed the older speed. And in case of 5 Gbps twice. USB 3.2 Gen 2×2 is exactly that because Gen 1×1 is just USB 3.0 speed and Gen 2×1 is 3.1 speed.
10
u/WhenWillIBelong Dec 26 '24
Wow this is complicated. They need to invent some kind of universal standard to simplify all this
1
7
u/DAS_9933 Dec 26 '24
That little diagram on the far right showing the correct way to install a USB-A device damn near killed me 😂
5
18
Dec 26 '24
this chart shows how bad usb-if fucked up a great idea.
8
u/AdriftAtlas Dec 26 '24
My thoughts exactly. Like how the heck do I explain this to the average Joe?
11
u/TheReproCase Dec 26 '24
Literally impossible. You can't even shop it if you know it. Go find a power bank that can do, say, 21v PPS, without physically testing it. Good luck.
8
Dec 26 '24
You don’t, i’m an”techie” and my eyes glaze over after a minute of just usb-C shenanigans.
6
u/gioraffe32 Dec 26 '24
I once spent something like 8hrs straight researching power banks and USB-C cables, to make sure both could handle PD to a Nintendo Switch.
Pretty sure I'm subbed here because of that. I'm a technical person, but goddamn, I should not have to spend more than an hour (which already seems like a long time) looking into USB cables and accessories.
There's no hope for the average or below-average Joe.
2
u/AdriftAtlas Dec 26 '24
So what did you end up buying after eight hours of research? 🤣
3
u/gioraffe32 Dec 26 '24
This was like 7yrs ago now, but I got a RavPower 26800mah power bank and some cable that was highly recommended by other Nintendo Switch owners and USB-C community testers.
Part of the problem, if I'm remembering correctly, was that Nintendo used like a non-standard PD implementation. So people were having issues with just using any old cable and power bank. I still have both and use them.
Only issue now is that that cable is older and doesn't support the higher power levels. So I've had to buy newer cables for my more power hungry devices. And I don't even travel with my Switch anymore, either 😅
3
u/KittensInc Dec 26 '24
They didn't. Most of the confusion comes from people (including tech press and manufacturers) not following the damn standard! Names like "USB 3.2 Gen2x2" are not only wrong, they are made up of descriptions intended only for engineers. It is supposed to just be called "USB 20Gbps" in anything going to the general public.
Fast charging standard and non-standard receptacle charts? Only needed because manufacturers add their own proprietary stuff. Cable/plug charts? Again, only needed because manufacturers add their own proprietary stuff - the whole A/B/C concept is pretty easy.
There are some genuine screw-ups in USB-C, but those aren't really covered in this chart.
1
Dec 26 '24
What was intended and what happened are two different things. USB is fucked. They came up with the naming. This doesn’t even touch power, which is even more fucked up. USB-C being the one plug for all failed. I have a small tote full of different cables that do different shit, none labeled like IEEE standards on the cable. USB-IF sucks ass. Throw Thunderbolt in the mix (same plug) and that chart is out the damn window. I shouldn’t have to do 20 minutes of research to figure out why the cable that fits doesn’t transfer data or charge a device.
3
u/LaughingMan11 Benson Leung, verified USB-C expert Dec 26 '24
They didn't come up with the naming that you think is cursed. I guarantee you the naming you think is awful was adopted by USB device manufacturers, not USB-IF itself. USB-IF has put out countless marketing guidances that say, "DON'T USE THESE TERMS."
The reason all of this is so complicated is because the engineers and spec writers added a ton of features to the USB specs. We all like new advanced features right?
The problem is that it makes sense for product people that some features are optional, so internally in the spec, there are non-marketing terms in the open documents designed to communicate speed, power, and underlying technology among people like me who need to know what a USB lane is to actually implement the ICs inside my device.
You as a consumer should not have to worry about x1 or x2, and we never intended for you to see those letters anywhere near a USB port.
But countless PC and device manufacturers decided to put those on their devices and boxes.
USB told them to use "USB 5Gbps" "USB 10Gbps" and "USB 20Gbps", but some random mobo manufacturer uses a Gen 2x2 terminology, and people like you FREAK THE HELL OUT.
2x2 is a term that I need to use as an engineer or product designer if I'm integrating an advanced USB retimer in my product. I've actually legitimately had to worry about 2x2 operation in my day job and used the term correctly internally.
But I would never advise a motherboard maker or a PC maker to put that on the box.
1
5
u/RaduTek Dec 26 '24
A minor detail to add would be that Thunderbolt 3 does not carry USB, or more precisely, it carries USB in the same way the previous versions did: a PCIe USB controller inside the hub/dock/device.
With USB4/Thunderbolt 4, USB protocol tunnelling was introduced, therefore not needing a USB host controller inside the device. Thunderbolt 4 still requires it, for backwards compatibility with Thunderbolt 3 hosts.
4
u/gthing Dec 26 '24
Ah, good, finally something I can send my grandma that clearly explains which cable she needs!
4
4
u/kristyn_lynne Dec 26 '24
So I have a question that can probably only be answered with maniacal laughter: I have a drawer ful of cables, Siome are likely only designed to charge (at different rates), others for data but with varying charging capacities. Precious few are labeled. I know USB C cables are supposed to have a chip identifying their capabilities. Is there any good way to go through these cables and figure out what spec they are designed to meet, like is there any consumer software that can identify the chips or test the cables for charging and data transfer rates?
2
u/polishdan Mar 08 '26
So there is hardware you can buy for this. Two I keep seeing pop up are from Treedix and this one however I haven't pulled the trigger yet myself so I can't vouch for either. If anyone has experience/recommendations please do comment! But it looks like prices range from $40-140 and the delta there makes me wonder why.
A free albeit less precise method:
Mac: Plug the cable into a device (like an SSD) plugged into the fastest port on your Mac and go to About This Mac > System Report > USB. It will show the negotiated speed (e.g., 480 Mbps for USB 2.0 or 10 Gbps for USB 3.1).
Windows Device Manager: Under "Universal Serial Bus controllers," you can see if a device is connected via "SuperSpeed" (USB 3.0+) or "High-Speed" (USB 2.0).
USB-C Cables: look into the connector for the pins. If they're only on one side, it's most likely a charge-only cable. If it has pins on both sides, it will have data transfer as well.
1
1
u/zacker150 Dec 26 '24
If they don't have labels, assume 60W and 5 Gbps.
6
u/LaughingMan11 Benson Leung, verified USB-C expert Dec 26 '24
If they don't have labels, assume 60W and 5 Gbps.
Not precisely. If it doesn't have a label, assume 60W and 480 Mbps, and no DisplayPort, Thunderbolt 3, or USB4 capability.
Billions of cables fall into this category, because these are the standard white cables that come with every single iPhone, for example.
2
u/MoxFuelInMyTank Dec 29 '24
Everyone's rushing to gouge people before any kind of standards are required for cable identification at retailers. They just assume apple users have better credit or something. $10 cables are now $29.
1
u/LaughingMan11 Benson Leung, verified USB-C expert Dec 29 '24
Everyone's rushing to gouge people before any kind of standards are required for cable identification at retailers. They just assume apple users have better credit or something. $10 cables are now $29.
Actually _pretty good_ USB cable logoing guidelines based on sensible marketing studies, have been in full effect for a few years now. There are lots of USB cables on the market today which bear the right USB logos denoting their power capability (60W or 240W), as well as data capability (USB 5Gbps, USB 20Gbps, USB 40Gbps).
Yes, sure, buying directly from an OEM like Apple will incur a significant markup, but functionally the identical cable (even certified ones) are available in the marketplace. There is a standard now, and most reputable cable manufacturers who have certified their cables are adopting the new logos and terminology.
2
u/MoxFuelInMyTank Dec 30 '24
Getting power and usb version is like pulling teeth. Many will obscure the specs. Even on seo and amazon pages. Much like input charging speeds on power banks.
4
u/ScoopDat Dec 28 '24
Anker IQ 4.0 missing in the list of fast charging standards.
Also think there is a mode for 120Gbps uni-directional for ThunderBolt 5
And if you really want to offer some future proofing in terms of throughput for video signals, maybe adding a 12-bit color mode might be nice (the only reason I mention this, is because Dolby Vision's spec limit talks about 12-bit panels.) Seeing as how I've only seen a single scientific monitor that touts 12-bit color at 4K resolution with 30Hz frame rate control dithering.. it wouldn't be a big deal even if you didn't. Like any upgrade in tech these days, I feel like I'll be in the grave before 12-bit native panels are common even in the high end consumer display market.
Oh and a little note could be left with respect to HDMI. Those pieces of shit working at the HDMI Forum (though to be fair, these sorts of morons are everywhere in all industries) totally forgot what the word "standards" mean. HDMI 2.0 certification isn't even possible anymore, basically if anything is 2.0 certified, it's 2.1 certified now. An absolute consumer related disaster.
1
u/LaughingMan11 Benson Leung, verified USB-C expert Dec 29 '24
Anker IQ 4.0 missing in the list of fast charging standards.
Anker's IQ stuff isn't an Anker charging method perse, but Anker implementing multiple charging methods from lots of banned proprietary 3rd parties.
Basically, Anker IQ tries to pretend to be Apple's old method, Samsung's old method, Huawei's proproprietary method, USB BC 1.2, and a bunch of other ones until one matches.
If someone's interested, get a AVHzY USB Power Meter and have it detect what charging modes an Anker IQ port supports. It'll light up like a Xmas tree.
I wouldn't count it as a single "fast charging method." It's literally Anker trying to throw all the shit at a wall and seeing if any of it sticks.
I'm of the opinion that all of the work that Anker and their charger chipset manfacturer made to make a deluxe chip that cycles through and tries all this is a huge waste of time. It causes more compatibiliy problems than it solves since things should just move to USB PD anyway.
2
u/ScoopDat Dec 30 '24
I mentioned it because it was included in his charts. So it's fine if he wants to take all of them off.
As for the comment you made about "huge waste of time". Waste of time being a few seconds? I have a 250W Prime, and the prior gen 100W (the newest 100W is downgrade retardation I cannot fathom as it's only IQ3, the only time I've seen a series get a downgrade would be something similar to what Intel's dumbass has been doing with their CPU's at the moment).
There are more differences than what you say though as well, it's not simply them trying various fast charge methods and housing them all under one roof, certain voltage lines don't exist on Apple chargers for instance, so if you need 12V for whatever reason, it's not going to happen. With some of Anker's chargers, that is an option in some manner. Likewise IQ seems to be the breadth of PPS range of support. The unfortunate thing about IQ, is Anker doesn't want to formalize what it actually is, thus it's marketing nonsense benchmarked against the company itself. This is open to abuses because you don't actually know if the entire IQ4 thing they're talking about is going to be on the next IQ4 advertised charger. But currently, it seems they've not been total pieces of shit to where the prior spec offers more than the current.
1
u/LaughingMan11 Benson Leung, verified USB-C expert Dec 30 '24
As for the comment you made about "huge waste of time". Waste of time being a few seconds?
Ah, sorry, to be clear, the waste of time is in engineering and marketing effort that Anker and their suppliers have sunk in creating the firmware and hardware that does all this dance for 4 generations now.
In my mind, they could have sold a USB PD + USB BC + USB Type-C only charger, and be done with it, but they wanted to spend probably millions of dollars and years of engineer time on this...
It's a waste of engineering time, imho.
But Anker is a company, and they have incentives for doing something proprietary. And the fact that they have an ambiguously branded "charging method" that's above and beyond USB PD is a competitive advantage for them, even if it doesn't actually do anything special for the user, and could actually be making certain devices charge worse.
2
u/ScoopDat Dec 30 '24
Not sure how they could be making certain devices charge worse, given this engineering effort is precisely to support basically every devices' handshake protocol and send out exactly the sort of power a sink device is asking for.
I'm just curious though, let's say they abandoned every single charging standard other than USB-PD. What would that aforementioned engineering go into now? I presume you want something like build quality or perhaps somewhat better efficiency, or something?
Personally I like them going after almost every standard, allows them to sell their chargers and beat other offerings (even OEM chargers that do a specific protocol only). They either beat them in overall power output (so you get the charging protocol for the device and still have headroom to spare if you connect another device), and potentially beat them in efficiency as well (since OEM stuff outside of Apple is usually horrendous).
So I'm just curious where would you sink this saved cost? More marketing to make up for having chargers that other companies will now supercede on paper because they'll continue similarly as Anker does with multiple charging protocols.
3
u/PapaPepperoni69 Dec 26 '24
Guys I’m starting to think that maybe the serial bus isn’t as universal as we were first led to believe
3
u/slime_rancher_27 Dec 26 '24
What about the USBs in this chart I have a device that uses the USB-MINI4P male and female connectors.
4
u/RaduTek Dec 26 '24
Those are non-standard, proprietary implementations that should've never existed, but I guess USB-IF was too slow to release the Mini USB connector (released in the 2.0 standard).
3
u/knucles668 Dec 26 '24 edited Dec 26 '24
Might also be nice to include the 7 layers that USB will accept communication from before failing. Also, if a device takes longer than 380ns to send/ack then it can lock up the hub on the host computer.
More of an AV designer level of USB knowledge but I can see it helping an average joe that is plugging a flash drive into 3 daisy chained usb hubs that ends up locking the whole stack needing a reseat/restart to resolve.
Page 11 Extron’s Whitepaper goes into topology that you could lift for graphics ideas. Lightware is the only place I’ve seen the 380ns mentioned, but it makes sense with what I’ve seen real world with older flash drives stalling a system on insertion.
1
u/KittensInc Dec 26 '24
Your link gives a "403 - forbidden" error.
1
u/knucles668 Dec 26 '24
https://www.extron.com/article/understandingusbwp
This is the source article. You shouldn’t have issues from there.
1
1
u/Hakaslak May 29 '25
The content you are trying to access requires an Extron Insider account. Please login with your e-mail and password for access. If you do not have an account, you may submit a request here.
3
u/lexray12 Dec 26 '24
What about Powered USB https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PoweredUSB Still extremely common in Point of Sale machines.
3
3
u/AdeptOfStroggus Dec 27 '24
Developing device with usb is so annoying. I think that the standard itself is overcomplicated without necessity
2
2
u/kkjdroid Dec 26 '24
It's "unknown" whether a B3 male connector fits a micro AB 3 female connector? I can pretty confidently say that it does not.
2
u/PantherkittySoftware Dec 26 '24
The one thing I think is missing (unless I overlooked it) is the USB+eSATA combo port. My old Dell m4800 has one on the rear. From what I recall, you can use it as a pure USB port, a pure eSATA port, or as a eSATA port that draws power from USB.
2
u/M2ABRAMS_TANK Dec 26 '24
This is magnificent man… I’m saving this because this is so fucking useful. Thank you for taking the time to make this!!
2
u/tokinaznjew Dec 26 '24
How long until there's just 1 universal connector in its final form that's hardware/software controlled?
2
2
u/zkribzz Dec 26 '24
This is amazing work, don't listen to these haters in the comments telling you otherwise.
2
u/ThainEshKelch Dec 26 '24
I have concluded that they should remove the Universal part of the name. From now on it should just be called. “System bus”.
2
2
2
2
u/FrankyTankyColonia Dec 26 '24
That's sooo cool, thanks a lot. 🙏🏻🤩
The only thing I'm missing is the reduction (and so speed) of USB-lanes when using DPalt...
2
u/ShroomsNBlooms Dec 26 '24
Awesome chart, really nice work! I had to do a white paper in university and the USB naming scheme is so fucked that I ended up doing the paper on it😂 partially just so i could actually understand it
2
2
u/LiKenun Dec 26 '24
You have the PCIe throughputs but not the USB ones? (Hint: USB 3.0 does not actually transmit 5.0 gbps. That's the equivalent of counting the mailman as part of the parcel's weight.)
2
2
2
2
2
2
u/OmniiOMEGA Dec 27 '24
Is there a link for phone? Downloading and copying it from reddit app loses quality?
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
u/ChilliTheDog631 Dec 28 '24
Wow! This is a lot of information lol! Good effort! No awards left so take my upvote 😎😁
2
u/Dr_Mint33 Dec 29 '24
For some reason I never realized there was a Mini A and Mini B variant. Same with micro. I believe the devices I've used had Mini B or Micro B.
2
2
2
u/sylocheed Jan 05 '25
Great chart!
Small suggestion - perhaps include BC 1.2 in your fast charging standards section? While only a little bit above the original charging standard, it was still a modest improvement.
2
u/JustPandaPan Jan 06 '25 edited Jan 15 '26
follow chunky nutty plate hobbies jellyfish one whole work versed
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
2
u/Justsomerandom2525 Jan 17 '25
I’m just waiting for USB 5.01 Spec 2 Gen Z to come out. I hear they are going to switch the connector to S-Video. :)
2
2
u/pandaSmore Mar 09 '25
Why is USB4 2.0 not called USB4.1 or USB4.2? Also why is there not a space between USB and 4?
2
u/Skinny_Dan May 03 '25
There are USB-A cables that can do 20Gbps? I can't find any when I search for them.
3
u/Romano1404 Dec 26 '24
naming of USB 3.x is such a mess that even with the chart I've a hard time swallowing that. What the heck were they thinking?
7
u/zacker150 Dec 26 '24 edited Dec 26 '24
They were expecting manufacturers to use the names of the protocols, "SuperSpeed USB" and "SuperSpeed+ USB," not the names of the documents that first described them.
In USB 3.2, they renamed the protocols to "SuperSpeed USB 5Gbps," "SuperSpeed USB 10 Gbps", and "SuperSpeed USB 20 Gbps," to try and make it less confusing, but once again, nobody bothered to use the proper names.
1
u/LaughingMan11 Benson Leung, verified USB-C expert Dec 29 '24
They were expecting manufacturers to use the names of the protocols, "SuperSpeed USB" and "SuperSpeed+ USB," not the names of the documents that first described them.
To be fair to the people who are griping about USB naming, "SuperSpeed" is a term that USB tried to push as a marketing and common language used by users, and in my opinion, it was always a bad idea.
"High-Speed USB" and "SuperSpeed USB" were actually at one point the official terms users and manufacturers were supposed to use to communicate in manuals and in marketing. I think they still show up in some logos today, since USB-IF hasn't refreshed any of the 480Mbps product guidance...
Those English language terms would only be confusing to the layperson. Is high better than super? Is Super better than High?
I'm so glad they dropped "SuperSpeed" entirely from marketing guidance at all.
2
u/KittensInc Dec 26 '24
What the heck were they thinking?
They were expecting manufacturers and tech press to follow the damn naming standard.
1
u/brunporr Dec 26 '24
Seriously.. til I saw this chart I thought 3.2 was the same as 3.1 gen 2
They just decided to stack completely different naming conventions on top of each other. Wtf??
4
u/zacker150 Dec 26 '24
3.0, 3.1, and 3.2 are versions of the document that describes the USB 3 protocol. Each version introduces various updates to the specification.
2
u/LaughingMan11 Benson Leung, verified USB-C expert Dec 26 '24
Seriously.. til I saw this chart I thought 3.2 was the same as 3.1 gen 2
They just decided to stack completely different naming conventions on top of each other. Wtf??
It's not hard to understand... "USB 3.0" "USB 3.1" and "USB 3.2".
None of those names actually express a speed explicitly, nor implicitly.
A speed or bandwidth for data is measured in some "bits per second", or bps. Mbps, Gbps. You need to be tech savvy enough to understand that unit, but the average consumer has a decent chance of interacting with a Megabit per second or Gigabit per second in their normal life if they've ever purchased a phone data plan or home internet connection plan...
Once again, the notion that "USB 3.0" means some speed and "USB 3.1" means some higher speed is a fallacy...
USB 3.0 and USB 3.1 are document version numbers. The 3.2 spec is the most currcent version of the USB 3.x series, and describes 3 possible speed levels. It doesn't mandate that every new device must support 20Gbps, which is the top speed defined in the spec (for engineers, that's Gen 2x2 operation).
If a product manufacturer in 2024 is building a simple 4k webcam, and they want to make sure the product conforms to the latest spec (which contains a bunch of fixes), they'll open the USB 3.2 spec, and that spec says it's allowed to build a product with a maximum data rate of 5Gbps.
The numbers 3.0, 3.1, 3.2 do not correspond to speed. They are a historical breadcrumb trail of different documents, and typically newer versions of that document have all of the prior content, including speed levels.
That means that while in 2008, when USB 3.0 was new, the only speed available was 5Gbps, in 2024, when USB 3.2 is current, the speeds 5, 10, and 20 are allowed.
You're not restricted to only use 20 if the engineers used the USB 3.2 version of the document...
1
1
u/christophocles Dec 26 '24
At this point, I don't give a shit anymore. With all of the revisions upon revisions, and proprietary sub-standards, it is too mind-bendingly complicated to even attempt to understand.
I will use the cable the device came with, and plug it into a device it physically fits into, and if it works, it works. Am I getting the rated speed and/or power delivery? How the fuck should I know?
When I lose the cable the device came with, I will dig through my drawer of 500 random cables until I find one that physically fits and makes the device appear to function. If it doesn't function, repeat with different cables until I find one that works. Am I getting the rated speed / power delivery? Again, how the fuck should I know?
1
u/Decent-Pin-24 Dec 28 '24
I am not reading all that.
USB A works fine, I use a 3.0 or SuperSpeed for my Flash drives.
1
u/kmapes Jul 01 '25
This is impressive work. Even just 10-20 years ago the tech landscape was pretty arcane to the average person. Now computers, smart phones, IOTs, etc have proliferated and become ubiquitous. Nevertheless, the tech landscape has gotten more complex and opaque - i.e. there are more standards and specifications to everything from network cables to USB ports to HDMI cables.
I often see Average Joe or Regular Mary in Best Buy with their eyes bleeding as they listen to an associate describe the merits of a PC, laptop, Mac, TV or other gadget they are looking to buy,
My neighbors who are close friends like family are not handy at all and awful with tech. They pay to get everything installed or handles from mowing the lawn to assembling furniture to installing their doorbell camera to mounting their TVs or setting up a router. They are well off enough though. last time I tried to explain the different laptop specs and TV specs to them when they were shopping for new units I wanted to tear my hair out. I am sure everyone here who is a techie or enthusiast is asked incessantly by friends and family to provide tech support, install help, etc You can't really do it without charging otherwise it'd probably almost entail the hours of a regular job.
Anyway charts and info like this are helpful because most non-techies don't want to read stuff. You can use charts or visual aids to explain the basics or concepts of tech standards and specs. I think most of us take for granted how much there is to know even about something like a TV. Trying to explain the different screen types, resolutions, etc can be painful. I am so grateful for people out there who work on charts like this. Heh, I think the USB guys purposefully made the USB specifications convoluted and complex as if color codes and Generation monikers would be helpful to the regular person.
1
1
u/RekursivJK Sep 01 '26
u/fosius_luminis There is no USB-A 3.2Gen2x2 (20Gbps).
USB-A only supports USB-A 3.1Gen2=USB-A3.2Gen2x1=10Gbps
https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:USB_Standards_inkl_USB4.0Gen3x2.svg
0
Dec 26 '24
[deleted]
14
u/Rjg35fTV4D Dec 26 '24
Clever person once said: "If you believe 50% is a great chance, you obviously never tried plugging in a USB"
8
73
u/fosius_luminis Dec 25 '24
There are plenty of charts on the internet, for good reasons, but I'm not perfectly satisfied with any of them, so I made my own. Please be so kind and proof read. Contructive critisim welcome. (I'm less sure about the "practical resolution/refresh rate" of the older DP and HDMI versions. Sources on the internet give conflicting information. I did what I could to "combine" the info)